Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion deals with a matrimonial dispute involving a divorce petition filed by the wife in India, where the husband is a US citizen residing abroad. The husband challenged the jurisdiction of Indian courts, asserting that foreign courts had prior jurisdiction due to his residence and actions abroad. The wife contested this, stating her domicile remains in India and she seeks to exercise her right to file for divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act. The procedural context includes the husband's application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC for rejection of the divorce petition on grounds of lack of jurisdiction and the wife's domicile status. The Family Court rejected the husband's application, leading to the present appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Indian Family Courts have jurisdiction to entertain a divorce petition filed by a wife residing in India when the husband resides abroad and claims foreign jurisdiction.
  2. Whether the domicile of the parties, particularly the wife, affects the maintainability of the divorce petition under the Hindu Marriage Act.
  3. The legal effect of the amendment to Section 19 of the Hindu Marriage Act, specifically sub-clause (iiia), on jurisdiction in matrimonial matters involving parties residing outside India.
  4. The burden of proof required to establish a change of domicile and its impact on jurisdiction in matrimonial proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant/Husband's Arguments

  • The husband contended that the courts in Illinois, USA, had acquired prior jurisdiction by entertaining his divorce petition.
  • He asserted that both parties must be domiciled in India for Indian courts to have jurisdiction over the divorce petition.
  • He claimed that the wife had abandoned her domicile of origin (India) and was no longer entitled to invoke jurisdiction of Indian courts.
  • He sought rejection of the wife's divorce petition under Order VII Rule 11 CPC on grounds of lack of jurisdiction and maintainability.

Respondent/Wife's Arguments

  • The wife asserted that she remains a citizen and domicile of India and has not abandoned her domicile of origin.
  • She argued that Section 19(iiia) of the Hindu Marriage Act permits her to file the divorce petition in the court where she resides in India, even if the husband resides abroad.
  • She maintained that the Indian courts have jurisdiction to entertain her petition and that foreign decrees based on grounds not recognized under the Hindu Marriage Act are not binding.
  • She contended that the husband's assertion about foreign jurisdiction does not bar Indian courts from exercising jurisdiction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R. Sridharan v. The Presiding Officer, Principal Family Court, Chennai & Ors., 2010 SCC Online Mad 3807 Explanation of the legislative intent behind amendment to Section 19 of the Hindu Marriage Act, extending jurisdiction to courts where the wife resides. Supported the interpretation that the wife can file a petition in the court of her residence regardless of husband's location.
Mandeep Kaur v. Dharam Lingam, 2016 SCC Online P&H 10594 Jurisdiction of Indian courts over matrimonial petitions involving parties residing abroad and the effect of Section 19(iiia) amendment. Held that absence of objection on domicile and jurisdiction from husband implied acceptance; wife entitled to file petition in India.
Sondur Gopal (Supra) Principles relating to domicile, especially that domicile of the wife does not automatically follow that of the husband; burden of proof on party alleging change. Court rejected husband's argument that wife's domicile followed his, emphasizing need for proof of intention to abandon domicile of origin.
Kedar Pandey v. Narain Bikram Sah, AIR 1966 SC 160 Definition and principles of domicile of origin and domicile of choice; requirement of animus manendi (intention to reside indefinitely) for change of domicile. Applied to establish that domicile change requires strong proof and intention; wife's domicile presumed to be India absent such proof.
Abdus Samad v. State Of West Bengal, (1973) 1 SCC 451 Definition of domicile as permanent home and burden of proof for change of domicile. Reaffirmed that domicile is a voluntary choice and burden lies on party alleging change; supported wife's claim of Indian domicile.
Union of India v. Dudh Nath Prasad, (2000) 2 SCC 20 Clarification on types of domicile and distinction between domicile and residence in statutory context. Guided the court to interpret domicile and residence in context of Hindu Marriage Act jurisdiction provisions.
Y. Narasimah Rao & Ors. Vs. Y. Venkta Lakshmi & Anr, (1991) 3 SCC 451 Recognition that marriage solemnized under Hindu law must be dissolved under Hindu Marriage Act and foreign decrees on non-statutory grounds are not binding. Supported rejection of husband's claim that foreign courts had prior jurisdiction based on grounds not recognized under the Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the legislative intent behind the amendment to Section 19 of the Hindu Marriage Act, which was introduced to address the prejudice faced by women in matrimonial proceedings by allowing wives to file petitions in courts where they reside. The court emphasized that domicile is a mixed question of law and fact, requiring strong proof to establish a change from domicile of origin to domicile of choice.

