Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary: High Court of Karnataka — Writ Appeal No. 4652 of 2017

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a challenge to the judgment and order dated 1 March 2017 of the learned Single Judge in W.P. No. 12370/2009 and to the order dated 12 January 2009 passed by the Special Deputy Commissioner (Revisional Authority) in Revision Petition No.205/2007-2008.

The dispute concerns mutation entries in revenue records for a parcel of land. The appellant, Sri R.A. Pradeep, purchased the subject land by a Sale Deed dated 9 September 2005 from H. Narayanappa (the vendor), who is stated in the opinion to be deceased. The first respondent, Sri N. Murari, claimed the land as a joint family property that had been partitioned between him and his father H. Narayanappa and filed a civil suit O.S.No.6777/2005 on 3 September 2005 against H. Narayanappa seeking partition and separate possession.

On 3 September 2005, the civil court passed an order of status quo on an interim application filed by the first respondent seeking to restrain H. Narayanappa from alienating the property. Before that order could be served on H. Narayanappa, the Sale Deed in favour of the appellant was executed on 9 September 2005.

Mutation entries were made in the Record of Rights on the basis of the Sale Deed and an order to that effect was passed by the Special Tahsildar on 24 April 2006. The first respondent's appeal against that order resulted in further proceedings, and the Revisional Authority (Special Deputy Commissioner) on 12 January 2009 set aside the orders of the two revenue authorities and directed restoration of the khatha as it stood before, subject to the decision of the civil court. The learned Single Judge, by the impugned order dated 1 March 2017, confirmed the Revisional Authority's order and also directed the parties to maintain status quo regarding possession until disposal of the suit.

The appellant filed this writ appeal under Section 4 of the Karnataka High Court Act, 1961, seeking to set aside the Single Judge's order and to quash the Revisional Authority's order. The appellant also filed I.A. No.1/2017 for condonation of delay of 105 days in filing the appeal; the High Court condoned the delay. The trial court later dismissed the civil suit by judgment dated 5 December 2018, and the first respondent has preferred an appeal against that judgment to this Court, which is pending with an interim order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the writ court should interfere with orders of revenue authorities concerning mutation/revenue entries where a civil suit on title is pending.
  2. Whether the Revisional Authority and the learned Single Judge were justified in restoring earlier revenue entries (restoring khatha) because of the pendency of the civil suit and in directing the parties to maintain status quo regarding possession till the civil suit is decided.
  3. Whether the status of a Sale Deed executed while an order of status quo/injunction was in existence (and before service) affects the revenue entries and the rights of the parties as a matter of revenue adjudication (as opposed to determination of title by civil courts).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The authorities under the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964 (in particular Section 128) had to give effect to the registered Sale Deed and make mutation entries accordingly.
  • The appellant's vendor did not challenge or avoid the Sale Deed; hence the mutation based on the Sale Deed was lawful.
  • The Sale Deed was executed on 9 September 2005 before the order of status quo could be served on the vendor and therefore the order of status quo did not affect the deed's validity.
  • The mutation entries were rightly ordered on the basis of the Sale Deed and the Revisional Authority ought not to have interfered with the concurrent orders merely because the civil suit was pending.
  • It was submitted that the suit has been dismissed (by Trial Court) and that the appellant is a bona fide purchaser; the rights conferred by the Sale Deed remain unaffected.
  • It was urged that restoring the name of the deceased vendor in revenue records is unlawful and would defeat the scheme of the said Act of 1964.
  • The appellant relied on several decisions, including SRINIVAS AMBAJI KULKARNI S/O AMBAJI KULKARNI vs. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER, K. JAYAMMA & OTHERS vs. TAHSILDAR & ANOTHER, and P.K. VASUDEVAN vs. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF KODAGU DISTRICT AND OTHERS (the opinion records these authorities as relied upon by the appellant).

