AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 125
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not mentioned in this excerpt.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 125
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not mentioned in this excerpt.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Gopal Prasad, brother of Ramesh Kumar (a partner of the firm “Kejriwal Films”), lodged Criminal Complaint No. 464 of 2001 before the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Barh. He alleged that Govind Prasad Kejriwal (appellant) and Balabhadra Prasad Kejriwal forcibly entered Savera Chitra Mandir cinema hall, removed equipment and documents, assaulted him, and threatened him. Offences cited included Sections 379, 323, 504, 506, 406, 452, 147, 148/34 IPC.

Prior to this complaint, the appellant had filed an FIR on 6-12-2001 alleging theft of a generator from the same premises; the police charge-sheeted, inter alia, the present complainant under Section 379 IPC.

The Magistrate initially dismissed Complaint No. 464/2001 on 14-2-2003. In revision, the Additional Sessions Judge set aside that dismissal on 1-12-2004 and remanded the matter for fresh inquiry. After recording one witness, the Magistrate took cognisance on 25-7-2005 only for Sections 323, 341 and 379 IPC and issued summons to the appellant.

The appellant’s first quashing petition (Cr. Misc. No. 34168/2005) was declined by the Patna High Court on 16-5-2006. His subsequent discharge application was rejected by the Magistrate on 4-8-2011; the High Court, by judgment dated 21-4-2017 (2017 SCC OnLine Pat 747), upheld that rejection. The appellant then approached the Supreme Court, resulting in the present appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the allegations in Complaint No. 464 of 2001, taken at face value, disclosed the essential ingredients of offences under Sections 323, 341 and 379 IPC against the appellant.
  2. Whether continuance of the criminal proceedings constituted an abuse of the process of law, warranting quashing under Section 482 CrPC.
  3. Whether the dispute between the parties was essentially civil in nature and, if so, whether criminal jurisdiction could be invoked.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The complaint seeks to convert a civil dispute over partnership and property into a criminal case, amounting to abuse of process.
  • Even accepting the complaint allegations, no ingredients of Sections 323, 341 or 379 IPC are satisfied.
  • The High Court failed to exercise its jurisdiction by not quashing proceedings that lack a criminal foundation.

Respondent (Original Complainant)’s Arguments

  • After inquiry under Section 202 CrPC, the Magistrate found a prima facie case; the scope of interference at the discharge stage is limited.
  • The complaint also alleges assault, attracting Section 323 IPC, independently justifying prosecution.
  • Defences raised by the appellant should be tested at trial; both the Magistrate and High Court correctly refused discharge.
  • Reliance placed on National Bank of Oman v. Barakara Abdul Aziz (2013) 2 SCC 488 to emphasise the limited nature of inquiry under Section 202 CrPC.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
National Bank of Oman v. Barakara Abdul Aziz (2013) 2 SCC 488 While conducting inquiry under Section 202 CrPC, the Magistrate must take a broad, prima facie view to decide whether to issue process. The Supreme Court held the precedent inapplicable because, even on a prima facie view, the complaint revealed a purely civil dispute and lacked ingredients of the alleged offences.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

After examining the complaint, previous litigation, and submissions, the Supreme Court reasoned as follows:

  • The complainant is not a partner of Kejriwal Films; his grievance relates to partnership affairs in which he has no direct stake.
  • The allegations primarily concern surrender of a cinema licence and removal of partnership property—matters of civil partnership dispute.
  • Essential ingredients of Sections 341 (wrongful restraint) and 379 (theft) IPC are missing; similarly, no specific facts support Section 323 (voluntary hurt).
  • Prior to the complaint, the appellant had itself lodged an FIR for theft, leading to charge-sheet against the complainant—indicating counter-blows in a civil dispute.
  • Civil proceedings (a title suit for dissolution and accounts) had already been pursued and withdrawn, reinforcing the civil nature of the controversy.
  • Continuing criminal prosecution would therefore amount to abuse of judicial process; powers under Section 482 CrPC should be exercised to prevent such abuse.
  • The revisional order remanding the case to the Magistrate contained no merits findings; hence, it did not bar quashing.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed; the order of the Magistrate taking cognisance and issuing summons, and the High Court’s order affirming it (2017 SCC OnLine Pat 747), are quashed. Criminal Complaint No. 464 of 2001 against the appellant stands set aside.

Implications: The appellant is discharged from all criminal proceedings arising from the complaint. The judgment underscores the Supreme Court’s readiness to invoke Section 482 CrPC to terminate prosecutions that merely cloak civil disputes in criminal allegations, thereby reinforcing safeguards against misuse of criminal law. No new legal doctrine is created, but the decision reiterates existing principles on abuse of process.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Govind Prasad Kejriwal (S) v. State Of Bihar And Another (S).

