AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Miss. Thakur Kanchan Singh v. Cafe Bahar Restaurant

    (PER HONBLE SRI NIMMA NARAYANA, B.A., LL.B., PRESIDENT, ON BEHALF OF THE BENCH)

    1. The complainant filed this complaint under section 12 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, seeking refund of Rs.15/-; Compensation of Rs.2,50,000/- and costs of Rs.35,000/- .

    2. The case of the complainant as set out in the complaint in brief is that she went to the opposite party Restaurant on 15.07.2019 and ordered for soft drink and water bottle. The opposite party charged Rs.30/- for Kinley 750ml water bottle and charged Rs.25/- for soft drink. The actual price for the water bottle was Rs.25/- and that of the soft drink Rs.20/-. The opposite party therefore, charged Rs.5/- more for each of the two water bottles and also charged Rs.25/- for soft drink, the actual price of which was Rs.20/-. Hence, the complaint.

    3. The opposite party filed written version resisting the complaint filed by the complainant. The opposite party submitted that the Kinley water bottle was charged for Rs.30/- per bottle and the soft drink was charged Rs.20/-. It further contended that the opposite party is entitled to charge over and above the MRP, in view of decision of the Honble Supreme Court, in Federation of Hotel and Restaurant Association of India vs. Union of India, in Civil Appeal No.21790 of 2017, dated 12.12.2017. It is contended that the complaint filed by the complainant is frivolous in nature and liable to be dismissed, with exemplary costs of Rs.10,000/-.

    4. The points for consideration are:- (1) Whether there is deficiency of service/unfair trade practice on the part of the opposite party? (2) Whether the complainant is entitled for refund of Rs.15/- as prayed for? (3) Whether the complainant is entitled for compensation and costs as prayed for? (4) To what relief?

    5. During the course of trial, the complainant got herself examined as PW1 and got marked Ex.A1 to A3. Sri Sayed Ali Azghar, the Managing Partner of the opposite party Restaurant, is examined as DW1. Ex.B1 to B3 are marked on behalf of the opposite party. Written arguments are filed by the complainant as well as the opposite party. Heard both sides.

    6. Point No.1:- Admittedly, the complainant went to the opposite party Restaurant on 15.07.2019 and ordered for a soft drink and two Kinley water bottles apart from other items. She was charged Rs.60/- for two mineral water bottles @ Rs.30/- and Rs.25/- for soft drink, 250ml. Ex.A2, also corroborates the evidence of the complainant in this regard. It is the contention of the complainant that she was charged Rs.10/- more than MRP, in respect of mineral water bottles and Rs.5/- more than MRP in respect of soft drink. DW1 in his evidence asserted that the opposite party is entitled to charge the prices of the items supplied above the MRP rates and the prices of Kinley mineral water bottles and soft drink collected by the opposite party, is in accordance with law. It is the contention of the complainant that the prices of the items above the MRP, can be collected only by the high level Restaurants and residential hotels and not by Restaurant, like the opposite party. The complainant relied upon the judgment of Delhi High Court, in Federation of Hotel and Restaurant Association of India vs. Union of India, in support of her contention. On careful perusal of the Judgment of the Honble Supreme Court, in Federation of Hotels and Restaurant Association of India vs. Union of India, and others, in Civil Appeal No.s 21790/2017 and 21791/2017 dated 12.12.2017, the orders passed by the Delhi High Court, dated 11.02.2015 and 15.05.2015 were set aside. The Honble Supreme Court, held as follows:- We are therefore, of the view that neither the standard of rates and measures Act, 1976, R/w enactment of 1985, or the Legal Meteorology Act, 2009, will apply so as to interdict the sale of mineral water in hotels and Restaurants at prices above the MRP. The Judgment of the Delhi High Court, relied upon by the complainant no longer holds the field, in view of the judgment of the Honble Supreme Court, dated 12.12.2017, under Ex.B1. In other words, it is open for the Restaurants and Hotels to collect the prices of the items above the MRP. There is therefore, no deficiency of service on the part of the opposite party at all. In as much there was no false promise or deceptive practice for promoting the sale of soft drink and mineral water bottles by the opposite party, it cannot be said that the opposite party took recourse to unfair trade practice so far as sale of soft drink and mineral water is concerned. There is no deficiency of service on the part of the opposite party at all. This point is accordingly, answered against the complainant.

    7. Point No.2:- In view of the findings on Point No.1 that there is no deficiency of service and unfair trade practice on the part of the opposite party with regard to sale of Soft Drink and Mineral water bottles, the complainant is not entitled for refund of Rs.10/- collected from the complainant above the MRP of Mineral Water Bottle and Rs.5/- more than the MRP in respect of Soft drink. In other words the complainant is not entitled for refund of Rs.15/- from the opposite party. This point is accordingly, answered against the complainant

    8. Point No.3:- In view of the findings on Point No.1, the complainant is not entitled for compensation and costs as prayed for. This point is accordingly decided against the complainant

    9. Point No.4:- In view of the findings on Point No.1 to 3, the complaint is devoid of merits and liable to be dismissed. In the result, the complaint is dismissed. No costs. Dictated to steno transcribed and typed by her pronounced by us on this the 20th Day of May 2020. PRESIDENT MEMBER APPENDIX OF EVIDENCE WITNESSES EXAMINED For Complainant:- PW1 : Thakur Kanchan. For Opposite Party:- DW1 : Sayed Ali Azghar. Documents Marked:- For Complainant: Ex.A1 is the Photostat copy of Invoice, dated 15.07.2019. Ex.A2 is the Photostat copy of water bottle. Ex.A3 is the Photostat copy of soft brink bottle. For Opposite Party Ex.B1 is the copy of Judgment in Civil Appeal No.21791 of 2017 of the Honble Supreme Court of India. Ex.B2 is the copy of order in W.P.No.6517/03 & WP NO.141691-16927/05 of High Court of Delhi. Ex.B3 is the copy of Menu Card of opposite party. PRESIDENT MEMBER

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Miss. Thakur Kanchan Singh v. Cafe Bahar Restaurant
    (May 20, 2020)