Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 8, Rule 1 CPC
  • Order 8, Rule 1 of the Code
  • Order 8, Rule 1, CPC,
  • Order 8, Rule 1
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 8, Rule 1 CPC
  • Order 8, Rule 1 of the Code
  • Order 8, Rule 1, CPC,
  • Order 8, Rule 1
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

A suit for specific performance was instituted by the plaintiff respondent against the petitioner on 24.12.2015. Summons were issued on the same date, fixing 29.01.2016 for filing of the written statement and 29.02.2016 for settlement of issues. The petitioner appeared through counsel on 11.07.2016 and filed the written statement on 22.11.2016, which was after a delay of more than four months from the date of appearance. The petitioner did not file any application explaining the delay at that time. The plaintiff objected to the late filing by submitting an application (No. 38Ga). After about eight months, the petitioner filed an application (No. 42Ga dated 31.07.2017) seeking condonation of the delay, citing mistake and oversight as the only reason. The trial Court rejected this application on 04.01.2018, holding that the petitioner failed to disclose any satisfactory or compelling reason for the delay. The trial Court referred to several Supreme Court judgments in its reasoning.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the delay in filing the written statement beyond the stipulated time under Order 8, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) can be condoned on the ground of inadvertence or mistake.
  2. Whether the trial Court was justified in rejecting the petitioner's application for condonation of delay in the absence of compelling reasons beyond the control of the petitioner.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The delay in filing the written statement was due to inadvertence.
  • The petitioner has a strong case on merits, and therefore, the slight delay should be condoned and the written statement taken on record.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • Objected to the late filing of the written statement by filing application No. 38Ga.
  • Impliedly argued that no sufficient reason was given for condoning the delay.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Salem Advocate Bar Association, Tamil Nadu v. Union of India, 2005 AIR(SC) 3353 General principles on procedural compliance and condonation of delay. Referred by the trial Court to support the principle that delay cannot be condoned routinely.
Sakh Saleem Haji v. Kumar & another, 2006 AIR(SC) 396 Procedural rules regarding filing and condonation of delay. Referred to emphasize strict adherence to procedural timelines.
Rani Kusum v. Kanchan Devi & another, 2005 RevDec 616 (SC) Conditions for condoning delay in filing pleadings. Used to reinforce the requirement of compelling reasons for delay.
Kailash v. Nanhku & another, 2005 1 ARC 861 (SC) Interpretation of Order 8, Rule 1 CPC on filing written statement and condonation of delay. Extensively cited to establish that delay is to be condoned only for compelling reasons beyond control and not for laxity or negligence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the application for condonation of delay in filing the written statement under Order 8, Rule 1 CPC. It noted that the petitioner filed the written statement after a delay of more than four months without initially seeking condonation or providing any reason. The sole reason later provided was inadvertence or mistake. The Court referred to the Supreme Court's ruling in Kailash v. Nanhku, which clarified that the timeline for filing the written statement is generally to be honored and extensions are exceptions granted only for compelling reasons beyond the party's control. The Court emphasized that delay due to negligence or oversight does not qualify for condonation. The trial Court’s rejection of the condonation application was upheld as it found no compelling or satisfactory reason to excuse the delay. The Court found no illegality or infirmity in the trial Court's order warranting interference under Article 227 of the Constitution.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed for lack of merit.

