AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 102
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 79(c) of the Electricity Supply Act, 1948
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The 1976 Act
  • Article 309 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5 of the 1976 Act
  • Section 41 of the U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act, 1976
  • Section 9 of the Report
  • Section 41 of the U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973
  • Section 12 of the said Act
  • Section 3 of the U.P. Industrial Development Act, 1976
  • Section 19 of the 1976 Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 102
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 79(c) of the Electricity Supply Act, 1948
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The 1976 Act
  • Article 309 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5 of the 1976 Act
  • Section 41 of the U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act, 1976
  • Section 9 of the Report
  • Section 41 of the U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973
  • Section 12 of the said Act
  • Section 3 of the U.P. Industrial Development Act, 1976
  • Section 19 of the 1976 Act
Smart Summary

Supreme Court of India
Assistant Project Engineers (Electrical) v. State of U.P. & Ors.
(Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. —)

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 4, then serving as a Sub-Divisional Officer in U.P. Power Corporation Ltd., sought appointment to a vacant Group ‘A’ post of Project Engineer (Electrical) in the New Okhla Industrial Development Authority (“NOIDA”). At the State Government’s request (letter dated 13-2-2014), NOIDA issued an order on 19-2-2014 appointing him on deputation for three years. On 16-2-2015 the State Government recommended his absorption, and on 7-5-2015 he was formally absorbed.

The appellants, both Assistant Project Engineers (Electrical) in NOIDA, filed a writ petition before the Allahabad High Court, Lucknow Bench, challenging (i) the 16-2-2015 recommendation, (ii) the 19-2-2014 deputation order, and (iii) the 7-5-2015 absorption order, while also seeking directions to fill the post strictly under the NOIDA Service Regulations, 1981.

The High Court dismissed the writ petition on 8-2-2017. The appellants obtained special leave, and the present Supreme Court judgment decides their civil appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the recruitment of Respondent 4 to the post of Project Engineer (Electrical) on deputation, and his subsequent absorption, was permissible under the NOIDA Service Regulations, 1981.
  2. Whether the appellants were eligible for promotion to that post and, if ineligible, whether they possessed locus standi to challenge Respondent 4’s appointment and absorption.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • Regulation 16(2)(i) of the 1981 Regulations mandates that 66% of Group ‘A’ posts be filled by direct recruitment and 34% by promotion; deputation is impermissible for such posts, rendering the deputation/absorption illegal.
  • A 2005 Recruitment and Promotion Policy allegedly superseded earlier policies and prescribed 100% promotion for the Project Engineer post, eliminating deputation as a recruitment source.
  • Respondent 4, being an employee of U.P. Power Corporation and not of the Government, could not be absorbed under the U.P. Absorption Rules, 1984, which apply only to Government servants.

Respondents’ Arguments (State & NOIDA)

  • Regulation 16(1)(c) expressly recognises deputation as a recruitment mode for any post, including Group ‘A’. Reading clause 16(2)(i) in isolation would render 16(1)(c) redundant.
  • The 2005 Recruitment and Promotion Policy never received State approval because it conflicted with the 1981 Regulations; hence, Regulation 16 continues to govern.
  • The State Government absorbed Respondent 4 under the U.P. Absorption Rules, 1984 read with the 1987 Regulations framed under the Electricity Supply Act, 1948; therefore the absorption is lawful.
  • The appellants lacked the requisite eight years’ experience as Assistant Project Engineers and were ineligible for promotion when Respondent 4 was deputed/absorbed; accordingly, they suffer no legal injury and have no locus standi.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jasbhai Motibhai Desai v. Roshan Kumar (1976) 1 SCC 671; AIR 1976 SC 578 Defines “person aggrieved” and locus standi—one must show personal legal injury. Used to hold that appellants, being ineligible for promotion, suffered no personal legal injury and therefore lacked locus to challenge Respondent 4’s appointment.
Jamil Ahmed v. Industrial Development Commissioner (2004) 13 SCC 736 Protects an employee who has resigned from the parent department and been absorbed by NOIDA; such employee cannot be left without service status. Cited to emphasise that once Respondent 4 was absorbed and lien severed, he could not be placed in limbo; supports sustaining his absorption.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Harmonious Construction of Regulation 16: The Court read Regulation 16 as a whole. Clause 16(1)(c) explicitly permits recruitment “by deputation,” applicable to all Groups. Reading clause 16(2)(i) alone would nullify 16(1)(c), which is impermissible.