First Respondent's Arguments

  • The Sale Deed on which the appellant relies is a nullity.
  • The first respondent supported the Revisional Authority's order restoring the earlier revenue entries and opposed interference by the writ court.
  • The first respondent relied on several decisions of the Supreme Court (as recorded in the opinion) including JEHAL TANTI & ORS. vs. NAGESHWAR SINGH (DEAD) THROUGH LRS, SURJIT SINGH & ORS. vs. HARBANS SINGH & ORS., MATHURA PRASAD vs. AJEEM KHAN and SATYABRATA BISWAS & ORS. vs. KALYAN KUMAR KISKU & ORS.; these were advanced to support the contention that a sale effected in breach of injunction may be invalid and that no interference was called for in the writ proceedings.
  • The Additional Government Advocate (for respondents 2 to 4) supported the impugned judgment and the Revisional Authority's order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
SRINIVAS AMBAJI KULKARNI S/O AMBAJI KULKARNI vs. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER (ILR 1997 KAR 1183) Relied upon by the appellant (the opinion does not set out a specific principle from this decision). The court records that the appellant relied on this Division Bench decision; the opinion does not expressly analyse or adopt a specific principle from it.
K. JAYAMMA & OTHERS vs. TAHSILDAR & ANOTHER (ILR 1999 KAR 3250) Relied upon by the appellant (the opinion does not set out a specific principle from this decision). Noted as relied upon by the appellant; the court's analysis does not expressly extract a rule from this authority in the reported reasoning.
P.K. VASUDEVAN vs. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF KODAGU DISTRICT AND OTHERS (ILR 2002 KAR 4637) Relied upon by the appellant (the opinion does not set out a specific principle from this decision). Recorded as relied upon by the appellant; the opinion does not explicitly apply a distinct principle from this case in its reasoning.
JEHAL TANTI & OTHERS vs. NAGESHWAR SINGH (DEAD) THROUGH LRS (Supreme Court) Cited by the first respondent in support of the contention (the opinion lists it among Apex Court decisions relied upon; the precise rule from this case is not separately set out in the opinion). Listed among Supreme Court authorities relied upon by the first respondent to support the proposition that transfers in breach of injunction may be invalid; the court mentions such "catena of decisions" but does not decide that point in this appeal.
SURJIT SINGH & OTHERS vs. HARBANS SINGH & OTHERS (Supreme Court) Cited by the first respondent (the opinion does not extract a specific paragraph or principle beyond noting reliance). Noted as relied upon by the first respondent; the court acknowledged these authorities as supporting the first respondent's position but did not rule on the substantive question of sale validity in these proceedings.
MATHURA PRASAD vs. AJEEM KHAN (Supreme Court) Cited by the first respondent (the opinion does not reproduce the decision's text beyond citation). Recorded among authorities relied upon by the first respondent; the court did not determine the substantive issue governed by this authority in the present revenue-focused proceedings.
SATYABRATA BISWAS & OTHERS vs. KALYAN KUMAR KISKU & OTHERS (Supreme Court) Cited by the first respondent (the opinion lists it among the Apex Court decisions relied upon). Mentioned as a part of the first respondent's reliance; not separately applied to decide the revenue-entry issues in this appeal.
SURAJ BHAN & OTHERS vs. FINANCIAL COMMISSIONER AND OTHERS (2007) 6 SCC 186 The opinion quotes para 9: an entry in revenue records does not confer title; revenue records have fiscal purpose and title must be determined by civil court. The court relied on this authority to reinforce the principle that mutation/revenue entries do not determine title and that writ courts should be slow to interfere with revenue entries when title is litigated before civil courts.
RAMESH DUTT & OTHERS vs. STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS (Supreme Court) The opinion quotes para 15: entry in revenue record-of-rights is evidence of possession only and does not create or extinguish title. The court cited this authority to support the legal position that mutation is evidence of possession for fiscal purposes and cannot substitute for adjudication on title by a civil court.
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, AURANGABAD THROUGH ITS COMMISSIONER vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER (Supreme Court) The opinion quotes para 13: mutation does not confer any right or title; cancellation of mutation does not extinguish title; mutation recorded normally on basis of possession for revenue purposes. The court relied on this precedent to state the settled law that mutation entries have only fiscal consequences and that revenue entries are subordinate to civil adjudication on title.
JATTU RAM v. HAKAM SINGH (mentioned within Suraj Bhan quotation) Mentioned in the Suraj Bhan quote as authority for the proposition that title can only be decided by a competent civil court. Used indirectly via the Suraj Bhan quotation to support the proposition that revenue entries do not determine title.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning proceeded from established legal propositions about the nature and effect of mutation and revenue entries under the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964. The opinion identifies and relies upon a consistent line of authority (including Suraj Bhan, Ramesh Dutt and Municipal Corporation, Aurangabad) to establish that:

  • Entries in revenue records (mutation/jamabandi) serve primarily fiscal purposes (liability to pay land revenue) and do not confer title or extinguish title.
  • Mutation entries may be prima facie evidence of possession in a given case, but they do not decide the issue of ownership or title which is within the domain of a competent civil court.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court noted:

