AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Acts
  • Statutory Notices U/s 13(2) of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets & Enforcement of Security Interest Act ("SARFAESI")
  • 05.07.2018, 18.08.2018 & 27.08.2018 U/s 19 of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 ("RDDBFI")
  • Section 5(1) PMLA and Section 8(1) PMLA,
  • PREVENTION OF MONEY LAUNDERING ACT
  • section 14 of the I&B Code
  • provision of Section 5(1)
  • Section 173 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 2(1)(v)
  • Section 68-E
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Acts
  • Statutory Notices U/s 13(2) of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets & Enforcement of Security Interest Act ("SARFAESI")
  • 05.07.2018, 18.08.2018 & 27.08.2018 U/s 19 of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 ("RDDBFI")
  • Section 5(1) PMLA and Section 8(1) PMLA,
  • PREVENTION OF MONEY LAUNDERING ACT
  • section 14 of the I&B Code
  • provision of Section 5(1)
  • Section 173 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 2(1)(v)
  • Section 68-E
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant, a financial institution, holds mortgage, hypothecation, pledge, and guarantee rights over various properties, shares, bank balances, valuables, and vehicles associated with Gitanjali Group entities including GGL, GECL, and NWL. These securities were created pursuant to legitimate banking transactions and credit facilities extended since 2004, with the earliest security deed executed in 2006. The Appellant initiated recovery proceedings after the borrowers failed to repay loans, declaring accounts as Non-Performing Assets and issuing statutory notices under SARFAESI and filing Original Applications before the Debt Recovery Tribunal. Insolvency proceedings under the Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code (I&B Code) were also initiated, resulting in moratoriums declared by the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) Mumbai against GGL and NWL.

The Enforcement Directorate (Respondent) provisionally attached the properties under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) on the basis that proceeds of crime were involved. The Adjudicating Authority confirmed the attachment order. The Appellant challenges the Impugned Judgment confirming the attachment order, asserting that the properties are not proceeds of crime and were mortgaged prior to the predicate offence period (2015-2017). The Appellant seeks setting aside of the Impugned Judgment on grounds including lack of valid reasons to believe, non-application of mind, and the effect of the moratorium under the I&B Code.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the properties mortgaged in favour of the Appellant qualify as proceeds of crime under Section 5(1) of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act?
  2. Whether the Adjudicating Authority correctly confirmed the Provisional Attachment Order without properly considering the Appellant's legitimate third-party claim?
  3. Whether the mandatory statutory requirement of recording and communicating 'reason to believe' prior to attachment under Sections 5(1) and 8(1) of the PMLA was complied with?
  4. Whether the moratorium declared by the NCLT under Section 14 of the I&B Code prohibits continuation of attachment proceedings under PMLA against the corporate debtors?
  5. Whether the Appellant's claim as a secured creditor with mortgage rights on the attached properties can be defeated or frustrated by the attachment order?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The properties mortgaged to the Appellant and Consortium Lenders were acquired prior to the commission of the predicate offence (2015-2017) and thus do not constitute proceeds of crime.
  • The Appellant and Consortium Lenders are bonafide third-party claimants holding legitimate security interests under valid agreements executed after due diligence.
  • The Respondent failed to record valid and independent reasons to believe as required under Sections 5(1) and 8(1) of the PMLA, rendering the attachment order invalid.
  • The moratorium declared by NCLT under the I&B Code bars continuation of civil proceedings including attachment against GGL and NWL.
  • The properties are already mortgaged/hypothecated/pledged and hence cannot be concealed, transferred, or alienated to frustrate proceedings.
  • The Appellant has initiated recovery proceedings under SARFAESI, RDDBFI, and insolvency laws and should not be deprived of pursuing its legal claims.
  • The Respondent's allegation of attempts to dispose of properties by Mehul Choksi lacks material evidence and was not stated in the Provisional Attachment Order or Complaint, amounting to a malafide afterthought.
  • The Appellant contends that the attachment order was passed without proper application of mind and understanding of the law, and the properties mortgaged to banks cannot be treated as proceeds of crime.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Respondent found that proceeds of crime amounting to Rs. 6097.63 crores were siphoned out of the country and layered overseas by entities including GGL and GECL.
  • The properties attached are involved in money laundering and thus liable for attachment under the PMLA.
  • The Respondent submitted that it is not necessary to record reasons to believe prior to passing the provisional attachment order and that such reasons need not be communicated to the aggrieved party at the stage of arguments or subsequent proceedings.
  • The Respondent alleged that during investigation, Mehul Choksi was trying to dispose of his properties, justifying the attachment order, though this was not mentioned in initial documents.
  • The Respondent opposed the claim that banks’ rights should prevail over attachment, arguing that such matters should await trial and that attachment should not be disturbed prematurely.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Khem Chand v. Union of India [AIR 1958 SC 300] Requirement that a Show-Cause Notice must fulfill basic ingredients to be valid and not vitiate proceedings. Applied to hold that absence of valid reasons to believe renders the notice and attachment order invalid.
Aslam Mohammad Merchant v. Competent Authority [2008 (14) SCC 186] Clarification on the necessity of recording reasons to believe and principles governing issuance of show cause notices. Held that reasons to believe must be recorded independently and communicated; failure vitiates proceedings.
C.B. Gautam vs. Union of India (1993 (1) SCC 78) Reasons for orders must be recorded in writing and communicated to affected parties to constitute a valid order. Applied to emphasize that reason to believe must be recorded and served to the affected party with the order.
Kranti Associates v. Masood Ahmed Khan (2010) 9 SCC 496 Judicial trend mandates recording of reasons for decisions affecting rights to ensure transparency, accountability, and fairness. Reiterated the necessity of cogent, clear, and reasoned decisions, rejecting mere rubber-stamp reasons.
Income Tax Officer v. Lakhmani Mewaldas [1976 (3) SCR 956] Requirement of a close nexus between material before authority and formation of belief for issuing notices. Applied to hold that belief must be based on material and not ipse dixit.
Joti Parshad Vs. State of Haryana [1993 Supp (2) SCC 497] Distinction between suspicion and reason to believe; reason to believe is a higher state of mind requiring sufficient cause. Used to clarify that mere suspicion does not justify attachment; proper grounds must exist.
J. Sekar v. Union of India and Ors. [2018 SCC Online Del 6523] Clarification on the dual reasons to believe under Sections 5(1) and 8(1) of PMLA and the requirement of disclosure to the noticee. Held that failure to disclose reasons to believe under Section 8(1) vitiates proceedings and attachment order.
Niranjan Chatterjee v. State of West Bengal & Ors. [2007 SCC OnLine Cal 283] Interim orders do not wipe out existence or precedential value of judgments; status quo orders bind parties but do not destroy precedent. Applied to clarify that interim stay orders do not affect binding nature of underlying legal principles.
Shree Chamundi Mopeds Ltd. v. Church of South India Trust Assn. (1992) 3 SCC 1 Right to access materials forming basis of reasons to believe; transparency in quasi-judicial proceedings. Applied to affirm that noticee must be given access to relevant materials to file effective reply.
Barium Chemicals Ltd. & Ors v. The Company Law Board & Ors. [AIR 1967 SC 295] Discretionary powers contingent on existence of stipulated circumstances must be exercised based on actual existence of such circumstances. Applied to hold that attachment must be based on actual existence of conditions under Section 5(1)(b) of PMLA.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the Appellant's challenge to the Provisional Attachment Order and the Impugned Judgment confirming it, focusing on compliance with statutory safeguards under the PMLA and the effect of the moratorium under the I&B Code. The Court noted that the properties mortgaged to the Appellant were acquired prior to the predicate offence period (2015-2017) and thus do not constitute proceeds of crime under Section 5(1)(a) of the Act. The properties were secured pursuant to legitimate banking transactions, with security deeds executed well before the commission of the alleged offences.