The court analyzed the husband's claim that Indian courts lack jurisdiction due to his residence abroad and prior proceedings in foreign courts. It found that the wife had asserted her domicile remains in India and that no evidence was led to prove otherwise. The court highlighted that the husband's oral assertions without evidence were insufficient to displace the presumption of the wife's Indian domicile.

Further, the court noted that the marriage was solemnized under Hindu law in India, and thus, dissolution must be sought under the Hindu Marriage Act. Foreign decrees based on grounds not recognized under the Act (such as irretrievable breakdown of marriage) cannot be accepted as valid jurisdictional claims.

The court held that the Family Court in India was vested with jurisdiction under the amended Section 19(iiia) to entertain the wife's petition, as she resides within its territorial limits. It found no merit in the husband's application for rejection under Order VII Rule 11 CPC at the preliminary stage without trial or evidence.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed, and the Family Court's order rejecting the husband's application for dismissal of the divorce petition is upheld.

The decision confirms that Indian courts have jurisdiction to entertain matrimonial petitions filed by wives residing in India, even if the husband resides abroad, pursuant to the amendment of Section 19(iiia) of the Hindu Marriage Act. It underscores the necessity of leading evidence to establish any change in domicile and rejects the notion that foreign court proceedings automatically oust Indian jurisdiction. The ruling protects the rights of women to seek matrimonial relief in India without undue hardship and clarifies that foreign decrees on non-statutory grounds do not bar Indian proceedings. No new precedent beyond the application of existing statutory and case law principles is established.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Karan Goel v. Kanika Goel

    Enforcement) Act, 1933 enacted by the British Parliament under Section (1) in pursuance of which the Government of United Kingdom issued Reciprocal Enforcement of Judgments (India) Order, 1958. Apart from it there are other enactments such as Indian and Colonial Divorce Jurisdiction Act, 1940 which safeguard the interests so far as United Kingdom is concerned. But the rule of domicile replacing the nationality rule in most of the countries for assumption of jurisdiction and granting relief in matrimonial matters has resulted in conflict of laws. What is this domicile rule is not necessary to be gone into. But feasibility of a legislation safeguarding interests of women may be examined by incorporating such provisions as- (1) No marriage between a NRI and an Indian woman which has taken place in India may be annulled by a foreign court; (2) Provision may be made for adequate alimony to the wife in the property of the husband both in India and abroad. (3)The decree granted by Indian courts may be made executable in foreign courts both on principle of comity and by entering into reciprocal agreements like Section MAT.APP.(F.C.).101/2020 Page 14 of 24 44-A of the Civil Procedure Code which makes a foreign decree executable as it would have been a decree passed by that court.

    24. The reasons that had weighed with the legislature for amending Section 19 of the Act and inserting sub-clause (iiia) have been succinctly stated in the following words by a Division Bench of the High Court of Madras in R.Sridharan v. The Presiding Officer, Principal Family Court, Chennai & Ors., reported as 2010 SCC Online Mad 3807 :

    12. The Hindu Marriage Act, as it originally stood besides its coverage to the whole of India, also applied to all Hindus domiciled in India. The Act was subsequently amended and it was given an extended application. Accordingly domicile in India was substituted by a new clause domiciled in the territories to which this Act extends. This amendment was made with a specific purpose to extent the provisions of the Act to all Hindus with such domicile, even though for the time being, they are outside the said territories. Because of this amendment, it was not open to a person governed by Hindu Law to contest the matter on the sole ground that he is residing outside India and as such the Act has no application to him.

