Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 1286
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 32 of the Constitution
  • Clause (2) of Article 212 of the Constitution
  • Article 333 of the Constitution
  • Article 14 of the Constitution of India
  • Article 356 of the Constitution
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 1286
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 32 of the Constitution
  • Clause (2) of Article 212 of the Constitution
  • Article 333 of the Constitution
  • Article 14 of the Constitution of India
  • Article 356 of the Constitution
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The case arises out of the formation of the Government in Maharashtra following the 2019 Legislative Assembly elections. A pre-poll alliance between the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and Shiv Sena contested the elections jointly. When results were declared on 24-10-2019, no party had a majority. On 9-11-2019, the Governor invited the BJP, as the single largest party with 105 seats, to form the Government; the BJP declined on 10-11-2019 due to the alleged breakdown of its alliance with Shiv Sena. The Governor thereafter invited Shiv Sena and then the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), but neither attempt led to Government formation. Presidential Rule was recommended on 12-11-2019 and imposed the same day.

During this period, Shiv Sena, NCP, and the Indian National Congress (INC) were in discussions to form a coalition Government, and a press conference was said to have been held on 22-11-2019. On 23-11-2019 at 5:47 a.m., Presidential Rule was revoked under Article 356(2) of the Constitution. The Governor invited Respondent 3 to form the Government by letter dated 23-11-2019, and the oath of office and secrecy was administered to Respondents 3 and 4 at around 8:00 a.m. the same day at Raj Bhavan, Mumbai.

Aggrieved, the petitioners (Shiv Sena, NCP, and INC) filed a petition under Article 32 on 23-11-2019 seeking, inter alia, a declaration that the Governor’s action of 23-11-2019 inviting Shri Devendra Fadnavis to form the Government was unconstitutional, and a direction to invite the Maha Vikas Aghadi alliance to form the Government. As interim relief, they sought convening a special session to administer oaths to MLAs and hold an immediate floor test (initially on 24-11-2019), video recording of House proceedings following earlier Supreme Court orders, and appointment of a pro tem Speaker.

The matter was urgently listed; on 24-11-2019 (a Sunday), after hearing the parties, the Court issued notice and requested the Solicitor General to produce the Governor’s order and letters submitted by Respondent 3. On 25-11-2019, the Solicitor General produced the letters. The Court then heard counsel for both sides and proceeded to pass interim directions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, at the interim stage, the Court should direct an immediate floor test to ascertain whether the Chief Minister enjoys the confidence of the House.
  2. Whether Article 212 of the Constitution bars the Court from issuing directions that impact the timing and conduct of a floor test or from “monitoring” House proceedings.
  3. Whether questions relating to maintainability, the extent of judicial review, and the validity of the Governor’s satisfaction should be adjudicated immediately or deferred.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The early-morning revocation of Presidential Rule (5:47 a.m.) and the administration of oaths at around 8:00 a.m. indicate mala fides.
  • Respondent 4 was never authorised to form an alliance with Respondent 3; therefore, Respondent 3 must prove majority on the floor of the House.
  • Established norms require appointment of the seniormost member as pro tem Speaker; the floor test should be by open ballot and video-recorded to ensure transparency.
  • The Governor improperly accepted a proposal based on an unaddressed letter allegedly signed by 54 NCP MLAs without a covering letter or clear statement of alliance with the BJP; sole reliance on such material was imprudent.
  • As both sides are agreeable to a floor test, ordering it immediately would not prejudice anyone and should not be deferred.

Union of India / Solicitor General

  • The Governor’s satisfaction was based on material indicating Respondent 3 had support of 105 BJP MLAs, 54 NCP MLAs, and 11 independents (total 170); the Governor relied on letters from Respondents 3 and 4 and was not obliged to conduct a roving inquiry.
  • Under Article 212, the Court cannot monitor the proceedings of the House.

Respondent 3's Arguments

  • While a floor test is imperative, the Court cannot sit in appeal over the Governor’s order fixing the date for the floor test.
  • Conducting a floor test falls within the Speaker’s discretion; therefore, no interim order should be passed by the Court setting the schedule.