The Court emphasized the necessity of recording valid and independent reasons to believe before issuing attachment orders, as mandated by Sections 5(1) and 8(1) of the PMLA. It held that mere repetition of statutory language without application of mind and without communicating reasons to the affected party violates principles of natural justice and renders the attachment order invalid. The Court relied on authoritative precedents underscoring the importance of reasoned decisions, transparency, and communication of reasons to the affected parties.

The Court also found that the Respondent's claim of imminent risk of concealment or alienation of properties due to non-cooperation of the accused was unsubstantiated and not supported by material in the Provisional Attachment Order or Complaint. The fact that the properties were already mortgaged/hypothecated/pledged to the Appellant negates the possibility of their alienation or concealment to frustrate proceedings.

Further, the Court held that the moratorium declared by the NCLT under Section 14 of the I&B Code prohibits continuation of pending civil proceedings, including attachment proceedings under the PMLA, against the corporate debtors GGL and NWL. The attachment proceedings continued despite the moratorium, which the Court found to be contrary to settled law and thus liable to be set aside.

The Court rejected the Respondent's contention that reasons to believe need not be recorded or communicated prior to attachment and observed that non-compliance with these safeguards vitiates the attachment order. The Court also recognized the Appellant as a bonafide third-party claimant with legitimate security interests, entitled to pursue recovery and enforcement of its rights without being rendered a mere spectator to attachment proceedings.

In conclusion, the Court found that the Provisional Attachment Order and the Impugned Judgment confirming it were passed without proper application of mind, without valid reasons to believe, and in disregard of statutory safeguards and the moratorium under the I&B Code. Therefore, the attachment order qua the properties mortgaged to the Appellant was liable to be set aside.

Holding and Implications

The appeals are allowed and the order dated 11.12.2018 confirming the Provisional Attachment Order No. 09/2018 dated 25.06.2018 is set aside as regards the properties mortgaged to the Appellant.

The direct effect of this decision is that the Appellant’s rights as a secured creditor over the mortgaged properties stand protected from attachment under the PMLA for the reasons that these properties are not proceeds of crime and were acquired prior to the predicate offence period. The attachment proceedings against these properties are quashed. The decision does not express any opinion on the merits of the allegations against the accused persons, who remain subject to prosecution and other legal proceedings. No new precedent beyond the facts and statutory interpretation in this case is established. The Respondent remains free to attach other properties not mortgaged to the Appellant, including those acquired from proceeds of crime.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    ICICI Bank Ltd. v. The Joint Director Directorate of Enforcement, Mumbai

    mortgaged/hypothecated/pledged/guaranteed in favour of the Appellant, who is now seeking setting aside of the Impugned Judgment.

    3. The details of properties in the present appeals mortgaged/pledged/hypothecated in favour of appellant and other consortium lenders are as under: FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 3 of 45

    I. DETAILS OF PROPERTIES MORTGAGED/PLEDGED/ HYPOTHECATED S.No Name of Property Owner of Property Facility Secured Mortgage Deed Executed Fair Market Value (INR) (Approx.) Year of Purchase

    1 Unit No.1, Lease Land & Building at Plot No - 61, SEEPZ, Parajapur, Kondivita, Marol, Andheri (EAST), Mumbai GGL GECL WC Facility extended vide Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated June 29, 2011 Deed of Mortgage cum Charge Guarantee dated 29.06.2011 29.75 Cr. 04th February, 2010

    2 Flat No 33, 5th Floor, Sukhshanti building No 2, 19 Peddar road, Cumbalia Hill, Mumbai-26 GuniyalCh oksi GECL WC Facility extended vide Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated June 29, 2011 Deed of Mortgage cum Charge Guarantee dated 29.06.2011 4.03 Cr. 01st January, 1970

    4 Unit No II, on Plot 16 (part), 17, 28, 29 MIDC, Andheri East, Mumbai GGL GGL WC Facility extended vide Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated July 6, 2012 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated December 26, 2017 Indenture of Mortgage dated 17.04.2015 and Deed of Mortgage dated 26.12.2017 68.28 Cr. 23rd September , 2013 Aggregate Value of Immoveable Properties- Rs. 102,36,00,000/- Cr. (Rupees One Hundred and Two Crore Thirty Six Lacs Only)

    II. SHARES FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 4 of 45 SHARES ISIN ISIN Descript Total Shares Facility Secured Pledge Deed Executed Value as 20.04.20 (INR)(App rox.) INE34 6H010 Gitanjali Gems Ltd. EQ 22575053 1. GGL WC Facility extended vide Master Joint Lenders Forum Agreement dated 06.08.2014

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011 Amendatory Facility Agreement dated 17.10.2011