    13. Section 19 of the Hindu Marriage Act deals with jurisdiction and procedures. Before the amendment made to Section 19 as per Act 50 of 2003, the provision was as under:

    19. Court to which Petition shall be presented. Every Petition under this Act shall be presented to the District Court within the local limits of whose ordinary original Civil jurisdiction

    (i) the marriage was solemnized, or

    (ii) the Respondent, at the time of presentation of the Petition, resides, or

    (iii) the parties to the marriage last resided together, or MAT.APP.(F.C.).101/2020 Page 15 of 24 [(iii-a) in case the wife is the Petitioner, where she is residing on the date of presentation of the Petition, or]

    (iv) the Petitioner is residing at the time of the presentation of the Petition, in a case where the Respondent is, at that time, residing outside the territories to which this Act extends, or has not been heard of as being alive for a period of seven years or more by those persons who would naturally have heard of him if he were alive.

    14. It was found that the provision regarding jurisdiction caused serious prejudice to the cause of women. It was not possible for a women to initiate proceedings before the Court in whose jurisdiction she was residing. Because of this rigid provision, women were compelled to approach the Courts in whose jurisdiction the marriage was solemnized or the husband resides or the parties to the marriage last resided together. They have to approach Courts in distant places to resolve their matrimonial disputes. Courts were flooded with transfer petitions to transfer those proceedings on various grounds so as to enable the wife to contest the proceedings before the nearest Court without any kind of difficulties. The jurisdiction clause as it stood originally, was really unfair to the women. Accordingly it was decided to amend Section 19 for the purpose of incorporating a provision to enable the wife to file a Petition before the District Court in whose jurisdiction she is actually residing. This provision was inserted by Act 50 of 2003 with effect from

    23 December, 2003. Therefore the wife is now entitled to file a Matrimonial Petition before the District Court in whose territorial jurisdiction she is residing.

    15. The provision regarding jurisdiction as per sub- clause( iv) of Section 19 permits initiation of Matrimonial proceedings before the Court in whose local jurisdiction the Petitioner is residing at the time of presentation of the petition, in a case where the Respondent is, at that time, residing outside the territories to which the Hindu Marriage Act extends. Therefore the fact that the other party to the proceeding is residing outside the territory to which the Hindu Marriage Act extents does not disentitle the Petitioner wife from applying before the local MAT.APP.(F.C.).101/2020 Page 16 of 24 designated Court to redress her grievances.(emphasis supplied)

    25. In Mandeep Kaur v. Dharam Lingam, reported as 2016 SCC Online P&H 10594, while dealing with a case where the husband was a citizen of Canada who had raised the issue of jurisdiction in a petition for divorce filed by the wife in Ludhiana, Punjab, a Division Bench of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana had observed as under:

    12. In the case in hand, the respondent was stated to be citizen of Canada. On notice of the petition, he had appeared before learned trial Court but without filing written reply to the petition and raising any objection/pleading relating to his status as domicile of India or jurisdiction of the Court, had walked out of the proceedings. In the absence of pleading on his part, it cannot be assumed that he was not a Hindu domiciled in India by origin and residing outside the territory of India. Issue No. (i) is answered accordingly.

    14. Section 19 of the Act deals with jurisdiction and procedure, which reads as under:

    19. Court to which petition shall be presented. -Every petition under this Act shall be presented to the district court within the local limits of whose ordinary original civil jurisdiction-

    (i) the marriage was solemnised, or

    (ii) the respondent, at the time of the presentation of the petition, resides, or

    (iii) the parties to the marriage last resided together, (iiia) in case the wife is the petitioner, where she is residing on the date of presentation of the petition, or

    (iv) the petitioner is residing at the time of the presentation of the petition, in a case where the respondent is, at that time, residing outside the territories to which this Act extends, or has not been heard of as being alive for a period of MAT.APP.(F.C.).101/2020 Page 17 of 24 seven years or more by those persons who would naturally have heard of him if he were alive.

