Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 356 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Clause (2) of Article 356 of the Constitution
  • Clause (3) of Article 187 of the Constitution of India
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 356 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Clause (2) of Article 356 of the Constitution
  • Clause (3) of Article 187 of the Constitution of India
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Special Leave Petitions (SLP (C) No. 11567 of 2016 and connected matters) arise out of the judgment dated 21-4-2016 of the High Court of Uttarakhand in Harish Chandra Singh Rawat v. Union of India, which had quashed the Presidential Proclamation dated 27-3-2016 imposing President’s Rule in the State of Uttarakhand under Article 356 of the Constitution. The Union of India challenged that judgment before the Supreme Court.

From 22-4-2016 to 12-7-2016, the Supreme Court issued a series of interim orders. Initially it:

  • Granted exemption from filing certified copies and issued notice in the SLPs;
  • Stayed operation of the High Court’s judgment and directed that the Presidential Proclamation would not be revoked pending further orders;
  • Fixed successive dates for hearing and allowed the Union of India to amend its petition once the High Court judgment was on record.

After hearing the Attorney General, counsel for the dismissed Chief Minister (Respondent 1) and counsel for the Speaker, the Court suggested— and eventually ordered — that a floor test be conducted in the Uttarakhand Legislative Assembly under the Court’s supervision. The floor test was held on 10-5-2016; the result (33 votes for Respondent 1 out of 61 eligible votes) was placed before the Court in a sealed cover on 11-5-2016. Accepting the uncontested result, the Court permitted the Union of India to revoke President’s Rule the same day. The larger constitutional question concerning the validity of the 27-3-2016 Proclamation, as well as the disqualification of nine MLAs, was kept open for final adjudication, and the matters were listed for further hearing on 24-8-2016 after completion of pleadings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Presidential Proclamation dated 27-3-2016 imposing President’s Rule in Uttarakhand was constitutionally valid within the scope of judicial review under Article 356.
  2. What interim arrangement would best preserve democratic governance pending a final decision—specifically, whether the Court could order and supervise a floor test of the Assembly.
  3. Whether the nine disqualified Members of the Legislative Assembly were entitled to participate in the confidence vote, and what effect their disqualification might have on the ultimate outcome.

Arguments of the Parties

Union of India (Petitioners)

  • Sought interim stay of the High Court judgment and undertook not to revoke the Presidential Proclamation during pendency of the proceedings.
  • Ultimately “had no objection” to a Court-supervised floor test as a means to resolve the controversy and requested time to obtain instructions, later consenting to the procedure.
  • Requested modification of the order dated 6-5-2016 to substitute the “Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs” (a District-Judge-cadre officer) for the “Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly” as neutral observer during the floor test.
  • After the floor test, prayed for liberty to revoke President’s Rule, describing the Union as “wedded to the concept of democracy.”

Respondent 1 – Shri Harish Chandra Singh Rawat (Dismissed Chief Minister)

  • Did not object to a floor test supervised by the Supreme Court.
  • Opposed inclusion of an “outsider” (Principal Secretary, Legislative & Parliamentary Affairs) inside the Assembly, contending that only the Secretary, Legislative Assembly, appointed under Article 187(3), should oversee the voting.
  • Accepted the result of the floor test and sought restoration to office upon revocation of President’s Rule.

Speaker of the Uttarakhand Legislative Assembly (Intervener)

  • Supported Respondent 1’s position regarding internal Assembly procedure and the role of the Secretary, Legislative Assembly.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jagdambika Pal v. Union of India, (1999) 9 SCC 95 Power of the Supreme Court to direct and structure a composite floor test to ascertain majority support in the Assembly. Used as precedent for convening a special session with a single agenda (confidence vote) under the Court’s supervision.
Anil Kumar Jha v. Union of India, (2005) 3 SCC 150 Permissibility of directing video recording of Assembly proceedings without appointing an observer. Court borrowed language and methodology for ordering videography and preserving an objective record of the vote.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

In a series of interim orders, the Court balanced two constitutional imperatives: (i) safeguarding democratic governance in the State, and (ii) preserving the Union’s right to justify the Proclamation under Article 356.