    M.R. Shah, J.— Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order dated 21-4-2017 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Patna in Govind Prasad Kejriwal v. State of Bihar 2017 SCC OnLine Pat 747 by which the High Court has dismissed the said quashing petition preferred by the original accused and has refused to quash the criminal proceedings in Complaint Case No. 464 of 2001 for the offences under Sections 323, 341 and 379 IPC, the original accused has preferred the present appeal.

    2. That the private respondent herein Gopal Prasad son of Shri Shyam S. Prasad, brother of one Ramesh Kumar — a partner of a firm called Kejriwal Films filed the criminal complaint being Complaint Case No. 464 of 2001 in the Court of Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Barh against the appellant herein — one of the partner of Kejriwal Films, for the offences under Sections 379, 323, 504, 506, 406, 452, 147, 148/34 IPC. The complaint reads as under:

    “1. That the complainant is the brother of Ramesh Kumar, who is a partner of a firm called Kerjiwal Films. The accused Balabhadra Prasad Kejriwal is also a partner in the said firm. Both the accused persons are father and son by relation.
    2. That the aforementioned Kejriwal Films has taken the Savera Chitra Mandir on lease and carry on their film business there, whose licence was taken in the name of Govind Prasad Kejriwal.
    3. That in order to cause loss to the complainant's brother and his partner Satyanarayan, both the accused persons had hatched a conspiracy and thereby had surrendered the cinema filming licence before the District Magistrate. As such, the cinema filming has been closed since 5-2-2000 and the building has been locked. The complainant and his brother were looking after the building from outside. The complainant's brother is staying outside for the last some days.
    4. That during the time of the occurrence, the complainant was going towards the market. When the complainant reached near the Savera Chitra Mandir, saw the gate open. Seeing the gates open, the complainant went inside the Savera Chitra Mandir and saw that the accused persons Govind Prasad Kejriwal and Balbhadra Prasad Kejriwal and 4-5 other unknown people have broken the lock of the cinema hall and its office and had kept their Maruti Car No. HR 51 D 8974 inside. The accused Govind Prasad Kejriwal was putting the documents of the cinema hall in a baggage. The accused Balbhadra Prasad Kejriwal was removing the electric fan and other machines by some other people. The accused Balabhadra Prasad Kejriwal himself was holding an electric starter in his hand.
    5. That when the complainant objected, the accused persons Govind Prasad Kejriwal and Balabhadra Prasad Kejriwal gave a kick to the complainant and threatened him to kill. The other unknown accused persons pointed their pistol on the complainant and drove him away from the cinema hall.
    6. That the accused persons Govind Prasad Kejriwal and Balabhadra Prasad Kejriwal kept the bag containing the documents in their car whose number is HR 51 D 8974. The other accused persons removed the fan, etc. and kept those in the car.
    7. That the accused persons Govind Prasad Kejriwal and Balabhadra Prasad Kejriwal and two unknown accused persons went towards the market in their car. They asked their other people to put their new lock in the cinema hall and threw the old locks. Then the other accused persons came out of the hall and fled in an autorickshaw towards the market.
    8. That those accused persons, with ill-intention, and to cause loss to the complainant's brother and partner Ramesh Kumar and with the intention to misappropriate the properties of partnership firm had entered inside the cinema hall by breaking its locks and taken away all the valuable instruments. They had broken the old lock of the cinema hall and put new locks in it and caused damage inside the hall driving out the complainant from the premises.
    9. That the complainant's brother had suffered a loss of Rs 50,000 due to this theft. There is possibility of causing irreparable loss on account of theft of important documents. The description of these documents can be known only when the complainant's brother arrives.
    10. That after the occurrence, the complainant had gone to the local police station to lodge a report thereof. But the police did not lodge the report. Then the complainant went to the Sub-Divisional Police Officer, but he did not accept the report of the complainant. There is illegal collusion between the police and the accused persons.
    Hence, it is being prayed to summon the accused persons and punish them adequately.”