    1. Pledge Agreement dated 10.10.2014 and Pledge Agreement dated 16.02.2015

    2. Pledge Agreement for ECB Facility dated 14.11.2011 9.36 Cr. INE34 6H010 Gitanjali Gems 1343000 1. GGL WC Facility extended vide Master Joint Lenders Forum Agreement dated 06.08.2014

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011 Amendatory Facility Agreement dated 17.10.2011

    1. Pledge Agreement dated 10.10.2014 and Pledge Agreement dated 16.02.2015

    2. Pledge Agreement for ECB Facility dated 14.11.2011 .55 Cr. FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 5 of 45 INE34 6H010 Gitanjali Gems Ltd. EQ 1276100 1. GGL WC Facility extended vide Master Joint Lenders Forum Agreement dated 06.08.2014

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Pledge Agreement dated 10.10.2014, Pledge Agreement dated 16.02.2015

    2. Pledge Agreement for ECB Facility dated 14.11.2011 .52 Cr. Aggregate Value of Shares- Rs. 10,43,00,000/- Cr. (Rupees Ten Crores and Forty Three Lacs Only)

    III. BANK BALANCE BANK ACCOUNTS Account Holder Name Facility Secured SecurityDeed Executed Account Balance (In INR) (Approx.)

    2 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Supplemental Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 1,32,591/-

    3 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    1. Supplemental Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012 1,09,103/- FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 6 of 45

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011.

    5 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extendedvide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011.

    1. Supplemental Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 13,91,757/-

    7 GBL (now known Nakshatr a World Limited /NWL) NWL WC Facility extended Vide Supplemental Amendatory Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 29.09.2014 and Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 18.04.2012 Deed of Hypothecation dated 29.09.2014 and Joint Deed of Hypothecation dated 18.04.2012 8,54,703/-

    8 GECL GECL WC Facility extended vide Supplemental and Amendatory Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 30.10.2014 and Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 29.06.2011 Deed of Hypothecation dated 30.10.2014 and Deed of mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 29.06.2011. 35,825/-

    9 GECL GECL WC Facility extended vide Supplemental and Amendatory Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 30.10.2014 and Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 29.06.2011 Deed of Hypothecation dated 30.10.2014 and Deed of mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 29.06.2011 107/-

    10 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 1,19,943/- FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 7 of 45 vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    15 GECL GECL WC Facility extended vide Supplemental and Amendatory Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 30.10.2014 and Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 29.06.2011 Deed of Hypothecation dated 30.10.2014 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 29.06.2011. 2,80,638/-

    16 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extendedvide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011.

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 51,705/-

    18 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 43,726/-

    21 GECL GECL WC Facility extended vide Supplemental and Amendatory Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated October 30, 2014 and Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated June 29, 2011 Deed of Hypothecation dated 30.10.2014 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 29-06-2011. 44,310/-

    25 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 4,63,242/- FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 8 of 45 vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    27 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 12,58,957/-

    28 NWL NWLWC Facility extended Vide Supplemental Amendatory Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 29.09.2014 and Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 18.04.2012 Deed of Hypothecation dated 29.09.2014 and Joint Deed of Hypothecation dated 18.04.2012 6,916/-

    29 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 66/-

    30 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 2,33,594/-

    31 GECL GECL WC Facility extended vide Supplemental and Amendatory Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 30.10.2014 and Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 29.06.2011 Deed of Hypothecation dated 30.10.2014 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 29.06.2011. 8,46,222/- FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 9 of 45

    32 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 6,528/-

    34 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 1,36,045/-

    35 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 24,834/-

    36 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 29,63,893/-

    37 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 1,64,817/- FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 10 of 45

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011 17.10.2011.

    38 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 1,80,836/-

    39 NWL NWLWC Facility extended Vide Supplemental Amendatory Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 29.09.2014 and Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 18.04.2012 Deed of Hypothecation dated 29.09.2014 and Joint Deed of Hypothecation dated 18.04.2012 74,769/-

    40 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 3,51,412/-

    41 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 1,800/-

    42 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation 10/- FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 11 of 45 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011 for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011.

    43 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 63,50,956/-

    44 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 9,242/-

    45 GECL GECL WCFacility extended vide Supplemental and Amendatory Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 30.10.2014 and Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 29.09.2011 Deed of Hypothecation dated 30.10.2014 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 29.09.2011. 40,658/-

    47 NWL NWLWC Facility extended Vide Supplemental Amendatory Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 29.09.2014 and Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 18.04.2012 Deed of Hypothecation dated 29.09.2014 and Joint Deed of Hypothecation dated 18.04.2012. 2,75,088/-

    54 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 3,28,87,831/ FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 12 of 45

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    60 GGL 1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 15,089/- MehulCh oksi

    1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    3. NWLWC Facility extended Vide Supplemental Amendatory Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 29.09.2014 and Third Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 18.04.2012 Personal guarantee(s)

    1. Deed of Guarantee dated 29.09.2014.

    2. Deed of Guarantee dated 27.09.2011.

    3. Agreement of Guarantee dated 30.12.2014 16,63,226/- 9,143/- 65,526/- 97,57,393/- 6,201/- 81,554/- 13,199/- 1,615/- 5,676/- GitanjaliI nfratech Limited ECB Facility Deed of Corporate Guarantee dated 27.09.2011. 1,91,910/- 17,68,109/- Gilli India Limited GGL WC Facility extended by ICICI Bank vide facility agreement dated 18.04.2012. Deed of Hypothecation dated 24.10.2016. 13,63,608/- 4,609/- 72,656/- 95,020/- Aggregate Value of Bank Balances: Rs. 6,44,56,658/- (Rupees Six Crores Forty Four Lac Fifty Six Thousand Six Hundred and Fifty Eight Only) FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 13 of 45

    IV. VALUABLES SEIZED DURING SEARCH VALUABLES SEIZED DURING THE SEARCH Address of Searched Premises Owner Stock Facility Secured Security Deed Executed Value as per Govt. Approved Valuer

    1 Gili Showroom, Viviana Mall, Thane West, Maharashtra Gili India Limited GGL WC Facility extended Vide Supplementary Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016. Deed of Hypothecation executed by Gili India Limited in favour of ICICI Bank Limited dated 24.10.2016. 1,11,57,884/- (1.11 cr.)

