Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 8/20 of NDPS Act, 1985
  • Section Sentence/imprisonment Fine Default 8(C) r/w. Section 20(B)(II)(C) of NDPS Act, 1985 10
  • Section 8(C) r/w. Section 20(B)(II)(C) of NDPS Act, 1985
  • Section 374 of Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 391 of Cr.P.C,
  • Section 50 of Cr.P.C,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 8/20 of NDPS Act, 1985
  • Section Sentence/imprisonment Fine Default 8(C) r/w. Section 20(B)(II)(C) of NDPS Act, 1985 10
  • Section 8(C) r/w. Section 20(B)(II)(C) of NDPS Act, 1985
  • Section 374 of Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 391 of Cr.P.C,
  • Section 50 of Cr.P.C,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Vivek Rusia, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal under Section 374 of the Code of Criminal Procedure challenges the judgment dated 22.03.2012 of the Special Judge (NDPS), Shajapur, in Sessions Trial No. 12/2009. The trial court convicted the appellant under Section 8(C) read with Section 20(B)(II)(C) of the NDPS Act, 1985 and sentenced him to 10 years rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 1,00,000/-, and an additional 1000 days RI in default of payment.

The prosecution case, as recorded in the opinion, states that on information received on 11.8.2009 that one "Gokul" of gram Nimkheda had a narcotic substance in his house, police went to the village and, finding the house locked, broke the lock and found four bags containing cannabis (ganja) weighing 48 kg 200 gms. Samples of 100 g each were taken and sealed as Articles A/1 and A/2. The search was carried out without a search warrant on the stated grounds of distance (45 kms) and the possibility of disposal of contraband. A criminal case (crime no. 138/2009) was registered, and during investigation the house was found to be registered in the name of the present appellant (Gangadhar), whereupon he was added in the charge-sheet along with co-accused Gokul.

At trial the prosecution examined 17 witnesses and produced 39 documents (Exhibits P/1 to P/39). The appellant produced an agreement of sale dated 12.06.2009 (Exhibit P/28) claiming he had sold the house to Gokul for Rs. 45,000/-. The trial court acquitted Gokul but convicted Gangadhar (the present appellant), holding the alleged agreement to be forged, finding the house remained in the appellant's name (including as shown in the voter list), and drawing the presumption that the recovered cannabis belonged to the appellant. The appellant appealed against this conviction and sentence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction can be sustained by drawing a presumption of possession against the appellant on the basis that the house where contraband was found was registered in his name.
  2. Whether non-compliance with the procedure prescribed under Section 50 of the NDPS Act vitiates the search and consequent conviction.
  3. Whether both seized samples (Article A/1 and Article A/2) were required to be sent to the forensic laboratory and whether failure to send A/2 affects the prosecution case.
  4. Whether the agreement of sale dated 12.06.2009 (Exhibit P/28) is admissible and sufficient to show transfer of title/possession to Gokul.
  5. Whether additional evidence (affidavit of Ghasiram) should be admitted under Section 391 Cr.P.C. in the criminal appeal to establish that possession was handed over to Gokul.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as presented to the Court)

  • The information and search related to the house of Gokul; when police arrived the appellant himself took them to Gokul's house and signed panchnama documents as a witness (Exhibits P/20 and P/21), indicating he had relinquished possession and would not have brought the team to a house of his own.
  • The appellant had already sold the house to Gokul by agreement dated 12.06.2009 (Exhibit P/28) and given possession, so the conviction based on presumption of ownership is erroneous.
  • Mandatory procedure under Section 50 of the NDPS Act was not followed; reliance was placed on the decisions Vijay Singh Chandubha Jadeja v. State of Gujarat ((2011) 1 SCC 609) and Arif Khan @ Agha Khan v. State of Uttarakhand (AIR 2018 SC 2123) to submit that failure to comply requires acquittal.
  • Only Article A/1 was sent to the forensic laboratory; Article A/2 was not tested. Further, the prosecution included leaves and seeds in the recovered material to make up a commercial quantity of 48.200 kg, whereas the definition of "cannabis" (Section 2(iii)) refers to ganja as the flowery/fruiting tops and not leaves or seeds—this, the appellant argued, inflated the quantity.
  • The search witness Ghasiram, who allegedly gave information about Gokul's house, was not examined; the appellant sought to place Ghasiram's affidavit on record under Section 391 Cr.P.C.

