AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 seeking a declaration that the selection and allotment of a seat in the M.S. (Ophthalmology) course at Government Medical College, Tirunelveli to the fourth respondent was illegal, and seeking a direction to respondents 1 to 3 to re-allot that seat to her. The order is delivered by Pushpa Sathyanarayana, J.

Relevant factual and procedural points explicitly stated in the opinion:

  • The petitioner is an MBBS doctor, registered with the Tamil Nadu Medical Council on 07.07.2014. She scored 67.52 marks and ranked 474 (General) and 288 (B.C. Community) in the Tamil Nadu Post Graduate Entrance Examination for the academic year 2016-2017 under the 50% private non-service quota.
  • In the first counselling held on 04.04.2016 she was allotted the DGO Course at Madras Medical College. In the second phase of counselling on 12.05.2016 she was re-allotted M.S. (Ophthalmology) in Rajah Muthiah Medical College and Hospital (Annamalai University), a private institution, which she is about to complete.
  • The petitioner alleges that officials failed to display a third seat surrendered from the All India Quota in the second counselling (12–13.05.2016). She contends that, had that vacancy been shown, she would have obtained the seat at the Government Medical College, Tirunelveli and avoided the expense of private study. She also alleges misapplication of reservation rules in favour of the fourth respondent.
  • Respondents 1 to 3 and the fourth respondent filed counter-affidavits denying wrongdoing, asserting the counselling was transparent and the reservation rules were followed.
  • The court directed impleadment of the necessary party concerning the surrendered All India Quota seats; the fifth respondent was impleaded. The fifth respondent produced a communication (dated 23.11.2017) listing surrendered seats but without specific timing information about when seats reverted to the State quota.
  • The respondents' position (as set out in their affidavits) is that they received a reporting list from the Dean, Tirunelveli Medical College (signed 23.05.2016) showing one candidate did not join M.S. (Ophthalmology), and that seat was included in the seat matrix as on 27.05.2016 for the third-phase counselling (28.05.2016), at which the fourth respondent obtained the seat.
  • The court recorded certain undisputed facts in numbered form (i)–(v) concerning marks/rank, initial allotment, total seats and quotas, non-joining of two originally allotted candidates and the consequent conduct of subsequent counselling.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the selection and allotment of the M.S. (Ophthalmology) seat at Government Medical College, Tirunelveli to the fourth respondent was illegal because a surrendered All India Quota vacancy was not displayed during the second phase of counselling (12–13.05.2016), depriving the petitioner of that seat.
  2. Whether the respondents wrongly applied the rules of reservation (the roster/prospectus rules) in allocating the surrendered seat, thereby favouring the fourth respondent and denying the petitioner her rightful entitlement.
  3. Whether, in the circumstances, the petitioner is entitled to a declaration of illegality and a direction to re-allot the seat to her.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The official respondents deliberately failed to display the third vacant seat surrendered from the All India Quota in the second counselling conducted on 12.05.2016, which prevented the petitioner from securing the Government Medical College, Tirunelveli seat.
  • The respondents did not follow the rules of reservation stricto sensu, thereby paving the way for the fourth respondent to obtain the seat; had the rules been followed, the petitioner claims she alone would have been entitled to the seat.
  • Reliance was placed on the Apex Court judgment in Asha v. Pt. B.D. Sharma University of Health Sciences, (2012) 7 SCC 389 (the opinion records that the petitioner’s counsel relied on this judgment, but does not detail the specific principle from the case).

Respondents 1–3 (State) / Learned Additional Advocate General

  • Contended that the counselling process was transparent at each stage and the rules of reservation were applied strictly; students were admitted based on merit in accordance with the communal roster.
  • Explained that communications regarding reporting/non-joining were received from the Dean, Tirunelveli Medical College and that the seat in question was included in the seat matrix used for the third-phase counselling (27.05.2016 matrix; third counselling on 28.05.2016).
  • Provided a roster-based arithmetic demonstrating that allocating the third surrendered seat to an SC candidate (as occurred) produced an allotment closer to the reservation percentages than allotting it to a BC candidate, and therefore there was no infirmity in allotting the seat to an SC candidate.

Fourth Respondent

  • Adopted the arguments of the learned Additional Advocate General and submitted that the petitioner misinterpreted reservation rules in an attempt to displace a lawfully secured seat of the fourth respondent. Sought dismissal of the writ petition.

