Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule.1.14. The provision of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code
  • 1956 ORISSA 77.20. Clauses (a) and (b) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code
  • sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • clause (b) of sub-rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order 23 of the Code.
  • provision of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code
  • clause (b) of sub-rule 3 of order 23 Rule 1 of the Code
  • clause (a) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code,
  • clause (a) Sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code.
  • sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code
  • clause (b) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • below:13..Clause (b) of sub-rule (3)
  • Rule 1 of Order 23 of the Code
  • clause (a) of Rule 1 sub-rule (3),
  • record.11. Rule 1 of Order 23
  • Rules 1 to 14 Order 32
  • Order 23 Rule 1(3) CPC,
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1
  • Order 23 Rule 1(3)(b)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule.1.14. The provision of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code
  • 1956 ORISSA 77.20. Clauses (a) and (b) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code
  • sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • clause (b) of sub-rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order 23 of the Code.
  • provision of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code
  • clause (b) of sub-rule 3 of order 23 Rule 1 of the Code
  • clause (a) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code,
  • clause (a) Sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code.
  • sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code
  • clause (b) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • below:13..Clause (b) of sub-rule (3)
  • Rule 1 of Order 23 of the Code
  • clause (a) of Rule 1 sub-rule (3),
  • record.11. Rule 1 of Order 23
  • Rules 1 to 14 Order 32
  • Order 23 Rule 1(3) CPC,
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1
  • Order 23 Rule 1(3)(b)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a suit for eviction of the opposite party from the suit property, alleging possession under a “leave and licence agreement” for a stipulated period. Subsequent agreements of similar nature were executed after expiry of the initial agreement. Upon expiry of the last agreement, the opposite party refused to vacate and continued possession as a trespasser. During the trial, one of the agreements was impounded by the learned Trial Judge for insufficient stamp duty and sent for assessment. The petitioner then filed an application under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking permission to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit on the same subject matter. The Trial Judge permitted withdrawal but refused the liberty to file a fresh suit, leading to the present revisional application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit on the same subject matter under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. The interpretation and scope of “formal defect” and “sufficient grounds” under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC, particularly whether “sufficient grounds” must be ejusdem generis with “formal defect”.
  3. The extent of the Court’s discretion and duty to be satisfied about the grounds before granting permission to withdraw with liberty to file a fresh suit.
  4. The effect of impounding the tenancy agreement due to insufficient stamp duty on the viability of the eviction suit and the petitioner’s right to withdraw and refile.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The tenancy agreement was treated as an unregistered lease and impounded for insufficient stamp duty, making the suit defective and unlikely to succeed.
  • The petitioner’s counsel advised that continuing the suit without valid notice terminating tenancy would be imprudent.
  • The petitioner sought withdrawal with liberty to file a fresh suit under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC, arguing that the prayer under this provision is composite and cannot be split.
  • Relied on decisions of the Calcutta High Court Division Bench in SURADHANI DEBYA v. CHANDRA NATH PRAMANIK and the Karnataka High Court in D.P. SHARMA v. BANGALORE MAHANAGARA PALIKE to support the entitlement to withdraw with liberty to refile.

