Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Act, O.P.L.E. Act and O.G.L.S. Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Act, O.P.L.E. Act and O.G.L.S. Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners challenged an order dated 27.12.2016 passed by the learned Member of the Board of Revenue, Odisha, dismissing their claims to record ownership of land bearing Plot No. 1215/1390 measuring Ac.0.100 decimal recorded as Stitiban in Khata No. 326/83 of Bhubaneswar. The facts are undisputed: In 1968-69, lease records were created for two adjacent plots in the names of Kedar Nath Nanda and his younger brother Narayan Nanda. Narayan Nanda sold his plot (Plot No. 1215/1390) to Kedar Nath Nanda in 1974, and the Tahasildar mutated the land records accordingly in 1976. The petitioners have been in possession and paid rent since then. During a settlement operation, a draft record was prepared in favor of Kedar Nath Nanda for a combined area of Ac.0.200 decimal. In 2011, Kedar Nath Nanda executed gift deeds in favor of his son Samir Ranjan Nanda and daughter-in-law Lily Nanda, who constructed houses after approval by BDA in 2012. An application by Samir and Lily to record the rights in their name was dismissed in 2016, ordering the record to be prepared in the name of the General Administration Department.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sale and gift deeds executed by Kedar Nath Nanda and Narayan Nanda, in light of the lease agreement clause prohibiting transfer without permission, are valid or void ab initio.
  2. Whether the Board of Revenue was justified in dismissing the petitioners’ claims and directing the record of rights in favor of the G.A. Department.
  3. The scope of authority of revenue officials, particularly the Tahasildar and Collector, to cancel lease agreements and take possession when conditions of the lease are violated.

Arguments of the Parties

State's Arguments

  • The lease deed contains a clause prohibiting transfer, sale, or gift of the leased land without prior written permission of the Tahasildar on behalf of the Collector.
  • Based on Clause 10, the sale and gift deeds executed without permission are void ab initio and do not confer any title on the vendee or donees.

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The clause in the lease deed does not render unauthorized transfers void but empowers the revenue authorities to cancel the lease and take possession following due procedure.
  • The cancellation of lease and taking possession can only be effected by the Collector, with the Tahasildar acting on his behalf, and not by survey and settlement authorities.
  • Recordings made under the O.E.A. Act, O.P.L.E. Act, and O.G.L.S. Act cannot be invalidated by the settlement authorities.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed Clause 10 of the lease agreement, which restricts transfer or assignment of the leased land without written permission from the Tahasildar on behalf of the Collector. The Court observed that the clause does not declare unauthorized transfers void ab initio; rather, it grants the revenue authorities the power to cancel the lease and take possession of the land after following legal procedures. The Court emphasized that the cancellation of lease and possession must be carried out by the Collector, with the Tahasildar acting on his behalf. The Court further noted that the survey and settlement authorities lack jurisdiction to declare transfers void or to invalidate recordings made under the relevant land laws (O.E.A. Act, O.P.L.E. Act, and O.G.L.S. Act). Consequently, the Court found the order of the Board of Revenue, which dismissed the petitioners’ claims and directed record preparation in favor of the G.A. Department, to be illegal.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the writ applications and quashed the orders dated 27.12.2016 in OSS Case Nos. 1101/2015 and 1102/2015, including the direction to prepare record of rights in favor of the G.A. Department.

The Court directed the Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar, to prepare fresh records of rights in favor of the petitioners within sixty working days after the expiry of the appeal limitation period. No order as to costs was made.

This decision directly restores the petitioners’ rights to the disputed land and clarifies the limits of revenue authorities’ jurisdiction regarding lease cancellations and transfer validity. No new precedent beyond the facts was established.

    Lily Nanda And Ors. v. State Of Odisha And Ors

    S.K. Mishra, J.

    1. Heard learned Counsel for the petitioners and learned Addl. Standing Counsel. In both the writ applications, the petitioners assail the order passed by the learned Member, Board of Revenue, Odisha, Cuttack on 27.12.2016 in O.S.S. Case No. 1102 and 1101 of 2015, dismissing the claims of the petitioners to record the land bearing Plot No. 1215/1390 measuring an area of Ac.0.100 decimal recorded as Stitiban in Khata No. 326/83 of Bhubaneswar.