    15. Sub-clause (iii-a) was inserted by Act 50 of 2003. As it was found that the provision regarding jurisdiction caused serious prejudice to the cause of women and the jurisdiction clause as it stood originally, was unfair to the women, necessary amendment was made in Section

    19 of the Act for the purpose of incorporating a provision to enable the wife to file a petition before the District Court in whose jurisdiction she is actually residing. Accordingly, the wife is now entitled to file a matrimonial petition before the District Court in whose territorial jurisdiction she is residing. (emphasis supplied)

    26. A reading of the judgment in Sondur Gopal (supra), would show that the argument advanced by the appellant/husband therein that the domicile of the respondent/wife would automatically follow the domicile of the husband, had not been decided in his favour by the Supreme Court. Nor can the observations made in para 27 of the said judgment and relied upon by the appellant/husband herein come to his aid. Para 34 of the said judgment makes it clear that for proving domicile, it has to be established that there is a manifest intention of the party of abandoning the domicile of origin. For ready reference, the observations made by the Supreme Court in para 34 of Sondur Gopal (supra), is extracted as under:-

    34. Domiciles are of three kinds viz. domicile of origin, the domicile by operation of law and the domicile of choice. In the present case, we are concerned only with the domicile of origin and domicile of choice. Domicile of origin is not necessarily the place of birth. The birth of a child at a place during temporary absence of the parents from their domicile will not make the place of birth as the domicile of the child. In domicile of choice one is abandoned and another domicile is acquired but for that, MAT.APP.(F.C.).101/2020 Page 18 of 24 the acquisition of another domicile is not sufficient. Domicile of origin prevails until not only another domicile is acquired but it must manifest intention of abandoning the domicile of origin.

    35. The right to change the domicile of birth is available to any person not legally dependent and such a person can acquire domicile of choice. It is done by residing in the country of choice with intention of continuing to reside there indefinitely. Unless proved, there is presumption against the change of domicile. Therefore, the person who alleges it has to prove that. Intention is always lodged in the mind, which can be inferred from any act, event or circumstance in the life of such person. Residence, for a long period, is an evidence of such an intention so also the change of nationality. (emphasis supplied)

    27. The captioned judgment refers to Section 1(2) of the Act and states that the said provision applies to Hindus by religion in any form and takes in its fold, sub-sects like Buddhists, Jains, Sikhs and covers all such persons who are domiciled in India, not being Muslims, Christians, Parsis or Jews unless it is proven that they are not governed by the Act. The conclusion drawn was that Section 2 would apply to Hindus domiciled in territories contemplated in Section 1(2) of the Act including those Hindus who are living outside the territories of India.

    28. In Kedar Pandey v. Narain Bikram Sah, reported as AIR 1966 SC 160, on the aspect of domicile, the Supreme Court held as under:

    10. The law on the topic is well established but the difficulty is found in its application to varying combination of circumstances in each case. The law attributes to every person at birth a domicil which is called a domicil of origin. This domicil may be changed, and a new domicil, which is called a domicil of choice, acquired; but the two kinds of domicil differ in one respect. The domicil of MAT.APP.(F.C.).101/2020 Page 19 of 24 origin is received by operation of law at birth; the domicil of choice is acquired later by the actual removal of an individual to another country accompanied by his animus manendi. The domicile of origin is determined by the domicile, at the time of the child's birth, of that person upon whom he is legally dependent. A legitimate child born in a wedlock to a living father receives the domicil of the father at the time of the birth; a posthumous legitimate child receives that of the mother at that time. As regards change of domicile, any person not under disability may at any time change his existing domicile and acquire for himself a domicile of choice by the fact of residing in a country other than that of his domicile of origin with the intention of continuing to reside there indefinitely. For this purpose residence is a mere physical fact, and means no more than personal presence in a locality, regarded apart from any of the circumstances attending it. If this physical fact is accompanied by the required state of mind, neither its character nor its duration is in any way material. The state of mind, or animus manendi, which is required demands that the person whose domicile is the object of the inquiry should have formed a fixed and settled purpose of making his principal or sole permanent home.. (emphasis added)