  1. Initially, the Court stayed the High Court judgment to maintain status quo but restrained the Union from revoking President’s Rule to avoid fait accompli.
  2. Recognising that a definitive decision on Article 356 would take time, the Bench explored a practical solution—the floor test—to determine which political faction enjoyed majority support, citing Jagdambika Pal.
  3. After all parties consented, the Court framed detailed, neutrality-enhancing modalities: fixed date and time, single agenda, police protection, videography, and sealed-cover reporting.
  4. When doubt arose about the neutrality of the designated official, the Court modified its earlier order, appointing both the Secretary, Legislative Assembly and the Principal Secretary, Legislative & Parliamentary Affairs (a District-Judge-cadre officer) to oversee voting, thereby ensuring “perceptible objectivity.”
  5. Post-vote, the Court opened the sealed results in open court, found no irregularities, and accepted that Respondent 1 had secured 33 of 61 valid votes.
  6. Given the undisputed outcome, the Court varied its earlier restraint order, allowing the Union of India to revoke President’s Rule, while expressly keeping alive the legal issue of the Proclamation’s validity and the pending challenge to the MLAs’ disqualification.

Holding and Implications

INTERIM DIRECTIONS CONFIRMED. The Supreme Court:

  • Validated the Court-supervised floor test held on 10-5-2016 and accepted its result (majority in favour of Respondent 1).
  • Granted liberty to the Union of India to revoke the 27-3-2016 Presidential Proclamation, paving the way for Respondent 1 to resume office as Chief Minister.
  • Kept pending for final adjudication the constitutionality of the original Proclamation and the validity of the nine MLAs’ disqualification, scheduling the matters for detailed hearing on the merits.

Implications: The immediate effect was restoration of an elected government in Uttarakhand. No final precedent on Article 356 was set at this stage; however, the orders reinforce the Supreme Court’s willingness to employ innovative, court-supervised floor tests as an equitable interim remedy to uphold democratic norms while larger constitutional questions remain sub judice.

    Union Of India v. Harish Chandra Singh Rawat And Another

    (2016) 16 SCC 748(1)

    Order dated 22-4-2016

    (Before Dipak Misra and Shiva Kirti Singh, JJ.)

    SLP (C) No. … (CC No. 7913 of 2016) with SLPs (C) Nos. … (CCs Nos. 7915-16 of 2016)

    SLP (C) No. … (CC No. 7913 of 2016)

    1. Applications for exemption from filing certified copy as well as plain copy of the impugned order 2016 SCC OnLine Utt 502 and permission to file the special leave petition without certified copy as well as plain copy of the impugned order are allowed. Issue notice.

    2. As Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel along with Mr Amit Bhandari, learned counsel has entered appearance on behalf of Respondent 1, no further notice need be issued. As far as Respondent 2 is concerned, let service be effected through dasti.

    3. Let the matter be listed on 27-4-2016. The High Court is requested to provide the judgment dated 21-4-2016, passed in Harish Chandra Singh Rawat v. Union of India 2016 SCC OnLine Utt 502, to the parties by 26-4-2016. The judgment shall be filed before this Court on that day.

    4. Having heard Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for the Union of India, Mr Harish N. Salve, learned Senior Counsel for the Union of India in connected special leave petitions, Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel for Respondent 1 and Mr Kapil Sibal, learned Senior Counsel for the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly, Uttarakhand, it is directed that the judgment of the High Court shall remain in abeyance till 27-4-2016. That apart, as undertaken by Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General, the Union of India shall not revoke the Presidential Proclamation till the next date of hearing.

    SLPs (C) Nos. … (CCs Nos. 7915-16 of 2016)

    5. Let these special leave petitions be listed on 27-4-2016.

    (2016) 16 SCC 748(2)

    Order dated 27-4-2016

    (Before Dipak Misra and Shiva Kirti Singh, JJ.)

    SLP (C) No. 11567 of 2016 with SLPs (C) Nos. … (CCs Nos. 7915-16 of 2016)

    6. Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General, submits that as the judgment passed by the High Court has been filed, he will amend the special leave petition by filing an application for amendment by 29-4-2016. A copy of the special leave petition incorporating the amendments, after serving copies on the learned counsel for the parties, shall be filed on that date. Reply, if any, be filed by 2-5-2016. Needless to say, the parties are at liberty to file documents in support of their contentions. We may hasten to clarify that the documents mean the documents that were filed before the High Court and nothing else, unless specifically permitted by this Court.

