AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Amendment to the statute (25.11.1982)
  • Statute approved by the Chancellor (1980)
  • This scheme will be applicable from the date of amendment in statute.
  • (i) xxx xxx This amendment statute
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Amendment to the statute (25.11.1982)
  • Statute approved by the Chancellor (1980)
  • This scheme will be applicable from the date of amendment in statute.
  • (i) xxx xxx This amendment statute
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants are retired teaching and non-teaching staff of “deficit-grant” minority colleges in the State of Bihar. These colleges are affiliated to different universities; they are not constituent units, but the State meets any deficit in their planned expenditure.

Under Government Resolution No. 1500 dated 05 November 1980, the State introduced the General Provident Fund-cum-Pension-cum-Gratuity facility, commonly called the “Triple Benefit Scheme”, with effect from 01 April 1978. The Chancellor approved the corresponding statute on 18 November 1980, and an amendment followed on 25 November 1982.

In 1998 employees of deficit-grant colleges requested extension of the Scheme to them. After protracted correspondence, the State issued a Resolution on 18 January 2011 extending the Scheme but expressly excluding:

  • staff who had retired before the amendment; and
  • benefits accruing prior to the date of amendment.

The statutory amendment was eventually notified on 15 January 2014, yet it fixed 31 August 2010— the date of the Cabinet decision—as the cut-off from which benefits would accrue. Employees who had retired before that date were therefore denied coverage.

The appellants challenged this exclusion in three writ petitions before the Patna High Court, which a Division Bench dismissed on 08 November 2017. They then sought special leave from the Supreme Court. Delay in one petition was condoned; leave was granted; all appeals were heard together and decided on 04 February 2020.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether fixing 31 August 2010 as the cut-off date for extending the Triple Benefit Scheme to deficit-grant college employees is arbitrary and violative of equality principles.
  2. Whether employees who retired before the cut-off date are entitled to the Scheme on the strength of the precedent in D.S. Nakara v. Union of India.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The differential treatment between employees who retired before and after 31 August 2010 is unreasonable and arbitrary.
  • D.S. Nakara v. Union of India (1983) 1 SCC 305 prohibits the State from creating arbitrary classifications among pensioners; therefore the cut-off is unconstitutional.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The State is entitled to alter service conditions and terminal benefits prospectively, as recognised in State of West Bengal v. Ratan Behari Dey (1993) 4 SCC 62.
  • Pensionary and similar benefits involve significant financial implications; executive discretion in fixing a date must be respected unless demonstrably capricious.
  • Later authority such as Government of A.P. v. N. Subbarayudu (2008) 14 SCC 702 emphasises judicial restraint where no manifest arbitrariness is shown.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
D.S. Nakara v. Union of India (1983) 1 SCC 305 Pensioners similarly situated cannot be arbitrarily classified by cut-off dates. Court distinguished the present case, holding the Scheme was a new benefit, not an existing right, and the cut-off was supported by fiscal considerations.
State of West Bengal v. Ratan Behari Dey (1993) 4 SCC 62 The State may unilaterally change conditions of service, including terminal benefits, if the effective date is reasonable. Relied upon to uphold the State’s power to prescribe 31 August 2010 as the operative date.
Government of Andhra Pradesh v. N. Subbarayudu (2008) 14 SCC 702 Courts should not interfere with executive choice of cut-off dates unless capricious or outrageous. Cited to reinforce that the chosen date did not produce an irrational or shocking result warranting judicial intervention.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that deficit-grant colleges are merely affiliated institutions; the State had no initial obligation to extend the Triple Benefit Scheme to their employees. Extension of the Scheme, and its subsequent amendment, were therefore characterised as ex gratia welfare measures subject to the State’s fiscal capacity.

The bench found a rational nexus between the cut-off date (31 August 2010) and the Cabinet’s decision taken on that very day. Providing part-retrospective, rather than wholly prospective, benefit already favoured employees in service on that date; insisting on benefits for all past retirees would impose an unpredictable financial burden.