2. Status of 2005 Policy: Evidence showed the 2005 Recruitment and Promotion Policy never came into force because the State Government directed that it not contravene the 1981 Regulations. Therefore, Regulation 16 remains operative.

3. Statutory Power to Absorb: Regulation 2 of the 1981 Regulations anticipates deputationists and their possible absorption. Section 5 of the 1976 Act empowers NOIDA to appoint staff, subject to State control. No restriction was shown limiting deputation or absorption.

4. Legal Basis for Absorption: Respondent 4’s absorption order was issued by the State Government under (a) the U.P. Absorption Rules, 1984 (for Government servants) and (b) the 1987 Regulations under the Electricity Supply Act, 1948, which extend similar absorption rights to U.P. Power Corporation employees. By virtue of Regulation 80 of the 1981 Regulations and Section 41 of the Urban Planning and Development Act, State directions override contrary NOIDA rules.

5. Locus Standi of Appellants: The appellants lacked the mandatory eight years’ experience as Assistant Project Engineers at the relevant time (Appellant 1 eligible only in 2021; Appellant 2 only in 2017). Consequently, they were not in the zone of consideration and suffered no legal injury. Applying Jasbhai Motibhai Desai, the Court held they had no locus to challenge Respondent 4’s appointment.

6. Equity Considerations: Following Jamil Ahmed, the Court noted that Respondent 4 had severed lien with his parent department after absorption; unsettling his status years later would be inequitable.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed.

Direct Effect: The High Court’s dismissal of the writ petition stands affirmed; Respondent 4’s deputation and absorption remain valid. The appellants obtain no relief.

Broader Implications: The judgment clarifies that NOIDA’s Service Regulations, 1981 permit deputation and subsequent absorption for Group ‘A’ posts unless expressly curtailed. It reinforces the principle that employees lacking eligibility cannot litigate purely on theoretical promotional prospects. No new precedent is created beyond applying settled rules of statutory interpretation and locus standi.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Shripal Bhati And Another (S) v. State Of U.P. And Others (S).

    Krishna Murari, J.— Leave granted. This appeal has been preferred against the judgment of the High Court (High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench) dated 8-2-2017 2017 SCC OnLine All 2917 dismissing the writ petition filed by the appellants laying a challenge to the appointment of Respondent 4 on the post of Project Engineer (Electrical) on deputation in the New Okhla Industrial Development Authority (hereinafter referred to as “Noida”) and his subsequent absorption.

    2. The appellants are presently posted as Assistant Project Engineer (Electrical) in Noida.

    3. On a request made by Respondent 4, who was employed as a Sub-Divisional Officer with U.P. Power Corporation Ltd., seeking appointment on a vacant post of Project Engineer (Electrical) in Noida, the State Government, vide Letter dated 13-2-2014 required Noida to appoint him on the said post on deputation for a period of three years. In pursuance to the aforesaid letter, an appointment order dated 19-2-2014 was issued by Noida and Respondent 4 was permitted to join the said post. Subsequently, vide Letter dated 16-2-2015, Respondent 2 made a recommendation to Respondent 1 for absorption of Respondent 4. Aggrieved by the same, the appellants approached the High Court by way of a writ petition praying, inter alia, for:

    (i) Quashing the recommendation letter dated 16-2-2015 for absorption.
    (ii) Quashing letter dated 19-2-2014 appointing Respondent 4 on deputation on the post of Project Engineer (Electrical).
    (iii) Commanding the respondents to fill up the post of Project Engineer in accordance with Service Rules and to restrain Respondent 4 from functioning as Project Engineer (Electrical) in Noida.

    4. During the pendency of the writ petition before the High Court, Respondent 4 was absorbed on the post of Project Engineer (Electrical) vide order dated 7-5-2015, issued by Respondent 1. This order was challenged in the writ petition by way of an amendment application which was allowed 2015 SCC OnLine All 9607 by the High Court.