    7. Let the matter be listed on 3-5-2016. As agreed to by the learned counsel for the parties, it shall be taken up at 2.00 p.m.

    8. The interim order passed on the earlier occasion to remain in force till the next date of hearing.

    (2016) 16 SCC 749 (1)

    Order dated 4-5-2016

    (Before Dipak Misra and Shiva Kirti Singh, JJ.)

    SLP (C) No. 11567 of 2016 with SLPs (C) Nos. … (CCs Nos. 7915-16 of 2016)

    9. Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for India submitted that the Union of India is seriously considering the suggestion given by this Court to have a floor test of the Assembly to put an end to the controversy that has emerged in this case. Dr A.M. Singhvi, Mr Kapil Sibal and Dr Rajeev Dhavan, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the 1st respondent submitted that they have no objection, if the Union of India will accept the said suggestion so that there can be a floor test. Mr Rohtagi, learned Attorney General prays for time till 6-5-2016.

    10. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, we are inclined to grant time till 6-5-2016. However, if the learned Attorney General for India does not obtain appropriate instructions accepting the suggestion, the hearing shall commence on that day.

    11. List the matter on 6-5-2016 as the first item on the board. Interim order to remain in force.

    (2016) 16 SCC 749(2)

    Order dated 6-5-2016

    (Before Dipak Misra and Shiva Kirti Singh, JJ.)

    SLP (C) No. 11567 of 2016 with SLPs (C) Nos. … (CCs Nos. 7915-16 of 2016)

    SLP (C) No. 11567 of 2016

    12. The present special leave petition is directed against the judgment and order dated 21-4-2016, passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in Harish Chandra Singh Rawat v. Union of India 2016 SCC OnLine Utt 502, whereby the Division Bench has quashed the order of Proclamation dated 27-3-2016, issued by the President of India under Article 356 of the Constitution of India. We need not advert to any of the facts that have been adumbrated in the said judgment, for the nature of the order we are passing today. That is for another day.

    13. When the special leave petition was taken up on 22-4-2016 the Court issued notice and passed the following order:

    “1. Issue notice.
    2. As Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel along with Mr Amit Bhandari, learned counsel has entered appearance on behalf of Respondent 1, no further notice need be issued. As far as Respondent 2 is concerned, let service be effected through Dasti.
    3. Let the matter be listed on 27-4-2016. The High Court is requested to provide the judgment dated 21-4-2016, passed in Harish Chandra Singh Rawat v. Union of India 2016 SCC OnLine Utt 502, to the parties by 26-4-2016. The judgment shall be filed before this Court on that day.
    4. Having heard Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for the Union of India, Mr Harish N. Salve, learned Senior Counsel for the Union of India in connected special leave petitions, Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel for Respondent 1 and Mr Kapil Sibal, learned Senior Counsel for the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly, Uttarakhand, it is directed that the judgment of the High Court shall remain in abeyance till 27-4-2016. That apart, as undertaken by Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General, the Union of India shall not revoke the Presidential Proclamation till the next date of hearing.”

    14. Be it stated, after the said order was passed, the judgment passed by the High Court was brought on record and the petitioner had sought time to amend the special leave petition to incorporate the grounds assailing the defensibility of the same and the same was permitted. The matter was adjourned thereafter and when it was listed on 4-5-2016, regard being had to the oral suggestion given on the prior date, Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General, submitted that the Union of India was seriously considering the suggestion given by this Court to have a floor test of the Assembly to put an end to the controversy that has emerged in this case. Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Mr Kapil Sibal and Dr Rajeev Dhavan, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent 1 submitted that they had no objection. The matter was accordingly adjourned and the interim order was allowed to remain in force.

    15. Today, Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for the Union of India, has submitted that the petitioners have no objection to have a floor test of the Assembly. The learned counsel appearing for both the sides have debated over the suggestions that have been given by the Court, as well as by each other, sometimes with appreciable amity and sometimes with some cavil, but, eventually, there has been an agreement.