Fifth Respondent (Central Authority / MCC-related response)

  • After impleadment, addressed a communication dated 23.11.2017 (File No. C-18018/12/2017-MEC) to the then Assistant Solicitor General, annexing a college/subject-wise list of surrendered seats. The communication did not specify the time at which seats were reverted to the State quota (as noted in the opinion).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Asha v. Pt. B.D. Sharma University of Health Sciences, (2012) 7 SCC 389 The opinion records that the petitioner relied on this Apex Court judgment; the specific rule or principle from the judgment relied upon is not described in the provided opinion. The court held that the proposition enunciated in Asha (as relied upon by the petitioner) was of no help to the petitioner in the facts of this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by isolating and addressing the two principal complaints raised by the petitioner: (1) non-display/timing of the surrendered All India Quota seat in the second-phase counselling, and (2) alleged wrong application of reservation rules (roster) in allotting the seat.

On the first complaint (timing and non-display):

  • The court recorded undisputed facts including number of seats, quotas, ranks and that two originally allotted doctors did not join, producing vacancies filled in the second phase (12–13.05.2016).
  • The petitioner produced a seat matrix as on 11.05.2016 at 8:40 pm showing only two surrendered All India Quota seats plus two non-joining vacancies (total four seats) — i.e., no third surrendered seat appearing in that matrix.
  • The Medical Counselling Committee (MCC) schedule indicated transfer of vacant seats to State quota would take place on 10.05.2016 at 5:00 pm; the petitioner relied on this timing to claim the third surrendered seat should have been available in the second counselling.
  • The respondents explained that they received a reporting list from the Dean, Tirunelveli Medical College (reference given; signed on 23.05.2016) indicating one candidate had not joined M.S. (Ophthalmology); this vacancy was included in the seat matrix prepared as on 27.05.2016 at 3:42 pm for the third-phase counselling (28.05.2016).
  • The court found "some force" in the respondents' explanation and noted the fifth respondent's annexed list did not specify the time seats were reverted to the State quota; the court did not find the petitioner’s allegation of deliberate concealment or timing defect established on the materials before it.

On the second complaint (application of reservation rules):

  • The court set out the relevant prospectus clauses (clause 51.b and clause 52.b) and the reservation percentages for categories where seats are 8 or more (Open Competition 31%; Backward Class 30%; Most Backward/Denotified Community 20%; Scheduled Caste 18%; Scheduled Tribe 1%). It also recorded sub-allocations and treatment of unfilled ST seats (per clause 52.b and GO Ms No.77).
  • The court considered a roster-based computation for 17 seats (14 state quota seats plus 3 surrendered seats) showing fractional seat entitlements for each category as explicitly set out in the opinion (e.g., 5.27 for OC; 4.51 for BC; 0.60 for BCM; 3.4 for MBC; 3.06 for SC; 0.17 for ST; and adjusted SC seats if no ST candidates are available).
  • The Additional Advocate General's arithmetic (as recorded by the court) showed that up to the second phase of counselling the distribution was 5 (OC), 4 (BC), 1 (BCM), 3 (MBC) and 3 (SC). The AAG argued that allotting the third surrendered seat to a BC candidate would push BC representation to 6 seats (35.29%, i.e., 5.29% over its reservation share), whereas allotting it to an SC candidate would result in SC representation being 23.53% (only 4.53% over its reserved share). Based on that touchstone, the respondents' decision to allot the seat to an SC candidate was defensible under the roster system.
  • The court accepted that applying the roster arithmetic as advanced by the respondents did not reveal an infirmity in allocating the third surrendered seat to the fourth respondent (an SC candidate) and therefore the reservation challenge failed on the facts before the court.

On the precedent relied upon by the petitioner, the court simply stated that the proposition enunciated in Asha (2012) was of no help to the petitioner in the present facts, without elaborating further.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED. The writ petition failed and was dismissed.

Implications and direct consequences (as explicitly stated in the opinion):

  • The allotment of the M.S. (Ophthalmology) seat at Government Medical College, Tirunelveli to the fourth respondent was upheld; the court found no fault in the respondents' conduct on the available materials.
  • The petitioner is not granted the declaration or a direction to re-allot the seat to her.
  • There shall be no order as to costs.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal precedent; the court confined its decision to the facts and the roster arithmetic presented. (The opinion expressly states that the Asha precedent relied upon by the petitioner did not assist her in this case.)

This summary is strictly based on information contained in the provided court opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.

    Dr. Nithya M . v. Principal Secretary, Health And Family Welfare Department, Secretariat And Others

    Prayer: Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying for issuance of a Writ of Declaration declaring the selection and allotment of seat in MS Ophthalmology course in Government Medical College, Tirunelveli to the fourth respondent as illegal, and consequently direct the respondents 1 to 3 to re-allot the said seat to the petitioner.