Respondent 4's Arguments

  • Jurisdiction under Article 32 cannot be invoked in the present matter; the Governor’s independence should be respected.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S.R. Bommai v. Union of India, (1994) 3 SCC 1 Where doubt arises whether the Council of Ministers enjoys the confidence of the House, the only way to test it is on the floor of the House (except in extraordinary situations such as all-pervasive violence). Relied upon to underscore that an immediate floor test is the most appropriate mechanism to determine majority and uphold democratic principles.
Jagdambika Pal v. Union of India, (1999) 9 SCC 95 Directions summoning a special session with a single agenda of a composite floor test; Court can issue interim directions to facilitate a floor test and require faithful announcement of results. Cited to demonstrate precedent for the Court convening/ directing a special session and floor test through interim orders.
Anil Kumar Jha v. Union of India, (2005) 3 SCC 150 Interim directions for convening Assembly, administering oaths, holding a floor test with a singular agenda, and ensuring security for MLAs. Used to reinforce the Court’s power to structure interim measures for an expedited floor test to ascertain majority.
Union of India v. Harish Chandra Singh Rawat, (2016) 16 SCC 744; (2016) 16 SCC 749; (2016) 16 SCC 752 Floor test as a means to strengthen democratic values; permissibility of video-recording proceedings; Court’s role as sentinel of democracy. Cited both for the constitutional ethos supporting floor tests and the procedural directions (e.g., video recording) the Court may order.
Chandrakant Kavlekar v. Union of India, (2017) 3 SCC 758 Floor test at the earliest removes ambiguity and lends credibility to the democratic process. Invoked to justify expediting the floor test to resolve sensitive and contentious issues over Government formation.
Dr G. Parmeshwara v. Union of India, (2018) 16 SCC 46; (2018) 16 SCC 48 Procedure when MLAs have not yet taken oath and the Speaker is not elected: appointment of a pro tem Speaker; oaths to members; floor test not by secret ballot; security arrangements. Followed to craft the procedural framework for Maharashtra: appointment of pro tem Speaker, administering oaths, open (non-secret) floor test, and related logistics.
Shrimanth Balasaheb Patil v. Karnataka Legislative Assembly, 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1454 Constitutional functionaries must imbibe constitutional morality; undemocratic and illegal political practices must be curtailed. Cited to emphasize constitutional morality and the need to protect democratic values in directing an immediate floor test.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

  • The Court acknowledged the longstanding tension between judicial intervention and parliamentary independence, emphasizing institutional comity and separation of powers. However, it stressed the necessity to preserve democratic values and citizens’ right to good governance in exceptional situations.
  • While issues of maintainability, the extent of judicial review, and the validity of the Governor’s satisfaction were argued, the Court deferred their adjudication to an appropriate time. At the interim stage, it focused on safeguarding the democratic process.
  • The Court noted the risk that any delay in conducting a floor test could lead to horse trading and undermine democracy. It therefore considered an immediate floor test as the most effective safeguard, aligning with the principle articulated in S.R. Bommai that majority must be tested on the floor of the House.
  • In response to the respondents’ reliance on Article 212, the Court held that Article 212 has no application here because the petition did not call into question any act of an officer or member of the State legislature in regulating procedure or conduct of business. Thus, the constitutional bar on judicial interference with legislative procedure did not prevent the Court from issuing the interim directions.
  • The Court drew on a consistent line of precedents—Jagdambika Pal, Anil Kumar Jha, Harish Chandra Singh Rawat, Chandrakant Kavlekar, and Dr G. Parmeshwara—to demonstrate that it has, in similar circumstances, directed special sessions, structured floor tests with a single agenda, ordered video recording, and provided for logistical arrangements, all to promptly ascertain majority and maintain constitutional trust.
  • Given that, in the present case, a month had elapsed since results were declared and elected members had not yet taken oath, and no Speaker had been elected, the Court adopted the procedural framework previously used in Dr G. Parmeshwara: appointment of a pro tem Speaker, administration of oaths to all elected members, and an immediate floor test conducted in accordance with law and not by secret ballot, with live telecast to ensure transparency.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court directed that a floor test be held on 27-11-2019 to ascertain whether Respondent 3 commands the confidence of the House. The Court ordered: - Immediate appointment of a pro tem Speaker solely for this agenda. - All elected members shall take oath on 27-11-2019, to be completed before 5:00 p.m. - The pro tem Speaker shall then conduct the floor test in accordance with law; it shall not be by secret ballot. - The proceedings shall be live telecast, with appropriate arrangements made. Additionally, respondents were granted eight weeks to file counter-affidavits, rejoinders within four weeks thereafter, with the matter to be listed after twelve weeks.

