AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 8
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 148, Section 120-B, Section 302 read with Section 149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2020 INSC 8
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 148, Section 120-B, Section 302 read with Section 149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 2 lodged FIR No. 155/2019 at Karimnagar Rural Police Station under Sections 148, 120-B, 302 read with 149 of the Indian Penal Code alleging that the appellants, whose memberships in the Fishermen Co-operative Society of Chamanapalli had been cancelled, attacked and killed her husband, Bojja Thirupathi, on 19-4-2019 near a village tank. Three years earlier, the same appellants had allegedly assaulted the deceased and were facing a criminal case for that incident.

The appellants applied for bail before the Principal Sessions Judge, Karimnagar, who—after perusing the case diary and witness statements—granted bail subject to stringent conditions, including appearance at the local police station on alternate days and a prohibition on leaving the court’s territorial jurisdiction.

Respondent 2 then sought cancellation of bail under Section 439(2) CrPC before the High Court for the State of Telangana. After the police filed a charge-sheet on 10-7-2019 (attributing a specific overt act only to A-6), the High Court, by judgment reported as 2019 SCC OnLine TS 2259, cancelled the appellants’ bail on the grounds that the Sessions Court had not adequately considered the material on record, the appellants’ criminal antecedents, and allegations that they were threatening witnesses.

The present appeals challenge the High Court’s order before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in cancelling the appellants’ bail under Section 439(2) CrPC on the ground that the Sessions Court’s order was perverse or suffered from serious infirmities.
  2. Whether subsequent allegations of witness intimidation by the appellants constituted sufficient cause for cancellation of bail.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • No specific overt act was attributed to most appellants; allegations in the charge-sheet were largely omnibus.
  • The complaint of witness intimidation was vague and lacked particulars, rendering it an unreliable basis for cancellation.
  • The Sessions Court had considered the entire record before granting bail; therefore, the High Court lacked compelling reasons to interfere.

Respondent 2's Arguments

  • The Sessions Court failed to consider crucial material, including the appellants’ criminal antecedents, before granting bail.
  • After release, the appellants allegedly roamed the village and threatened witnesses, thereby justifying cancellation of bail.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
(2012) 12 SCC 180 Enumerated factors relevant to granting bail (gravity of offence, likelihood of tampering, flight risk, etc.) and circumstances warranting cancellation when the granting court ignores relevant material. Used to frame the legal standard for assessing whether the Sessions Court’s bail order was perverse and whether cancellation criteria were met.
Raghubir Singh v. State of Bihar, (1986) 4 SCC 481 Illustrative grounds for cancelling bail, such as interference with investigation, tampering with evidence, or threat to witnesses; emphasised that cancellation is a harsh measure affecting personal liberty. Guided the Court’s evaluation of whether alleged threats by the appellants justified cancelling bail.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reiterated that cancellation of bail is an exceptional remedy that should only be employed where the granting order is perverse or where post-release conduct demonstrably undermines the administration of justice. Although the Sessions Court’s order did not contain detailed reasoning, it expressly recorded that all relevant material had been perused. Neither the State nor Respondent 2 asserted that the Sessions Court relied on irrelevant considerations.

Examining the subsequent complaint alleging witness intimidation, the Court found the allegations “vague” and lacking specifics regarding which of the fifteen accused had issued threats or how evidence was being tampered with. In the absence of concrete particulars, the complaint did not satisfy the stringent standards for cancelling bail.

Consequently, the High Court’s finding that the Sessions Court ignored material evidence and failed to consider criminal antecedents was unsupported by the record. The Supreme Court concluded that the Sessions Court’s grant of bail was not perverse and that the High Court had overstepped its jurisdiction in cancelling the bail.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed; High Court judgment (2019 SCC OnLine TS 2259) set aside.

Direct Effect: The appellants’ bail stands restored under the original conditions imposed by the Sessions Court.

Broader Implications: The judgment reinforces that cancellation of bail demands concrete material showing perversity in the original bail order or clear post-release misconduct. Vague or unsubstantiated allegations are insufficient, thereby underscoring the judiciary’s duty to safeguard personal liberty against unwarranted interference.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Myakala Dharmarajam And Others v. State Of Telangana And Another

    L. Nageswara Rao, J.— Respondent 2 in the above appeals lodged a complaint which was registered under Sections 148, 120-B, 302 read with Section 149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) at Karimnagar Rural Police Station vide FIR No. 155 dated 19-4-2019. It was alleged in the complaint that the husband of Respondent 2, Bojja Thirupathi was the Chairman of the Fishermen Co-operative Society of Chamanapalli Village, Karimnagar District. Members of the Society alone were permitted to carry out fishing activities in the tanks in Rajasamudram and Appanapalli Villages.

    2. The membership of the appellants in the Fishermen Co-operative Society was cancelled due to which they were not permitted to carry out fishing activities. Three years before the complaint the husband of Respondent 2 was attacked by the appellants at the village Panchayat office and a criminal case was registered against the appellants, which was pending. On 19-4-2019, the husband of Respondent 2 went to Chamanapalli Village to inspect the tank. At about 5.00 p.m., the appellants attacked the husband of Respondent 2 with stones and he succumbed to the injuries.

