Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Acts
  • Sections 122, 123 and 124 of the Indian Evidence Act.
  • Order 11 Rules 14 and 15 read with Section 151 CPC
  • provision of Order 11 Rule 12 CPC
  • Order 11 Rules 12 and 14 CPC
  • Order 11 Rule 14 CPC
  • Order 11 Rule 12 CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Acts
  • Sections 122, 123 and 124 of the Indian Evidence Act.
  • Order 11 Rules 14 and 15 read with Section 151 CPC
  • provision of Order 11 Rule 12 CPC
  • Order 11 Rules 12 and 14 CPC
  • Order 11 Rule 14 CPC
  • Order 11 Rule 12 CPC
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Petitioner (plaintiff in the trial court) filed a suit for declaration and permanent injunction claiming ownership and possession of 3 kanals of land, alleging that a sale deed dated 09.09.2013 was illegal and resulted from fraud. Plaintiff relied on an agreement to sell dated 09.03.2013 (photocopy produced) and alleged that the original agreement was in the defendant's possession. Possession of khasra No.103//8/1 was delivered to the defendant, while plaintiff contended a different khasra (103//3/2/2/1) was referred to improperly in the sale deed. Plaintiff filed an application under Order 11 Rules 14 and 15 read with Section 151 CPC for production of the original agreement dated 09.03.2013. The trial Court (Civil Judge, Junior Division, Amritsar) dismissed that application by order dated 18.10.2017. The petitioner preferred this revision petition against that dismissal. The High Court (Raj Mohan Singh, J.) heard the matter and delivered its judgment on 31.01.2019.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Court erred in dismissing the plaintiff's application for production of the original agreement to sell dated 09.03.2013 under Order 11 Rules 14 and 15 read with Section 151 CPC.
  2. Whether the trial Court complied with the requirements of Order 11 Rule 12 CPC and Order 11 Rule 14 CPC in recording satisfaction as to necessity, relevancy and possession of the document before refusing production.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Plaintiff's) Position

  • Plaintiff asserted that the original agreement to sell dated 09.03.2013 was in the defendant's possession and relied on a photocopy of that agreement.
  • Plaintiff alleged fraud in incorporation of a different khasra number in the sale deed and sought production of the original agreement to establish his case.

Respondent's (Defendant's) Position

  • Defendant contended the agreement to sell related to khasra No.103//3/2/2/1 and that the sale deed accorded with that agreement; alleged the plaintiff's photocopy was manipulated.
  • Defendant argued there was no necessity to produce the original at that stage, since she would lead her evidence and produce documents when she led evidence.
  • Respondent's counsel submitted that the plaintiff had not pleaded that the original was with the defendant and had not led secondary evidence; relied on the principle that the Court must determine relevancy/expediency before ordering production (citing Tata Iron and Steel Co. Ltd. ...).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
The Tata Iron and Steel Co. Ltd. and others Vs. Prop. Ajit Cotton Ginning Pressing Dall and Stell Rolling Mills, 2013(1) RCR (Civil) 506 That expediency and relevancy of a document must be determined by the Court before ordering production under Order 11 Rule 14 CPC; Court should not undertake a roving inquiry to fish for evidence. Cited by respondent's counsel to support the proposition that the trial Court must determine relevancy/expediency before ordering production; High Court referenced this context when assessing trial Court's approach.
Sharvan Kumar Vs. Sumeet Kumar Garg, 2002(3) PLR 666 Held that under Order 11 Rule 14 CPC, nature of the provision does not leave room to refuse production request except for privileged documents; distinction drawn with Order 11 Rule 12 CPC (discovery on oath) and scope of refusal when unnecessary for disposing of suit. Relied upon by the High Court to explain that documents relevant under Order 11 Rule 14 generally must be produced and that refusal requires specific legal basis; used to indicate trial Court's order was silent on these requirements.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court considered the parties' submissions and the trial Court record. It observed that the defendant had not specifically denied existence of the document but had taken the stance she would produce documentary evidence when leading her evidence. The High Court emphasized that the trial Court must satisfy itself as to the necessity and relevancy of the document and must record its satisfaction in terms of Order 11 Rule 12 CPC (regarding whether the document is necessary for fair disposal of the suit or for saving costs) before refusing production under Order 11 Rule 14 CPC. The High Court found the trial Court's impugned order silent on compliance with Order 11 Rules 12 and 14 CPC and therefore concluded the trial Court had not acted judiciously on the legal requirements. Applying precedents (Sharvan Kumar and Tata Iron and Steel reference), the High Court directed the trial Court to re-visit the issue and pass a fresh order in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition was DISPOSED OF by directing the trial Court to re-visit the application for production of the original agreement and to pass a fresh order in accordance with law, after recording the required satisfaction under Order 11 Rules 12 and 14 CPC.