Implications: The immediate effect is to promptly determine, through a transparent floor test, whether the Chief Minister enjoys majority support, thereby curtailing horse trading, reducing uncertainty, and facilitating stable governance. The order operates as interim relief and does not finally resolve questions regarding maintainability, judicial review limits, or the Governor’s satisfaction. The decision follows and applies existing precedent and does not set a new substantive rule; its implications are confined to directing the immediate floor test and procedural safeguards in this case.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Shiv Sena And Others v. Union Of India And Others

    Order

    1. There is no gainsaying that the boundaries between the jurisdiction of courts and parliamentary independence have been contested for a long time. However, there is a need and requirement for recognising institutional comity and separation of powers so as to tailor judicial interference in the democratic processes only as a last resort. This case pertains to one such situation, wherein this Court is called upon to adjudicate and maintain democratic values and facilitate the fostering of the citizens' right of good governance.

    2. Before we pass any orders, we need to make a brief reference to the factual aspects giving rise to the petition herein. It was well known that there existed a pre-poll alliance between the Bharatiya Janata Party (for short “BJP”) and Shiv Sena, who contested the Fourteenth Maharashtra Legislative Assembly elections jointly. On 24-10-2019, the results for the aforesaid elections were declared and no single party had the requisite majority in the House. On 9-11-2019, the Governor called upon the BJP to indicate its willingness to form the Government, being the single largest party with 105 seats. However, the BJP declined to form the Government on 10-11-2019, as the alliance with Shiv Sena allegedly broke down.

    3. Subsequently, the Governor invited Shiv Sena to form the Government. In this regard, Shiv Sena is said to have shown its willingness to stake a claim to form the Government, claiming to have support of the majority. However, the aforesaid endeavour was not fruitful either. Thereafter, the Governor's effort to seek the Nationalist Congress Party's (for short “NCP”) willingness to stake a claim to form the Government was also not successful. Ultimately, the Governor recommended President's Rule on 12-11-2019, which was imposed by a Presidential Proclamation on the same day.

    4. It is brought to our attention that the petitioners i.e. Shiv Sena, NCP and the Indian National Congress (for short “INC”) were in discussion to form a coalition Government during this period, and accordingly, a press conference is supposed to have been held on 22-11-2019 regarding the same.

    5. It has been canvassed before us that at 5.47 a.m., on 23-11-2019, the President's Rule was revoked in exercise of powers conferred by clause (2) of Article 356 of the Constitution. Thereafter, the Governor, by Letter dated 23-11-2019 invited Respondent 3 to form the Government. The oath of office and secrecy was administered accordingly to Respondents 3 and 4 at around 8.00 a.m. on 23-11-2019 at Raj Bhavan, Mumbai.

    6. Aggrieved by the Governor's action in calling upon Respondent 3 to form the Government, the petitioners have approached this Court under Article32 of the Constitution on 23-11-2019 with the following prayers:

    “(a) Pass an appropriate writ/order/direction declaring that action/order of the Hon'ble Governor dated 23-11-2019 inviting Shri Devendra Fadnavis to form the Government on 23-11-2019 as unconstitutional, arbitrary, illegal, void ab initio, and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India; and accordingly quash the same;
    (b) Pass an appropriate writ/order/direction to the Hon'ble Governor to invite the alliance of Maha Vikas Aghadi comprising of Shiv Sena, Indian National Congress and the Nationalist Congress Party which has the support of more than 144 MLAs to form the Government under the leadership of Shri Uddhav Thackeray;
    ***”

    7. At this juncture, it is necessary to extract some of the prayers for interim directions sought by the petitioners in the present petition:

