Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 18 of the KGLO Rules
  • Rule 18 of KGLOA Rules,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 18 of the KGLO Rules
  • Rule 18 of KGLOA Rules,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Bechu Kurian Thomas, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter concerns a former Additional Government Pleader (the petitioner) who served from 09.03.1992 to 28.07.1997 and was subsequently served with notices seeking recovery of alleged loss to the Government arising out of a delay in obtaining and forwarding a certified copy of a judgment in a land acquisition reference (LAR).

Key events and documents recorded in the opinion:

  • Ext.P1 (show cause notice dated 20.05.2005): alleged delay of about 4½ years in obtaining and forwarding the judgment in LAR No. 296/94; judgment delivered 31.01.1997 and a copy was alleged to have been received by the District Collector only on 16.06.2001. The notice alleged huge losses to the Government.
  • Ext.P2: the petitioner replied, stating he applied for a certified copy on 31.01.1997 but the application was rejected for non-payment of stamp after 18.03.1998; his term ended 28.07.1997.
  • Ext.P3 (notice dated 03.03.2008): alleged the copy application was filed only on 06.06.1997 and the petitioner failed to inform his successor; asserted loss of Rs. 72,033/- and sought recovery.
  • Petitioner submitted a detailed explanation denying negligence and liability, stating the decree in LAR No. 269/1994 was prepared only on 07.11.1997 and stamp was called for on 18.03.1998; the application was rejected for lack of stamp.
  • Ext.P8 (order dated 13.04.2009): the Government issued a unilateral order finding liability upon the petitioner for the alleged loss.
  • Subsequent revenue recovery steps included Ext.P9 and revenue recovery notices issued as Ext.P10.
  • The petitioner challenged Ext.P8 by filing the present petition; the Court heard counsel for both sides and examined the statutory Rule (Rule 18 of the KGLO Rules) and the documentary record including Ext.P11 indicating an application for a certified copy by 07.06.1997 and the dismissal of a copy application on 24.03.1998 for non-production of stamp paper.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Government may, under Rule 18 of the Kerala Government Law Officers Rules (KGLO Rules), unilaterally assess and levy damages on a former Government Law Officer without independent adjudication when the officer disputes liability and loss.
  2. Whether the petitioner can be held personally liable for the alleged delay in obtaining and forwarding a certified copy of a judgment and for the alleged financial loss asserted by the Government.
  3. Whether the procedure adopted (including the long delay in issuing notices and absence of an independent adjudicatory process) violated principles of natural justice, including the maxim nemo judex in causa sua (no one shall be a judge in his own cause).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contended there was no proper adjudication by any independent authority before fixing liability; instead the Government unilaterally assessed liability (Ext.P8).
  • He asserted there was no evidence for the alleged loss to the Government and that liability and the figures were unilaterally arrived at without basis.
  • The petitioner denied negligence, stating he had made an application for a certified copy (initially asserting application on 31.01.1997 and later referencing Ext.P11 indicating an application by 07.06.1997) and that the court's own procedures (rejection for non-production of stamp) caused delay beyond his term (term ended 28.07.1997).
  • The petitioner questioned the jurisdiction of the Government to fix liability and attempt recovery from him when the Government itself was an aggrieved party and thereby not an impartial adjudicator.
  • He also relied on prejudice caused by the very long delay (first notice issued eight years after his term ended), arguing this hampered his ability to defend the allegations.

Respondent's (Government) Arguments

  • The Government alleged a delay of 1,629 days in obtaining a certified copy and attributed that delay to the petitioner.
  • It contended that a carbon copy of the judgment was not applied for and that, due to the delay, the Government had to incur an enhanced land value liability for the period 30.04.1994 to 30.04.1995 at 15%, constituting the loss to the State.
  • The respondent argued that because the petitioner was a lawyer who conducted the case on behalf of the State during his tenure as Government Pleader, liability was properly imposed on him.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Uma Nath Pandey v. State of Uttar Pradesh [(2009) 12 SCC 40] Support for the principle of impartial adjudication and aspects of natural justice (nemo judex in causa sua). The decision was cited to illustrate and reinforce the necessity that the decision-maker be impartial and that a party with an interest cannot be the adjudicator of its own claim.
Philip v. Registrar of Co operative Societies [(2018) 3 KLT 347] Support for the same facet of natural justice and impartial adjudication. Referred to by the Court to underline the importance of the impartiality requirement and to support the conclusion that the Government cannot assess and fix liability without independent adjudication.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by examining Rule 18 of the Kerala Government Law Officers (Appointment and Conditions of Service) and Conduct of Cases Rules, 1978 (as amended in 1994), which provides that a Government Law Officer shall conduct cases carefully and shall be liable to pay damages equal to the loss suffered by the Government as a result of carelessness, negligence or other misconduct, and that such liability may persist even after the officer ceases to be Government Law Officer.