    29. Similarly, in Abdus Samad v. State Of West Bengal ., reported as (1973) 1 SCC 451, the Supreme Court observed as under:

    6. .. By domicile is meant a permanent home. Domicile means the place which a person has fixed as a habitation of himself and his family not for a mere special and temporary purpose, but with present intention of making it his permanent home. Domicile of choice is thus the result of a voluntary choice.

    7. Every person must have a domicile. A person cannot have two simultaneous domiciles. Domicile denotes connection with the territorial system of law. The burden of proving a change in domicile is on those MAT.APP.(F.C.).101/2020 Page 20 of 24 who allege that a change has occurred. (emphasis added)

    30. Yet again, on the concept of resident and domicile, following are the pertinent observations made by the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Dudh Nath Prasad reported as (2000) 2 SCC 20:- "27. ...........The classical division of domicile is well known. There are the domicile of origin, the domicile of choice and the domicile of dependence. There has been little change in the essential concept of these three domiciles........

    28. In view of the above, the concept of "domicile" as canvassed by learned counsel for the appellants with reference to change of nationality or change of domicile from one country to another, cannot be imported in the present case. Moreover, "Domicile" and "Residence" are relative concepts and have to be understood in the context in which they are used, having regard to the nature and purpose of the statute in which these words are used. (emphasis supplied)

    31. To crystallize the law, the aforesaid decisions of the Supreme Court amply demonstrate that the question of domicile of the parties depends on their intention. It is well-settled that strong proof would be required to establish that a person has abandoned the domicile of origin and has acquired a new domicile. Domicile being primarily a mixed question of law and fact, this intention can be determined by the court after the parties get an opportunity to lead evidence. Under Order VII Rule 11, CPC, the court can only scrutinize the contents of the plaint taken as a whole but it cannot consider the evidence, if any, or the pleas taken in the written statement. In Abdus Samad Vs. State of West Bengal reported as (1973) 1 SCC 451, it has been categorically held that the burden of proving a MAT.APP.(F.C.).101/2020 Page 21 of 24 change in domicile is on those who allege that a change has occurred. Since the appellant/husband has asserted that the respondent/wife has changed her domicile, it shall be for him to discharge the said onus by leading evidence. His oral assertion would certainly not suffice.

    32. In the present case, the stage of leading evidence has yet to arrive. The question as to whether the respondent/wife is a domicile of India or not, has not been proved. The matter was still at the stage of completion of pleadings, when the application was moved by the appellant/husband for seeking rejection of the divorce petition. The respondent/wife has categorically stated in her petition that she wants to reside in India. To establish as to whether she has abandoned the domicile of origin which is India, evidence will necessarily have to be led. We are therefore of the opinion that after amendment to the Act in the year 2003 and on insertion of sub-clause (iiia) in Section 19, it cannot be said that Family Courts in Delhi are not vested with the jurisdiction to try and entertain the divorce petition filed by the respondent/wife.