Respondent/State's Arguments (as presented to the Court)

  • The search revealed that the house was locked, the lock was broken, and cannabis (48 kg 200 gms) was recovered; initial information implicated Gokul but investigation revealed the house was registered in the appellant's (Gangadhar's) name and that the appellant had prepared a false agreement to implicate Gokul.
  • Because the house was owned by the appellant, the trial court rightly drew the presumption against him and convicted him; no interference is required.
  • The appellant could not invoke Section 50 of the NDPS Act because at the time of the search he was not an accused; the search was conducted in respect of Gokul's house and only later was the appellant shown to be the registered owner.
  • Sending Article A/1 to the forensic laboratory was proper; Article A/2 is required to be sent only if the accused requests its examination, and that request was not made at trial.
  • The power under Section 391 Cr.P.C. to admit additional evidence in a criminal appeal is exceptional and should be exercised with caution; the appellant's attempt to rely on Ghasiram's affidavit does not satisfy the exceptional circumstances needed to admit additional evidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vijay Singh Chandubha Jadeja v. State of Gujarat, (2011) 1 SCC 609 Cited by the appellant to support that procedure under Section 50 of the NDPS Act is mandatory and non-compliance vitiates prosecution. The court considered the appellant's reliance on this authority but rejected the submission on facts: it held that the appellant could not take advantage of non-compliance with Section 50 because he was not an accused at the time of the search.
Arif Khan @ Agha Khan v. State of Uttarakhand, AIR 2018 SC 2123 Cited by the appellant for the proposition that Section 50 procedure under NDPS Act is mandatory. The court acknowledged the precedent relied upon but, on the factual matrix before it, held that the appellant's contention based on Section 50 was not available to him because he was not an accused when the search took place.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The following summarizes the court's step-by-step analysis as recorded in the opinion.

  1. The court accepted the core investigative facts recorded by the prosecution: police received information regarding Gokul's house, reached the village, found the house locked, broke the lock, and recovered 48 kg 200 gms of cannabis. Samples (Articles A/1 and A/2) were taken and sealed.
  2. Regarding the agreement of sale (Exhibit P/28) said to show transfer of the house to Gokul, the court relied on evidence produced at trial: PW11 (Tolaram), one of the alleged witnesses to the agreement, denied making the thumb impression and said he signs in Hindi. Tolaram also stated that the house was in front of his house and that the appellant (Gangadhar) was using it and that Gokul never used it. The court noted the agreement was neither registered nor executed on proper stamp paper, so for want of registration under Section 17 of the Registration Act and for insufficient stamping it was not admissible to transfer title or possession.
  3. The trial court's finding that the agreement was forged was supported by the evidence: denial by Tolaram of his thumb impression and inconsistencies in signatures (Ghasiram's affidavit later differed from how Ghasiram purportedly signed the agreement). The court concluded the agreement did not effect transfer of title or possession to Gokul.
  4. The court drew attention to the voter list and the fact that the house remained recorded in the appellant's name and that, except for the appellant, no one was residing in or using the house. On these facts the trial court's presumption that the seized quantity belonged to the appellant was held to be rightly drawn.
  5. On the contention regarding Section 50 of the NDPS Act, the court held the appellant could not take advantage of alleged non-compliance because at the time of the search he was not an accused; the search was carried out in relation to Gokul's house and only later did investigation reveal the house's registration in the appellant's name. Thus, non-compliance with Section 50 did not, on these facts, entitle the appellant to relief.
  6. Concerning the forensic testing of samples, the court observed that Article A/1 was sent to the forensic laboratory for verification. Article A/2 was not sent; the opinion records the prosecution's position that Article A/2 is to be sent only when the accused makes a request to the trial court, and that the appellant had not raised this ground at trial. The court found no merit in the late objection.
  7. On the application under Section 391 Cr.P.C. to admit Ghasiram's affidavit as additional evidence, the court reiterated the settled principle that reception of additional evidence in a criminal appeal is exceptional and permissible only where failure of justice is likely without it. The court found the affidavit unreliable and inconsistent with the record (for example, Ghasiram's signature/format differed), and noted that other evidence (PW11's denial, unregistered and unstamped deed) undermined the claim of transferred possession. Accordingly, the court refused to admit the additional evidence.
  8. Having considered the evidence, the court concluded there was no reason to interfere with the trial court's findings: the agreement was unreliable and inadmissible to transfer title/possession; the house remained attributable to the appellant; the presumption drawn by the trial court was justified; procedural contentions did not avail the appellant on the facts; and additional evidence was not fit to be admitted. The appeal was therefore dismissed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed and the conviction and sentence imposed by the Special Judge (NDPS), Shajapur in Sessions Trial No. 12/2009 are upheld. In the court's words, no interference was called for.

Direct effect: The appellant's conviction under Section 8(C) read with Section 20(B)(II)(C) of the NDPS Act, 1985 and the sentence of 10 years RI with a fine of Rs. 1,00,000/- (and 1000 days additional RI in default) remain in force.

Implications: The opinion confines its reasoning to the facts of the case and the application of existing principles; it does not purport to lay down any novel legal proposition or broad precedent beyond applying established rules on admissibility of unregistered/insufficiently stamped documents, the limited scope for relief under Section 50 when the person was not an accused at the time of search, and the exceptional nature of admitting additional evidence under Section 391 Cr.P.C.