    3. That the said complaint was filed on 19-12-2001. From the record it appears that prior thereto, a written report was lodged by the appellant herein — Govind Prasad Kejriwal, against Ramesh Kumar and others for the offence under Section 379 IPC. After the investigation, the IO filed the charge-sheet against all the four accused persons including the complainant herein and even Ramesh Kumar for the offence under Section 379 IPC. That the learned trial court has taken cognizance against all the accused persons including original private respondent herein — original complainant under Section 379 IPC. That the said trial is pending. That the complaint filed by the private respondent — original complainant herein — Gopal Prasad being Complaint No. 464 of 2001 came to be dismissed by the learned Judicial Magistrate vide order dated 14-2-2003. That the original complainant filed the revision application before the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Barh. Vide order dated 1-12-2004, the learned Sessions Judge, Barh allowed the said revision application and set aside the order passed by the learned Magistrate dated 14-2-2003 and remanded the case back to the learned Magistrate for further inquiry and to pass fresh order in accordance with law. That pursuant to the remand order, the complainant deposed one witness in support of his case. Thereafter the learned Magistrate vide order dated 25-7-2005 had taken cognizance against the appellant herein under Sections 323, 341 and 379 IPC, against the order passed by the learned Magistrate taking cognizance under Sections 323, 341, 379 IPC, the appellant herein preferred quashing petition before the High Court being Criminal Miscellaneous Application No. 34168 of 2005. That vide order dated 16-5-2006 Criminal Misc. No. 34168 of 2005, the High Court declined to interfere, however observed that the appellant is at liberty to move the learned lower court. That thereafter brother of the original complainant — Ramesh Kumar filed a title suit against the appellant and the partnership firm for dissolution of the partnership and rendition of accounts. That the said suit came to be dismissed, against which the first appeal was preferred by the said Ramesh Kumar which came to be dismissed as withdrawn vide order dated 17-1-2011. That thereafter the appellant filed an application for discharge. The learned Magistrate vide order dated 4-8-2011 rejected the prayer of the appellant for discharge. That thereafter the appellant filed an application before the High Court for quashing of order dated 4-8-2011 passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate rejecting the discharge application. Vide impugned judgment 2017 SCC OnLine Pat 747 and order the High Court has dismissed the said application and has refused to discharge the appellant and has refused to quash the criminal proceedings. Hence, the original accused has preferred the present appeal.

    4. Mr Pankaj Bhagat, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the appellant has vehemently submitted that in the facts and circumstances of the case the High Court has materially erred in dismissing the application and confirming the order passed by the learned trial court dismissing the discharge application.

    4.1. The learned advocate appearing on behalf of the appellant has vehemently submitted that the High Court has materially erred in not considering the facts and circumstances of the case and even considering the averments and the allegations in the complaint as they are, they do not constitute any offence against the appellant that too for the offences under Sections 323, 341, 379 IPC.

    4.2. It is further submitted by the learned advocate Mr Pankaj Bhagat that the High Court has not appreciated the fact that the complainant has tried to convert a civil dispute into criminal, which is nothing but an abuse of process of law and the court.

    4.3. It is submitted that therefore the High Court has materially erred in not exercising the jurisdiction vested in it.

    4.4. Making the above submissions it is prayed to allow the present appeal and consequently discharge the appellant by quashing and setting aside the order passed by the learned Magistrate as well as the High Court.

    5. The present appeal is vehemently opposed by Mr Pavan Kumar, learned advocate appearing for the original complainant. It is vehemently submitted by the learned advocate for Respondent 2 — original complainant that in the facts and circumstances of the case and more particularly when after holding the inquiry under Section 202 CrPC when the trial court has taken cognizance against the appellant for the offences under Sections 323, 341, 379 IPC, the learned trial court thereafter has rightly refused to discharge the appellant — original accused and the High Court has committed no error in confirming the order passed by the learned trial court taking cognizance and not discharging the accused.

    5.1. It is vehemently submitted by the learned advocate appearing on behalf of the original complainant that at the time of inquiry under Section 202 CrPC and at the time of taking cognizance, the trial court is required to hold a limited inquiry to satisfy itself whether there is any prima facie case. In support of his above submission, the learned counsel for the complainant has heavily relied upon the decision of this Court in National Bank of Oman v. Barakara Abdul Aziz (2013) 2 SCC 488.

    5.2. It is further submitted by the learned advocate appearing on behalf of the original complainant that in any case, the allegations are for the offence under Section 323 IPC also and the case is made out against the accused for the offence under Section 323 IPC also.

    5.3. It is further submitted that in fact earlier the learned Sessions Court set aside the order passed by the learned Magistrate dismissing the complaint and remanded the matter to the learned Magistrate. It is submitted thereafter on remand and after holding necessary inquiry the learned trial court has taken the cognizance against the accused. It is submitted therefore that no interference of this Court is called for in exercise of powers under Article 136 of the Constitution of India more particularly when both, the learned trial court and the High Court have refused to discharge the accused. It is submitted that whatever the submissions are made on behalf of the accused are his defences, which are required to be considered at the time of the trial.