Citing Ratan Behari Dey, the Court reiterated that pensionary benefits are part of service conditions and can be revised prospectively. Quoting N. Subbarayudu, it stressed that fixation of effective dates lies primarily within executive discretion and should not be disturbed unless it results in manifestly arbitrary or whimsical consequences, which was not the case here.

Consequently, the Division Bench’s conclusion that the cut-off date was neither arbitrary nor discriminatory was affirmed, and the appellants’ reliance on Nakara was held misplaced.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED.

The judgment of the Patna High Court stands affirmed; employees who retired before 31 August 2010 remain outside the Triple Benefit Scheme. The decision leaves intact the State’s discretion to extend welfare schemes prospectively or with limited retrospectivity based on fiscal and administrative considerations. No new legal principle was created; the Court reiterated existing doctrine on executive leeway in fixing cut-off dates.

    Md. Ali Imam And Others (S) v. State Of Bihar Thr. Its Chief Secretary And Others (S).

    Sanjay Kishan Kaul, J.:— Leave granted.

    2. The appellants before us are the retired teaching and non-teaching employees of the deficit grant minority colleges of the State of Bihar who are aggrieved by what is alleged to be unreasonable and arbitrary discrimination between such of them who retired before 31.08.2010, as against those who retired after that date, for the grant of benefit of the amendment made to the Triple Benefit Scheme.

    3. We may, at the inception, first note that the appellants before us have impleaded not only the State of Bihar but also the concerned Universities being respondent Nos. 3 to 8 since they are affiliated to these Universities. The universities are also distinct from an aided institution in as much as when, in their planned expenditure there is some amount of deficit, the Government makes up the deficit as a matter of assistance to education. It is in this background that the controversy has to be analyzed by us.

    4. The story starts from 05.11.1980 when resolution No. 1500 was passed by the Government of Bihar introducing the General Provident Fund-cum-pension-cum-gratuity benefit (Triple Benefit Scheme) which came into effect as on 01.04.1978. The Chancellor vide memo dated 18.11.1980 approved the statute for grant of benefit of Triple Benefit Scheme. The Amendment to the statute was made on 25.11.1982.

    5. It was in the year 1998 that a representation was made requesting for the benefit of the Scheme to be extended to employees in such deficit colleges. This resulted in some communications and enquiry and it was only on 18.01.2011 that a resolution was passed extending the Triple Benefit Scheme to the deficit colleges. The relevant clauses of this which have been assailed in the present proceedings are as under:

    “(i) xxx xxx

    (ii) This amendment statute will not be applicable to such teaching and non-teaching staffs who retired before the amendment of statute.

    (ii) xxx xxx

    (iii) xxx xxx

    (iv) xxx xxx

    (v) xxx xxx

    (vi) This scheme will be applicable from the date of amendment in statute..”

    6. We may note at this stage itself that the extension of the Scheme to the employees was in the nature of a benefit being extended to the employees, and did not form part of their original terms and conditions of employment. The Amendment came into being on 15.01.2014 but provided for a cut-off date of 31.08.2010. The rationale of this is stated to be that the Cabinet took the decision on that date, and thus, the Amendment was not made applicable from the date it was carried out but from a retrospective date, giving benefits for that period on the premise of the Cabinet decision, to those who were in service on that date. We may also note another aspect that all these resolutions and decisions have a financial implication and thus, some leeway has to be provided to the Government in deciding as to the extent to which they can make funds available and that too for such a beneficial aspect, keeping in mind these are not constituent unit colleges.

    7. The endeavour of the appellant was not successful before the Division Bench of the Patna High Court which dismissed the writ petition filed by them vide impugned order dated 8.11.2017.

    8. We have heard learned counsel for the parties at some length and the plea on behalf of the appellants is based on a discriminative practice and the cut-off dates being so provided, which according to the submissions of learned counsel for the appellant(s) are in violation of the principles of law laid down by this Court in D.S. Nakara v. Union of India (1983) 1 SCC 305.