Opposite Party’s Arguments

  • The plaintiff has an unqualified right to withdraw the suit, but when seeking leave to file a fresh suit on the same subject matter, the defendant can object.
  • The Court must be satisfied about the existence of proper grounds before granting permission to file a fresh suit.
  • Supported by two Supreme Court decisions: K.S. BHOOPATHY v. KOKILA and ANIL KUMAR SINGH v. VIJAY PAL SINGH.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K.S. BHOOPATHY v. KOKILA, (2000) 5 SCC 458 Mandate that Court must be satisfied about sufficiency of grounds before allowing withdrawal with liberty to file fresh suit under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC. Used to emphasize Court’s duty to ensure grounds exist before permitting withdrawal with liberty to refile, protecting defendant’s rights.
ANIL KUMAR SINGH v. VIJAY PAL SINGH, (2018) 12 SCC 584 Recognition of defendant’s right to object to plaintiff’s prayer for liberty to file fresh suit after withdrawal. Supported the principle that defendant’s objection is valid and Court must be satisfied about grounds before granting permission.
SURADHANI DEBYA v. CHANDRA NATH PRAMANIK, 1915 SCC OnLine Cal 56 Withdrawal with liberty to file fresh suit is a composite prayer and cannot be split; if liberty is refused, withdrawal application must be dismissed. Relied upon to hold that the Trial Court should have either granted both withdrawal and liberty or refused both.
D.P. SHARMA v. BANGALORE MAHANAGARA PALIKE, 2001 SCC OnLine Kar 329 Similar principle to SURADHANI DEBYA regarding composite nature of withdrawal with liberty and consequences of refusal. Supported the petitioner’s contention that the Trial Court erred in refusing liberty while allowing withdrawal.
V. RAJENDRAN v. ANNASAMY PANDIAN, (2017) 5 SCC 63 Interpretation of “formal defect” and “sufficient grounds” under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC; Court’s discretion in granting withdrawal with liberty. Clarified that “sufficient grounds” need not be restricted to formal defects; Court gave liberal meaning to “formal defect”.
SAJEDA KHATOON v. SHAHATA HOSSAIN, 2012 (4) CHN (CAL) 707 Application under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC need not be perfectly clear for Court to grant permission if grounds exist. Used to hold that lack of clarity in petitioner’s application cannot bar permission if grounds are satisfied.
TRINATH BASANT RAY v. Sk. MOHAMMOD, WP (C) NO. 1813 OF 2004 (Orissa High Court) Rejected ejusdem generis interpretation restricting “sufficient grounds” to formal defects. Supported the wider discretion of the Court to grant permission based on sufficient grounds beyond formal defects.
ATUL KRUSHNA ROY v. RAUKLSHORE MOHANTY, AIR 1956 ORISSA 77 View on interpretation of “sufficient grounds” under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC. Approved by larger Bench of Orissa High Court in TRINATH BASANT RAY case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the petitioner’s right to withdraw the suit under Rule 1 of Order 23 CPC, which provides an unqualified right to abandon a suit or part of a claim, with limited exceptions for minors or persons under Order 32 protections. The Court emphasized that the defendant’s right to object arises only when the plaintiff seeks permission to file a fresh suit on the same subject matter under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC.

The Court examined the two clauses under sub-rule 3: (a) formal defect and (b) sufficient grounds. It clarified that “sufficient grounds” is not restricted to formal defects and must be interpreted broadly, allowing the Court discretion to prevent abuse of process and protect defendants’ rights.

Applying these principles, the Court found that the tenancy agreement was impounded for insufficient stamp duty, constituting a “formal defect” that affects the viability of the suit due to the absence of valid notice terminating tenancy. This defect, given a liberal meaning as per Apex Court precedents, justified withdrawal with liberty to file a fresh suit.

The Court further held that no rights had accrued in favor of the defendant during the pendency of the suit that would bar the petitioner from refiling. The Trial Judge erred in refusing liberty to file a fresh suit on the ground that the application did not explicitly mention “formal defect.” The Court relied on precedents to affirm that if the conditions under sub-rule 3 are satisfied, the prayer for withdrawal with liberty cannot be split.

Consequently, the Court modified the impugned order to grant liberty to the petitioner to institute a fresh suit on the same subject matter, while affirming the Trial Judge’s order permitting withdrawal subject to payment of costs.

Holding and Implications

The Court’s final decision is to modify the impugned order by granting the petitioner liberty to institute a fresh suit on the same subject matter or cause of action of Title Suit No. 132 of 2016. The petitioner is permitted to withdraw the suit subject to payment of costs, as originally ordered by the Trial Judge.

The direct effect is that the petitioner may refile the eviction suit despite the impounding of the tenancy agreement, as the defect identified is a “formal defect” justifying withdrawal with liberty to refile. No new precedent is set; rather, the Court applies and reaffirms established principles governing withdrawal of suits and the Court’s discretion under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Archana Roy v. Dipanjan Bhattacharjee

    Biswajit Basu, J.:— The instant revisional application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is directed against the order dated September 25, 2018 passed by the 9 Court, Civil Judge (Senior Division) at Alipore in Ejectment Suit No. 132 of 2016.