  • The Revisional Authority observed the pendency of the civil suit (O.S.No.6777/2005) on the date the Sale Deed was executed and therefore directed restoration of the earlier mutation/khatha, making that restoration subject to the decision in the civil suit and permitting parties to approach revenue authorities after final civil adjudication.
  • The learned Single Judge confirmed the Revisional Authority's order. Given the settled law that revenue entries do not adjudicate title and the existence of pending civil proceedings on title, the court explained that a writ court should be very slow to interfere with revenue authority orders; such orders are ordinarily left open to adjudication by the civil court on title.
  • The court further observed that issues framed in the civil suit included whether the appellant was a bona fide purchaser and whether the Sale Deed was binding on the first respondent; those issues were still subject to further proceedings (an appeal against the Trial Court's dismissal was pending in this Court). Because the title issues remained live in civil proceedings, the learned Single Judge's overall restraint from interfering with the Revisional Authority was appropriate.
  • However, the court found that the learned Single Judge ought not to have directed a status quo regarding possession in the writ proceedings since possession/injunction orders as against the appellant (who was impleaded in the suit) should be made, if at all, only by the Civil Court. For that reason the aspect of the Single Judge's order directing both parties to maintain status quo regarding possession required interference.
  • The court expressly refrained from deciding the substantive title question (including whether a Sale Deed executed in breach of injunction is valid), noting that such issues are part of the pending civil appeal and that the present appeal concerns revenue-entry proceedings; accordingly, the court made no adjudication on title.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The appeal is partly allowed.

More specifically, the court ordered:

  • (i) The impugned judgment and order of the learned Single Judge dated 1 March 2017, in so far as it confirms the order of the Revisional Authority dated 12 January 2009 (Annexure-A to the writ petition), is upheld and no interference is called for.
  • (ii) That part of the impugned order by which the learned Single Judge directed both parties to maintain status quo with regard to possession until the decision of the civil suit is set aside.
  • (iii) The court made clear that it has made no adjudication on the disputed questions of title involved in the pending civil appeal/proceedings.
  • (iv) The appeal is partly allowed on the above terms and the pending interlocutory application (I.A. for condonation of delay) stands disposed of.

Direct consequences: The Revisional Authority's order restoring the earlier khatha (subject to the civil court's decision) stands affirmed by this Court. The specific direction in the Single Judge's order maintaining status quo as to possession is removed so that issues of injunction or possession relating to the parties should be determined by the civil court exercising jurisdiction over the title dispute. The Court refrained from deciding title and did not establish a new precedent on the substantive question of validity of the Sale Deed.

Procedural notes recorded in the opinion: The High Court condoned a delay of 105 days in filing the appeal; notice of appeal was taken by respondents; the appeal was heard and partly disposed of by final order.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SRI R A PRADEEP v. SRI N MURARI

    - 1 -

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

    DATED THIS THE 17TH DAY OF JUNE, 2020

    PRESENT

    THE HON'BLE MR.ABHAY S. OKA, CHIEF JUSTICE

    AND

    THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE S.VISHWAJITH SHETTY WRIT APPEAL NO. 4652 OF 2017 (KLR-RR/SUR)

    BETWEEN:

    SRI R.A. PRADEEP

    S/O SRI AMBIKAPATHI

    AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS

    R/AT NO.3/8, II CROSS

    GANESHA BLOCK

    BENGALURU-560 032

    ... APPELLANT

    (BY SRI RADESH PRABHU K, ADVOCATE)

    AND:

    1. SRI N. MURARI

    S/O SRI H. NARAYANAPPA R/AT NAGAVARA VILLAGE

    KASABA HOBLI

    BENGALURU NORTH TALUK-560045

    2. THE SPECIAL DEPUTY COMMISIONER

    BENGALURU DISTRICT

    BENGALURU-560001

    3. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER

    BENGALURU NORTH SUB-DIVISION BENGALURU-560001

    4. THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR

    BENGALURU NORTH TALUK

    BENGALURU-560001

    ... RESPONDENTS

    (BY SRI MITHUN G.A., ADVOCATE FOR

    SRI G. D. ASWATHANARAYANA REDDY, ADVOCATE FOR R1;

    SRI I. THARANATH POOJARY, AGA FOR R2 TO R4)

    1

    THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE

    KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE

    THE ORDER DATED 01.03.2017 OF THE LEARNED SINGLE

    JUDGE IN W.P.NO.12370/2009 (KLR-RR/SRU) AND

    CONSEQUENTLY QUASH THE ORDER DATED 12.01.2009

    PASSED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.2 - THE SPECIAL DEPUTY COMMISSIONER, IN REVISION PETITION NO.205/2007-2008 VIDE ANNEXURE-A AND ETC.

    THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR DICTATING JUDGMENT

    THIS DAY, CHIEF JUSTICE DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

    JUDGMENT

    The appellant has filed I.A.No.1/2017 seeking condonation of delay of 105 days in filing the appeal. We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the appellant, the learned counsel appearing for the first respondent and the learned Additional Government Advocate appearing for the second to fourth respondents. In view of the sufficient cause made out in the affidavit filed in support of the application, the delay in filing the appeal is condoned. Accordingly, the application is allowed.

    2. Issue notice of appeal. The learned counsel appearing for the first respondent takes notice. The learned Additional Government Advocate takes notice for the second to fourth respondents. By consent, the appeal was taken up for final disposal. The submissions were heard yesterday.

    2

    3. The challenge in this appeal is to the judgment and order dated 1stMarch 2017 passed by the learned Single Judge. In a writ petition filed by the present petitioner, what was challenged before the learned Single Judge was an order passed on 12th January 2009 by the Special Deputy Commissioner, Bengaluru District in a Revision Petition filed under the provisions of sub- section (3) of Section 136 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964 (for short 'the said Act of 1964').

    4. With a view to appreciate the submissions, few facts will have to be set out. The land subject matter of the appeal has been more particularly described in paragraph 1 of the writ appeal. The dispute arises out of the mutation entry proceedings. According to the case of the first respondent, the subject land was a joint family property which was partitioned between him and his father - H.Narayanappa. The appellant purchased the subject land on 9thSeptember 2005 from H. Narayanappa who is no more. On the basis of the Sale Deed, mutation entries were made in the Record of Rights. An order to that effect was passed by the Special Tahsildar on 24thApril 2006 which was confirmed in an appeal preferred by the first respondent and therefore, a revision petition was filed by the first respondent. In the order dated 12thJanuary 2009 which

    3

    was impugned before the learned Single Judge, it was observed that as the said H.Narayanappa refused to abide by the agreement relating to the partition, the first respondent filed a civil suit bearing O.S.No.6777/2005 on 3rdSeptember 2005. On 3rdSeptember 2005, on an I.A. filed by the first respondent in the said suit, an order of status quo was passed. The prayer in the I.A was to restrain the said H.Narayanappa from alienating the subject property. Before the said order of status quo could be served to said Sri H. Narayanappa, the Sale Deed dated 9thSeptember 2005 was executed by him in favour of the appellant. Noting these facts, by the said order dated 12thJanuary 2009, the Revisional Authority proceeded to set aside the orders of both the authorities and directed restoration of khatha as it is stood before and continue the same which will be subject to the decision of the Civil Court. It was observed that after the decision of the Civil Court, the parties are at liberty to approach the revenue authorities for such action as may be warranted in accordance with law. The learned Single Judge by the order impugned in this appeal confirmed the order of the Revisional Authority and directed the parties to maintain status quo regarding the possession till the disposal of the suit.

    4

    5. As a factual aspect, we must also note here that by the judgment and order dated 5thDecember 2018, the suit was dismissed by the Trial Court. It is pointed out that an appeal has been preferred by the first respondent in this Court which is pending in which an interim order has been passed.

    6. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant relied upon the provisions of Section 128 of the said Act of 1964 and submits that the authorities under the said Act of 1964 had no choice but to give effect to the registered Sale Deed. He submitted that the appellant's vendor has never challenged the Sale Deed or has never avoided the Sale Deed. He relied upon various decisions. Firstly, he relied upon a decision of a Division Bench of this Court in the case of SRINIVAS AMBAJI KULKARNI S/O AMBAJI KULKARNI VS. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER, BELGAUM1. Secondly, he relied upon a decision of the learned Single Judge in the case of

    K. JAYAMMA & OTHERS VS. TAHSILDAR & ANOTHER2. Lastly, he relied upon a decision of the learned Single Judge of this Court in the case of P.K. VASUDEVAN VS. THE DEPUTY

    COMMISIONER OF KODAGU DISTRICT AND OTHERS3.