    3. The appellants moved applications for bail before the Principal Sessions Judge, Karimnagar who summoned the case diary, statements of the witnesses and other connected records. The Principal Sessions Judge released the appellants on bail by imposing conditions that the appellants shall appear before Karimnagar Rural Police Station on every alternate day between 10.00 a.m. to 5.00 p.m. and shall not leave the territorial jurisdiction of the First Additional Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Karimnagar. Another condition was imposed that the appellants shall not influence or tamper with the evidence.

    4. Respondent 2 filed a petition for cancellation of bail under Section 439(2) CrPC before the High Court for the State of Telangana. On 10-7-2019, a charge-sheet was filed against the appellants. According to the charge-sheet, all the accused gathered and planned to kill Bojja Thirupathi on 19-4-2019. They formed into two groups. The first group, consisting of A-5, A-7 to A-11 and A-15, attacked the deceased and remaining persons were standing guard near the tank. Even according to the charge-sheet, there is no overt act alleged against any of the accused, except A-6 who is alleged to have strangulated the deceased with a towel.

    5. We are informed at the Bar that the case has been committed for trial. The High Court allowed 2019 SCC OnLine TS 2259 the applications filed for cancellation of bail on the ground that the Principal Sessions Judge did not consider the material available on record before granting bail to the appellants. The High Court further held that the criminal antecedents of the appellants were not taken into account by the trial court. That apart, the High Court accepted the submissions on behalf of Respondent 2 that the appellants indulged in threatening the witnesses after being released on bail.

    6. The appellants contended that no specific overt act was attributed to any of the accused, except for omnibus allegations made against them. It is argued that the complaint that was made by Respondent 2 is on the basis of vague allegations regarding tampering with the evidence. The appellants urged that the order passed by the High Court is liable to be set aside as there were no compelling reasons for interfering with the order of the Sessions Court by which they were released on bail.

    7. The factors to be considered while granting bail have been held by this Court to be the gravity of the crime, the character of the evidence, position and status of the accused with reference to the victim and witnesses, the likelihood of the accused fleeing from justice and repeating the offence, the possibility of his tampering with the evidence and witnesses, and obstructing the course of justice, etc. Each criminal case presents its own peculiar factual scenario and, therefore, certain grounds peculiar to a particular case may have to be taken into account by the court. The court has to only opine as to whether there is prima facie case against the accused. For the purpose of bail, the court must not undertake meticulous examination of the evidence collected by the police and comment on the same. (2012) 12 SCC 180

    8. In Raghubir Singh v. State of Bihar (1986) 4 SCC 481 this Court held that bail can be cancelled where (i) the accused misuses his liberty by indulging in similar criminal activity, (ii) interferes with the course of investigation, (iii) attempts to tamper with evidence or witnesses, (iv) threatens witnesses or indulges in similar activities which would hamper smooth investigation, (v) there is likelihood of his fleeing to another country, (vi) attempts to make himself scarce by going underground or becoming unavailable to the investigating agency, (vii) attempts to place himself beyond the reach of his surety, etc. The above grounds are illustrative and not exhaustive. It must also be remembered that rejection of bail stands on one footing but cancellation of bail is a harsh order because it interferes with the liberty of the individual and hence it must not be lightly resorted to.

    9. It is trite law that cancellation of bail can be done in cases where the order granting bail suffers from serious infirmities resulting in miscarriage of justice. If the court granting bail ignores relevant material indicating prima facie involvement of the accused or takes into account irrelevant material, which has no relevance to the question of grant of bail to the accused, the High Court or the Sessions Court would be justified in cancelling the bail (2012) 12 SCC 180.

    10. Having perused the law laid down by this Court on the scope of the power to be exercised in the matter of cancellation of bails, it is necessary to examine whether the order passed by the Sessions Court granting bail is perverse and suffers from infirmities which has resulted in the miscarriage of justice. No doubt, the Sessions Court did not discuss the material on record in detail, but there is an indication from the orders by which bail was granted that the entire material was perused before grant of bail. It is not the case of either the complainant Respondent 2 or the State that irrelevant considerations have been taken into account by the Sessions Court while granting bail to the appellants. The order of the Sessions Court by which the bail was granted to the appellants cannot be termed as perverse as the Sessions Court was conscious of the fact that the investigation was completed and there was no likelihood of the appellant tampering with the evidence.

    11. The petition filed for cancellation of bail is both on the grounds of illegality of the order passed by the Sessions Court and the conduct of the appellants subsequent to their release after bail was granted. The complaint filed by one Bojja Ravinder to the Commissioner of Police, Karimnagar is placed on record by Respondent 2. It is stated in the complaint that the appellants were roaming freely in the village and threatening witnesses. We have perused the complaint and found that the allegations made therein are vague. There is no mention about which accused out of the 15 indulged in acts of holding out threats to the witnesses or made an attempt to tamper with the evidence.

    12. After considering the submissions made on behalf of the parties and examining the material on record, we are of the opinion that the High Court was not right in cancelling the bail of the appellants. The orders passed by the Sessions Judge granting bail cannot be termed as perverse. The complaint alleging that the appellants were influencing witnesses is vague and is without any details regarding the involvement of the appellants in threatening the witnesses. Therefore, the appeals are allowed and the judgment 2019 SCC OnLine TS 2259 of the High Court is set aside.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Myakala Dharmarajam And Others v. State Of Telangana And Another
    (Jan 7, 2020)