    5. Vide the impugned judgment dated 8-2-2017 2017 SCC OnLine All 2917, the High Court dismissed the writ petition.

    6. The core issue which arises for our consideration is whether the recruitment of Respondent 4 on the post of Project Engineer (Electrical) on deputation and his subsequent absorption on the said post is permissible under the Noida Service Regulations, 1981.

    7. Incidentally another issue which arises is whether the appellants are eligible for being promoted to the post on which Respondent 4 has been appointed and whether the appellant's right of promotion gets eclipsed by absorption of Respondent 4 and in case the appellants were not found eligible for promotion whether any challenge to appointment or absorption of Respondent 4 would be maintainable at their behest.

    8. Noida was constituted by the State Government by means of notification issued under Section 3 of the U.P. Industrial Development Act, 1976 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1976 Act”) enacted by the State Legislature to provide for constitution of an Authority for development of certain areas in the State, into industrial and urban township.

    9. Section 5 of the 1976 Act vests with the Authority the power to appoint officers/employees for performance of its functions including determining their grades and designations subject to control/restrictions of the State Government through general/special orders. Section 19 of the 1976 Act vests with the Authority the power to make regulations with the previous approval of the State Government.

    10. In exercise of powers vested under Section 19 of the 1976 Act, Noida has framed the New Okhla Industrial Development Authority Service Regulations, 1981 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1981 Regulations”) to govern the conditions of service of its employees. Regulation 16 of the 1981 Regulations provides for sources of recruitment to all posts. The same reads as under:

    “16. Sources of Recruitment.—(1) Recruitment to any post under the Authority may be made from any of the sources—
    (a) by direct recruitment;
    (b) by promotion from amongst the employees occupying post carrying a lower scale through a departmental test or an interview of selection or in any other manner specified by the Authority.
    (c) by deputation or re-employment or on contractual basis.
    (d) from any other source as approved by the Authority.
    (2)(i) Sixty-six per cent of Group ‘A’ posts shall be filled in by direct recruitment and the remaining thirty-four per cent posts shall be filled in by promotion from amongst the employees upon the basis of seniority subject to the rejection of the unfit and fulfilment of the requisite qualifications and also subject to the condition of the particular employee having worked for at least a period of two years on a post carrying scale of pay next below. If at any time it is found that sufficient number of employees are not available for filling in the percentage prescribed for promotion such posts may be filled in by direct recruitments;
    (ii) Various posts falling under Group ‘B’ will be filled in such a way as to ensure that fifty per cent of the posts are filled in the promotion from amongst the employees and such promotion shall be made on the basis of seniority subject to the rejection of the unfit and fulfilment of the requisite qualifications and also subject to the condition of the particular employee having worked on carrying the scale of pay next below for a period of at least two years;
    (iii) Posts under Group ‘C’ carrying lowest scale of pay shall be filled in to the extent of twenty-five per cent by promotion from amongst the employees belonging to Group ‘D’ on the basis of seniority subject to the rejection of the unfit and fulfilment of the requisite qualifications and also subject to the condition of the particular employee having worked on a post carrying a scale of pay next below for at least a period of two years. The remaining seventy-five per cent of such posts shall be filled in by direct recruitment;
    (iv) Notwithstanding anything hereinbefore contained the Authority shall have full power to modify the source of recruitment or the percentage of promotion or direct recruitment in relation to any posts or class of posts.”

    11. It has been contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that since, Clause 16(2) provides that 60% of Group ‘A’ posts are to be filled in by direct recruitment and remaining 34% by way of promotion from amongst the existing employees on the basis of seniority, the post of Project Engineer (Electrical) which is a Group ‘A’ post could not have been filled in by way of deputation and thus the appointment of Respondent 4 on the said post on deputation is illegal and directly in the teeth of the Service Regulations.