    1

    ILR 1997 KAR 1183

    2

    ILR 1999 KAR 3250

    ILR 2002 KAR 4637

    3

    7. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that mutation entries were ordered to be made by the authorities on the basis of the Sale Deed for giving effect to the provisions of Section 128 of the said Act of 1964 and there was no reason for the Revisional Authority to interfere with the two concurrent orders only on the ground of pendency of the suit. He submitted that now in any case, the suit has been dismissed on merits and in fact, it is held that the appellant is a bona fide purchaser and that the Sale Deed dated 9th September 2005 is binding on the first respondent. He submitted that the Sale Deed was executed before the order of status quo was served upon his vendor. He submitted that merely because there was an order of status quo in operation when the Sale Deed was executed, it does not affect the title. He urged that the rights conferred on the appellant by virtue of the Sale Deed remain unaffected. He submitted that the order passed by the Revisional Authority of restoring the name of the appellant's vendor who is no more is completely illegal. He urged that a void cannot be created in the revenue records by directing restoration of name of a deceased person. He submitted that it will completely defeat the scheme of the said Act of 1964.

    6

    8. The learned counsel appearing for the first respondent supported the impunged order. His submission is that the Sale Deed on which the appellant is placing reliance is nullity. He relied upon the decisions of the Apex Court in the case of

    JEHAL TANTI AND OTHERS VS. NAGESHWAR SINGH (DEAD)

    THROUGH LRS4, SURJIT SINGH AND OTHERS VS. HARBANS

    SINGH AND OTHERS5, MATHURA PRASAD VS. AJEEM KHAN6

    and SATYABRATA BISWAS AND OTHERS VS. KALYAN KUMAR KISKU AND OTHERS7. He submitted that no interference is called for. The learned Additional Government Advocate also supported the impugned judgment and order as well as the judgment and order of the Revisional Authority.

    9. Few are the admitted facts. The appellant's vendor had executed the Sale Deed in favour of the appellant when a substantive suit bearing O.S.No.6777/2005 filed by the first respondent for seeking partition and separate possession of half share against the appellant's vendor was pending. On an interim application seeking temporary injunction restraining the appellant's vendor from alienating the property, an order of status quo was passed by the Trial Court on 3rdSeptember

    7

    2005 which was in force on 9thSeptember 2005 when the Sale Deed in favour of the appellant was executed. Though the said suit has been dismissed by the judgment and order dated 5th December 2018, a substantive appeal preferred by the first respondent to this Court is pending which is a continuation of the proceedings of the suit.

    10. The writ petition before the learned Single Judge arose out of the proceedings relating to the revenue entries. As far as the revenue entries are concerned, the law is well settled. In paragraph 9 of the decision of the Apex Court in the case of

    SURAJ BHAN AND OTHERS VS. FINANCIAL COMMISSIONER

    AND OTHERS8, the Apex Court held thus:

    "9. There is an additional reason as to why we need not interfere with that order under Article 136 of the Constitution. It is well settled that an entry in revenue records does not confer title on a person whose name appears in record-of-rights. It is settled law that entries in the revenue records or jamabandi have only "fiscal purpose" i.e. payment of land revenue, and no ownership is conferred on the basis of such entries. So far as title to the property is concerned, it can only be decided by a competent civil court (vide Jattu Ram

    v. Hakam Singh). As already noted earlier, civil proceedings in regard to genuineness of will are pending with the High Court of Delhi. In the circumstances, we see no reason to interfere with the order passed by the High Court in the writ petition."

    (underline supplied)

    (2007) 6 SCC 186

    8

    11. In the case of RAMESH DUTT AND OTHERS VS. STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS9in paragraph 15 of its decision, the Apex Court held thus:

    "15. Mr Grover, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents, may not be correct in contending that only because the order of mutation made in favour of the appellants had been cancelled, the same ipso facto would lead to the conclusion that they have no title over the property. It is now a well-settled principle of law that entry in a revenue record-of-rights merely is an evidence of possession. (See Faqruddin v. Tajuddin) Such an entry does not create title; absence thereof does not extinguish the same. Furthermore, it is one thing to say that the appellants had committed acts of criminal misconduct while trying to obtain orders of mutation but it is another thing to say that only because they filed such an application, the same by itself would tantamount to commission of a criminal offence."