    9. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents have pointed out that much water flowed after that judgment and, inter alia, invited our attention to the judgment in State of West Bengal v. Ratan Behari Dey (1993) 4 SCC 62 (referred to in the impugned judgment itself) opining that it is open to the State or the Corporation to change the conditions of service unilaterally, and terminal benefits as well as pensionary benefits constitute conditions of service. Thus, the power to revise salaries and/or pay scales, as also terminal benefits/pensioners' benefit can be made as a concomitant of that power so long as the date is specified in a reasonable manner.

    10. If we see the rationale of the impugned judgment as set out para 29 onwards, we may notice that the same is predicated on the absence of arbitrariness in the applicability of the cut-off date of the amendment in the Triple Benefit Scheme statute as well as the rationality behind it based on the date of the Cabinet decision granting Triple Benefit Scheme to such deficit grant colleges. We cannot find any fault with the reasoning in the impugned order.

    11. We must notice that firstly there was really no obligation for exercise of powers of the Government or University in the absence of the institutions being not constituent colleges, but only affiliated colleges. In order to support education, a decision was taken to provide deficit financing. There was again no requirement that the Triple Benefit Scheme ought to be extended to the employees of these colleges and was not so initially extended. A second step was taken in this direction by extending the scheme. The third step was the Amendment of the Scheme. It can hardly be said that by taking these beneficial steps, the State Government is not liable to take into consideration the financial implications of the same, and that the benefits should be extended across the board. The amendments could have, in fact, been implemented prospectively, but were given part-retrospective effect based on the rationale of the date of the Cabinet decision.

    12. Apart from this, there may be other considerations in the mind of the Executive authority while fixing a particular date i.e. economic conditions, financial constraints, administrative and other circumstances, and if no reason is forthcoming from the executive for fixation of a particular date, it should not be interfered with by the Court unless the cut-off date leads to some blatantly capricious or outrageous result. In such cases it has been opined that there must be exercise of judicial restraint and such matters ought to be left to the Executive authorities, to fix the cut-off date, and the Government thus, must be left with some leeway and free play at the joints in this connection. Even if no particular reasons are given for the cut-off date by the Government, the choice of cut-off date cannot be held to be arbitrary (unless it is shown to be totally capricious or whimsical)- Government of Andhra Pradesh v. N. Subbarayudu (2008) 14 SCC 702.

    13. We are thus of the view that the impugned judgment deserves our imprimatur and these appeals are dismissed, leaving the parties to bear their own costs.

    SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

    RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

    Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s). 18577-18579/2018

    (Arising out of impugned final judgment and order dated 08-11-2017 in CWJC No. 17286/2011, CWJC No. 12376/2014 and CWJC No. 8414/2017 passed by the High Court Of Judicature At Patna)

    Md. Ali Imam & Ors.….Petitioner(s)
    v.
    The State of Bihar Thr. Its Chief Secretary & Ors.….Respondent(s)

    SLP(C) No. 20783/2018 (XVI)

    IA No. 98802/2018 - EXEMPTION FROM FILING C/C OF THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT

    IA No. 98804/2018 - EXEMPTION FROM FILING O.T.)

    SLP(C) No. 26881/2018 (XVI)

    (IA No. 135146/2018-CONDONATION OF DELAY IN FILING and IA No. 135151/2018-EXEMPTION FROM FILING C/C OF THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT and IA No. 135150/2018-EXEMPTION FROM FILING O.T.)

    Date : 04-02-2020 These petitions were called on for hearing today.

    (Before Sanjay Kishan Kaul and K.M. Joseph, JJ.)

    For Petitioner(s) Mr. S.B. Upadhayay, Sr. Adv.

    Mr. Neeraj Shekhar, AOR

    Mr. Sumit Kumar, Adv.

    Mr. Rana Prashant, Adv.

    Mr. Heyshiv Parasher, Adv.

    For Respondent(s) Mr. Saket Singh, Adv.

    Mrs. Niranjana Singh, AOR

    Mr. Rohit K. Singh, AOR

    UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following

    14. Delay condoned in SLP [C] No. 26881/2018.

    15. Leave granted.

    16. The appeals are dismissed in terms of the signed order.

    17. Pending applications stand disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Md. Ali Imam And Others (S) v. State Of Bihar Thr. Its Chief Secretary And Others (S).
    (Feb 4, 2020)