    12. The argument is based on an isolated reading of Regulation 16(2)(i) which is impermissible. It is well settled that a provision is required to be read in whole and not in part and in isolation to the other parts of the provision. The entire provision is required to be read out harmoniously. Regulation 16(i)(c) clearly provides that recruitment to any post under the Authority can be made by deputation. If the provisions of Regulation 16 are to be read in a manner suggested by the learned counsel for the appellant it would render Clause 16(i)(c) totally redundant. It is well-settled principle of law that any particular portion of provision cannot be read in isolation in a manner so as to render the other part of the same provision totally redundant. Similar situations exist under Clauses 16(2)(ii) and (iii) providing for appointment on post falling under Groups ‘B’ and ‘C’. If the provisions of Regulation 16 are read in the mode and manner suggested by the learned counsel for the appellant, the provisions of Section 16(i)(c) would be rendered totally redundant in respect of posts falling under Groups ‘B’ and ‘C’ as well. Regulation 16 is intended to provide the modes of recruitment and combined reading of the entire regulations makes it amply clear that an appointment to a post falling either under Groups ‘A’, ‘B’ and ‘C’ can very well be made on deputation.

    13. The learned counsel for the appellants further submitted that Noida had formulated a Recruitment and Promotion Policy in the year 1993, wherein the mode of recruitment provided was by way of promotion, direct recruitment and deputation. Subsequently, another Recruitment and Promotion Policy was framed in 2005, which provided that the post of Project Engineer in the Engineering cadre was required to be filled in 100% by promotion. Thus, the three sources of recruitment contemplated in the 1993 Policy were reduced to one source in the 2005 and thus, thereafter, no recruitment could have been made on the post of Project Engineer by way of deputation.

    14. In the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of Noida, it has been stated that the Recruitment and Promotion Policy, 2005 was sent for approval of the State Government. Vide Letter dated 18-10-2007, the State Government while clarifying that the Board is competent to frame its Recruitment and Promotion Policy directed Noida to ensure that the Policy is not inconsistent with the provisions of the 1981 Regulations. It is the specific case set up by Noida in its counter-affidavit that the Policy could not be implemented in view of the directions issued by the State Government, since the proposal to do away with direct recruitment to Group ‘A’ posts and to fill them only on the basis of promotion was inconsistent with the Noida Service Regulations 16(i)(c) of the 1981 Regulations. In view of the specific case set up by Noida that the 2005 Policy was never implemented being inconsistent with the 1981 Regulations and that no part of Regulation 16 of the 1981 Regulations has been amended till date, the reliance placed by the appellants upon the 2005 Policy is completely misplaced and erroneous. Regulation 16 as it stands (quoted hereinabove) holds field with regard to source of recruitment in the Authority. The State Government has taken the same stand in its counter-affidavit.

    15. Now coming to the issue of absorption of Respondent 4, Regulation 16 of 1981 expressly provides that recruitment can be made either by deputation or direct recruitment or from any other source. Regulation 2 deals with applicability of these Regulations and expressly provides for posting/recruitment on deputation basis and absorption of such persons in the service of Noida. It may be useful to extract Regulation 2, which reads as under:

    “2. Application.—These Regulations shall apply to every whole-time employee of the Authority except a person working with the Authority on deputation from the Union Government or any State Government or a Local Authority or a Corporation or any other organisation, by whatever name called, and such a person shall continue to be governed by the rules applicable to him in relation to his service under his parent department or organisation, by whatever name called unless such person is absorbed in the service of the Authority as a regular employee.”

    16. The decision to absorb Respondent 4 was taken by the State Government exercising the powers under the U.P. Absorption Rules, 1984 framed in exercise of the powers conferred by Article 309 of the Constitution of India. Rule 5 of the U.P. Absorption Rules, 1984 provides that any government servant may be permitted to be absorbed in the services of undertaking in which the employee is on deputation, if he applied to the Government for his absorption in the undertaking before expiry of three years from the date of commencement of his deputation or before the date on which he attains the age of 53 years, whichever is earlier, and the undertaking concerned also moved the Government for his absorption within such period and the Government agrees to such absorption in public interest.

    17. A specific stand has been taken by the State Government as well as Noida in the counter-affidavit that the State Government has exercised the power under the U.P. Absorption Rules, 1984 by issuing orders of absorption of Respondent 4 in Noida.