    “(a). Issue appropriate directions in terms of summoning a special session of the Fourteenth Maharashtra Legislative Assembly with the only agenda of administering oath to the MLAs, immediately followed by the holding of a floor test on 24-11-2019;
    ***
    (d) Issue appropriate directions in terms of the order dated 24-2-1998 passed by this Hon'ble Court in Jagdambika Pal (1999) 9 SCC 95 as well as Harish Chandra Singh Rawat (2016) 16 SCC 744, (2016) 16 SCC 752 directing that the proceedings of the House be video recorded and a copy of the video recording be placed on record of this Hon'ble Court;
    (e) Issue appropriate directions appointing a protem Speaker to preside over the conduct of the floor test;”

    8. Further, the petitioners have filed an affidavit indicating the urgency and requirement for hearing the matter on 23-11-2019 itself. Accordingly, the Hon'ble Chief Justice was pleased to place the matter before this Bench and the matter was heard on 24-11-2019 (2019) 10 SCC 820 (Sunday) at 11.30 a.m. After hearing the parties, this Court passed the following order:

    “1. Issue notice. It was brought to our notice by the learned Senior Counsels appearing for the petitioners that they have served the respondents through email. However, there is no representation for Respondents 2, 3 and 4.
    2. Mr Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General appearing for the Union of India is willing to produce the relevant record, if necessary, from the Governor also.
    3. Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior Counsel who is appearing for some BJP MLAs and two independent MLAs, who are not parties to this writ petition, opposed the entertaining of the writ petition as well as passing of any order.
    4. We have taken note of all the arguments, particularly the argument that the Governor's decision dated 23-11-2019 inviting Respondent 3 to form a Government on 23-11-2019 is unconstitutional. With regard to the second prayer as at (b), we are not going to consider the same at present. As adjudication of the issues and also the interim prayers sought by the petitioners to conduct floor test within 24 hours has to be considered after perusing the order of the Governor as well as the letters submitted by Mr Devendra Fadnavis, Respondent 3, even though none appeared for the State Government, we request Mr Tushar Mehta to produce those two letters by tomorrow morning at 10.30 a.m. when the matter will be taken up, so that appropriate order will be passed.”

    9. When the matter was taken up for hearing on 25-11-2019, the Solicitor General of India, produced the letters in compliance of the order of this Court dated 24-11-2019 (2019) 10 SCC 820.

    10. Heard the learned counsel appearing for both sides.

    11. The learned Senior Counsel for Petitioner 1, Mr Kapil Sibal submitted that prima facie, the action of the Governor revoking President's Rule at 5.47 a.m. and administering the oath of office at around 8.00 a.m. reeks of mala fide. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that Respondent 4 was never authorised to form the alliance with Respondent 3. Therefore, Respondent 3 must prove his majority on the floor of the House. For this purpose, as per established norms, the seniormost member must be called for assuming the role of pro tem Speaker, after which there must be an open ballot and the same should be captured in a video recording so as to ensure transparency.

    12. Agreeing with the aforementioned submissions, learned Senior Counsel Dr A.M. Singhvi appearing for Petitioners 2 and 3 submitted that the Governor turned a blind eye by accepting the proposal of formation of the Government put forth by Respondent 3. The letter presented to the Governor, although allegedly signed by 54 elected members of the NCP, was unaddressed and did not have a covering letter or any other statement promising their alliance to the BJP. In the aforesaid context, the sole reliance on the aforesaid letter to prove majority was not prudent. Moreover, when both sides are agreeable to the conduction of a floor test, and an order directing the conduction of the same is not prejudicial to anyone, then there is no reason to defer the same.

    13. On the other hand, the learned Solicitor General submitted that the satisfaction of the Governor was based on the material placed before him, wherein it was indicated that Respondent 3 enjoyed the support of 105 elected members of the BJP, 54 elected members of the NCP and 11 independent elected members (170 in total). The Governor had, in his own wisdom, relied upon the letters of Respondents 3 and 4 and he had no reason to disbelieve the same. The Governor is not obligated to conduct a roving enquiry into the same. The learned Solicitor General also contended that this Court cannot monitor the proceedings of the House as per the provision of Article 212 of the Constitution.