    16. Be it noted, the learned counsel appearing for Respondent 1, very fairly stated, which was conceded to by Mr Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for the Union of India, that they have no objection and we state it with uninhibited appreciation at our command that the floor test should be conducted under the supervision of this Court. The agreed position which has emerged after quite a long debate, is recorded below:

    16.1. A Special Session of Uttarakhand Legislative Assembly be summoned/convened on 10-5-2016, commencing 11.00 a.m.

    16.2. The only agenda in the Assembly would be the vote of confidence sought by Respondent 1, namely, Shri Harish Singh Rawat.

    16.3. Apart from the said agenda, nothing else shall be discussed in the Assembly.

    16.4. The proceedings in the Assembly are expected to be absolutely peaceful and without any disturbance. This Court expects that all the Members and all concerned with the affairs of the Assembly shall abide by the same in letter and spirit.

    16.5. The Chief Secretary and the Director General of Police, State of Uttarakhand, shall see that all the qualified Members of the Legislative Assembly, freely, safely and securely attend the Assembly and no interference or hindrance is caused by anyone therein.

    16.6. Mr Maninder Singh, learned Senior Counsel, being assisted by Mr Gaurav Sharma, learned counsel appearing for the State of Uttarakhand, shall convey it to the Chief Secretary and the Director General of the Police of the State of Uttarakhand so that the order is carried out as directed hereinabove, because it is the duty of the State and its high officials to take care to do so.

    16.7. The Assembly Session shall commence at 11.00 a.m. for the singular agenda, that is, the floor test of the Assembly and shall be over by 1.00 p.m.

    16.8. On the confidence motion having been put, a division of the House shall take place and the Members who are inclined to vote in favour of the motion, shall sit on the one wing/side and the others who are against the motion, shall sit on the other wing/side.

    16.9. The Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand, shall see to it that the voting is appositely done and recorded.

    16.10. The Members voting in favour of the motion shall singularly vote by raising their hands one by one and that will be counted by the Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly. Similar procedure shall be adopted while the Members voting against the motion.

    16.11. The entire proceedings shall be videographed and the video recording shall be placed before this Court so that it can be perused by this Court, if required.

    16.12. The result of the voting shall be placed before this Court at 10.30 a.m. on 11-5-2016, in a sealed cover.

    17. Having stated about the mode of voting, computation, the person in-charge and also the control to be made outside the House, the smooth functioning and entry of the Members, we are obliged to record the submission of Mr C.A. Sundaram, learned Senior Counsel, which has been done with immense vehemence. His submission is that the disqualified Members should be allowed to vote, though their votes may not be counted as long as the disqualification remains. This Court cannot direct them to participate in the Assembly. We say no more on this score. However, our observation in praesenti will not cause any kind of prejudice to the merits of the case of disqualified Members of Legislative Assembly, which is sub judice before the High Court.

    18. As the parties have conceded for the floor test and we have recorded the method, to give effect to the same, there has to be a variation of the order passed by us on the earlier occasion and, accordingly, we direct that Presidential Proclamation shall remain in abeyance from 10.30 a.m. to 1.00 p.m. on 10-5-2016, and during that period the Governor shall remain in charge of the State. Needless to say, after 1.00 p.m. the judgment of the High Court shall remain in abeyance and our order passed on 22-4-2016, shall revive.

    19. Let the matter be listed on 11-5-2016.

    20. The Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand, shall come on that day with the documents in the sealed cover and the video recording of the proceedings.

    21. The Registrar (Judicial) is directed to communicate this order to the Chief Secretary of the State of Uttarakhand. A copy of the order be also handed over to Mr Maninder Singh, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the State of Uttarakhand, to do the needful in the matter.

    SLPs (C) Nos. … (CCs Nos. 7915-16) and SLP (C) No. … (CC No. 7916 of 2016)

    22. Let these matters be listed on 11-5-2016.

    (2016) 16 SCC 752

    Order dated 9-5-2016

    (Before Dipak Misra and Shiva Kirti Singh, JJ.)