Implications: The direct effect is that the trial Court must reconsider the plaintiff's application for production of the original document and decide afresh in light of the legal requirements cited by the High Court. The opinion does not pronounce any broader new precedent beyond this direction.


Bench: Raj Mohan Singh, J. — Judgment dated 31.01.2019.

Counsels: Mr. Ranjit Saini for petitioner; Mr. Hitesh Ghai for respondent No.1.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    DESA SINGH THROUGH LRS. v. SUKHRAJ KAUR AND ORS.

    Present: Mr. Ranjit Saini, Advocate for the petitioner. Mr. Hitesh Ghai, Advocate for respondent No.1. RAJ MOHAN SINGH, J.

    [1]. Petitioner has preferred this revision petition against the order dated 18.10.2017 passed by Civil Judge (Junior Division), Amritsar vide which the application filed by the plaintiff/petitioner under Order 11 Rules 14 and 15 read with Section 151 CPC for production of original agreement to sell dated 09.03.2013 was dismissed.

    [2]. Plaintiff filed a suit for declaration to the effect that the plaintiff is owner in possession of the suit land and alleged sale deed dated 09.09.2013 is illegal, null and void. Consequential relief of permanent injunction was also sought, restraining the defendant from interfering in the possession of the plaintiff. Plaintiff claimed that he is owner in possession of the land measuring 3 kanals and the defendant entered into an agreement to sell to purchase the same from the Northern side of the khasra number to the extent of 3 kanals from the plaintiff vide agreement to sell dated 09.03.2013. From the said land, the plaintiff had already dug out the earth and this fact was also mentioned in the agreement to sell and consequently, a rate was agreed and settled between the parties at Rs.11,25,000/- for the said land. The date of execution of sale deed was fixed for 09.09.2013. Plaintiff further claimed that he is an illiterate and old person and the defendant has played a fraud upon him by mentioning the khasra No.103//3/2/2/1 in the recital of the sale deed which was never agreed to be sold by the plaintiff. The said khasra number is of more value and more fertile and the defendant illegally and unlawfully got the same incorporated in the sale deed in connivance with deed writer and attesting witnesses. Plaintiff alleged fraud in the aforesaid context.

    [3]. The possession of the suit land was never delivered to the defendant, rather possession of khasra No.103//8/1 was delivered and since then, defendant is in possession of khasra No.103//8/1. The sale deed was claimed to be illegal, null and void and result of fraud.

    [4]. Plaintiff filed an application under Order 11 Rules 14 and 15 read with Section 151 CPC for production of original agreement to sell dated 09.03.2013 on the ground that the document in question is with the defendant and the same was not filed by the defendant along with the written statement. Photocopy of agreement to sell dated 09.03.2013 was relied by the plaintiff by claiming that the original of the same is with the defendant. Production of original agreement to sell was sought.

    [5]. The application was contested by the defendant on the ground that the agreement to sell was executed in respect of 103//3/2/2/1 and sale deed was executed strictly in consonance with agreement to sell. The photocopy as projected by the plaintiff was claimed to be a manipulated document after making alterations in khasra numbers by erasing real khasra numbers. Defendant pleaded that she will lead her evidence and will produce her documents at the relevant stage of her leading evidence and there is no necessity to produce any original document and it was for the plaintiff to prove his case by leading his affirmative evidence without taking assistance of the Court.