The Court made the following analytical points, grounded in the text of the Rule and the record:

  • Scope of Rule 18: While Rule 18 creates liability for losses caused by default (carelessness, negligence or misconduct) in conducting cases or safeguarding Government interests, the Rule does not prescribe the procedure for determining liability or the authority that must adjudicate default and assess quantum.
  • Need for adjudication: When the Government initiates proceedings under Rule 18 and the officer disputes the allegations, an adjudication is essential. The adjudication must (a) determine that a default occurred, (b) establish that the default was caused by carelessness, negligence or other misconduct in conducting the case or safeguarding Government interests, and (c) determine the quantum of loss that is directly attributable to that default.
  • Prohibition on self-adjudication: The Court emphasised that the Rule and principles of natural justice require that levy of damages should not be undertaken by the interested party itself (the Government) without independent adjudication. The maxim nemo judex in causa sua was invoked: a person cannot be judge in his own cause. The Court cited decisions (Uma Nath Pandey and Philip) in support of the general requirement of impartial adjudication.
  • Application to the facts: The petitioner disputed both the fact of loss and his alleged action causing loss. Despite these disputes, the Government proceeded to assess and fix liability unilaterally in Ext.P8 without evidence or adjudication by an independent authority, producing an assessment that the Court characterized as arbitrary and vitiated.
  • Documentary record and causation: The Court noted documents (Ext.P11) showing the petitioner had applied for a certified copy at least by 07.06.1997, and that an application was dismissed on 24.03.1998 for non-production of stamp paper. The decree in a related judgment was prepared on 07.11.1997 and stamp was called for on 18.03.1998. Given these facts and that the petitioner's term ended on 28.07.1997, the Court found it not appropriate to hold the petitioner responsible for delay until 13.06.2001.
  • Prejudice and delay in initiating proceedings: The Court also considered the Government's eight-year delay in issuing Ext.P1 after the petitioner's term had ended, concluding that such delay prejudiced the petitioner and impeded his ability to mount an effective defence.
  • Absence of proof of loss: The Court observed that there was no adequate evidence on the loss sustained by the Government—no proof of the loss or explanation of the manner in which it was sustained—so that liability could not legitimately be imposed on assumptions.

On the basis of these legal and factual considerations, the Court concluded that Ext.P8 was illegal, lacked any basis and was arbitrary because the Government had fixed liability without an independent adjudication and without evidence of loss directly attributable to a culpable default by the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court quashed Ext.P8 (order dated 13.04.2009) which imposed liability on the petitioner, and consequently quashed Ext.P9 and the revenue recovery notices issued as Ext.P10. The original petition was allowed.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • Direct effect on parties: The Government's unilateral assessment of liability (Ext.P8) and the consequent recovery steps (Ext.P9 and Ext.P10) are set aside; the petitioner is relieved of the liability imposed thereby.
  • Procedure emphasized: The decision requires that before damages are levied under Rule 18 against a Government Law Officer who disputes allegations, there must be an adjudication by an independent authority establishing default and quantifying loss directly attributable to that default.
  • Precedential breadth: The opinion applies established principles of natural justice (including nemo judex in causa sua) to the statutory context of Rule 18; the Court did not purport to create a novel legal principle beyond enforcing impartial adjudication and evidentiary requirements. The opinion does not state that it is laying down a new binding precedent beyond its application in this case.

Exhibits and citations referenced in the opinion include Ext.P1, Ext.P2, Ext.P3, Ext.P8, Ext.P9, Ext.P10, Ext.P11, as well as the judicial authorities Uma Nath Pandey v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Philip v. Registrar of Co operative Societies, which the Court relied on for articulating the natural justice principle of impartial adjudication.

    M.M. Hussain v. State Of Kerala

    Bechu Kurian Thomas, J.:— A former Government Pleader is placed in a peculiar situation in which he is served with a revenue recovery notice for an alleged loss caused to the Government. The loss is alleged to have been caused due to a lapse, allegedly committed by the Petitioner, in applying for a certified copy of the judgment in a land acquisition reference case.