    SLP (C) No. 11567 of 2016 with SLPs (C) Nos. … (CCs Nos. 7915-16 of 2016)

    23. On being mentioned, the matter is taken on board. On 6-5-2016, this Court, after taking note of the order passed on 22-4-2016, had passed an order to which both the parties had agreed. It was also conceded that the floor test should be conducted under the supervision of this Court. Ordinarily, there should not have been any difficulty or occasion to mention. However, submits Mr Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for India, that in paras 9 and 10 of the order, this Court had stated about the role of the Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand. To have a complete picture, we think it appropriate to reproduce paras 16.9 and 16.10 of the previous order. They read as follows:

    “16.9. The Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand, shall see to it that the voting is appositely done and recorded.
    16.10. The Members voting in favour of the motion shall singularly vote by raising their hands one by one and that will be counted by the Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly. Similar procedure shall be adopted while the Members voting against the motion.”

    24. It is urged by Mr Rohatgi that a communication was sent to the Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand and a reply has been received from the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, State of Uttarakhand on 7-5-2016 indicating, inter alia, that there is no post of Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand but there is a post which is called Secretary, Legislative Assembly and there is another post called the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, State of Uttarakhand. The learned Attorney General would submit that this Court desired to have a neutral personality to remain present at the time of voting and an impression was given that the Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand, is from the cadre of Higher Judicial Service of the State and, therefore, a necessity has arisen for modification of the order.

    25. Mr Harish Salve, learned Senior Counsel, supporting the argument of Mr Rohatgi, would contend that in a situation like this, there has to be an arrangement by this Court so that voting takes place in the manner the Court has intended. He has pointed out certain aspects of the order to highlight that when situations like this emerge, different steps have been taken by this Court and this is one of such instance.

    26. Dr A.M. Singhvi, Mr Kapil Sibal and Dr Rajeev Dhavan, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the first respondent, have seriously opposed the prayer on the ground that there cannot be an outsider, namely, the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, State of Uttarakhand, inside the House. Emphasising his plea on the Rules made to guide the functioning of the House, it is urged that the Secretary, Legislative Assembly is appointed by the Speaker who has been authorised under the Uttarakhand Vidhan Sabha Secretariat Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2011 which have been framed under clause (3) of Article 187 of the Constitution of India. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the first respondent would contend that the persons who are outsiders will not be apt and it should be done by the Secretary, Legislative Assembly, who has a right to enter inside the House. It is also canvassed that the petitioners should not have any apprehension as the Court has directed the manner in which the voting shall take place, and also for video recording.

    27. First of all, it is obligatory on our part to recapitulate what transpired in Court on 6-5-2016. We think it necessary to do so. In course of hearing on that day, it was debated upon with regard to the status of the Principal Secretary of the Legislative Assembly and we were apprised that he is a member of the Higher Judicial Services of the State of Uttarakhand. Today, it has been told to us that he is not so. The present situation, if we allow ourselves to say so, is a piquant one. The Court ordinarily would not have directed for having a Session and direct Respondent 1 to prove the majority in the floor test.

    28. Be it noted, in Jagdambika Pal v. Union of India (1999) 9 SCC 95, the Court was under the constitutional obligation to innovate the method and accordingly, the following order was passed:

    “1. (i) A special session of the Uttar Pradesh Assembly be summoned/convened for 26-2-1998, the session commencing forenoon.
    (ii) The only agenda in the Assembly would be to have a composite floor test between the contending parties in order to see which out of the two contesting claimants of Chief Ministership has a majority in the House.
    (iii) It is pertinently emphasised that the proceedings in the Assembly shall be totally peaceful and disturbance, if any, caused therein would be viewed seriously.
    (iv) The result of the composite floor test would be announced by the Speaker faithfully and truthfully.
    2. The result is expected to be laid before us on 27-2-1998 at 10.30 a.m. when this Bench assembles again.”

    29. In Anil Kumar Jha v. Union of India (2005) 3 SCC 150, the language of which we had borrowed to some extent in the last order, the Court in para 6 had stated thus:

    “6. We are not inclined to appoint any observer for the proceedings on the Assembly to be held on 11-3-2005. However, we desire and accordingly request the pro tem Speaker of the Legislative Assembly to have the proceedings of the State Legislative Assembly as held on 11-3-2005 to be video recorded and send a copy of the video recording to this Court forthwith.”