    [6]. Trial Court dismissed the application vide impugned order dated 18.10.2017 by holding that assertion to the effect that the agreement to sell is in possession of the defendant has not been supported by any affidavit of the plaintiff. Plaintiff has already availed number of opportunities and it was only on 4th opportunity of leading evidence, the application in question came to be filed. In the plaint itself, plaintiff has not pleaded in any manner that the original agreement to sell is in possession of the defendant.

    [7]. Learned counsel for the respondent submitted that while leading evidence on three initial dates, the plaintiff did not alter a single word in respect of production of original document, rather proceeded to adduce evidence as per his own desire. It was only on 4th opportunity, the plaintiff woke up and filed the application asserting that the original agreement to sell is in possession of the defendant. There is no whisper in the plaint as to the original agreement to sell is with the defendant. Plaintiff has never resorted to any leading of secondary evidence.

    [8]. Learned counsel further submitted that it is a settled principle of law that production of documents in terms of Order 11 Rule 14 CPC can only be ordered by the Court after satisfying itself about the relevancy, relativity or essentiality of production of such document. All the aforesaid requirements cannot be ascertained without there being a determination of issue with reference to evidence. Plaintiff has not pleaded anything in the plaint in respect of agreement to sell being in possession of the defendant. Such a course cannot be adopted in a routine matter. Reference can be made to The Tata Iron and Steel Co. Ltd. and others Vs. Prop. Ajit Cotton Ginning Pressing Dall and Stell Rolling Mills, 2013(1) RCR (Civil) 506 in the aforesaid context. The expediency and relevancy of the document have to be determined by the Court in a judicious manner before resorting to provision in terms of Order 11 Rule 14 CPC as no roving inquiry for fishing out the evidence can be resorted to by the Court. At the same time, it cannot be lost sight of. Learned counsel also submitted that the stand taken by the defendant is that the defendant will lead her evidence and will produce her documents at the relevant stage of her leading evidence and there is no necessity to produce any original document at this stage.

    [9]. I have considered the submissions made by learned counsel for the parties. [10]. From the arguments raised by learned counsel for the parties, this Court finds that the defendant has not denied the existence of document in specific terms, rather the stand taken by the defendant is that she will lead evidence/documentary evidence at the relevant time. The Court has to satisfy itself with regard to necessity and relevancy of the document. The Court has to record its satisfaction in terms of provision of Order 11 Rule 12 CPC that the document in question is not necessary either for disposing fairly of the suit or for saving costs. On that premise, the Court has to record findings in respect of satisfaction and the possession of the document with the defendant. It appears from the record that the trial Court has not acted in a judicious manner to answer the compliance of Order 11 Rules 12 and 14 CPC while deciding the application in question. [11]. In Sharvan Kumar Vs. Sumeet Kumar Garg, 2002(3) PLR 666, it was held that nature of provision itself does not leave any room to refuse such a request. The only exception that can be made is with regard to privilege document under Sections 122,

    123 and 124 of the Indian Evidence Act. This rule is entirely different to Order 11 Rule 12 CPC which is confined to discovery of document. Under Order 11 Rule 14 CPC, all the documents are required to be produced as long as they are found to be relevant. Under Order 11 Rule 12 CPC, party can be asked to make discovery on oath, of document which is in his possession or power. If such discovery is found to be unnecessary, then such a prayer can be rejected on the ground that it is not necessary for disposing of the suit. [12]. Since the impugned order dated 18.10.2017 passed by Civil Judge (Junior Division), Amritsar is silent about the aforesaid requirement of law, therefore, I deem it appropriate to direct the trial Court to re-visit the issue in terms of legal grounds and pass a fresh order in accordance with law. [13]. Disposed of accordingly. (RAJ MOHAN SINGH) JUDGE 31.01.2019 Prince Whether reasoned/speaking Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    DESA SINGH THROUGH LRS. v. SUKHRAJ KAUR AND ORS.
    (Jan 31, 2019)