    2. Facts of the case are not in dispute. In the year, 1968-69, lease record of rights called "Dakhal Satwa Sunya" status was recorded in the name of Kedar Nath Nanda as per the khata bearing No. 327/25 having Plot No. 1215/1389 measuring an area Ac.0.100 decimal. On 04.11.1968, lease agreement was executed. In the year, 1968-69, another lease record of rights was recorded in the name of Narayan Nanda, who happens to be the younger brother of Kedar Nath Nanda, as per the Khata being No. 327/26 having plot No. 1215/1390 measuring an area of Ac.0.100 decimal. On 20.11.1969, another lease agreement was executed in favour of Narayan Nanda. On 24.04.1974, Narayan Nanda sold the land in favour of Kedar Nath Nanda. The said land is Plot No. 1215/1390 pertaining to Khata No. 326/83 of Mouza - Ghatika, Bhubaneswar. In 1976, the Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar mutated the land records in favour of Kedar Nath Nanda. Thereafter, the petitioners were in possession of both the pieces of land have paid the rent receipts to the authorities.

    3. While the matter stood thus, the settlement operation started for Bhubaneswar and the draft record of rights was prepared in favour of the Kedar Nath Nanda having an area Ac.0.200 decimal.

    4. On 22.07.2011, Kedar Nath Nanda executed a gift deed in favour of his son Samir Ranjan Nanda. On that day also, he executed another gift deed in favour of his daughter-in-law, Lily Nanda. In both the cases, on 13.08.2012. BDA approved the building plan thereafter, they constructed house and residing there. On 27.12.2016, an application filed by Samir Ranjan Nanda and Lili Nanda for preparing the record of rights in their name with respect to the two plots, was dismissed and it was ordered that the record of rights be prepared in the name of G.A. Department.

    5. The learned Addl. Standing Counsel very emphatically argued that the lease deed prohibits a 3rd party transfer and, therefore, the sale and gifts are void ab initio and consequently, the donee has not acquired any title. He drawn attention of the Court to Clause 10 of the agreement in both the cases. It is appropriate to take note the extra words used.

    " 10. That the lessee shall not by any means Or in any way whatsoever bequeath, mortgage, charge, transfer assign sub-let or part with possession of his holding or any portion thereof to any person without first obtaining the written permission of the Tahasildar, on behalf of the Collector, Puri. Any bequeath, transfer, assignment sub-letting and parting with possession of the holding or part thereof without the permission of the Tahasildar on behalf of the Collector, Puri and he may determine this lease and take khas possession of the holding or part thereof. In case of unauthorised bequeath taking effect from the date of the lease the option to take khas possession will accrue on the death of the lessee."

    6. Basing on this clause, it was argued by the learned Addl. Standing Counsel for the State that the sale and both gift deeds are void ab-initio and it will not create any title in favour of the vendee and the subsequent donees. However, a careful examination of the aforesaid clause shows that it stipulates any bequeath, mortgage, charge, transfer assign sub-let of holding or any portion thereof without the permission of the Tahasildar on behalf of the Collector, Puri, he may determine the lease and take khas possession of the holding or part thereof. It is provided that in case of unauthorised bequeath taking effect from the date of lease the option to take khas possession will accrue from the death of lessee. So, the clause itself does not provide that a transfer without permission of the revenue authorities, will be void, rather, the revenue authorities with a power to cancel the lease and take possession thereof. But in case of a will, the said cancellation of lease and taking khas possession will accrue on the death of the lessee. Thus, the revenue authority has the jurisdiction to cancel the lease and take possession thereof after following the procedure established by law. The revenue authorities empowered to carry out settlement operation do not have the jurisdiction to come to a conclusion that conditions of the lease deed has been violated and all subsequent transfers are void. Thus, the cancellation of lease deed and taking possession thereof can only be undertaken by the Collector and the Tahasildar may take steps on behalf of the Collector.

    7. Any recording made pursuant to the O.E.A. Act, O.P.L.E. Act and O.G.L.S. Act cannot be set at naught by the survey & settlement authorities. Hence, this Court is of the opinion that the order passed by the learned Member, Board of Revenue is illegal in both the cases and hence, the writ applications are allowed. The orders dated 27.12.2016 passed in OSS Case No. 1101/2015 and OSS Case No. 1102/2015 are hereby quashed. The preparation of record of rights in favour of the G.A. Department is hereby quashed. The Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar is directed to prepare fresh records of rights in favour of the present petitioners within a period of sixty working days after expiry of the period of limitation of appeal. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Both the writ applications are disposed of.

    Urgent certified copy of this order be granted as per rules.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lily Nanda And Ors. v. State Of Odisha And Ors
    (Jan 9, 2018)