    2. The petitioner filed the suit for eviction of the opposite party from the suit property alleging that the opposite party was put into possession of the suit property on the basis of the agreement styled as “leave and licence agreement” for a period stipulated in the said agreement. On expiry of the period fixed by the initial agreement subsequent agreements of same nature was entered into by and between the petitioner and the opposite party. The opposite party on expiry of the period fixed by last of such agreements refused to vacate the suit property and is continuing the possession over it as a trespasser.

    3. The learned Trial Judge in course of the hearing of the said suit impounded one of the said agreements holding that the said agreement is not sufficiently stamped and send it to the collector for assessment of proper stamp duty payable on the said document.

    4. The petitioner in the suit filed an application under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure praying that she may be permitted to withdraw the said suit with a liberty to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter of the said suit (hereinafter referred to as the ‘said application’ in short).

    5. The petitioner in the said application contended, inter alia, that the learned Trial Judge during the pendency of the said suit observed that the agreement which is executed between the parties is in the nature of an unregistered lease and as such the agreement under the nomenclature of tenancy agreement executed between the parties in the year 2009 cannot be relied upon on the ground of insufficient stamp duty and impounded the said document. The plaintiff in view of the said circumstances has been advised by her learned counsel that as the proceeding was instituted in a defective manner, insufficient to sustain the present plaint, it would not be prudent on the part of the plaintiff to continue with the present proceeding as chances of getting any relief in the present proceeding is very bleak.

    6. The learned Trial Judge by the order impugned has permitted the petitioner to withdraw the suit but refused to grant liberty to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter and cause of action of the said suit.

    7. The learned advocate for the petitioner submits that the petitioner is seeking eviction of the opposite party from the suit property describing him as a trespasser but the defendant in his written statement has taken the defence of a premises tenant and the learned Trial Judge has already treated the agreement of tenancy under which the defendant came into possession of the suit property as an unregistered deed of lease, under the said circumstances the petitioner realised that the suit will fail for want of a valid notice terminating the tenancy of the opposite party in respect of the suit property created under the said agreements or otherwise and accordingly filed the said application but the learned Trial Judge has refused to grant the permission to the petitioner to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter of the said suit, erroneously holding that the said application does not speak about the ‘formal defect’.

    8. He further submits that the Court under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code, if satisfied that either of the grounds contemplated under clause (a) or clause (b) of the said provision of the Code exists shall allow a plaintiff to withdraw the suit and to file a fresh one on the self-same subject matter of the suit allowed to be so withdrawn or part of it's claim but the prayer of the plaintiff under the said provision of the Code being composite cannot be split up. In support of his such contention he places reliance on the decision of the Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court in the case SURADHANI DEBYA v. CHANDRA NATH PRAMANIK reported in 1915 SCC OnLine Cal 56 : (20 CWN 1011) and also on a decision of the Single Judge of the Karnataka High Court in the case of D.P. SHARMA v. BANGALORE MAHANAGARA PALIKE reported in 2001 SCC OnLine Kar 329 : (AIR 2001 KARNATAKA 401).

    9. The learned advocate for the opposite party refuting the contentions of the learned advocate for the petitioner submits that the plaintiff has an unqualified right to withdraw her suit to which the defendant cannot object but when the plaintiff is seeking the leave of the Court to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter upon withdrawal of the pending suit the defendant can very well object to such prayer of the plaintiff. He further submits that before grant of permission to the plaintiff to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter of the suit allowed to be withdrawn, Court is duty bound to get itself satisfied regarding the existence of proper ground for grant of such permission. He takes support the two decisions of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of K.S. BHOOPATHY v. KOKILA report in (2000) 5 SCC 458 and in the case of ANIL KUMAR SINGH v. VIJAY PAL SINGH reported in (2018) 12 SCC 584 : AIR 2017 SUPREME COURT 5587 to substantiate his said contentions.