    18. The learned counsel for the appellants submits that Respondent 4 was employee of erstwhile U.P. Power Corporation which is not a government department hence, he was not a government employee and thus could not be absorbed in the service of Noida under the Absorption Rules, 1984 as the said Rules are applicable only in the case of a government employee. No doubt Respondent 4 was not a government servant and Absorption Rules are applicable only to a government servant, but the issue need not detain us for the reason that there are another set of Rules known as “Uttar Pradesh Rajya Vidyut Parishad Ke Sewako Ka Sashan Evam Anya Upkarmo Me Samvilayan Viniyam, 1987” (hereinafter referred to as “the 1987 Regulations”), which is a statutory Regulation framed under the provisions of Section 79(c) of the Electricity Supply Act, 1948, whereunder the employees of corporation can be absorbed in the service of the State Government or in other undertakings of the Government or corporations in the same manner as employees of the Government can be absorbed under the Absorption Rules, 1984.

    19. Reference at this stage may be made to provisions of Section 5 of the 1976 Act which reads as under:

    “5. Staff of the Authority.—(1) Subject to such control and restrictions as may be determined by general or special orders of the State Government, the Authority may appoint such number of officers and employees as may be necessary for the performance of its functions and may determine their grades and designations.
    (2) Subject as aforesaid the officers and other employees of the Authority shall be entitled to receive from the funds of the Authority, such salaries and allowances and shall be governed by such other conditions of service as may be agreed upon with the Authority.”

    20. From a perusal of the aforesaid provisions, it is clear that the power of appointment of officers and employees lies with the Authority subject to such control and restrictions as may be determined by the general or special orders of the State Government. The learned counsel for the appellants failed to place before us any such general or special orders of the State Government whereunder the power of appointment which includes power of appointment by deputation is restricted. Contrary thereto, Regulation 16(1)(c) of the 1981 Regulations gives express power to Noida to make appointment on deputation which is one of the sources recognised under the sources of recruitment. Once the deputation as a source of recruitment is available under the Rules of Recruitment, we do not see any impediment in assuming the power of absorption of a deputationist with the Authority by necessary intendment or implication, under the 1976 Act and the 1981 Regulations framed thereunder.

    21. Besides this, Regulation 80 of the 1981 Regulations provides that these Regulations are subject to the provisions of any rule made by the State Government under the 1976 Act as directions issued by the State Government under Section 41 of the U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973 or to the provisions of any other law made on the subject by an Act of Legislature of Uttar Pradesh or Parliament.

    21.1. Regulation 80 of the 1981 Regulations reads as under:

    “80. Regulation to be subject to rules, etc. of the State Government.—For the removal of doubt it is hereby declared that these Regulations shall be subject to any rules made by the State Government under the Act or any directions issued by the State Government under Section 41 of the U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973 or to the provisions of any other law made on the subject by an Act of the Legislature of Uttar Pradesh or Parliament.”

    21.2. Section 41 of the U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act reads as under:

    “41. Control by State Government.—(1) The (Authority), the Chairman or the (Vice-Chairman) shall carry out such directions as may be issued to it from time to time by the State Government for the efficient administration of this Act.
    (2) If in, or in connection with, the exercise of its powers and discharge of its functions by the (Authority, the Chairman or the Vice-Chairman) under this Act any dispute arises between the Authority, the Chairman or the Vice-Chairman and the State Government the decision of the State Government on such dispute shall be final.
    (3) The State Government may, at any time, either on its own motion or on application made to it in this behalf, call for the records of any case disposed of or order passed by the (Authority or the Chairman) for the purpose of satisfying itself as to the legality or propriety of any order passed or direction issued and may pass such order or issue such direction in relation thereto as it may think fit:
    Provided that the State Government shall not pass an order prejudicial to any person without affording such person a reasonable opportunity of being heard.
    (4) Every order of the State Government made in exercise of the powers conferred by this Act shall be final and shall not be called in question in any court.”

    Section 41 of the U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act, 1976 is applicable to the 1976 Act by virtue of Section 12 of the said Act.