The direct effect of this decision is the rejection of the petitioner's application for condonation of delay in filing the written statement, thereby upholding the trial Court’s order. No new precedent is established by this ruling; rather, it affirms the settled principle that delay in filing pleadings under Order 8, Rule 1 CPC is condoned only upon disclosure of compelling reasons beyond the party’s control.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Shoraj Singh v. Charan Singh

    Rajesh Kumar Tripathi, Advocate, For the Petitioner

    JUDGMENT/ORDER

    Manoj Kumar Gupta, J. - A suit for specific performance was instituted by the plaintiff respondent against the petitioner on 24. 12. 2015. On the same date, summons were issued to the petitioner fixing 29. 1. 2016 for filing of written statement and 29. 2. 2016 for settlement of issues. The petitioner entered appearance through counsel on 11. 7. 2016. He filed written statement on 22. 11. 2016 i. e. after a lapse of more than four months from the date he entered appearance in the suit. Although the written statement was filed beyond the time stipulated under Order 8, Rule 1, CPC, but the petitioner did not file any application disclosing reason for not being able to file written statement within time. The plaintiff objected to the filing of the written statement by filing application paper No. 38Ga. After a lapse of about eight months, the petitioner filed an application paper No. 42Ga dated 31. 7. 2017 for condoning the delay. The only reason disclosed in the said application for not being able to file written statement within stipulated time is on account of mistake and oversight. The trial Court by impugned order dated 4. 1. 2018 has rejected the said application holding that the petitioner has failed to disclose any satisfactory reason much less any compelling reason for not being able to file written statement within time. The trial Court has referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Salem Advocate Bar Association, Tamil Nadu Versus Union of India, 2005 AIR(SC) 3353, Sakh Saleem Haji Versus Kumar & another, 2006 AIR(SC) 396, Rani Kusum Versus Kanchan Devi & another, 2005 RevDec 616 (SC), Kailash Versus Nanhku & another, 2005 1 ARC 861 (SC).

    2. The sole submission made by learned counsel for the petitioner is that on account of inadvertence, the written statement could not be filed. He submitted that the petitioner has got a very good case on merits and, therefore, the slight delay in filing the written statement be condoned and the written statement be taken on record.

    3. The Supreme Court in Kailash Versus Nanhku & another, 2005 1 ARC 861 (SC), has held that provisions of Order 8, Rule 1 CPC stipulating filing of written statement within thirty days, which period could be extended up to ninety days, is not mandatory but only directory and in suitable case the period could be relaxed. However, it has also been held that the delay could not be condoned as a matter of course, but upon disclosure of compelling reasons beyond the control of a party. The relevant observations made in this regard are extracted below :-

    "42. Ordinarily, the time schedule prescribed by Order 8, Rule 1 has to be honoured. The defendant should be vigilant. No sooner the writ of summons is served on him he should take steps for drafting his defence and filing the written statement on the appointed date of hearing without waiting for the arrival of the date appointed in the summons for his appearance in the Court. The extension of time sought for by the defendant from the court whether within 30 days or 90 days, as the case may be, should not be granted just as a matter of routine and merely for the asking, more so, when the period of 90 days has expired. The extension can be only by way of an exception and for reasons assigned by the defendant and also recorded in writing by the Court to its satisfaction. It must be spelled out that a departure from the time schedule prescribed by Order 8, Rule 1 of the Code was being allowed to be made because the circumstances were exceptional, occasioned by reasons beyond the control of the defendant and such extension was required in the interest of justice, and grave injustice would be occasioned if the time was not extended.

    "44. The extension of time shall be only by way of exception and for reasons to be recorded in writing, howsoever brief they may be, by the court. In no case, shall the defendant be permitted to seek extension of time when the court is satisfied that it is a case of laxity or gross negligence on the part of the defendant or his counsel. The court may impose costs for dual purpose: (i) to deter the defendant from seeking any extension of time just for asking, and (ii) to compensate the plaintiff for the delay and inconvenience caused to him. "

    4. In the instant case, as noted above, the only reason disclosed by the petitioner for not being able to file written statement within stipulated period is mistake on his part. In the considered opinion of the Court, the ground taken cannot be said to be a compelling circumstance beyond the control of the petitioner, so as to condone delay in filing the written statement. This Court does not find any illegality in the view taken by the trial Court to warrant interference under Article 227 of the Constitution.

    5. The petition lacks merit and is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shoraj Singh v. Charan Singh
    (Jan 30, 2018)