    The Order of the Court was delivered by

    Pushpa Sathyanarayana, J.:— The petitioner seeks a declaration of the selection and allotment of seat in MS Ophthalmology course in Government Medical College, Tirunelveli to the fourth respondent as illegal, and consequently direction to the respondents 1 to 3 to re-allot the said seat to her.

    2. The petitioner is a MBBS Doctor and she got registered with the Tamil Nadu Medical Council on 07.07.2014. She secured 67.52 marks and ranked 474 in General and 288 in B.C. Community category under 50% private non-service quota in the Tamil Nadu Post Graduate Entrance Examination conducted for the Academic Year 2016-2017. In the first counseling held on 04.04.2016, she was allotted with the DGO Course in the Madras Medical College. However, in the second phase of counseling conducted on 12.05.2016, she was re-allotted M.S. (Ophthalmology) in Rajah Muthiah Medical College and Hospital being run by the Annamalai University. Now she is about to complete the said course.

    3. It is claimed by the petitioner that the official respondents deliberately failed to display the third vacant seat surrendered from the All India Quota in the second counseling held on 12.05.2016. Had it been shown as the vacant seat, she would have secured a seat in Government Medical College, Tirunelveli and would have saved from incurring huge expenditure for studying P.G. Course in a private medical institution. It is her further claim that official respondents wantonly failed to follow the Rules of Reservation stricto sensu, preventing the petitioner from securing the said seat and thus, they paved way for the fourth respondent to get the said seat. She alleges that had the respondents followed the rules of reservation, she would have alone got the seat. With the above allegations, she is before this Court seeking the relief of declaration stated supra.

    4. Refuting the allegations of the petitioner, counter affidavits have been filed by the official respondents as well as the fourth respondent seeking dismissal of the writ petition on the ground that the counseling was held transparently and the rules of reservation were followed stricto sensu.

    5. The learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the officials respondents failed to maintain transparency in displaying the vacant seats at the time of second counseling, which necessitated the petitioner to opt for a private medical college. The official respondents wantonly contravened the rules of reservation to favour the fourth respondent. Hence, the petitioner is entitled for the relief claimed. In support of the said submission, learned counsel for the petitioner relied on the judgment of the Apex Court in Asha v. Pt.B.D. Sharma University of Health Sciences, (2012) 7 SCC 389.

    6. The learned Additional Advocate General submitted that the respondents 1 to 3 acted transparently at each and every stage of the selection process following the rule of reservation to make it sure that the students have been admitted to P.G. Course only based on their merit in accordance with their communal roster.

    7. The learned counsel for the fourth respondent, while adopting the arguments of the learned Additional Advocate General, submitted that it is the petitioner who misinterpreted the reservation rules to grab the P.G. Medical seat lawfully secured by the fourth respondent and sought for dismissal of this writ petition.

    8. Heard the learned Central Government Standing Counsel appearing on behalf of the fifth respondent.

    9. At the outset, it is to be stated that from the materials produced before this Court, the following undisputed facts could be culled out for better appreciation of the instant case:

    (i) The petitioner, a MBBS Doctor, secured 67.52 marks and ranked 474 in General and 288 in B.C. Community category under 50% private non-service quota in the Tamil Nadu Post Graduate Entrance Examination conducted for the Academic Year 2016-2017.

    (ii) She was allotted with the DGO Course in the Madras Medical College in the first phase of counseling held on 04.04.2016.

    (iii) There were 28 seats available for M.S. (Ophthalmology), of which, 50%, i.e., 14 seats are meant for the All India Quota, while the remaining 50% (14 seats) is given under the State Quota. Out of the 14 seats that come under the State Quota, 7 were allotted to Service candidates and balance 7 were allotted for Non-Service candidates.

    (iv) Two doctors, who were originally allotted with the M.S. (Ophthalmology) course in the first phase of counseling, did not join the course. Due to non-joining of two doctors under the All India Quota two more seats were surrendered to the State. Hence, for those four seats counseling was conducted in the second phase.

    (v) Accordingly, the said seats were filled in the second phase of counseling held on 12.05.2016 and 13.05.2016, wherein, the petitioner, having left with no seat to opt in Government Medical Colleges, opted the private medical college.

    10. At this juncture, it is to be stated that the respondents 1 to 3, claimed to have got one more seat surrendered from the All India Quota, conducted the third phase of counseling on 28.05.2016, wherein, the fourth respondent secured the seat at the Tirunelveli Government Medical College in M.S. (Ophthalmology). However, the allegation of the petitioner in this regard is two fold: (i) firstly, the said vacancy was not shown in the second counseling held on 12.05.2016 and 13.05.2016, though the State would have got the same surrendered on 10.05.2016, after 5.00 p.m., as per the time schedule for online All India Quota 50% PG Counseling; and (ii) secondly, the official respondents wantonly applied the rules of reservation wrongly favouring the fourth respondent.