    2 Gili Showroom, R- City Mall, Ghatkopar West, Mumbai, Maharashtra Gili India Limited GGL WC Facility extended Vide Supplementary Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016. Deed of Hypothecation executed by Gili India Limited in favour of ICICI Bank Limited dated 24.10.2016. 81,97,155/- (.82 cr.)

    3 Gitanjali Gems Limited, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana, Andhra Pradesh Gitan- jali Gems Limited

    1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012.

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011.

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 103,06,81,223 (103 cr.)

    4 Gitanjali Gems Ltd, Siapura Industrial Estate, Jaipur Gitan- jali Gems Limited

    1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012.

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.10.2011.

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 2,64,28,596/- (2.64 cr.)

    6 Shoppers Stop, New Delhi Gitanjali Gems Limited

    1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012. 61,97,985/- (.62 cr.) FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 14 of 45 06.07.2012.

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011.

    7 M/s B SarkarJohury, Kollkata Gili India Limited GGL WC Facility extended Vide Supplementary Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 Deed of Hypothecation executed by Gili India Limited in favour of ICICI Bank Limited dated 24.10.2016. 2,86,00,000/- (2.86 cr.)

    9 Office of the Custodian of Bharat Diamond Bource, BandraKurla Complex, Bandra East, Mumbai Gitan- jali Gems Limited

    1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 85,00,00,000/- (85 cr.) Office of the Custodian of Bharat Diamond Bource, BandraKurla Complex, Bandra East, Mumbai Gitan- jali Gems Limited

    1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 5,10,00,000/- (5.10 cr.)

    11 Office of the Custodian of Bharat Diamond Bource, BandraKurla Complex, Bandra East, Mumbai Gitan- jali Gems Limited

    1. GGL WC Facility extended Vide Working Capital Facility Agreement dated 19.08.2016 and Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 06.07.2012.

    2. ECB Facility extended vide Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011.

    1. Deed of Hypothecation dated 19.08.2016 and Deed of Mortgage cum charge cum guarantee dated 06.07.2012.

    2. Deed of Hypothecation for ECB Facility dated 17.10.2011. 2,28,75,000/- (2.28 cr.) FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 15 of 45 Aggregate Value of Valuables: Rs. 203,51,37,843 (Rupees Two Hundred and Three Crores Fifty One Lacs Thirty Seven Lacs Eight Hundred and FortyThree Only)

    V. VEHICLES OF MEHUL CHOKSI Vehicles Make & Model Owner Facility Secured Personal Guarantee Executed Fair Market Value (In INR)

    1. BMW BMWX118l MehulChoksi Supplemental Working Capital Consortium Agreement dated 29.09.2014 Deed of Guarantee dated 29.09.2014 14,00,000/-

    2. Toyota Innova 15,00,000/- Aggregate Value of Vehicles: Rs. 29,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty Nine Lacs Only) Aggregate Value of Properties (Serial No. I+II_III+IV+V) qua which relief is sought: Rs. 323,03,94,501/- (Rupees Three Hundred and Twenty Three Crores Three Lacs Ninety Four Thousand Five Hundred and One Only)

    4. The following facts have not been specifically denied by the respondents which are alleged by the appellant in its pleadings. 4.1 The Appellant is in no manner connected with any of the other persons arraigned as Defendants in the Complaint. Further, there is no charge of money laundering against the Appellant nor has the Appellant been made an Accused in the Prosecution Complaint filed in the Special Court. 4.2 The Appellant and the other Consortium Lenders have entered into legitimate banking transactions by providing FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 16 of 45 Working Capital ("WC") and External Commercial Banking ("ECB") facilities to GGL, GECL & NWL, details of which are specified in Paragraph No. 4 of the Appeal. 4.3 The credit facilities were extended to the Borrowers as far back as 2004, when the first WC Consortium Agreement was executed amongst GGL and the Consortium Lenders. Such Agreement was only subsequently modified contemporaneously in order to provide enhanced credit facilities for which the requisite Mortgage/Hypothecation/Guarantee/Pledge Agreement was got executed in favour of the Consortium Lenders. 4.4 The earliest security deed executed in favour of the Appellant and the other Consortium Lenders, in order to secure the credit facilities and the extended limits thereon, was in 2006. 4.5 For the purpose of grant of such credit and enhanced facilities thereon, the Consortium Lenders carried out all the Due Diligence and Credit Assessment as is required. 4.6 Such credit facilities were enhanced from time to time for amounts as are mentioned in the respective revised Supplemental Working Capital Agreements and bilateral ECB Facility Agreement dated 10.09.2011, annexed along with the Appeal. 4.7 Admittedly the period of the commission of the predicate offence as stated in the FIR and the ECIR, which is noted in FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 17 of 45 the Impugned Judgment, is between the years 2015-2017. In order to secure such credit facilities and avail enhanced limits thereon, guarantees both personal and corporate, Mortgage Deeds, Deeds of Hypothecation and Pledge Agreements were executed in favour of the Appellant and the other Consortium Lenders. The said documents executed are binding and shall continue to remain in force till such time as amounts borrowed are repaid by GGL and NWL to the Consortium Lenders. 4.8 The fact that NCLT, Mumbai pronounced the Admission Orders vide Judgment dated 08.10.2018 & 29.01.2019 has declared Moratorium U/s 14 of the I&B Code against GGL & NWL to come into operation with immediate effect, the said Judgments have declared moratorium, which prohibits the continuation of pending suits or other civil proceedings, including the present attachment proceedings against the corporate debtors i.e GGL & NWL. 4.9 The Judgment dated 08.10.2018 was in the knowledge of the Adjudicating Authority since the Insolvency Resolution Professional as appointed by NCLT, was party to the proceedings before the Adjudicating Authority.

    5. Upon failure of GGL and NWL to repay the amounts advanced under the GECL WC Facility, GGL WC and ECB Facility and NWL WC Facility, the Appellant initiated all its rightful legal remedies to recover such amounts. The Appellant in its individual capacity has declared the account of GGL and GECL as Non-Performing Asset (NPA) with effect FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 18 of 45 from 31.03.2018. The Appellant in furtherance of its actions, issued Statutory Notices U/s 13(2) of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets & Enforcement of Security Interest Act ("SARFAESI") dated 07.05.2018 and 17.05.2018.

