AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from an application filed under Order 8 Rule 10 CPC read with section 16 of the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015, seeking to have the written statement filed by defendant No. 1 taken off the record. The genesis lies in a prior order dated 05.12.2017, where the court dismissed an application by defendant No. 1 under Order 7 Rules 10 and 11 CPC. In that order, the court granted defendant No. 1 an extension to file the written statement by 15.12.2017, subject to payment of costs of Rs. 25,000 to the plaintiff's counsel. Defendant No. 1 complied by filing the written statement before the deadline and issuing a cheque for the costs, which the plaintiff did not encash. The plaintiff later challenged the validity of the extension and sought to have the written statement struck off the record through the present application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court had the discretion to extend the time for filing the written statement beyond 120 days after service of summons, in light of statutory amendments and relevant case law.
  2. Whether the written statement filed by defendant No. 1 pursuant to the court's order dated 05.12.2017 should be struck off the record on the plaintiff's challenge.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The extension granted to defendant No. 1 to file the written statement beyond 120 days was contrary to the statute.
  • Reliance was placed on a judgment of this court in OKU Tech Pvt. Ltd. v. Sangeeta Agarwal (11.08.2016), where a Co-ordinate Bench held that discretion to extend time beyond 120 days after summons service no longer exists due to amendments to the CPC.
  • Other judgments were cited reiterating the principle that no extension beyond 120 days is permissible.
  • The plaintiff contended that the cheque for costs was never encashed, challenging compliance with the court's condition.

Defendant No. 1's Position

  • Defendant No. 1 complied with the court's order dated 05.12.2017 by filing the written statement before 15.12.2017.
  • Payment of costs was made to the plaintiff's counsel by cheque as ordered.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
OKU Tech Pvt. Ltd. v. Sangeeta Agarwal (11.08.2016, CS(OS) 3390/2015) Discretion to extend time for filing written statement beyond 120 days after service of summons no longer survives due to CPC amendments. The court noted the plaintiff’s reliance on this precedent but held that the order granting extension had attained finality and was not challenged in time, thus not disturbed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the procedural history and noted that the order dated 05.12.2017, which granted defendant No. 1 extension to file the written statement upon payment of costs, had attained finality. The court emphasized that if the plaintiff believed the order was erroneous, the proper remedy was to file a review or appeal promptly, which was not done. The plaintiff's delay in filing the present application was noted, along with the fact that defendant No. 1 complied with the order by filing the written statement and issuing the cheque for costs. The court rejected the plaintiff’s contention regarding the statutory bar on extending time beyond 120 days as the order had not been challenged timely and therefore stood binding. Consequently, the court dismissed the application and took the written statement on record.

Holding and Implications

The application to strike off the written statement filed by defendant No. 1 is dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is that the written statement filed by defendant No. 1 pursuant to the court's order dated 05.12.2017 remains on record. The court did not set any new precedent but reaffirmed the principle that orders attaining finality must be challenged within the prescribed time and that belated applications are misplaced.

    Scg Contracts India Pvt. Ltd. v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.

    Jayant Nath, J.:—

    IA No. 10569/2018

    1. This application is filed under Order 8 Rule 10 CPC read with section 16 of the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015 to direct the written statement filed by defendant No. 1 be taken off the record.

    2. Genesis of this application lies in the order of this court dated 05.12.2017. This court on that date had dismissed IA No. 14346/2017 filed under Order 7 Rules 10 and 11 CPC filed by defendant No. 1. After having dismissed the said application, this court had accordingly made the following orders:

    “9. The counsel for the defendant No. 1 now states that seven days time be granted to file written statement.

    10. None appears for the plaintiff inspite of advance copy stated to have been given.

    11. The counsel for the plaintiff having not bothered to appear, need to issue notice to him for consideration of the said request, is not felt.

    12. Though I have refrained from imposing costs on the defendant No. 1, even though the application aforesaid was found to be totally misconceived but now it appears that the application was filed only to get over the time for filing the written statement which had lapsed.

    13. Further time cannot be granted without imposition of costs on the defendant No. 1.

    14. Subject to the defendant No. 1 paying costs of Rs. 25,000/- to the counsel for the plaintiff on or before 15 December, 2017, the time for filing the written statement is extended till 15 December, 2017. If either of the conditions is not complied with, the right of the defendant No. 1 to file written statement shall stand closed without any further order.”

    3. It appears that defendant No. 1 has filed written statement before 15.12.2017 and has also transmitted the cost of Rs. 25,000/- to the counsel for the plaintiff by a cheque.

    4. The grievance of the plaintiff in the present application is that the opportunity granted by this court vide order dated 05.12.2017 to file written statement is contrary to the statute as 120 days had already expired by the date written statement was filed. Reliance is placed on the judgment of this court in the case of OKU Tech Pvt. Ltd. v. Sangeeta Agarwal, decided on 11.08.2016, CS(OS) 3390/2015 to submit that a Co-ordinate Bench of this court has held that the discretion of the court to extend the time for filing written statement beyond 120 days after service of summons no longer survives in view of the amendments to the CPC. Reliance is also placed on some other judgments reiterating the above proposition of law.

    5. I may only note some of the facts. After the order was passed on 05.12.2017, time was granted to defendant No. 1 to file written statement on or before 15.12.2017. Defendant No. 1 made a compliance of the order and filed written statement, purportedly on behalf of defendants No. 1 and 2. The payment of costs was sent to the plaintiff vide cheque which cheque has not been encashed by the plaintiff. The plaintiff has now on 06.08.2018 woken up and filed the present application stating that the written statement placed on record be struck off the record.

    6. At this stage, the learned counsel for the plaintiff however states that the application was filed earlier but was lying under objecting, some talks of compromise were also going on between the parties. However, a perusal of this application shows that it is dated 06.08.2018, the affidavit was also attested in support of this application on 06.08.2018. It is also stated by the learned counsel for the plaintiff that the cheque of Rs. 25,000/- was never encashed.

    7. In my opinion, the order of this court dated 05.12.2017 has attained finality. If there was an error in the said order, the plaintiff had to challenge the said order in a higher court. In case, there was an error apparent on the face of the record, the plaintiff had to take steps to file a review application against the said order. But no such application/appeal was filed and belatedly now the present application has been filed.

    8. As the order dated 05.12.2017 had attained finality, in my opinion, the present application is misplaced. The same is dismissed. Hence, the written statement filed by defendant No. 1 is taken on record.

    CS(COMM) 199/2017

    9. List before the Joint Registrar on 09.10.2018. Let the replication to the written statement filed by defendant No. 1 be filed within four weeks from today.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Scg Contracts India Pvt. Ltd. v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.
    (Sep 24, 2018)