    11. As far as the first allegation is concerned, it is pertinent to mention that since in the counter affidavit dated 06.04.2017, the respondents 1 to 3 categorically stated that they have got two seats surrendered from the All India Quota, this Court gave a direction to the petitioner to implead the necessary party. Consequent to such a direction only, the fifth respondent was impleaded in this writ petition vide order dated 30.10.2017. Though the fifth respondent addressed a communication dated 23.11.2017 in File No. C-18018/12/2017-MEC, to the then Assistant Solicitor General annexing the list of college/subject wise surrendered seats, there is no specific mention about the time, on which, the seats were reverted to the State Quota.

    12. The petitioner produced a tabular column of seat matrix for Government Colleges as on 11.05.2016 at 8.40 pm, wherein, only two seats surrendered from the All India Quota along with two vacancies on the ground of non-joining of candidates under the State Quota totaling to four seats were shown as vacant seats. The time schedule for online All India Quota 50% PG Counseling issued by the Medical Counseling Committee (MCC) would make it amply clear that the transfer of vacant seats to State Quota would take place on 10.05.2016 at 5.00 pm. However, the claim of the official respondents is that they received the communication from the Dean, Tirunelveli Medical College, Tirunelveli, in Ref. No. 10101/ME3/2015, dated ..05.2016 signed on 23.05.2016, annexing the reporting list of joining of the candidates, wherein, only it is stated that one candidate did not join the course in M.S. (Ophthalmology), which was included in the seat matrix for Government Colleges as on 27.05.2016 at 3.42 p.m. for conducting the third phase of counseling, which was held on 28.05.2016. Accordingly, in the third counseling, following the rules of reservation/roster, the fourth respondent was re-allotted with the said vacant seat. There is some force in the said explanation of the official respondents, which cannot be found fault with.

    13. Now coming to the second crucial question of application of rules of reservation, it is claimed by the petitioner that the officials respondents have not followed the Rules of Reservation for each category in accordance with clause 51.b of the prospectus. As per the said clause, if the seats are 8 and more, the rule of reservation shall be as follows:

    Open Competition - 31% Backward Class - 30% Most Backward/Denotified Community - 20% Scheduled Caste - 18% Scheduled Tribe - 1%

    14. It is further stated in the said clause that within the 30% reservation for Backward Classes 3.5% reservation will be provided for Muslims and 16% of seats out of 18% quota earmarked to SC shall be allocated to the Schedule Caste Arunthathiyar Community. Clause 52 b. of the Prospectus says that “any remaining reserved seats in ST Quota for want of adequate number of eligible candidates belonging to ST community shall be allotted to candidates belonging to SC Community as per merit” as per G.O.(Ms) No. 77, Health and Family Welfare (MCA.1) Department, dated 24.02.2011. If the 17 seats, i.e., 14 seats under the State Quota and 3 seats surrendered from the All India Quota, are filled as per the above rules of reservation/roster, number of seats available to each category have to be: 5.27% for OC; 4.51 for BC; 0.60 for BCM; 3.4 for MBC; 3.06 for SC, of which, one seat shall be given to SCA; and 0.17 for ST. Since there is no ST candidates available, SC candidates would get 3.23 seats.

    15. It is submitted by the learned Additional Advocate General that applying the above roster system, up till the second phase of counseling, 5, 4, 1, 3 and 3 seats were alloted to OC, BC, BCM, MBC and SC candidates respectively. It is submitted that if the third All India Quota surrendered seat is allotted to a BC candidate, BC candidates including BCM will get 6 seats, which will be 35.29%, i.e., 5.29% over and above the seats reserved for BC, whereas, if the said seat is allotted to a SC candidate, SC candidates will get 23.53, which is only 4.53% above the seats reserved for SC and ST candidates. Hence, if the action of the official respondents in earmarking the third surrendered vacant seat for a SC candidate is tested with the above touchstone of aforesaid roster system, there is no infirmity in the said action. Hence, the allotment of the said vacant seat to the fourth respondent, as stated supra, could not be found fault with.

    16. In view of the above factual finding, the proposition enunciated in the judgment of the Apex Court relied on by the learned counsel for the petitioner in Asha v. Pt.B.D. Sharma University of Health Sciences, (2012) 7 SCC 389 is of no help to the petitioner.

    17. For the foregoing reasons, this writ petition fails and the same is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dr. Nithya M . v. Principal Secretary, Health And Family Welfare Department, Secretariat And Others
    (Feb 21, 2019)