    30. It is contended before us by the learned Senior Counsel for the first respondent with immense vigour that there should not be an observer as that would not be constitutionally permissible. The purpose is to save the sanctity of democracy which is the basic feature of our Constitution. This Court, being the sentinel on the qui vive of the Constitution is under the obligation to see that the democracy prevails and not gets hollowed by individuals. The directions which have been given on the last occasion, were singularly for the purpose of strengthening the democratic values and the constitutional norms. The collective trust in the legislature is founded on the bedrock of the constitutional trust. This is a case where one side even in the floor test does not trust the other and the other claims that there is no reason not to have the trust. Hence, there is the need and there is the necessity to have a neutral perceptionist to see that absolute objectivity is maintained when the voting takes place. Solely for the aforesaid purpose, we intend to modify the order by directing that the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs who belongs to the cadre of the District Judge shall remain present to conduct the affairs with perceptible objectivity and singularity of purpose of neutrality along with the Secretary, Legislative Assembly. The order is modified accordingly. We ingeminate it that we have so directed so that no party can raise a cavil with regard to the process of voting.

    31. A copy of the order be sent to the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, State of Uttarakhand, Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand and the Chief Secretary of the State of Uttarakhand by the Registry in course of the day. The learned counsel for the parties are requested to apprise the said authorities about the order passed today. The voting shall take place on 10-5-2016 as directed on the earlier occasion. Let the matter be listed as scheduled.

    (2016) 16 SCC 755

    Order dated 11-5-2016

    (Before Dipak Misra and Shiva Kirti Singh, JJ.)

    SLP (C) No. 11567 of 2016 with SLPs (C) Nos. … (CCs Nos. 7915-16 of 2016)

    32. In pursuance of orders dated 6-5-2016 and 9-5-2016, a special session of the Uttarakhand Assembly was convened on 10-5-2016 at 11.00 a.m. The proceedings of the floor test was appropriately observed by the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, Government of Uttarakhand and the Secretary, Legislative Assembly of Uttarakhand. Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for India along with Mr Tushar Mehta and Mr Maninder Singh, learned Additional Solicitors General for the Union of India and Mr Kapil Sibal, Dr A.M. Singhvi and Dr Rajeev Dhavan, learned Senior Counsel for the respondents, fairly submit that there has been no irregularity in carrying out the voting. We have opened the result of the voting that has been produced before us in a sealed cover by Mr Jaidev Singh, Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, Government of Uttarakhand. On a perusal of the same, we find that the first respondent has obtained 33 votes out of 61 votes. Be it clarified, nine Members of the Legislative Assembly could not vote as they stood disqualified as on that day and even today. Mr Jaidev Singh, Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, Government of Uttarakhand has apprised us that there was no irregularity in the voting procedure. We accept the same. We may hasten to clarify that the same position has been accepted by the learned Attorney General for India.

    33. At this juncture, it is submitted by the learned Attorney General that the order dated 22-4-2016 be modified so that the Union of India which is wedded to the concept of democracy, shall take steps for revocation of the proclamation of President's Rule. For the sake of completeness, we may reproduce the relevant part of the order dated 22-4-2016:

    “4. Having heard Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for the Union of India, Mr Harish N. Salve, learned Senior Counsel for the Union of India in connected special leave petitions, Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel for Respondent 1 and Mr Kapil Sibal, learned Senior Counsel for the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly, Uttarakhand, it is directed that the judgment of the High Court shall remain in abeyance till 27-4-2016. That apart, as undertaken by Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General, the Union of India shall not revoke the Presidential Proclamation till the next date of hearing.”

    34. Keeping in view the prayer made by the learned Attorney General, we vary the order by granting liberty to the Union of India to revoke the proclamation of President's Rule in the State of Uttarakhand in course of the day. Needless to say, after the Presidential Rule is revoked, the first respondent can assume the office of the Chief Minister of Uttarakhand.