    6. Recall Notices dated 19.02.2018 and 21.02.2018, Demand Notice dated 28.02.2018 under the Pledge Agreements and Notices of Invocation of Personal and Corporate Guarantee dated 22.02.2018 and 28.02.2018 to the borrowers and corporate and personal guarantors as mentioned in Paragraph Nos. 4.15 and 4.16 of the Appeal.

    7. The Appellant gave a description of the Assets, which included the Properties (subsequently attached by the Respondent), which had been secured in favour of the Appellant, in the annexures to these Notices.

    8. The Appellant and the other Consortium Lenders have filed Original Applications before the Debt Recovery Tribunal ("DRT"), Mumbai being OA No. 408/2018, OA No. 520/2018 & OA No. 540/2018 on 05.07.2018, 18.08.2018 & 27.08.2018 U/s 19 of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 ("RDDBFI") seeking recovery of debts advanced under the GGL WC and ECB and NWL WC Facilities respectively.

    9. The Appellant has also filed a Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process ("CIRP") Application against GGL & NWL U/s 7 of the Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (I&B Code) before the National Company Law Tribunal, Mumbai ("NCLT") on 10.09.2018 & 03.10.2018 FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 19 of 45 byCompany Petition Nos. 3585/2018 & 3872/2018 respectively. NCLT pronounced the Admission Orders on the said Applications vide Judgment dated 08.10.2018 & 29.01.2019 respectively and declared Moratorium against GGL & NWL to come into operation with immediate effect.

    10. An amount of Rs.5843,97,35,652.30 (Rupees Five Thousand Eight Hundred and Forty Three Crores Ninety Seven Lakhs Thirty Five Thousand Six Hundred Fifty Two and Thirty Paisa Only) as is outstanding on April 30, 2018 together with further interest and other charges is owed collectively to the Appellant & the Consortium Lenders under inter-alia, the GECL and GGL WC Facilities.

    11. An amount of USD 12,053,106.29 (United States Dollars Twelve Million Fifty Three Thousand One Hundred and Six and Twenty Nine Cents Only) as is outstanding on June 30, 2018 together with further interest and other charges is payable to the Appellant and the other Consortium Lenders under the GGL ECB Facility.

    12. All the properties qua which the Appellant is seeking relief stand mortgaged/hypothecated/pledged/guaranteed as security with the Appellant and the Consortium Lenders. The appellant is not claiming any right in present proceedings, other properties owned by borrowers who have alleged that the proceedings are already pending for those properties.

    13. The Appellant is seeking setting aside of the Impugned Judgment on the following grounds: FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 20 of 45 Ingredients of S. 5(1) of the Act are not satisfied: An order of attachment U/s 5(1) of the Act can only be passed upon satisfaction of the compulsory twin conditions found in sub clauses (a) and (b), i.e. Firstly, the Director must have reason to believe, on the basis of the material in possession, that any person is in possession of any proceeds of crime; and Secondly, thatsuch proceeds of crime are likely to be concealed, transferred or dealt with in any manner which may result in frustrating any proceedings relations to confiscation of such proceeds of crime. 13.1 The admitted case of the Respondent, is that the alleged proceeds of crime generated are a sum of Rs. 6097.63 crores which the entities of the Gitanjali Group including GGL and GECL, have siphoned from Punjab National Bank, Brady House Branch, Mumbai and allegedly layered overseas for making payments to overseas suppliers and for settling existing Buyers Credit liabilities with the overseas branches of Indian banks. Upon the conclusion of investigation, the Respondent arrived at the finding that as the proceeds of crime have been siphoned off out of the country, the same is not available for attachment in the Country.Thereafter, the said funds were routed and diverted to various overseas companies out of country with the intention to launder the proceeds of crime.The said three accused entities have acquired the proceeds of crime and layered the same out of country to hide its criminal origin. The said proceeds of crime is not available in the country for attachment. Therefore, as FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 21 of 45 per the case of the Respondent, all the alleged Proceeds of Crime as were generated were siphoned out of the country. Consequently, it is not the case of the Respondent that the Properties attached were purchased from the ill-gotten gains generated by Mr.MehulChoksi& the borrowers. Further, admittedly neither the Appellant nor any of its officer(s)/employee(s) have been charged by the Respondent for the commission of the offence of money laundering. 13.2 The Respondent, whose finding found favour with the Adjudicating Authority, submitted that the proceeds of crime generated were layered out of the country and were accordingly not available in the country for attachment. Erroneously, the Ld. Adjudicating Authority then went ahead to take a diametrically opposite view, which is noted in the Impugned Judgment at Page No. 292 to 294, The Adjudicating Authority is required to record findings that all or any of the properties referred in the Notice to Show Cause are/is involved in Money Laundering or not. Money Laundering as can be seen from the definition of the Offence of Money Laundering given in section 3 of PMLA is any process or activity connected with the proceeds of crime and its projection as untainted. There is considerable evidence regarding generation of proceeds of crime by commission of the scheduled offences. There is sufficient evidence of such proceeds of crime having been utilized by the Defendants. FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 22 of 45 It is concluded that the properties are all involved in money laundering 13.3 Admittedly since the Accused Persons siphoned the proceeds of crime out of the country, the Properties in question cannot be said to have been involved in the offence of Money laundering and hence be generated as a result of criminal activities. Furthermore, the immoveable properties were purchased prior to the commission of the predicate offence and the first charge over such properties in favour of the Appellant and the other Consortium Lenders was created much prior to the period of the commission of the predicate offence being 2015-2017 as per the Respondent. Therefore, the properties do not qualify as proceeds of crimes. Consequently, the first ingredient as prescribed under S. 5(1)(a) is not satisfied in the present case.

    14. The Appellant and the Consortium Lenders are bonafide third party claimants of the properties. It is an admitted position that the Properties are already mortgaged/ hypothecated/pledged/guaranteed with the Appellant and the Consortium Lenders, pursuant to legitimate banking transactions. The Appellant and the other Consortium Lenders possess legitimate third party claim to the Properties on account of the security deeds executed in their favour in order to secure Working Capital facilities as were extended to GGL & NWL. Such facilities were extended after conducting due diligence and the necessary checks and balances. Furthermore, the first Working Capital Agreement executed FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 23 of 45 between the banks and GGL was in the year 2004 i.e prior to the commission of the alleged criminal activity by Mr.MehulChoksi and the Gitanjali group of Companies in the year 2015-17.