    10. Heard learned advocate for the parties and perused the materials on record.

    11. Rule 1 of Order 23 deals with withdrawal of suit or abandonment of part of claim. The said provision of the Code is reproduced below for ready reference:—

    ORDER XXIII

    “1. Withdrawal of suit or abandonment of part of claim. (1) At any time after, the institution of a suit, the plaintiff may as against all or any of the defendants abandon his suit or abandon a part of his claim:

    Provided that where the plaintiff is a minor or other person to whom the provisions contained in rules 1 to 14 of Order XXXII extend, neither the suit nor any part of the claim shall be abandoned without the leave of the Court.”

    12. The plaintiff, therefore, under Rule 1 of Order 23 of the Code has an unqualified right to abandon his suit or part of his claim against all or any of the defendants. The only restriction to such right of the plaintiff is that where the plaintiff is a minor or such other person to whom the provisions contend in Rules 1 to 14 Order 32 extend, neither the suit nor any part of the claim thereof can be abandoned without leave of the Court.

    13. The unfettered right of the plaintiff to abandon the suit under Rule 1 of Order 23 of the Code cannot be impeached by the defendant. The right of the defendant to object such prayer of the plaintiff matures when the plaintiff makes a prayer under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code seeking permission of the Court to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter of the suit sought to be withdrawn. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the decision reported in (2018) 12 SCC 584 : AIR 2017 SUPREME COURT 5587 (supra) has recognized such right of the defendant. The paragraph 26 of the said report being relevant is quoted below:—

    “26. However, when the plaintiff applies for withdrawal of the suit along with a prayer to grant him permission to file a fresh suit on the same subject-matter as provided in sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 then in such event, the defendant can object to such prayer made by the plaintiff. In such event, it is for the Court to decide as to whether the permission to seek withdrawal of the suit should be granted to the plaintiff and, if so, on what terms as provided in sub-rule (3) of Rule.1.”

    14. The provision of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code is, therefore, the relevant provision under which the plaintiff is entitled to apply for an order to withdraw the suit with a permission to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter of the said suit or such part of claim of the said suit. The said provision of the Code is also quoted below for ready reference:—

    ORDER XXIII

    “1. Withdrawal of suit or abandonment of part of claim.-

    (3) Where the Court is satisfied,-

    (a) that a suit must fail by reason of some formal defect, or

    (b) that there are sufficient grounds for allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit for the subject-matter of a suit or part of a claim, it may, on such terms as it thinks fit, grant the plaintiff permission to withdraw from such suit or such part of the claim with liberty to institute a fresh suit in respect of the subject-matter of such suit or such part of the claim.

    15. The clauses (a) and (b) of the provision of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code contemplates two contingencies, on demonstration of any of the said contingencies the plaintiff is entitled to withdraw his suit with a permission to file a fresh suit in respect of the subject matter of such suit or such part of the claim, the plaintiff under clause (b) thereof is entitled to the same relief on the proof of the existence of sufficient grounds favouring such relief.

    16. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of K.S. BHOOPATHY v. KOKILA reported in (2000) 5 SCC 458 (supra) has held that the Court must be satisfied about the sufficiency of the grounds for allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit for the same claim or part of the claim on the same cause of action, is the mandate to the Court under clause (b) of sub-rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order 23 of the Code. The relevant excerpts of paragraph. 13 of the said report is quoted below:—

    “13………………………………………………..Clause (b) of sub-rule (3) contains the mandate to the Court that it must be satisfied about the sufficiency of the grounds for allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit for the same claim or part of the claim on the same cause of action. The court is to discharge the duty mandated under the provision of the Code on taking into consideration all relevant aspects of the matter including the desirability of permitting the party to start a fresh round of litigation on the same cause of action.………………..”

    17. Another issue being incidental to the investigation as to the scope of the provision of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code crops up. The said issue is whether the expression ‘sufficient grounds’ appearing in clause (b) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code should be construed “ejusdem generis” with the expression “formal defects” appearing in clause (a) thereof.

