Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 4 of the 2001 Rules
  • Rule 4 of the 2001 Rules,
  • Rule 8 of the 2001 Rules.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Rule 4 of the 2001 Rules
  • Rule 4 of the 2001 Rules,
  • Rule 8 of the 2001 Rules.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These Special Appeals arise from a common judgment dated 28 May 2004 by a learned Judge of the Court, which dismissed a batch of writ petitions filed by daily wage employees working in the Forest Department of the State of Uttar Pradesh on group ‘D’ posts. The writ petitions sought regularisation of their services under the U.P. Regularisation of Daily Wages Appointment on Group ‘D’ Posts Rules, 2001 (hereinafter "2001 Rules").

The writ petitions were categorized into three groups claiming: (i) regularisation of services after condoning artificial breaks in service; (ii) setting aside termination orders of daily wagers who did not meet 2001 Rules’ conditions and reconsidering their cases for regularisation; and (iii) payment of the minimum pay scale applicable to regularly appointed employees until regularisation.

The learned Judge considered the writ petitions in light of the Supreme Court’s directions in State of U.P. v. Putti Lal (2006) 9 SCC 337, directing authorities to consider cases for regularisation and to condone insignificant breaks of up to three months. The Judge rejected claims for payment of minimum pay scales and upheld termination of daily wagers who did not meet the eligibility criteria under Rule 4 of the 2001 Rules, particularly those lacking requisite qualifications at the time of initial engagement, as per Rule 8 of the 2001 Rules. The only relief granted was condonation of artificial breaks in service, which the State did not challenge.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether daily wage employees working on group ‘D’ posts in the Forest Department are entitled to regularisation of their services under the 2001 Rules despite artificial breaks in service.
  2. Whether the minimum qualifications prescribed under relevant service rules at the time of initial engagement are mandatory for consideration of regularisation under the 2001 Rules.
  3. Whether daily wage employees are entitled to payment of the minimum pay scale applicable to regular employees until their services are regularised.
  4. Whether physical endurance requirements prescribed under service rules are applicable to daily wage employees seeking regularisation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The learned Judge erred in requiring daily wagers to possess minimum qualifications prescribed under the relevant service rules at the time of their initial engagement for regularisation under the 2001 Rules.
  • The physical endurance requirements prescribed under service rules should not apply to daily wage employees for regularisation.
  • Until their cases are considered under the 2001 Rules, daily wage employees are entitled to be paid the minimum pay scale applicable to regular employees.
  • Reliance was placed on the decision of a learned Judge dated 17 October 2005 in Sanjay Kumar Srivastava v. Principal Chief Conservator of Forest (2005) 3 UPLBEC 2527 and other Supreme Court decisions referenced therein.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of U.P. v. Putti Lal (2006) 9 SCC 337 Directions for regularisation of daily wage employees and consideration of breaks in service. The Court referred to these directions to direct authorities to consider cases for regularisation and condone insignificant breaks of up to three months.
Sanjay Kumar Srivastava v. Principal Chief Conservator of Forest (2005) 3 UPLBEC 2527 Entitlement of daily wage employees to minimum pay scale and regularisation criteria. Appellants relied on this precedent to argue for payment of minimum pay scale and against qualification requirements; the Court considered but ultimately did not uphold these contentions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the writ petitions by first applying the Supreme Court’s directions in State of U.P. v. Putti Lal, emphasizing compliance with Rule 4 of the 2001 Rules. The Court directed authorities to consider cases for regularisation, allowing condonation of artificial breaks in service not exceeding three months.

Regarding claims for payment of minimum pay scale, the Court examined the principle of "equal pay for equal work" but found no basis in the 2001 Rules or Supreme Court decisions to direct payment of minimum pay scale to daily wage employees pending regularisation.

The Court upheld termination decisions for daily wagers who failed to meet eligibility criteria under Rule 4 of the 2001 Rules, particularly those lacking requisite qualifications at initial engagement, consistent with Rule 8 of the 2001 Rules. The Court rejected the appellants' contention that minimum qualifications and physical endurance requirements were not mandatory.

Finally, the Court referred to its judgment in Special Appeal No. 1530 of 2007, which set aside directions allowing continuation of daily wagers and payment of minimum pay scale until reconsideration, holding such directions to be without jurisdiction.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED all the Special Appeals, thereby affirming the learned Judge’s order dated 28 May 2004.

The direct effect of this decision is that daily wage employees who do not meet the minimum qualifications prescribed under the relevant service rules at the time of initial engagement are not entitled to regularisation under the 2001 Rules, and are not entitled to payment of minimum pay scale pending regularisation. The only relief sustained was condonation of minor breaks in service. No new legal precedent was established beyond affirming the application of existing rules and Supreme Court directions.