    Gangadhar v. State Of M.P.

    Vivek Rusia, J.:— The present appeal has been filed under Section 374 of Cr.P.C., against the judgment dt.22.03.2012, passed by the Special Judge, (NDPS) Shajapur, in Sessions Trial No. 12/2009, by which the appellant has been convicted and sentenced as under:—

    Conviction under Section Sentence/imprisonment Fine Default 8(C) r/w. Section 20(B)(II)(C) of NDPS Act, 1985 10 years of R.I. 1,00,000/- 1000 days additional R.I.

    2. As per prosecution story, Shri S.N. Choudhary, Inspector posted at Police Station Badodiya, received the information on 11.8.2009 that one Gokul resident of gram Nimkheda has kept the narcotic substance in his house. The panchnama of the aforesaid information was prepared in presence of R. Ganesh Joshi and Suraj Singh and recorded in the Rojnamchasana of 21.5.2011 at 16.45 hrs. One copy was sent to the office of SDOP Shujalpur, Mukesh Patel Constable 317 was sent for calling the witnesses and constable Badrilal 596 was sent to arrange weighing machine and thereafter, they moved to conduct the search without search warrant because of the distance 45 Kms and possibility of disposal of the contraband articles. A team headed by ASI V.P. Dubey reached to the village Nimkheda and on the information of the witness Gangadhar, Guard Ghasiram, a panchnama was prepared. They reached to the house of Gokul and found it locked from outside. They prepared a panchnama for breaking the lock. After breaking the lock they entered inside the house and found that 4 bags containing the cannabis (Ganja). After following due process they measured the quantity of the cannabis (Ganja) as 48 Kg.200 gms. They took out the sample of 100-100 grmsand kept the same in seal pocket as Article A/1 and A/2. The boxes were sealed and panchnama was prepared. Since accused Gokul was not present in the house at the time of search hence in his absence, investigation was completed and a criminal case was registered against the appellant under Section 8/20 of NDPS Act, 1985 in connection with crime no. 138/2009. During the investigation, it was found that the said house is registered in the name of present appellant Gangadhar, therefore, his name was also added in the charge sheet. After completing the usual investigation, the challan was filed against the present appellant and co-accused Gokul.

    3. The prosecution examined as many as 17 witnesses and got exhibit 39 documents as Exhibit P/1 to P/39 and statements and Suresh and Tolaram as Exhibit D/1 and D/2. The appellant has got seized an agreement of sale dated 12.06.2009 Exhibit P/28, by which according to him he had sold the house to co-accused Gokul in total consideration of Rs. 45,000/- in which the cannabis (Ganja) was found.

    4. After appreciating the evidence which came on record the learned Special Judge came to the conclusion that the contraband the cannabis (Ganja) quantity weighing 48 Kg.200 grms was not found into the conscious possession of Gokul as he is not owner of the said house from where it was recovered, therefore, the court has acquitted him. The learned Sessions Judge has held that Gangadhar prepared the forged agreement to sale of the said house but same is still recorded in his name as shown in the voter list also, therefore, it is presumed that the seized quantity of cannabis was belonging to him and accordingly, he has been convicted under Section 8(C) r/w. Section 20(B)(II)(C) of NDPS Act, 1985 and sentenced to 10 years RI with fine of Rs. 1,00,000/-. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid conviction and sentence, the appellant has preferred this appeal.

    5. Shri P. Nair, learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the information was received that Gokul is keeping the contraband articles in his house. When the team came to the village, the appellant himself took them to the house of Gokul. He signed the Exhibits P/20 and P/21 as a witness. On his disclosure the search was conducted in the house of Gokul. Had the house belonged to him then, he would not have taken the search team to the said house. He has already sold the house and given the possession to Gokul vide agreement dt.12.6.2009, therefore, he has wrongly been convicted on the basis of presumption on the ground that the house belongs to him.

    6. Shri Nair, learned counsel for the appellant has further submitted that the procedure prescribed U/s.50 of the NDPS Act was not followed, which is mandatory in nature as held by the Apex Court in the case of Vijay Singh Chandubha Jadeja v. State of Gujarat reported as (2011) 1 SCC 609 and in the case of Arif Khan @ Agha Khan v. State of Uttarakhand, reported as AIR 2018 SC 2123, therefore, the appellant is entitled for the acquittal. He further submitted that two samples were prepared as Article A/1 and A/2 and only Article A/1 was sent to the FSL Laboratory and there is no report in respect of Article A/2. He has further drawn attention of this court to the definition of cannabis as defined U/s. 2(iii) according to which Ganja is only flowery and the fruits fruiting top at cannabis plant in which the seeds and the leave are not included, but the prosecution has collected the seeds and the leaves also from the spot and added in the quantity to make it 48. Kg200 grams which made it commercial quantity. This fact is evident from Exhibit P/39. He further submitted that the when the search team reached to the village Ghasiram has given the information in respect of the house of Gokul, but he was not examined as a witness. Therefore, the appellant has filed application under Section 391 of Cr.P.C, for taking the affidavit of Ghasiram on record.