    2. Petitioner was an additional Government Pleader during the period from 09.03.1992 to 28.07.1997. By Ext.P1 show cause notice dated 20.05.2005, petitioner was called upon to explain a delay of 4½ years in obtaining and forwarding a copy of the judgment in a LAR case [LAR No. 296/94]. It was alleged that even though the judgment was delivered on 31.01.1997, a copy of the judgment was not given to the District Collector and the copy was received only on 16.06.2001. The notice further stated that the Government suffered huge losses due to the default committed by the petitioner. Even though the show cause notice was issued almost 8 years after the term of the petitioner as Government Pleader ended, still, an explanation was submitted which is produced as Ext.P2. In the reply notice, petitioner explained that he had made an application on 31.01.1997 itself, however, the application was rejected for non-payment of stamp after 18.03.1998, while his term as Government Pleader ended on 28.07.1997.

    3. By another notice dated 03.03.2008 (Ext.P3) petitioner was informed that since the copy application was filed only on 06.06.1997 and due to the failure to inform the successor in the office about the application for a copy of the judgment, the Government suffered a loss of Rs. 72,033/-. The notice also sought for an explanation from the petitioner as to why the said amount ought not to be recovered from him. A detailed explanation was submitted by the petitioner in which it was further informed that the decree in the judgment in LAR. No. 269/1994 was prepared only on 07.11.1997 and stamp was called for, pursuant to the application for copy, only on 18.03.1998 alone. However, due to the failure of the Government to furnish the requisite stamp, the application is known to have been rejected. He thus denied any negligence or liability on his part.

    4. However, without considering his explanation and in a unilateral manner, Ext.P8 order was issued on 13.04.2009 finding liability upon the petitioner for causing the alleged loss.

    5. It is the petitioner's case that, before fixing the liability upon the petitioner, there has not been a proper adjudication, that too by any independent authority. Petitioner further contends that there is no evidence for the alleged loss to the Government and fixation of liability has been made without any basis or any evidence and even the figures have been arrived at unilaterally. Petitioner also questioned the jurisdiction of the Government to fix the liability and attempt recovery from the petitioner, especially when they are an aggrieved party.

    6. A counter affidavit has been filed on behalf of the first respondent pointing out that there was a delay of 1629 days in obtaining a certified copy, and the delay could be attributed only to the petitioner. It is also pointed out that carbon copy of the judgment was also not applied for and due to the delay in applying for the certified copy of the judgment, enhanced value of land for the period 30.04.1994 to 30.04.1995 @15% had to be incurred by the Government and the said liability was the loss caused to the State Government. Since the petitioner was a lawyer, he conducted the case on behalf of the State, during his tenure as Government Pleader. It is pointed out by the respondent that the liability has been properly imposed upon the petitioner.

    7. I have heard Adv. Mansoor Ali for Adv.P.J. Mathew on behalf of the petitioner and also the learned Senior Government Pleader Sri. B. Vinod on behalf of the respondents.

    8. The Kerala Government Law Officers (Appointment and Conditions of Service) and Conduct of Cases Rules, 1978 [for short, ‘KGLO Rules’] was amended in 1994 to incorporate Rule 18, providing for the liability of Law Officers to pay damages. Rule 18 of the KGLO Rules reads as follows:—

    18. Liability of Law Officers to pay damages in certain cases.- A person appointed as Government Law Officer shall conduct the cases carefully and efficiently and safeguard Government interests and in case of any default, he shall be liable to pay the Government, even after he ceases to be Government Law Officer, damages equal to the loss or injury incurred or sustained by the Government as a result of his carelessness, negligence or other misconduct in conducting any case or safeguarding Government interests.

    9. A reading of the aforestated provision makes it clear that in the case of any default, Government Law Officers shall be liable to pay to the Government damages, equal to the loss or injury incurred or sustained by the Government as a result of his carelessness, negligence or other misconduct. It, however, stipulates that the default specified as above must be in relation to the conduct of any case or safeguarding of the Government interests. The procedure to levy damages is not laid down in the said provision. The Authority to decide the default or the quantum is also not laid down in the Rule.

