AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The private respondents were initially appointed as daily-wage Beldars, later received work-charge status, and were working as regular Beldars when they retired. They applied for gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. [1]

The Controlling Authority directed payment of gratuity for the entire daily-wage period, calculated on the basis of last-drawn wages, with 9% interest. The appellate authority modified the order and awarded gratuity based on the emoluments last drawn as regular Beldars. [1][2]

The petitioners challenged the appellate award before the Court. [3]

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the appropriate mode and method of calculating gratuity for employees who initially served on a daily-wage basis and were subsequently regularized? [4]
  2. Whether gratuity should be calculated separately under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, or for the entire period of service on the basis of the last pay drawn at superannuation. [5][6][7][8][9]

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The appellate authority’s findings were erroneous and illegal because gratuity should have been calculated on the wages last drawn during the period of daily-wage service, rather than on the salary received as regular Beldars. [3]

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of H.P. v. Lashkari Ram, 2007 Lab.I.C.3760 : 2008 (1) SLC 245 : 2008 (ii) LLJ 513 Daily-wage service was to be covered under the Payment of Gratuity Act, while the period after regularization was to be covered under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. The Court identified this decision as one side of the apparent conflict. [5][10][11][12][13][9]
H.P.S.E.B. v. Balak Ram, 2007 (3) Shim.L.C. 202 The entire period of continuous service, including daily-wage and regular service, was directed to be counted for gratuity on the basis of the last pay drawn at superannuation. The Court identified this decision as conflicting with Lashkari Ram and noted that subsequent coordinate benches followed its ratio. [14][15][16][9][17]
H. Gangahanume Gowda v. Karnataka Agro Industries Corpn. Ltd. The decision was cited regarding interest payable on gratuity. It was relied upon in the directions concerning interest on gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act. [12]
Principal Secretary (Forests) v. Amar Chand, CWP No. 2307/2016, decided on 13.12.2017 The Court stated that this coordinate-bench decision followed the ratio in Balak Ram. It was mentioned as part of the conflict requiring resolution; the Court noted that Lashkari Ram did not appear to have been brought to that bench’s notice. [17]
Executive Engineer, HPSEBL v. Madan Lal Negi, CWP No. 3335/2016, decided on 13.6.2018 The Court stated that this coordinate-bench decision followed the ratio in Balak Ram. It was mentioned as part of the conflict requiring resolution; the Court noted that Lashkari Ram did not appear to have been brought to that bench’s notice. [17]

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court observed that the petitions raised a recurring and significant question concerning gratuity payable to employees who moved from daily-wage employment to regular service. [4][18][19]

It examined Lashkari Ram, which adopted a split approach: the daily-wage period was governed by the Payment of Gratuity Act, while the regular-service period was governed by the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. [5][10][11][13]

It then considered Balak Ram, where the entire continuous service was counted for gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act on the basis of the last pay drawn at superannuation. [14][15][16]

The Court found an apparent conflict between the two decisions. It further noted that two subsequent coordinate benches followed Balak Ram, apparently without consideration of Lashkari Ram. [9][17]

Because the issue was important and likely to recur, the Court concluded that the conflicting decisions should be resolved by a larger bench rather than deciding the merits in the present petitions. [19][20]

Holding and Implications

REFERRED FOR CONSTITUTION OF A LARGER BENCH. The Registry was directed to place the papers before the Chief Justice for constitution of a larger bench to resolve the conflict concerning calculation and payment of gratuity for employees initially engaged on daily wages and later regularized. [20]

The opinion does not finally determine the gratuity entitlement in these petitions. It instead initiates consideration by a larger bench; no new precedent was set by this procedural direction. [19][20]

    State Of H.P. And Another v. Bhoop Ram And Another

    Tarlok Singh Chauhan, J.:— The seminal issue involved in all these petitions is with regard to mode and method of payment of gratuity to workmen, who had initially worked on daily-wage basis and were thereafter regularized.

    2. However, before answering said question, certain minimal facts need to be noticed.

    3. The private respondents in all these cases were appointed as daily-wage Beldars and after putting in about decade's service, they were conferred with work charge status and at the time of retirement, they were working as regular Beldars. They individually filed application(s) before the Controlling Authority-cum-Labour Officer under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (in short, “the Act”) claiming gratuity. The same was allowed by directing the petitioners to pay private respondents gratuity for the entire period rendered by them on daily-wage basis taking into consideration the wages last drawn with interest @ 9% per annum.

    4. The private respondents filed an appeal(s) against the said order before the appellate authority, i.e. Joint Labour Commissioner, Shimla, who allowed the same and awarded gratuity to them under the Payment of Gratuity Act taking into consideration the emoluments last drawn as regular Beldars and accordingly modified the order.

    5. It is against this award that the petitioners have filed the present petitions on the ground that the findings recorded by the appellate authority are wrong and illegal as instead of calculating gratuity on the salary drawn by the private respondents as regular Beldars, the same was required to be calculated on the basis of the wages last drawn by them, for the period they rendered daily wage service.