    5.4. Making the above submissions it is prayed to dismiss the present appeal.

    6. Heard the learned advocates appearing on behalf of the respective parties at length.

    6.1. We have perused and considered the allegations made in the complaint as well as the order passed by the learned trial court taking cognizance against the accused. At the outset, it is required to be noted that summons have been issued against the accused for the offences under Sections 323, 341 and 379 IPC. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the respective parties and even considering/taking the allegations in the complaint as they are, we are of the opinion that initiation of criminal proceedings against the accused is nothing but an abuse of process of law and the court. A purely civil dispute is tried to be given the colour of criminal dispute.

    6.2. It is required to be noted that the original complainant, as such, has nothing to do with the partnership firm called Kejriwal Films. The original complainant claims to be the brother of one Ramesh Kumar who is a partner of the said partnership firm. The main allegations in the complaint are with respect to the partnership firm. Partner of the partnership firm has not made any complaint. The allegations in the complaint are with respect to surrender of cinema licence before the District Magistrate. Admittedly, one of the accused — Accused 2 is a partner in the aforementioned partnership firm. The appellant — Accused 1 is the son of the said partner — Balbadhadra Prasad Kejriwal. The appellant is issued summons for the offences under Sections 379 and 341 IPC along with for the offence under Section 323 IPC. None of the ingredients for making out the case under Sections 341 and 379 are satisfied. At this stage, it is required to be noted that prior to the impugned complaint/criminal proceedings, the appellant/petitioner lodged an FIR on 6-12-2001 alleging that one HMT Generator set was stolen from the premises of the cinema. In the said case, a charge-sheet has been filed against the private respondent herein Gopal Prasad and others for having committed the theft. It is also required to be noted that subsequently even one title suit was filed by the brother of the complainant — Ramesh Kumar against the partnership firm and its partners which came to be dismissed, against which an appeal was preferred which came to be withdrawn by the said Ramesh Kumar. Therefore, the impugned proceedings are nothing but an abuse of process of law and the court. A purely civil dispute is given a colour of criminal proceedings. As observed above, none of the ingredients of Sections 341 and 379 IPC, are satisfied.

    6.3. Even none of the ingredients of Section 323 IPC, are satisfied. Therefore, even considering the allegations in the complaint as they are, to continue the criminal proceedings against the accused even for the offence under Section 323 shall be an abuse of process of the court and the law. Therefore, we are of the opinion that this is a fit case to exercise the powers under Section 482 CrPC, and to quash the impugned criminal proceedings.

    6.4. Insofar as the reliance placed upon the decision of the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Barh, in Criminal Revision Application No. 31/235 of 2003 relied upon by the learned counsel for the complainant is concerned, it is required to be noted that in the said order there are no finding on merits by the learned Revisional Court. The Revisional Court had only remanded the matter back to the learned Judicial Magistrate for further inquiry and to pass a fresh order in accordance with law.

    6.5. Now so far as the reliance placed on the decision of this Court in National Bank of Oman v. Barakara Abdul Aziz (2013) 2 SCC 488 relied upon by the learned advocate appearing on behalf of the complainant is concerned, we are of the opinion that in the facts and circumstances of the case, the said decision shall not be of any assistance to the complainant. It cannot be disputed that while holding the inquiry under Section 202 CrPC the Magistrate is required to take a broad view and a prima facie case. However, even while conducting/holding an inquiry under Section 202 CrPC, the Magistrate is required to consider whether even a prima facie case is made out or not and whether the criminal proceedings initiated are an abuse of process of law or the court or not and/or whether the dispute is purely of a civil nature or not and/or whether the civil dispute is tried to be given the colour of criminal dispute or not. As observed hereinabove, the dispute between the parties can be said to be purely of a civil nature. Therefore, this is a fit case to quash and set aside the impugned criminal proceedings.

    7. In view of the reasons stated hereinabove, the present appeal succeeds. The order passed by the learned Magistrate taking cognizance against the accused and issuing the summons against the accused for the offences under Sections 341, 323 and 379 IPC and also the impugned judgment 2017 SCC OnLine Pat 747 and order passed by the High Court are hereby quashed and set aside. The impugned criminal proceedings initiated against the accused arising out of Criminal Complaint No. 464 of 2001 are hereby quashed and set aside.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Govind Prasad Kejriwal (S) v. State Of Bihar And Another (S).
    (Jan 31, 2020)