    18. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of V. RAJENDRAN v. ANNASAMY PANDIAN (DEAD) THROUGH LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES KARTHYAYANI NATCHIAR reported in (2017) 5 SCC 63 noticed that there are two views on the question whether the expression ‘sufficient grounds’ in clause (b) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code is restricted to the expression ‘formal defect’ or those analogous thereto appearing in clause (a) sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code. The Hon'ble Apex Court did not elaborate the said issue as the said question was not under consideration in the said case before the Hon'ble Apex Court. However, in the context of present discussion it is profitable to quote the paragraph. 11 of the said report:—

    “11. In terms of Order 23 Rule 1(3)(b) where the court is satisfied that there are sufficient grounds for allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit, the Court may permit the plaintiff to withdraw the suit. In interpretation of the words “sufficient grounds”, there are two views: one view is that these grounds in clause (b) must be “ejusdem generis” with those in clause (a), that it, it must be of the same nature as the ground in clause (a), that is, formal defect or at least analogous to them; and the other view was that the words “other sufficient grounds” in clause (b) should be read independent of the words a “formal defect” and clause (a). Court has been given a wider discretion to allow withdrawal from suit in the interest of justice in cases where such a prayer is not covered by clause (a). Since in the present case, we are only concerned with “formal defect” envisaged under clause (a) of Rule 1 sub-rule (3), we choose not to elaborate any further on the ground contemplated under clause (b), that is, “sufficient grounds”.”

    19. The said issue was considered by a larger Bench of the Orissa High in the case of TRINATH BASANT RAY v. Sk. MOHAMMOD in WP (C) NO. 1813 OF 2004. The larger Bench of Orissa High answered the said issue in negative by approving the view of the learned Single Judge of the Orissa High Court in the case of ATUL KRUSHNA ROY v. RAUKLSHORE MOHANTY reported in AIR 1956 ORISSA 77.

    20. Clauses (a) and (b) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code provides two alternatives, therefore, there is no justification for restricting the meaning of the expression other “sufficient grounds” appearing in clause (b) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code only to the formal defects or those analogous thereto as has been held by the learned Single Judge of the Orissa High Court in AIR 1956 ORISSA 77 (supra).

    21. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the decision reported in (2017) 5 SCC 63 (supra) approving the view expressed by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of K.S. BHOOPATHY v. KOKILA held that the fact is the plaintiff is entitled to abandon or withdraw the suit or part of the claim by itself, is no licence to the plaintiff to claim or to do so to the detriment of legitimate right of the defendant. In the said decision the Hon'ble Apex Court also held that “formal defect” is a defect of form prescribed by the rules of procedure such as, want of notice under Section 80 of the Code, improper valuation of the suit, insufficient court-fees, confusion regarding identification of the suit property, misjoinder of parties, failure to disclose cause of action etc. It has been further held in the said decision “formal defect” must be given a liberal meaning which connotes various kinds of defects not effecting the merits of the plea raised by either of the parties. Paragraph 10 of the said decision needs to be reproduced, as such quoted below:—

    “10. In K.S. Bhoopathy v. Kokila, it has been held that it is the duty of the Court to be satisfied about the existence of “formal defect” or “sufficient grounds” before granting permission to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit under the same cause of action. Though, liberty may lie with the plaintiff in a suit to withdraw the suit at any time after the institution of suit on establishing the “formal defect” or “sufficient grounds”, such right cannot be considered to be so absolute as to permit or encourage abuse of process of Court. The fact that the plaintiff is entitled to abandon or withdraw the suit or part of the claim by itself, is no licence to the plaintiff to claim or to do so to the detriment of legitimate right of the defendant. When an application is filed under Order 23 Rule 1(3) CPC, the Court must be satisfied about the “formal defect” or “sufficient grounds”. “Formal defect” is a defect of form prescribed by the rules of procedure such as, want of notice under Section 80 CPC, improper valuation of the suit, insufficient court fee, confusion regarding identification of the suit property, misjoinder of parties, failure to disclose a cause of action, etc. “Formal defect” must be given a liberal meaning which connotes various kinds of defects not affecting the merits of the plea raised by either of the parties.”

    22. The Court under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code is mandated to get itself satisfied about the sufficiency of the grounds for allowing the plaintiff to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter of the pending suit after allowing him to withdraw it. The object of the said mandate of the said provision of the Code is to prevent abuse of process of law and also to prevent prejudice to the defendant. In other words the plaintiff will not be entitled to the permission to file a fresh suit on the selfsame subject matter of the suit sought to be withdrawn, if such permission affects any right accrues in favour of the defendant in the said suit during it's pendency. The investigation to achieve the said object of the said provision of the Code is fact specific.