    35. Two aspects we intend to clarify. One, the issue of justifiability of the proclamation of President's Rule that was made on 27-3-2016 which has been annulled by the impugned order passed by the High Court will remain alive, for the High Court has ascribed many a reasons to arrive at the conclusion that the said proclamation was not tenable in law. It required to be scrutinised whether within the scope of judicial review, such a finding could have been arrived at or for that matter whether the opinion arrived at by the President of India to proclaim the President's Rule at the relevant point of time was justified or not. We may hasten to add, we have directed for floor test on concession of the parties and we had varied the order today on a prayer being made by the Union of India.

    36. The second aspect that deserves mention is that nine Members of the Legislative Assembly have been disqualified. Their disqualification which has been upheld by the High Court is under assail before this Court in Special Leave Petition No. 14140 of 2016. This Court has declined to grant interim prayer for stay of the impugned order against the disqualified MLAs in the special leave petition on 9-5-2016. The said matter has been adjourned to 12-7-2016. What will be the effect, if in the ultimate eventuate case the disqualification is set at naught would be a matter of debate. We say nothing on that score at present.

    37. For the purpose of production of the order of revocation, let the matter be listed on 13-5-2016. On that date, a day shall be fixed for hearing of the special leave petitions on merits.

    (2016) 16 SCC 757

    Order dated 13-5-2016

    (Before Dipak Misra and Shiva Kirti Singh, JJ.)

    SLP (C) No. 11567 of 2016 with SLPs (C) Nos. … of 2016 (CCs Nos. 7915-16 of 2016), 14584 and 14497 of 2016

    SLP (C) No. 11567 of 2016, SLP (C) No. … of 2016 (CC No. 7915 of 2016) and SLP (C) No. … of 2016 (CC No. 7916 of 2016)

    38. In pursuance of our order dated 11-5-2016, Mr Tushar Mehta, learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the petitioner Union of India, has produced the Gazette Notification dated 11-5-2016. The proclamation therein reads as follows:

    “Proclamation
    In exercise of the powers conferred by clause (2) of Article 356 of the Constitution, I, Pranab Mukherjee, President of India, hereby revoke the Proclamation issued under the said Article on 27-3-2016, in relation to the State of Uttarakhand.”

    The said proclamation is kept on record.

    39. Let these petitions be listed for further hearing on 12-7-2016.

    SLP (C) No. 14584 of 2016

    40. Heard Mr C.A. Sundaram, learned Senior Counsel along with Mr E.C. Agrawala appearing for the petitioners. Issue notice.

    41. Mr Kapil Sibal, learned Senior Counsel along with Mr Mukesh Kumar Giri, learned counsel, has entered appearance on behalf of Respondent 1.

    42. Dr Rajeev Dhavan, learned Senior Counsel along with Mr Rahul Kaushik, learned counsel, has entered appearance on behalf of Respondent 2.

    43. Hence, service is complete.

    44. Let counter-affidavit be filed by the respondents within six weeks. List the matter on 12-7-2016.

    45. Mr C.A. Sundaram, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners, submits that the respondents are taking steps to evict the petitioners from their allotted accommodation in the capacity of Members of Legislative Assembly.

    46. Mr Kapil Sibal, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent 1, has disputed the same.

    47. Dr Rajeev Dhavan, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent 2 i.e. Minister for Parliamentary Affairs, submits that the petitioners shall not be vacated from the allotted accommodation in the capacity of Members of Legislative Assembly and no facilities in the accommodation shall be withdrawn. We so record.

    SLP (C) No. 14497 of 2016

    48. Issue notice. Let copy of the special leave petition be served upon the Standing Counsel for the State of Uttarakhand.

    49. Mr Mukesh Kumar Giri, learned counsel, appears and accepts notice on behalf of other respondents.

    (2016) 16 SCC 758

    Order dated 12-7-2016

    (Before Dipak Misra and C. Nagappan, JJ.)

    SLP (C) No. 11567 of 2016 with SLPs (C) Nos. … (CCs Nos. 7915-16 of 2016), 14497 and 14584 of 2016

    50. As prayed for by the learned counsel for the petitioner, let the matter be listed on 24-8-2016. In the meantime, the parties shall complete the pleadings from all aspects.

    Court Masters

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India v. Harish Chandra Singh Rawat And Another
    (Jul 12, 2016)