    14. Adding to the aforesaid submissions, learned Senior Counsel Mr Mukul Rohatgi appearing for Respondent 3 submitted that although a floor test is imperative, this Court cannot sit in appeal over the Governor's order to set the dates for the floor test. It must be kept in mind that conducting a floor test is the discretion of the Speaker. In light of the above, no interim order can be passed in the aforesaid matter.

    15. Lastly, learned Senior Counsel Mr Maninder Singh appearing for Respondent 4 vehemently contended that the jurisdiction under Article 32 of the Constitution cannot be invoked in the present matter and the Governor's independence should be respected.

    16. We may note that, while the learned Solicitor General and the learned Senior Counsel Mr Mukul Rohatgi sought additional time to file affidavits in response, however we are of the opinion that the same might not be necessary at this stage.

    17. Having heard the submissions of the learned counsel on the issues of maintainability, extent of judicial review and validity of the Governor's satisfaction, we are of the opinion that they can be adjudicated at an appropriate time. There is no doubt that the contentions have to be answered, as the petitioners have raised questions concerning important constitutional issues touching upon the democratic bulwark of our nation. However, at this interim stage, we may note that it is imperative for this Court to be cognizant of the need to take into consideration the competing claims of the parties, uphold the democratic values and foster constitutional morality.

    18. At the outset, we need to emphasise that recently, in Shrimanth Balasaheb Patil v. Karnataka Legislative Assembly 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1454, this Court had emphasised the requirement of imbibing constitutional morality by the constitutional functionaries. Undemocratic and illegal practices within the political arena should be curtailed.

    19. In this context, this Court in Union of India v. Harish Chandra Singh Rawat (2016) 16 SCC 744, (2016) 16 SCC 752, held as follows:

    “30. … This Court, being the sentinel on the qui vive of the Constitution is under the obligation to see that the democracy prevails and not gets hollowed by individuals. The directions which have been given on the last occasion, were singularly for the purpose of strengthening the democratic values and the constitutional norms. The collective trust in the legislature is founded on the bedrock of the constitutional trust.”

    20. In a situation wherein, if the floor test is delayed, there is a possibility of horse trading, it becomes incumbent upon the Court to act to protect democratic values. An immediate floor test, in such a case, might be the most effective mechanism to do so. A similar view was expounded by B.P. Jeevan Reddy, J., in the celebrated nine-Judge Bench decision of this Court in S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994) 3 SCC 1, wherein he held as follows:

    “395. The High Court 1989 SCC OnLine Kar 253, ILR 1989 Kar 2425, in our opinion, erred in holding that the floor test is not obligatory. If only one keeps in mind the democratic principle underlying the Constitution and the fact that it is the Legislative Assembly that represents the will of the people — and not the Governor — the position would be clear beyond any doubt. … There could be no question of the Governor making an assessment of his own. The loss of confidence of the House was an objective fact, which could have been demonstrated, one way or the other, on the floor of the House. In our opinion, wherever a doubt arises whether the Council of Ministers has lost the confidence of the House, the only way of testing it is on the floor of the House except in an extraordinary situation where because of all-pervasive violence, the Governor comes to the conclusion — and records the same in his report — that for the reasons mentioned by him, a free vote is not possible in the House.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    21. This was also the opinion expressed by the Sarkaria Commission, Rajmannar Committee and the unanimous opinion expressed by the Committee of five Governors constituted by the President of India. In the aforementioned judgment, B.P. Jeevan Reddy, J., quoted the observations of the Committee of Five Governors with approval, as below:

    “393. … The five Governors unanimously recommended that “the test of confidence in the Ministry should normally be left to a vote in the Assembly. … Where the Governor is satisfied, by whatever process or means, that the Ministry no longer enjoys majority support, he should ask the Chief Minister to face the Assembly and prove his majority within the shortest possible time. … A Chief Minister's refusal to test his strength on the floor of the Assembly can well be interpreted as prima facie proof of his no longer enjoying the confidence of the legislature.”

