Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SC/ST Act
  • Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Rules 12(4) and (4-A) read with Annexure I of the 2016 Amendment to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Rules, 1995
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SC/ST Act
  • Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Rules 12(4) and (4-A) read with Annexure I of the 2016 Amendment to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Rules, 1995
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This order arises from a review petition challenging portions of the Supreme Court’s earlier judgment dated 20 March 2018 in Subhash v. State of Maharashtra, reported at (2018) 6 SCC 454. In that judgment the Court issued five prospective directions (paras 79.1 – 79.5) aimed at preventing abuse of arrest powers under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (“SC/ST Act”). The present proceedings were initiated after permission to file the review petition was granted and the matter was directed to be heard in open court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Directions 79.3 to 79.5 of the 20 March 2018 judgment—requiring prior approval for arrest of accused persons and mandating a preliminary inquiry—conflict with provisions of the SC/ST Act, the 2016 Amendment Rules, and the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (“CrPC”).
  2. Whether those directions delay or impede immediate compensation and other statutory reliefs to victims belonging to Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes.

Arguments of the Parties

Attorney General / Union of India

  • Immediate monetary compensation under Rules 12(4) and 12(4-A) of the 2016 Amendment to the SC/ST Rules may be delayed if a preliminary inquiry precedes First Information Report (“FIR”) registration.
  • A preliminary inquiry may postpone registration of offences under the Indian Penal Code or other laws that accompany an SC/ST Act allegation.
  • The directions allegedly conflict with procedural mandates in the CrPC.

Amicus Curiae (Shri Amarendra Sharan, Senior Advocate)

  • The preliminary inquiry is limited to seven days (para 76 of the earlier judgment) and can be initiated immediately, so victim compensation need not be delayed.
  • Compensation is independent of FIR registration; it can be disbursed forthwith while inquiry proceeds.
  • Non-SC/ST offences can be registered immediately, and SC/ST Act offences may be added after inquiry.
  • No provision of the SC/ST Act concerning compensation, trial, or punishment has been diluted; the directions merely shield innocent persons from false implication and arbitrary arrest.
  • Public discourse has mischaracterised the directions, necessitating clarification.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Subhash v. State of Maharashtra (2018) 6 SCC 454 Original judgment containing Directions 79.1-79.5 regarding arrest safeguards and preliminary inquiry. Order under review; specific focus on Directions 79.3-79.5.
Pankaj D. Suthar v. State of Gujarat (1992) 1 Guj LR 405 Recognised that anticipatory bail is not absolutely barred under the SC/ST Act where complaint appears mala fide. Earlier judgment approved this view; referenced here as part of Direction 79.2.
N.T. Desai v. State of Gujarat (1997) 2 Guj LR 942 Same principle as above regarding anticipatory bail. Approved in Direction 79.2 of earlier judgment.
State of M.P. v. Ram Kishna Balothia (1995) 3 SCC 221 Previous Supreme Court view on anticipatory bail under the SC/ST Act. Clarified, not overruled, in Direction 79.2.
Manju Devi v. Onkarjit Singh Ahluwalia (2017) 13 SCC 439 Another decision on anticipatory bail under the SC/ST Act. Clarified in Direction 79.2.
Lalita Kumari v. State of U.P. (2014) 2 SCC 1 Mandates time-bound preliminary inquiry (maximum seven days) before FIR in specific circumstances. Cited in para 76 to cap the duration of the preliminary inquiry ordered in Direction 79.4.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Bench confined its present review to Directions 79.3-79.5 of the earlier judgment. After hearing the Attorney General and the Amicus, the Court observed:

  • Nothing in the impugned directions prevents the immediate payment of compensation or other reliefs to SC/ST victims; such benefits can be disbursed without delay.
  • Registration of FIRs under the Penal Code or any other statute need not await completion of the preliminary inquiry; SC/ST Act offences can be added later if warranted.
  • Consequently, the contested directions do not dilute any substantive provision concerning compensation, trial, or punishment under the SC/ST Act; instead, they serve as procedural safeguards against misuse of arrest powers and false implication.

The Court emphasized that these observations align with the submissions of the Amicus Curiae and counter the concerns expressed by the Attorney General.

Holding and Implications

ORDER: Permission to file the review petition is granted and the matter will be heard in open court. The Court deferred substantive hearing, directing the State of Maharashtra and intervenors representing SC/ST members to file written submissions, after which the case will be listed again.

Implications: The original Directions 79.3-79.5 remain in force for the moment; no final determination on their validity has yet been made. Immediate compensation and FIR registration are clarified as unaffected. The matter’s ultimate resolution awaits further argument, so no new precedent has been set at this stage.