    15. The FIR No. RC 02(E)/2018/CBI/BS&FC/Mumbai registered for the commission of the Scheduled Offence notes that GGL, Gili India Ltd. and Nakshatra Brands Ltd. during 2017-18 defrauded Punjab National Bank. Furthermore, the ECIR as was subsequently registered on the basis of the FIR, notes that the said three entities of Gitanjali Group, since 2015, used to obtain the LOUs through fraudulent modes from PNB and siphoning off the funds of the said LOUs out the country through their alleged overseas suppliers.The said cycle of issuance of LOUs and its utilization has been continued till 2017(Reference from the Impugned Judgment at Page No. 97 and the Complaint at Para No. 22.5.)Therefore, admittedly the period of commission of the scheduled offence as per the case of the Respondent is 2015-2017. Consequently, the Appellant and the other Consortium Lenders acquisition of interest in the Properties was not with an intention to frustrate or defeat the purpose of the Act. The Appellant has filed a table of the Properties attached, detailing the year of purchase, Credit Facility sanctioned and Deed executed in favour of the Appellant and other Consortium Lenders. The said details have been reproduced in earlier part of my order.

    16. The Honble High Court of Delhi in the recent decision of The Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement, Delhi Vs. Axis Bank &Ors., reported in 2019 SCC Online Del 7854 (hereinafter referred to as the Axis Bank Decision) has rightly held that the interest of a third party FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 24 of 45 in the property of an accused, acquired prior to the commission of the proscribed offence cannot be defeated or frustrated by attachment of such property U/s 8 of the Act.

    17. The Honble High Court further recognized the right of such third party to proceed with enforcement of its interest in accordance with law such that while the order of attachment under the Act would not be rendered irrelevant, yet it would take a backseat such that the State action would be restricted to such part of the value of the property as exceeds the claim of the third party, if any. (Reference Paragraph No. 162-164 of the Axis Bank Decision) speak for itself.

    18. The Appellant has already initiated recovery proceedings under the SARFAESI and RDDBFI Act and insolvency proceedings under the I&B Code for enforcement of its interest. S. 13 SARFAESI allows secured creditors to enforce security interest created in their favour without the intervention of the Court or Tribunal.

    19. The Appellant has also issued Statutory Notices U/s 13(2) SARFAESI dated 07.05.2018 and 17.05.2018 to the borrowers (GGL & NWL) and their guarantors, prior to the issuance of the PAO on 25.06.2018. Consequently, in terms with the Axis Bank Decision, the claim of the Respondent to the Properties would be restricted to such part of the aggregate value of the properties attached as exceeds the claim of the Appellant. Claim of the Bonafide Third Party Claimant to be determined by the Appellate Tribunal. FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 25 of 45

    20. In terms with the statutory safeguards incorporated in the Act, any party aggrieved by the confirmation of the Provisional Attachment Order by the Adjudicating Authority may challenge such confirmation in an appeal to this Tribunal U/s 26 of the Act and then before the Honble High Court U/s 42 of the Act against the order of this Tribunal. Accordingly, under the legislative and statutory scheme of the Act, unless a party has exhausted its remedies in appeal right up to the Honble High Court, an order confirming the attachment cannot be said to have attained finality. Therefore, this Tribunal is fully equipped and possesses the requisite jurisdiction in terms with the Act as the court of first appeal, to adjudicate upon the pleas of the Appellant and determine the bonafides and legitimacy of its claims as well as the legality of the Provisional Attachment Order.

    21. There is no force in the argument of learned counsel appearing on behalf of Enforcement Directorate that claims of third parties are to be solely adjudicated by the Special Court before whom trial is pending, the Honble High Court of Delhi in the Axis Bank Decision has held that the claim of a party asserting a bonafide and legitimate claim would be inquired into by the Special Court only if the order confirming the attachment has attained finality. An order cannot be said to have attained finality until and unless all the remedies under the Act have been exhausted. I agree that the Tribunal has only to examine the impugned order and is empowered under section-26 of the Act as to FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 26 of 45 whether the attachment order has been passed as per law or not. This Tribunal has the exclusive jurisdiction on this issue. The Bank is otherwise if so may approach the Special Court for release of properties even during the pendency of appeal or after allowing the appeal. The validity of the confirmation of attachment order is only to be considered by this court.

    22. The factum of mortgage and the effect thereof on the claim of the Appellant, the Impugned Judgment erroneously notes at Page No. 230 &

    233 as under: .Thus if a property is a proceeds of crime or is a property involved in money laundering, the same is necessarily to be provisionally attached, confirmation whereof may be adjudicated and finally liability of confiscation may be determined by the Special Court.To advance the argument that Provisional Attachment Orders should not be issued in relation to the proceeds of crime involved in money laundering, as such properties are required to be liquidated in favour of the bank, who are custodian of public fund may amount to putting a premium on such unchecked activities carried on by the officers due to irresponsible approach or connivance of the bank management.The pleas of the mortgagees, therefore cannot be granted at this stage of confirmation of the provisional attachment order, as such grant of the relief would interject with the scheme of the Act, deliberately provided. As aforesaid section 8(8) of the PMLA provides for rights of claimant with a legitimate interest with the property provisionally attached/confiscated, who may have suffered a quantifiable loss as a result of the offence of money laundering.In view of the legal provisions above referred and the object sought to be achieved by the PMLA, I humbly and with great respect cannot concur with the view expressed by the Appellate Tribunal, PMLA in the Judgments of the Appellate Tribunal cited by D-21 and D- FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 27 of 45

    23. The Adjudicating Authority erred in upholding the view canvassed by the Respondent that the pleas of the Appellant of possessing a legitimate and bonafide claim as a third party to the Properties cannot be tackled at the stage of confirmation of the PAO and that the rights of the Appellate will be dealt with by the Special Court at the stage of Section 8(8) of the Act. The said argument of the respondent is contrary to the statutory and legislative scheme of the Act It would amount to an exercise in futility and wasteful litigation if the Appellant were required to be a mute spectator to the confirmation of attachment of mortgaged properties at this stage and await the conclusion of trial U/s 3, 4 of the Act to agitate and pursue its rightful legal claim over such mortgaged properties.