    7. In view of the aforesaid ground, Shri Nair, learned counsel for the appellant prays for acquittal of the appellant.

    8. Shri Pankaj Wadhwani, public prosecutor appearing for respondent/State argued that initially the information was received that the Gokul has kept the contraband articles in his house. The search was conducted. The said house was found locked and in an absence of Gokul, the entire proceedings were conducted. During the investigation, it was found that the house is owned by the present appellant who prepared a false agreement to sale in order to implicate Gokul falsely. Since the house belonging to the appellant, therefore, by way of presumption, the learned trial Court has rightly convicted him hence, no interference is called for. The provisions of 391 of Cr. P.C. cannot be invoked to fulfil the lacuna. The power of 391 of Cr.P.C. is liable to be exercised only in exceptional circumstances. Hence the appeal is liable to be dismissed.

    9. It is not in dispute that as per the information received by the police, a search was conducted in the house and which was found locked from outside. The lock was broken and the cannabis (Ganja) quantity 48 Kg.200 grms was recovered. Initially police received the information that the said house is belonging to Gokul and when they reached to the spot the appellant Gangadhar and Ghasiram took them to the said house. After breaking the lock a search was conducted and police found cannabis (Ganja) quantity 48 Kg.200 grms. During investigation the police has collected so called agreement to sale by which the present appellant said to have sold the said house to co-accused Gokul in total consideration of Rs. 45,000/-. The said agreement said to have been executed on 12.6.2009 in presence of two witnesses Ghansiram and Tolaram. Tolaram was examined as PW11, who stated that the said agreement to sale is a forged as he never puts his thumb impression because he signs in Hindi. His statement recorded by the police is also marked as Exhibit D/1A. In his statement he has also stated that the said house is infront of his house and appellant - Gangadhar is using the same and he also knows the Gokul who never used the said house, therefore, it is not in dispute that the said house is owned by the present appellant. According to him he has sold the same to Gokul by agreement dt.12.6.2009 but same is neither registered nor executed on any stamp paper, therefore, for want of registration u/s.17 of the Registration Act, it is not admissible in evidence as well as for want of insufficient stamp, it cannot be looked into. By this agreement no title was transferred to Gokul. Even Gokul has never claimed the possession by virtue of the said agreement. Therefore, the learned special judge has rightly held that the said deed was prepared by the appellant in order to save himself from the prosecution. The learned trial court also placed reliance over entries of the voter list in which the said house is recorded in front of the name of the appellant. Except the appellant, no one was using or residing in the said house, therefore, the presumption has rightly been drawn against the present appellant.

    10. So far the applicability of Section 50 of Cr.P.C, is concerned, the appellant cannot be permitted to take the advantage of the same because when the search was conducted, he was not made accused. The search was conducted in the name of the house belonging to Gokul. Later on, during investigation, it was found that the said house is registered in the name of Gangaram. At the time of search, the present appellant was not in the criminal case; therefore, he cannot take a plea that the search ought to have been conducted in the present of Magistrate or gazetted officer.

    11. So far the Article A/1 and Article A/2 are concerned; the prosecution has rightly sent the Article A/1 to the forensic laboratory for verification of the cannabis (Ganja). Article A/2 is liable to be sent only when the accused makes a request to the trial court. Even otherwise, this ground has not been raised during the trial, therefore, at this stage, the appellant cannot raise this ground.

    12. So far the application filed under Section 391 of Cr.P.C. is concerned, it is settled law that the reception of additional evidence in criminal appeal may be allowed when there is a likelihood of the failure of justice without it. It is an exception to the general rule and the power conferred by this provision must be exercised with great care.

    13. By this additional evidence the appellant wanted to establish that by way of agreement dt.12.6.2009, the house was sold to Gokul in which Ghasiram has signed as witness. In this affidavit, he has also stated that the possession of the house was also handed over to Gokul, but as held above, no right and title was transferred to Gokul by virtue of this agreement for want of its registration as well as insufficiently stamped. One of the witness PW11 Tolaram of the said agreement to sale has already denied his thumb impression. Ghasiram has put thumb impression in this affidavit, whereas, in agreement to sale, he has signed in hindi as Ghasiram Kotwal, which also establishes that deed is a forged one.

    14. In view of the above, no interference is called for. The appeal fails and is, accordingly, dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gangadhar v. State Of M.P.
    (Jan 2, 2019)