    23. In the present case the agreement for tenancy dated February 14, 2009 was impounded by the learned Trial Judge as the said document was not sufficiently stamped when the same was tendered as evidence in course of the trial of the suit. Therefore, the tenancy created by the said document in favour of the opposite party in respect of the suit property cannot be determined without a valid notice. That apart the opposite party in the suit has taken the defence of a premises tenant. In any event the suit will fail for want of a valid notice which is a “formal defect” within the meaning of clause (a) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code, which must be given a liberal meaning as has been held by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the decision reported in (2017) 5 SCC 63 (supra).

    24. That apart no right has been created in the suit by the order impounding the tenancy agreement or otherwise for which the prayer of the petitioner for the permission to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter of the said suit can be objected by the defendant. The plaintiff realising that the suit cannot succeed as the tenancy created by the agreement in favour of the defendant has not been determined by a valid notice when wants to withdraw the suit with a permission to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter of the said suit such permission must be granted as the situation covers existence of “sufficient grounds” envisaged under clause (b) of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code.

    25. The learned Trial Judge has refused to grant permission to the plaintiff to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter or cause of action of the suit allowed to be withdrawn by the order impugned on the ground that the said application does not speak about the “formal defect”. If the conditions of sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code are satisfied an application by the plaintiff is not an essential requirement for the said rule to apply as has been held by SOUMEN SEN, J. in the case of SAJEDA KHATOON v. SHAHATA HOSSAIN reported in 2012 (4) CHN (CAL) 707. In the present case the conditions of the said provisions of the Code as has already been discussed above have been satisfied. Therefore, lack of clarity in the said application cannot come in the way of the plaintiff to get a permission to file a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter or cause of action of the suit already filed by her upon it's withdrawal.

    26. The plaintiff has applied under sub-rule 3 of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code for a conditional order that subject to the grant of permission to institute a fresh suit she may be permitted to withdraw the pending suit. The said prayer of the plaintiff cannot be split up. The Court if satisfied that grounds contemplated under the said provision of the Code exist shall allow the plaintiff to withdraw the suit and shall grant permission to the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter of the suit, allowed to be withdrawn. If the Court is not satisfied about the existence of the grounds fulfilling the requirements of the said provision of the Code shall simply refuse both the prayers of the plaintiff. The Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court has expressed similar view in the decision reported in 1915 SCC OnLine Cal 56 : (20 CWN 1011) (supra). The relevant excerpts of paragraph. 1 of the said decision is reproduced below:—

    “1……………………. Now the Court having been of opinion that leave should not be granted to the plaintiff to withdraw from the suit with liberty to bring afresh suit, it ought to have dismissed the application for withdrawal. As pointed out by Sir Lawrence Jenkins, Chief Justice, in the case of Mahant Bihari Dasji v. Parshotamdas 32 B. 345: 10 Bom. L.R. 293. “Where a plaintiff does not desire to withdraw from the suit, unless with liberty to bring a fresh suit, and the Court considers that such liberty ought not to be granted, the proper course is simply to dismiss the application”………………………………..”

    27. Same is the view expressed by the learned Single Judge of the Karnataka High Court in the case reported in 2001 SCC OnLine Kar 329 : (AIR 2001 KARNATAKA 401) (supra). The argument of the learned advocate for the petitioner, therefore, on this score succeeds.

    28. In view of the discussion made above the order impugned is modified by granting liberty to the plaintiff/petitioner to institute a fresh suit on the self-same subject matter or cause of action of the Title Suit No. 132 of 2016. However, the liberty granted by the learned Trial Judge to the plaintiff to withdraw the said suit subject to payment of cost of Rs. 5000/- is hereby affirmed.

    29. With the above C.O. 3616 of 2018 is disposed of.

    30. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be supplied to the parties upon compliance with all requisite formalities.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Archana Roy v. Dipanjan Bhattacharjee
    (May 8, 2019)