    24. It would be futile to deny the Appellant his claim over the mortgaged properties at the stage of confirmation of the PAO itself. Further, the legislative intent for relief at this stage can be borne out from the fact that under the proviso to sub clause 1 and 2 of section 8 of the Act, prior to the confirmation of the PAO, the Adjudicating Authority is required to adjudicate over the claim of an innocent party who seeks claim over the attached property, apart from the person to whom notice had been issued.

    25. Therefore, the Adjudicating Authority by the Impugned Judgment has erred in failing to recognise the legitimate claim of the Appellant at the stage of confirmation of the PAO itself as the Appellant Bank is a victim of the fraud perpetuated by Mr MehulChoksi and the Gitanjali Group companies including GGL & NWL, which is further aggravated by FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 28 of 45 the effect of the Impugned Judgment, depriving it of pursuing its legal claims against properties mortgaged to it. The value of the properties on account of the present case as well as the FIR has depreciated significantly and is deteriorating on a daily basis, such that any delay in enforcement of recovery by the Appellant would be rendered meaningless. In the present case, the Appellant is the victim of the fraud played upon it by Mr.MehulChoksi and the Gitanjali group of Companies. Ingredients of S. 8(1) of the Act are not satisfied.

    25. Under Section 8(1), upon receipt of a Complaint U/s 5(5) of the Act, if this Authority has reason to believe that any person has committed an offence under section 3 or is in possession of proceeds of crime, he may serve a notice of not less than thirty days on such person calling upon him to indicate the sources of his income, earning or assets, out of which or by means of which he has acquired the property attachedU/s 5(1) of the Act. The fact that the Appellant along with the other Consortium Lenders have a mortgage on the attached properties and have provided facilities against the security of such attached Properties cannot and does not fall within the purview of Section 8(1) of the Act. Consequently, the notice U/s 8(1) of the Act as was issued to the Appellant as Lead Bank of Consortium Lenders was bad in law and hence also liable to be set aside.

    26. The words reason to believe used in S. 8(1) of the Act cast an onerous duty on the Adjudicating Authority, while deciding to act under the said Section and before issuance of notice under Section 8(1) of the Act. The Honble Supreme Court and various Honble High Courts have FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 29 of 45 held that reason to believe is not the same thing as suspicion or doubt and merely seeing cannot be equated to believing. Reason to believe is a higher level of state of mind. A person must have reason to believe if the circumstances are such that a reasonable man would, by probable reasoning, conclude or infer regarding the nature of the thing concerned. Further, at the initial stage for believing the existence of a thing, condition or a statement of fact, one would collect information and then examine the information and come to a final conclusion on the basis of that information, that such a thing, condition or statement of a fact exists. All these ingredients are pre-requisite for forming an opinion based on reason to believe. Reasons to believe

    27. Counsel appearing on behalf of ED submits that it is not necessary to record the reasons to believe prior to passing the provisional attachment order. Secondly, it can only be recorded in respect of provisional attachment order itself.

    28. Copy of the same is not to be served to aggrieved party even at the stage of arguments in the main appeal or any subsequent proceedings. These cannot be shown to the appellant.

    29. The guidelines of recording the reason to believe have been laid down in various judgements of Apex Court and High Courts. It is held time and again by the said Honble Courts directing that the approach should be not the subjective satisfaction of the officer concerned. Such power given to the officer concerned is not an arbitrary power and has to be exercised in accordance with the restraints imposed by law. The belief must be that of an honest and FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 30 of 45 reasonable person based upon reasonable grounds, the officer concerned may act on direct or circumstantial evidence but not on mere suspicion or the allegations mentioned in the FIR or charge-sheet so that the same can be scrutinized in order to verify whether they are relevant and germane or not. He cannot proceed further on the basis of opinion already formed by someone else. The officer who is supposed to write down his reasons to believe independently applying his mind in every case. It should not be merely a mechanical reproduction of the words mentioned in the statute in order to complete the formality as PMLA cases (being independent proceeding) as submitted on behalf of the respondent. If the person concerned are more than one, the officer authorized is to record the independent/separate, reasonsto believe for each person concerned.

    30. If no valid reasons to believe are recorded, the issuance of notice to the person concerned or without going into the material and non- application of mind, the same would be considered as invalid notice. It is settled law that if the Show-Cause notice fails to fulfil the basic ingredients as laid down by a Constitutional Bench of the Honble Supreme Court in Khem Chand v. Union of India [AIR 1958 SC 300],the Show-Cause Notice itself is bad in law. Thus, it is vitiating the proceedings. Also see another judgement in the case of Aslam Mohammad Merchant v. Competent Authority [2008 (14) SCC 186] in this regard.

    31. In the present case, copy of reason to believe has not been filed. Counsel for the respondent submits that reason to believe is not required prior to the order of passing the provisional attachment order. The attachment order shows that after recording the facts, the IO has just FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 31 of 45 used the expression by repetition of language of section 5(1) in the provisional attachment order. The respondent must understand that unlike other statute. Under this Act, the burden of proof lies with person concerned under. It is virtually not possible for any party to discharge the burden of proof unless he knows the allegations and copy of reason to belief. From the submission addressed on behalf of respondent, it is clear that the respondent does not wish to show or communicate the extract of reasons to believe recorded at the stage of Section 5(1) of the Act to the aggrieved party/person concerned. The said stand of the respondent cannot be accepted as the same is against the law and against the principle of natural justice. The reason to believe must be recorded in terms of para 22 of my order.

    32. In the case of C.B.Gautam vs. Union of India (1993(1) SCC 78),a Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India held that the reasons to be recorded in writing shall not only be incorporated in the order but also shall be communicated to the affected parties. The relevant extract from the judgement is as under: Sec. 269UD(1), in express terminology, provides that the appropriate authority may make an order for the purchase of the property for reasons to be recorded in writing. Sec. 269UD(2) casts an obligation on the authority that it "shall cause a copy of its order under sub-s. (1) in respect of any immovable property to be served on the transferor". It is, therefore, inconceivable that the order which is required to be served by the appropriate authority under sub-s. (2) would be the one which does not contain the reasons for the passing of the order or is not accompanied by the reasons recorded in writing. It may be permissible to record reasons separately but the order would be an incomplete order unless either the reasons are incorporated therein or are served separately along with the order on the affected party. Reasons for the order must be communicated to the affected party.[ FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 32 of 45 The above referred to decision has been followed in various judgments by many High Courts, as well the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in subsequent decisions.