    22. Ex facie, Article 212 of the Constitution, relied on by the respondents, would have no application as it relates to validity of proceedings in the legislature of a State that cannot be called in question in any court on the ground of any alleged irregularity of procedure. Clause (2) states that no officer or member of the legislature of a State, in whom powers are vested by or under the Constitution for regulating the procedure, conduct of business or for maintaining order, in the legislature shall be subject to the jurisdiction of any court in respect of exercise of those powers by him. Clause (2) has no application because no act of any officer or member of the legislature of the State has been made the subject-matter of the present petition before this Court. This Court, nearly two decades back, in Jagdambika Pal v. Union of India (1999) 9 SCC 95, had passed an order, after hearing counsel for the petitioner and the caveators, directing that a special session of the Uttar Pradesh Assembly will be summoned/convened after two days on 26-2-1998 with the following directions:

    “1. … (ii) The only agenda in the Assembly would be to have a composite floor test between the contending parties in order to see which out of the two contesting claimants of Chief Ministership has a majority in the House.
    (iii) It is pertinently emphasised that the proceedings in the Assembly shall be totally peaceful and disturbance, if any, caused therein would be viewed seriously.
    (iv) The result of the composite floor test would be announced by the Speaker faithfully and truthfully.
    2. The result is expected to be laid before us on 27-2-1998 at 10.30 a.m. when this Bench assembles again.
    3. Ancillary directions are that this order shall be treated to be a notice to all the MLAs, leaving apart the notices the Governor/Secretariat is supposed to issue. In the interregnum, no major decisions would be made by the functioning Government except attending to routine matters, not much of any consequence.”

    23. Six years later, in Anil Kumar Jha v. Union of India (2005) 3 SCC 150, similar directions were passed by this Court after recording and taking notice of events that had taken place and few developments which were in the offing, as reported in the media, to observe and direct as follows:

    “5. Though many a relief has been sought for in the writ petition, as also in the application for grant of ex parte stay, for the present, we are satisfied that a strong prima facie case on the averments made in the petition duly supported by affidavit, has been made out to issue the following interim directions and we order accordingly:
    (1) The session of the Jharkhand State Assembly has already been convened for 10-3-2005 on which day the newly elected Members of the Legislative Assembly shall be administered oath. We direct the session to continue and on 11-3-2005 i.e. the next day and on that day the vote of confidence to be put to test.
    (2) The only agenda in the Assembly on 11-3-2005 would be to have a floor test between the contending political alliances in order to see which of the political parties or alliance has a majority in the House and hence a claim for Chief Ministership.
    (3) It is emphasised that the proceedings in the Assembly shall be totally peaceful, and disturbance, if any, caused therein shall be viewed seriously.
    (4) The result of the floor test would be announced by the pro tem Speaker faithfully and truthfully.
    (5) This order by the Court shall constitute notice of the meeting of the Assembly for 11-3-2005 and no separate notice would be required.
    (6) Till 11-3-2005 there shall be no nomination in view of Article 333 of the Constitution and the floor test shall remain confined to the 81 elected members only.
    (7) We direct the Chief Secretary and the Director General of Police, State of Jharkhand to see that all the elected Members of the Legislative Assembly freely, safely and securely attend the Assembly and no interference or hindrance is caused by anyone therein. Dr A.M. Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the State of Jharkhand through the Chief Secretary and the Director General of Police has very fairly assured the Court that even otherwise it is the duty of the State and its high officials to take care to do so and the direction made by the Court shall be complied with in letter and spirit.”

    The aforesaid directions were interim in nature and were passed on the basis of averments made in the petition duly supported by an affidavit. Writ petitions were directed to be listed on the date of hearing fixed.

