Shiva Kirti Singh, Chairperson:— Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel for the respondent. Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the petitioner's major grievance in respect of license fee for Pure Internet Services stands satisfied in view of judgement and order of this Tribunal dated 18.10.2019 passed in T.P. No. 169 of 2014 (Internet Service Providers Association of India v. Union of India connected matters) because this petitioner was a party to T.P. No. 108 of 2017 in which petitioner number 1 was Anjani Broadband Solutions Pvt. Ltd. She further submits that the relief sought on the basis of claim for pass-through need not be pressed in view of relief already granted vide order dated 18.10.2019. She, however, has referred to prayer nos. (f), (g) & (h) which are as follows:
“f) Pass an order setting aside the letter dated 4.03.2015 and direct the respondent to refund the amount of Rs. 2,00,000/- (RupeesTwo Lakh) to the petitioner.
g) Pass an order directing the respondent to return the bank guarantee bearing No. PBG No. 1/9-10 dated 3.06.2009 and bearing No. FBG No. 01/2010 dated 15.07.2010.
h) Hold that the respondent is liable to refund the expenditureborne by the petitioner for keeping bank guarantee bearing No. FBG No. 01/2010 dated 15.07.2010 alive from 28.08.2015 till the date of actual return.”
2. The aforesaid three prayers have been pressed. These relate to Bank Guarantees furnished by the petitioner in respect of its earlier license agreement for provision of internet services dated 23.5.2003. It is not in dispute that the said license has come to an end on 11.8.2014. From the counter affidavit, it has been shown that the simple stand of the respondent is that if there are any dues against the petitioner, same shall be adjusted against the Bank Guarantee already encashed and the balance shall be paid to the petitioner. Same is the stand in respect of Financial Bank Guarantee (FBG) which has been kept alive so far. There is no reply to the prayer of the petitioner for compensating it for the cost in keeping the Bank Guarantee alive from 28.8.2015 till date of actual return. The date 28.8.2015 has been treated as a cut-off date because the petitioner was granted the unified license and it became effective from that date. The liability to furnish Bank Guarantees and undertaking under the unified license have been performed by the petitioner.
3. Learned counsel for the respondent submits that in accordance with the stand taken in the counter affidavit, the respondent is prepared to adjust the outstanding amount due from the petitioner, if any, and refund the balance of the Bank Guarantee already encashed. Same stand has been taken for return of the FBG. However, neither in the counter affidavit nor in the course of submission any detail is furnished as to whether there is any outstanding dues against the petitioner. In such circumstances, the prayers made in (f) and (g) for return of the amount of the encashed FBG and also for returning the FBG which has been kept alive, is allowed. This should be done within one month from today. If any deduction is made on account of outstanding dues, the details of such dues shall be duly furnished to the petitioner, otherwise that amount shall be refunded within the time indicated above.
4. In respect of prayer (h), it is observed that even according to policy decision of the respondent, Bank Guarantee should have been returned soon after 30.6.2016 as appears from Annexure P-14. Instead of going into calculation of the cost incurred by the petitioner, a lump sum of Rs. 10,000/- is awarded to the petitioner against the relief (h). That should be also paid within the time indicated above.
5. If the entire amount payable under this order is not paid within 30 days, it shall be paid along with a interest @ 10% p.a. from today till the date of realization.