    33. The contention of the appellant/husband that courts in the State of Illinois have acquired prior jurisdiction premised on the divorce petition filed by him and entertained by the said courts, is also found to be meritless. The facts as they stand today, show that the parties were married in Delhi and the marriage was conducted in accordance with Sikh ceremonies. Once the marriage was solemnized under the Hindu law, the divorce proceedings must also be initiated under the Hindu Marriage Act. The appellant/husband cannot raise an objection to the respondent/wife initiating proceedings of divorce in India under the provisions of the Act only because he is a US citizen and domiciled in USA. [Refer : Y. Narasimah Rao & Ors. Vs. Y. Venkta Lakshmi & Anr. reported as (1991) 3 SCC 451]. MAT.APP.(F.C.).101/2020 Page 22 of 24

    34. Even assuming for the sake of arguments, that the appellant/husband has abandoned his domicile as asserted by him, the facts as they emerge from a reading of the divorce petition shows that India remains the domicile of choice for the respondent/wife. Unless, it is proven otherwise by leading appropriate evidence, it cannot be stated at this stage that courts in India are divested of the territorial jurisdiction to entertain a petition filed under the Act simply on the say so of the appellant/husband. Once the respondent/wife has averred in clear and unequivocal terms that she has not abandoned the domicile of India, it has to be held that the divorce petition discloses a valid cause of action and cannot be held to be barred under any law.

    35. If we accept the contention of the appellant/husband that both the parties must be domiciled in India for a petition to be maintainable in India, it would lead to an absurd and untenable inference that after the marriage, if a wife is abandoned in a foreign land on being deserted by the husband, she will be left with no remedy other than to institute/contest the case in a foreign land where she may have no financial means, wherewithal or support for the same.

    36. The marriage between the parties herein having been solemnized under the Hindu Law, can only be dissolved on the grounds set out in Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act. Irretrievable break down of marriage is not a ground available under the said provision. It therefore, does not lie in the mouth of the appellant/husband to claim that courts in Illinois, California had acquired prior jurisdiction in the matter merely because he had approached the said courts for seeking divorce against the respondent/wife on grounds that are not even available under the Act. In fact, it will be for the appellant/husband to establish the validity of the decree of divorce granted by the foreign court in his favour on the ground MAT.APP.(F.C.).101/2020 Page 23 of 24 of irretrievable break down of marriage. [Refer (1991) 1 SCC 451, Y. Narasimah Rao & Ors. Vs. Y. Venkta Lakshmi & Anr.].

    37. In the instant case, the respondent/wife remains a citizen of India and therefore, is a domicile of India for all intents and purposes. She has chosen to approach the courts in India for obtaining a decree for divorce. Section 19(iiia) read with Section 1 and Section 2 of the Act must be interpreted meaningfully and in such a manner as to confer jurisdiction on courts in India for entertaining a petition under the Act filed by the wife in circumstances where her husband has deserted her to go abroad or invoked the jurisdiction of foreign courts to obtain ex-parte orders/decree, leaving her with no efficacious remedy outside the country.

    38. It was therefore, too premature a stage for the Family Court to have determined with certainty, the intention of the respondent/wife as to her domicile of choice. That would be a matter of trial and based on the evidence brought on record, the learned Family Court will have to draw an appropriate conclusion. In our opinion, the application filed by the appellant/husband under Order VII Rule 11 CPC for rejection of the divorce petition without taking the matter to trial, has been rightly turned down.

    39. To conclude, none of the two grounds invoked for rejection of the divorce petition under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, have been made out by the appellant/husband. The issue as to whether the respondent/wife has abandoned her domicile in India, is a mixed question of law and facts that can be established only in a trial, after evidence is led by the parties. The divorce petition filed by the respondent/wife read as a whole, does disclose a valid cause of action that can be entertained by the learned Family Court in India. Section 19(i), (iiia) and (iv) read with Sections 1 and 2 of the Act confer jurisdiction on courts in India to entertain such a dispute. MAT.APP.(F.C.).101/2020 Page 24 of 24

    40. We, therefore, do not find any infirmity in the impugned judgment. The appeal, therefore, fails and is accordingly, dismissed along with the pending application. HIMA KOHLI, J. SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD, J. OCTOBER 12, 2020 pst/ap/sk/NA/tr

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Karan Goel v. Kanika Goel
    (Oct 12, 2020)