    24. Ten years later, in Union of India v. Harish Chandra Singh Rawat (2016) 16 SCC 744, (2016) 16 SCC 749 (2), again an interim order was passed after the special leave petitions were taken up for hearing, though after concession which was made by Mr Mukul Rohatgi, the then Attorney General for India, that the Union of India has no objection, which the Court had appreciated, to observe that the floor test should be conducted on a special session of Uttarakhand Legislative Assembly to be summoned/convened in which the only agenda would be the vote of confidence sought by the first respondent and apart from the said agenda nothing will be discussed. Directions were issued to the Chief Secretary and the Director General of Police, State of Uttarakhand, to see that all qualified Members of the Legislative Assembly, freely, safely and securely attend the Assembly and no hindrance is caused to them. The floor test was to commence at 11.00 a.m. and was directed to be completed by 1.00 p.m. There was another direction that the confidence motion having been put, a division of the House shall take place and members inclined to vote in favour of the motion shall sit on one side/wing and those voting against the motion shall sit on the other side/wing. The entire proceedings were to be video-graphed and video recording was directed to be placed before the Court for being perused. The special leave petitions were directed to be listed thereafter.

    25. In Chandrakant Kavlekar v. Union of India (2017) 3 SCC 758, the challenge raised was to a press note and communication from a leader of a party to the Governor of the State on the issue relating to whether a particular party had misrepresented the facts. Observing that the sensitive and contentious issue could be resolved by a simple direction requiring holding of the floor test at the earliest. This would remove all possible ambiguities and would result in giving the democratic process, the required credibility. By order dated 14-3-2017, the Governor of the State of Goa was requested to ensure that a floor test is held on 16-3-2017. Further, it would be the only agenda for the day so as to determine whether the Chief Minister administered the oath of office enjoys the support of the majority. The order further highlights that the floor test should be held as early as possible.

    26. Lastly, we would refer to G. Parmeshwara v. Union of India (2018) 16 SCC 46, (2018) 16 SCC 48, wherein identical directions were issued in respect of formation of Government in the State of Karnataka to test whether the Chief Minister so appointed enjoyed the majority support of the House. Noticing the fact that the elected members of the Legislative Assembly, as in the present case, were yet to take oath and the Speaker was also not elected, the following procedure was directed to be followed for conducting the floor test:

    “(A) Pro tem Speaker shall be appointed for the aforesaid purpose immediately.
    (B) All the elected members shall take oath tomorrow (19-5-2018) and this exercise shall be completed before 4.00 p.m.
    (C) The pro tem Speaker shall conduct the floor test on 19-5-2018 at 4.00 p.m. in order to ascertain the majority and it shall not be by secret ballot and these proceedings shall be conducted in accordance with law.
    (D) Adequate and sufficient security arrangements shall be made and Director General of Police, State of Karnataka will himself supervise the said arrangements so that there is no lapse on this count whatsoever.”

    It was directed that the floor test would be conducted immediately on the next date i.e. the date following the order.

    27. We may note that in the present case, oath has not been administered to the elected members even though a month has elapsed since the declaration of election results. In such emergent facts and circumstances, to curtail unlawful practices such as horse trading, to avoid uncertainty and to effectuate smooth running of democracy by ensuring a stable Government, we are of the considered opinion that it is necessary to pass certain interim directions in this case. In this context, it is necessary and expedient to conduct the floor test as soon as possible to determine whether the Chief Minister, who was administered the oath of office, has the support of the majority or not. Since the elected members of the Legislative Assembly are yet to take oath as specified in Schedule III of the Constitution, and the Speaker is also yet to be elected, we request the Governor of the State of Maharashtra to ensure that a floor test be held on 27-11-2019. The following procedure is to be followed for conducting the floor test:

    27.1. Pro tem Speaker shall be solely appointed for the aforesaid agenda immediately.

    27.2. All the elected members shall take oath on 27-11-2019, which exercise should be completed before 5.00 p.m.

    27.3. Immediately thereafter, the pro tem Speaker shall conduct the floor test in order to ascertain whether Respondent 3 has the majority, and these proceedings shall be conducted in accordance with law. The floor test will not be conducted by secret ballot.

    27.4. The proceedings have to be live telecast, and appropriate arrangements are to be made to ensure the same.

    28. Eight weeks' time is granted to the learned counsel for the respondents to file their respective counter-affidavits. Rejoinder-affidavit, if any, is to be filed within four weeks thereafter. The matter to be listed after twelve weeks.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shiv Sena And Others v. Union Of India And Others
    (Nov 26, 2019)