    22. The 1987 Regulations having been framed under the provisions of Section 79(c) of the Electricity Supply Act, 1948, a parliamentary enactment authorising absorption of employees of erstwhile U.P. Power Corporation in government undertakings or other statutory corporations, in view of provisions of Section 80 of the 1981 Regulations read with Section 41 of the U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act, 1976, not only Respondent 2 is bound by every direction issued by the State Government from time to time, the appointment of Respondent 4 in Noida on deputation and his subsequent absorption under the orders of the State Government cannot be faulted with or can be held to be in violation of the 1981 Regulations. The first issue stands answered accordingly.

    23. The question of maintainability of challenge to appointment and subsequent absorption at the behest of the appellants has also been raised by the learned counsel for Respondents 2 and 3. It is vehemently contended that the appellant lacks requisite necessary qualifications for being considered for promotion to the post of Project Engineer (Electrical) and being ineligible for promotion any challenge to the appointment on the said post at their behest is not maintainable. It is pointed out that the eligibility for promotion to the post of Project Engineer is degree in Engineering with minimum 8 years of experience as Assistant Project Engineer.

    24. The specific case set up by Noida in its counter-affidavit is that Appellant 1 was appointed as Junior Engineer in 1987 and was promoted to the post of Assistant Project Engineer on 27-8-2013. Thus, he lacks necessary qualification of 8 years' experience and shall be eligible for being considered for promotion in 2021. Insofar as Appellant 2 is concerned, he was appointed on the post of Assistant Project Engineer in February 2009. As prescribed by the Service Regulations, he became eligible for being considered for promotion on completing 8 years of service in February 2017. Thus, at the time of appointment of Respondent 4 in 2014, and his subsequent absorption in 2015, both the appellants were not eligible for promotion to the post of Project Engineer for want of requisite 8 years' experience as Assistant Project Engineer.

    25. For the aforesaid facts and reasons, the challenge made by the appellants to the appointment and absorption of Respondent 4 is not tenable and they have no locus standi in the matter. It may be relevant to refer to the observations made by this Court in Jasbhai Motibhai Desai v. Roshan Kumar (1976) 1 SCC 671, AIR 1976 SC 578, relied upon by the High Court, holding that unless injury is suffered personally a person can not be said to be aggrieved and has no locus standi:

    “48. In the light of the above discussion, it is demonstrably clear that the appellant has not been denied or deprived of a legal right. He has not sustained injury to any legally protected interest. In fact, the impugned order does not operate as a decision against him, much less does it wrongfully affect his title to something. He has not been subjected to a legal wrong. He has suffered no legal grievance. He has no legal peg for a justiciable claim to hang on. Therefore, he is not a “person aggrieved” and has no locus standi to challenge the grant of the “no-objection certificate”.”

    26. There is yet another aspect of the matter liable to be taken into consideration, undisputedly after absorption of Respondent 4 in Noida, he was relieved from his parent department and his lien with the parent department ceased. Considering a somewhat similar controversy in Jamil Ahmed v. Industrial Development Commr. (2004) 13 SCC 736, where a Senior Inspector in Railway Protection Force was initially deputed to Noida and subsequently absorbed, this Court after analysing the provisions of the 1981 Regulations while holding the appointment on deputation and subsequent absorption in Noida was permissible, observed that such an employee cannot be put in a position which results in his being an employee neither of the Authority nor of the parent department. It may be relevant to reproduce observations made in para 9 of the Report:

    “9. On the facts and circumstances of this case, we need not go in depth into the question sought to be urged on behalf of the Authority, for, we are of the view that the appellant having resigned from the Railways and having been absorbed in the Authority eight years back, cannot be put in a position, for no fault of his, which results in his being an employee neither of the Authority nor of the parent department. The appellant cannot be made to suffer for the discrepancy, if any, assuming there is any such discrepancy which is now pleaded as a reason by the Authority.”

    27. As a result of our aforesaid discussion, we do not find any merit in this appeal and the same, accordingly, stands dismissed with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shripal Bhati And Another (S) v. State Of U.P. And Others (S).
    (Jan 29, 2020)