    Union Of India v. State Of Maharashtra And Others

    Order

    1. Permission to file review petition is granted. The same is permitted to be heard in the open court.

    2. We have heard the learned Attorney General, learned counsel for the parties and the learned Amicus, Shri Amarendra Sharan, learned Senior Advocate.

    3. The review has been sought of order of this Court dated 20-3-2018 (2018) 6 SCC 454. The operative part is as follows: (Subhash case (2018) 6 SCC 454)

    “79. Our conclusions are as follows:
    79.1. Proceedings in the present case are clear abuse of process of court and are quashed.
    79.2. There is no absolute bar against grant of anticipatory bail in cases under the Atrocities Act if no prima facie case is made out or where on judicial scrutiny the complaint is found to be prima facie mala fide. We approve the view taken and approach of the Gujarat High Court in Pankaj D. Suthar v. State of Gujarat (1992) 1 Guj LR 405 and N.T. Desai v. State of Gujarat (1997) 2 Guj LR 942 and clarify the judgments of this Court in State of M.P. v. Ram Kishna Balothia (1995) 3 SCC 221 and Manju Devi v. Onkarjit Singh Ahluwalia (2017) 13 SCC 439;
    79.3. In view of acknowledged abuse of law of arrest in cases under the Atrocities Act, arrest of a public servant can only be after approval of the appointing authority and of a non-public servant after approval by the SSP which may be granted in appropriate cases if considered necessary for reasons recorded. Such reasons must be scrutinised by the Magistrate for permitting further detention.
    79.4. To avoid false implication of an innocent, a preliminary enquiry may be conducted by the DSP concerned to find out whether the allegations make out a case under the Atrocities Act and that the allegations are not frivolous or motivated.
    79.5. Any violation of Directions 79.3 and 79.4 will be actionable by way of disciplinary action as well as contempt.
    The above directions are prospective.”

    4. Para 79.4 is to be read with para 76 as follows: (Subhash case (2018) 6 SCC 454)

    “76. … Such inquiry must be time-bound and should not exceed seven days in view of directions in Lalita Kumari v. State of U.P. (2014) 2 SCC 1”

    5. The learned Attorney General has focused on and accordingly we confine our consideration to Directions 79.3 to 79.5.

    6. It is pointed out that as per Rules 12(4) and (4-A) read with Annexure I of the 2016 Amendment to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Rules, 1995, immediate compensation or other assistance has to be given to victim belonging to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. If there is delay in preliminary inquiry, payment of such compensation or other immediate relief may be delayed. The second submission is that there may be offences under the provision of the Penal Code, 1860 or any other law and direction to hold preliminary inquiry may delay registration of case in respect of such other offences also. The third submission is that the directions are in conflict with the provision of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

    7. The learned Amicus submitted that the directions in the order of this Court do not in any manner obstruct the grant of relief as preliminary inquiry can be held forthwith. Seven days is the outer limit. He also submitted that compensation is different from registration of FIR or arrest. The compensation can be given forthwith, subject to further action. He submitted that there is no obstruction to a case under any other provision being registered forthwith. Offence under SC/ST can be added subsequently after the preliminarily inquiry. He further submitted that no provision of SC/ST Act relating to compensation, trial or punishment or otherwise has been in any manner diluted. What has been laid down is safeguard against false implications and arrest by the police by itself or at the instance of any other vested interest. The directions do not in any manner prejudice the remedy of the members of the SC/ST Act. The directions only protect the innocent against abuse of law. Wrong and misleading projection in this regard needs to be checked.

    8. A perusal of the order of this Court makes it clear that there is no bar to compensation or other immediate relief being given to the victim member of the SC/ST as per the provisions noted above without any delay whatsoever. There is also no bar to registration of FIR under any provision of the Penal Code or any other law and the offences under the SC/ST Act being added later, if necessary. Thus, there is no dilution of any provision of the SC/ST Act relating to compensation, trial, punishment or otherwise. The order only safeguards abuse of power of arrest or of false implication of an innocent without in any manner affecting the rights of the members of the SC/ST, as rightly submitted by the learned Amicus.

    9. The matter may have to be heard and considered further but since Shri Tushar Mehta, learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the State of Maharashtra and Shri C.U. Singh, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the intervenor representing members of SC/ST, seek time to file written submissions, hearing is deferred. Let the written submissions be filed.

    10. List the matter after written submissions are filed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India v. State Of Maharashtra And Others
    (Apr 3, 2018)