    Raj Kumar Ram v. State Of U.P. & Others

    1. All these Special Appeals arise out of a common judgment and order dated 28 May 2004 of a learned Judge of this Court by which batch of writ petitions that had been filed by daily wage employees working in the Forest Department of the State on group ‘D’ posts for regularisation of their services under the provisions of U.P. Regularisation of Daily Wages Appointment on Group ‘D’ Posts Rules, 2001 2001 Rules have been dismissed.

    2. Three categories of writ petitions, as has been stated by the learned Judge, had been filed and the reliefs that had been claimed in the writ petitions were basically for: (i) regularisation of the services of daily wage employees in the Forest Department working on group ‘D’ posts in accordance with 2001 Rules after condoning the artificial break; (ii) setting aside the orders passed for termination of services of such daily wagers who did not satisfy the conditions set out in the 2001 Rules and for reconsidering their cases for regularisation; and (iii) placing the daily wagers in the minimum of the pay scale of the regularly appointed persons till their services were not regularised by the Department.

    3. The learned Judge first considered the cases of such daily wage employees who had filed the writ petitions for a direction upon the respondents to consider their cases for regularisation in accordance with the directions issued by the Supreme Court in State of U.P. v. Putti Lal (2006) 9 SCC 337. The learned Judge after referring to the provisions of Rule 4 of the 2001 Rules expressed a hope that the concerned authority will comply with the statutory rules and dispose of the cases within two months. It was, however, also directed that the authorities shall ignore any insignificant break in service of not more than three months for examining whether they had been continuously working since prior to the cut-off date upto the date of implementation of the Rules.

    4. The learned Judge then examined the cases of such daily wage employees who had claimed that they should be paid the minimum of the pay scale applicable to group ‘D’ employees and in this connection the principle “equal pay for equal work” was considered. After taking into consideration the provisions of 2001 Rules and the decisions of the Supreme Court, the learned Judge held that the Court cannot issue any direction for payment of the minimum of the pay scale.

    5. In respect of the batch of writ petitions where the claim for regularisation had been rejected as the Selection Committee had found as a fact that the daily wagers did not satisfy the requirement set out in Rule 4 of the 2001 Rules, the learned found no illegality in the decision so taken for termination of the engagement of such daily wagers in accordance with Rule 8 of the 2001 Rules. It needs to be noted that these group of daily wagers did not possess the requisite qualification under the relevant service rules at the time they were initially engaged as daily wagers.

    6. Thus, the only relief that had been granted by the learned Judge in the batch of writ petitions was for condoning the artificial breaks in the service. The State did not question this direction of the learned Judge.

    7. We have heard Sri Pankaj Srivastava, learned counsel appearing for the appellants and Sri C.B. Yadav, learned Additional Advocate General assisted by Sri Shashank Shekhar Singh, learned Additional Chief Standing Counsel for the State-respondents.

    8. Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the learned Judge was not justified in insisting that the daily wagers who were considered for regularisation under the 2001 Rules should have possessed the minimum qualifications prescribed under the relevant service rules at the time they were initially engaged nor were they required to satisfy the physical endurance requirements prescribed under the service rules. Learned counsel also submitted that till such time as the cases of daily wagers were considered under the 2001 Rules, the daily wagers were entitled to be paid the minimum of the pay scale. In support of his contention, learned counsel for the appellants placed reliance upon the decision rendered by a learned Judge on 17 October 2005 in Sanjay Kumar Srivastava v. Principal Chief Conservator of Forest (2005) 3 UPLBEC 2527 and other decisions of the Supreme Court referred to in the said judgment.

    9. Special Appeal No. 1530 of 2007, which has been filed by the State of Uttar Pradesh to assail the judgment and order dated 17 October 2005 rendered in the batch of writ petitions has been decided by us by judgment of date.

    10. It has been held that the directions issued by the learned Judge to the State Government, while partly allowing the writ petition, to reconsider the cases of the writ petitioners for regularisation of their services by ignoring the minimum educational qualifications or the physical endurance requirement prescribed in the service rules with a further direction that until then all the petitioners who were still working should be allowed to continue on a daily wage basis and be paid the minimum of the pay-scale, could not have been issued and were, accordingly, set aside.

    11. Thus, for all the reasons stated in the judgment rendered in Special Appeal No. 1530 of 2007, all the Special Appeals are liable to be dismissed and are accordingly, dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raj Kumar Ram v. State Of U.P. & Others
    (Sep 24, 2015)