    (underline supplied)

    12. Lastly, the issue regarding relevance of the mutation entries and the entries in the revenue records is dealt with by the Apex Court in the case of MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,

    AURANGABAD THROUGH ITS COMMISSIONER VS. STATE OF

    MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER10. Paragraph 13 of the said decision reads thus:

    9

    (2009) 15 SCC 429

    (2015) 16 SCC 689

    10

    "13. It is settled that mutation does not confer any right and title in favour of any one or other, nor cancellation of mutation extinguishes the right and title of the rightful owner. Normally, the mutation is recorded on the basis of the possession of the land for the purposes of collecting revenue."

    (underline added)

    13. Thus, the law is very consistent. Even if by virtue of a mutation entry, the name of a person is entered in revenue records in respect of an immovable property, it does not confer any right, title and interest on the said person. Even if the name of a person appearing in the revenue record is removed, it does not extinguish the right, title and interest, if any, vesting in him in respect of the property. The mutation or revenue entries are made only for fiscal purposes for deciding the liability to pay land tax or land revenue. Consequently, the orders passed under the said Act of 1964 concerning the mutation entries and the revenue entries do not decide the issue of title in respect of the properties affected by the entries. Notwithstanding the orders of the authorities under the said Act of 1964 concerning mutation entries and the revenue entries, the aggrieved party can always establish his title by approaching the Civil Court. At the highest, an entry in revenue record, may in a given case, constitute prima facie

    10

    evidence of possession. But the said entries being made only for fiscal purposes have nothing to do with the title in respect of the immovable property. Therefore, while dealing with the writ petitions under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India arising out of the proceedings concerning mutation/revenue entries, normally a Writ Court should be very slow in interfering with the orders inasmuch as the orders do not affect the right, title and interest of the parties and do not take away the remedy of the parities to approach the Civil Court. In fact, the orders passed by the revenue authorities concerning mutation entries and revenue entries are always subject to the adjudication by the competent Civil Court.

    14. All that the Revisional Authority has done is that after noticing the pendency of the suit for partition filed by the first respondent against the vendor of the appellant which was pending on the date of execution of the Sale Deed, he directed that the mutation entry earlier existed should be restored which will be subject to the decision in the civil suit and further directed that after the final decision in the civil suit, the parties can again approach the revenue authorities.

    11

    15. A perusal of the judgment in the suit shows that the issues whether the appellant was a bona fide purchaser and whether the Sale Deed was binding on the first respondent were framed in the suit. Now the said issues are at large, as a substantive appeal against the judgment and decree is pending in this Court, which is a continuation of the suit. That is why the learned Single Judge did not interfere with the order of the Revisional Authority. As held earlier, in such cases and especially, when a civil suit on title is pending, a Writ Court should be very slow in interfering with the orders of the revenue authorities and that is how the approach adopted by the learned Single Judge cannot be faulted with.

    16. We may note here that there are catena of decisions of the Apex Court which hold that a Sale Deed which is executed in breach of the order of injunction is not valid. However, as this appeal arises out of the proceedings for revenue entries, we are not deciding the said issue as the said issue will be naturally of the title, more so when the issue of title is subject matter of the pending appeal in this Court.

    17. In the concluding part of the impugned order, the learned Single Judge has passed an order of status quo regarding

    12

    possession till the decision of the civil suit. The appellant/writ petitioner was impleaded as a party to the suit. Therefore, any order of injunction, if required to be made against the appellant, could have been made only by the Civil Court. Moreover, while deciding the issue regarding the legality of the order relating to mutation entry, the learned Single Judge ought not to have gone into the issue of possession. Therefore, to that extent, interference will have to be made with the impugned order.

    18. Accordingly, we pass the following order:

    (i) The impugned judgment and order of the learned Single Judge in so far as it confirms the order of the Revisional Authority dated 12thJanuary 2009 (Annexure-A to the writ petition) is upheld and no interference is called for;

    (ii) However, that part of the impugned order by which the learned Single Judge directed both the parities to maintain status quo with regard to the possession till

    the decision of the Civil Court is hereby set aside; (iii) We make it clear that we have made no adjudication on the disputed questions of title which are involved in the pending appeal;

    13

    (iv) The appeal is partly allowed on the above terms;

    (v) The pending interlocutory application stands disposed of.

    Sd/-

    CHIEF JUSTICE

    Sd/-

    JUDGE

    AHB/SN

    14

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SRI R A PRADEEP v. SRI N MURARI
    (Jun 17, 2020)