    10. When the Government initiates proceedings to levy damages against a Government Law Officer by recourse to Rule 18 of KGLOA Rules, and the officer concerned disputes the allegations leveled against him, it is essential that there must be an adjudication on his alleged default. The adjudication must also prove that the default was caused due to carelessness, negligence, or other misconduct in conducting a case or safeguarding Government interests. There must also be an adjudication on the quantum of loss or injury incurred or sustained by the Government which is directly relatable to the aforesaid default. In the absence of such an adjudication, levy of damages under Rule 18 by the Government itself cannot be justified. The procedure and the manner in which such levy of damages is to be imposed on a Government Law Officer is also not laid down in the Rule.

    11. The Rule itself is thus indicative of the legislative wisdom that adjudication and levy can only be through the available forum and not by one of the parties to the dispute - the Government. It is a reflection of the wisdom of applying the principle of ‘nemo judex in causa sua’ which means, literally, “no-one shall be a judge in his own cause.” It is a principle of natural justice that no person can judge a case in which he has an interest.

    12. The decision maker's impartiality is one of the most sublime and cherished ideals on which the rule of law thrives. Such impartiality must be experienced by the parties to the dispute also. The decision maker's impartiality is expressed in the maxim ‘nemo judex in causa sua’ and is one of the facets of natural justice. Natural justice is the essence of fair adjudication, deeply rooted in tradition and conscience to be ranked as fundamental. The purpose of following the principles of natural justice is the prevention of miscarriage of justice. They form the minimum protection of the rights of an individual against the arbitrary procedure that may be adopted by a judicial, quasi-judicial, and administrative authority while making an order affecting his rights. The rules of natural justice are intended to prevent such authority from doing injustice. One of the essential requirements of the principles of natural justice is that the authority deciding the issue must be impartial and should not have any personal interest in the controversy. Reference can be made to the decision in Uma Nath Pandey v. State of Uttar Pradesh [(2009) 12 SCC 40] and that of this Court in Philip v. Registrar of Co operative Societies [(2018) 3 KLT 347].

    13. Loss caused to the Government is disputed by the Petitioner. Alleged action of the Petitioner resulting in loss to the government is also disputed. In other words, liability of the Petitioner is disputed. In spite of the above mentioned disputes, loss caused and even the liability, is assessed by the Government, without recourse to any independent authority like an arbitrator or a Court of law. Based on an assessment of liability by one of the parties to the cause - the petitioner is being proceeded against. Ext.P8 is the order of assessment of liability imposed by the Government itself for recovering the loss sustained to it. No evidence is taken and no adjudication is carried out, despite a dispute raised by the petitioner. Such an order cannot be termed as valid in the eye of law. Ext.P8 is therefore arbitrary and hence vitiated.

    14. Apart from the above, it is evident from Ext.P11 that the petitioner had applied for a certified copy of the judgment atleast by 07.06.1997. I am mindful of the contention of the petitioner that he had applied for a certified copy of the judgment immediately after the judgment was delivered. However, it is pleaded that a copy of the said application was misplaced from the files of the court. Whatever be the veracity of the said contention, the fact remains that the petitioner had made arrangements to apply for a certified copy as is evident from Ext.P11. It is also the admitted case that a copy application pursuant to Ext.P11 was dismissed for the non-production of stamp paper on 24.03.1998. Petitioner's term as Government Pleader expired on 28.07.1997. Thus, the petitioner cannot be mulcted with the liability for the alleged long delay in obtaining a certified copy till 13.06.2001. These disputed facts that arose in the case could not have been determined by the Government and mulcted the petitioner with liability, without having recourse to a court of law.

    15. Further, the first notice itself was issued only after 8 years of expiry of petitioner's term as Government Pleader. The delay in issuing Ext.P1 notice and initiation of proceedings have also prejudiced the petitioner since he would not have been able to defend the allegations against him properly at such a belated stage. The proceedings against the petitioner are thus bad for violations of principles of natural justice.

    16. Yet another glaring aspect in the case is the absence of evidence on the loss sustained to the Government. There is no evidence of any loss sustained and if sustained, in what manner it was sustained. In the absence of evidence of loss sustained, the petitioner cannot be mulcted with a liability, based on assumptions.

    17. In such circumstances, I find that Ext.P8 order dated 13.04.2009 imposing liability upon the petitioner for the alleged loss caused to the Government is illegal and without any basis. I quash Ext.P8. Consequently, Ext.P9 as well as the revenue recovery notices issued as Ext.P10 also shall stand quashed.

    18. The original petition is allowed as above.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M.M. Hussain v. State Of Kerala
    (Oct 21, 2020)