    6. It is in this background, the aforesaid question is required to be answered.

    7. As regards this Court, the earliest judgment on the issue is by a learned Single Judge (Justice Rajiv Sharma) in State of H.P. v. Lashkari Ram, 2007 Lab.I.C.3760 : 2008 (1) SLC 245 : 2008 (ii) LLJ 513, wherein it was held that where a workman had worked on daily-wage basis and thereafter his services had been regularized, in that event the workman is entitled to get gratuity for the period he remained on daily-wage basis under the Act, whereas for rest of the period after his regularization upto his superannuation, he would be entitled to the payment of gratuity under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. It is apt to reproduce the relevant observations, which read thus:

    “10. Two questions which require deep consideration by this Court are:

    (1) Whether the workman is entitled to get gratuity for the period he remains on daily wages basis under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and thereafter is he entitled to get the gratuity under the CCS (Pension) Rues, 1972 for the period commencing from regularization to the date of superannuation?

    (2) Whether the workman's entire period w.e.f. his initial date of engagement on daily wages basis, including the period of regularization up to superannuation, Will entitle him to get the gratuity either under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 or under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972?

    11. Admittedly, the workman has worked ‘on daily wages basis w.e.f. March, 1982 to December 31, 1993 and thereafter after his regularization as Water Guard-helper from January 1, 1994 to October 31, 2001.

    23. In view of the above discussion, the Controlling Authority was required to calculate the gratuity for the period w.e.f. March, 1982 to December 31, 1993 under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and for the remaining period, i.e. January 1, 1994 to January 31, 2001 (regular period only), the State was bound to pay the gratuity under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of with the following directions:

    (i) The workman is entitled to get the gratuity for the period w.e.f. March, 1982 to December 31, 1993 under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 with interest as power law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in H. Gangahanume Gowda v. Karnataka Agro Industries Corpn. Ltd. . (supra);

    (ii) The workman is held entitled and is to be paid the gratuity w.e.f. January 1, 1994 to January 31, 2001 (sic) (regular period) under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 with interest @ 9% per annum. The copy of the judgment be sent to the Secretary Labour & Employment for its distribution to the Controlling as well as Appellate Authority constituted under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.”

    8. Another judgment on the same issued by the same learned Judge can be found in H.P.S.E.B. v. Balak Ram, 2007 (3) Shim.L.C. 202, where however this time the entire service of the workman, which he had rendered irrespective of fact that he had rendered the same on daily-wage basis or after his service had been regularized, was ordered to be calculated under the provisions of the Act on the basis of last pay drawn by him at the time of superannuation. It will be apposite to refer to the relevant observations, which read thus:—

    “31. The workman had continuously worked with the petitioner-Board initially on daily wages and thereafter on regular basis and thus he always remained in continuous service of the petitioner-Board.

    32. The upshot of the above discussion is that the order passed by the appellate authority dated November 16, 2002 cannot be faulted with. The entire period rendered by the workman with effect from 1983 to 1998 is to be counted for the purpose of determining the gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The workman is entitled to get the gratuity on the basis of last pay drawn by him i.e. Rs. 4239/- at the time of superannuation. The order passed by the appellate authority allowing interest with effect from February 1, 1999 cannot be interfered in view of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as cited above.”

    9. Evidently, there is an apparent conflict in both the judgments, as referred to above, as in similar circumstances where workman initially rendered his services as daily-wage worker and thereafter regular employee, in Lashkari Ram's case (supra), the period of service rendered by him as daily wage workman was directed to the calculated under the Act, whereas the subsequent period of service rendered by him on regular basis was directed to be calculated under the provisions of CCS (Pension) Rules, whereas in Balak Ram's case (supra), the entire service of the workman, initially on daily-wage basis and thereafter on regular basis, was ordered to be calculated under the provisions of CCS (Pension) Rules on the basis of last pay drawn by him at the time of superannuation.

    10. Apart from above, it would be noticed that two subsequent coordinate benches of this Court in their decisions rendered in CWP No. 2307/2016, titled as Principal Secretary (Forests) v. Amar Chand, decided on 13.12.2017 and CWP No. 3335/2016, titled as Executive Engineer, HPSEBL v. Madan Lal Negi, decided on 13.6.2018 have chosen to follow ratio in Balak Ram's case and the judgment rendered in Lashkari Ram's case does not seem to have been brought to the notice of the aforesaid coordinate benches.

    11. The question raised in these petitions is of great significance and importance and is likely to come up repeatedly before the Courts, therefore, it is not only desirable, but also imperative that the conflict amongst the various decisions is resolved at the earliest.

    12. Accordingly, the registry is directed to place the papers before the Hon'ble the Chief Justice for constitution of a larger bench.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of H.P. And Another v. Bhoop Ram And Another
    (Sep 5, 2018)