    33. a)In Kranti Associates v. Masood Ahmed Khan (2010) 9 SCC 496, the legal position was summarized as under:- a. In India the judicial trend has always been to record reasons, even in administrative decisions, if such decisions affect anyone prejudicially. b. A quasi-judicial authority must record reasons in support of its conclusions. c. Insistence on recording of reasons is meant to serve the wider principle of justice that justice must not only be done it must also appear to be done as well. d. Recording of reasons also operates as a valid restraint on any possible arbitrary exercise of judicial and quasi-judicial or even administrative power. e. Reasons reassure that discretion has been exercised by the decision maker on relevant grounds and by disregarding extraneous considerations. f. Reasons have virtually become as indispensable a component of a decision making process as observing principles of natural justice by judicial, quasi-judicial and even by administrative bodies. g. Reasons facilitate the process of judicial review by superior Courts. h. The ongoing judicial trend in all countries committed to rule of law and constitutional governance is in favour of reasoned decisions based on relevant facts. This is virtually the life blood of judicial decision making justifying the principle that reason is the soul of justice. i. Judicial or even quasi-judicial opinions these days can be as different as the judges and authorities who deliver them. All these decisions serve one common purpose which is to demonstrate by reason that the relevant factors have been objectively considered. This is important for sustaining the litigants' faith in the justice delivery system. j. Insistence on reason is a requirement for both judicial accountability and transparency. k. If a Judge or a quasi-judicial authority is not candid enough about his/her decision making process then it is impossible to know whether the person deciding is faithful to the doctrine of precedent or to principles of incrementalism. FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 33 of 45

    l. Reasons in support of decisions must be cogent, clear and succinct. A pretence of reasons or `rubber-stamp reasons' is not to be equated with a valid decision making process. m. It cannot be doubted that transparency is the sine qua non of restraint on abuse of judicial powers. Transparency in decision making not only makes the judges and decision makers less prone to errors but also makes them subject to broader scrutiny. (See David Shapiro in Defence of Judicial Candor (1987) 100 Harvard Law Review 731-737). n. Since the requirement to record reasons emanates from the broad doctrine of fairness in decision making, the said requirement is now virtually a component of human rights and was considered part of Strasbourg Jurisprudence. See (1994) 19 EHRR 553, at 562 para 29 and Anya vs. University of Oxford, 2001 EWCA Civ 405, wherein the Court referred to Article 6 of European Convention of Human Rights which requires, "adequate and intelligent reasons must be given for judicial decisions". o. In all common law jurisdictions judgments play a vital role in setting up precedents for the future. Therefore, for development of law, requirement of giving reasons for the decision is of the essence and is virtually a part of "Due Process".

    b) In Income Tax Officer v. LakhmaniMewaldas 1976 (3) SCR 956, the Supreme Court held that there should be a live link or close nexus between the material before the ITO and the formation of his belief that income had escaped assessment. More recently, in AslamMohd Merchant v. Competent Authority (2008) 14 SCC 186, the entire legal position has been explained elaborately by the Supreme Court as under:

    28. It is, however, beyond any doubt or dispute that a proper application of mind on the part of the competent authority is imperative before a show cause notice is issued. Section 68-H of the Act provides for two statutory requirements on the part of the authority viz: (i) he has to form an opinion in regard to his `reason to believe'; and (ii) he must record reasons therefor. Both the statutory elements, namely, `reason to believe' and `recording of reasons' must be premised on the materials produced before him. Such materials must have been gathered during the investigation carried out in terms of Section 68-E or otherwise. Indisputably therefore, he must have some materials before him. If no such material had been placed before him, he cannot initiate a proceeding. He cannot issue FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 34 of 45 a show cause notice on his own ipse dixit. A roving enquiry is not contemplated under the said Act as properties sought to be forfeited must have a direct nexus with the properties illegally acquired.

    29. It is now a trite law that whenever a statute provides for `reason to believe', either the reasons should appear on the face of the notice or they must be available on the materials which had been placed before him. We have noticed hereinbefore that when the authority was called upon to disclose the reasons, it was stated that all the reasons were contained in the show cause notices themselves. They, however, in our opinion, do not contain any reason so as to satisfy the requirements of sub-section (1) of Section 68H of the Act.

    c) In JotiParshadVs. State of Haryana [1993 Supp (2) SCC 497], the Honble Supreme Court observed that suspicion and reason to believe are not the same thing. Reason to believe is a higher level of state of mind and there must exist reason to believe. The following observations are relevant in this regard-

    5. We are now concerned with the expressions knowledge and reason to believe. Knowledge is an awareness on the part of the person concerned indicating his state of mind. Reason to believe is another facet of the state of mind. Reason to believe is not the same thing as suspicion or doubt and mere seeing also cannot be equated to believing. Reason to believe is a higher level of state of mind. Likewise, knowledge will be slightly on a higher plane than reason to believe. A person can be supposed to know where there is a direct appeal to his senses and a person is presumed to have a reason to believe if he has sufficient cause to believe the same. Section 26 IPC explains the meaning of the words reason to believe thus:

    26. Reason to believe A person is said to have reason to believe a thing, if he has sufficient cause to believe that thing and not otherwise.

    34. In paras 74 to 77, the Double Bench of Honble High Court of Delhi in its judgement J. Sekar v. Union of India and Ors. 2018 SCC Online Del 6523, has held that: FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 35 of 45

    74. The Court, therefore, holds as under as regards the submissions of the learned counsel for the Petitioners with regard to the constitutionality of the second proviso to Section 5(1) PMLA:

    (i) Although the second proviso to Section 5(1) states that the property has to be involved in money-laundering and section 5(1) states that mere possession of proceeds of crime is sufficient, the Court does not see any conflict in these expressions. When the definition in Section 3 PMLA is read with Section 2(1)(v) and the Explanation thereto, it becomes clear that the property which constitutes proceeds of crime is the property involved in money- laundering.

    (ii) The reasons to believe at every stage must be noted down by the officer in the file.

    (iii) While the reasons to believe recorded at the stage of passing the order of provisional attachment under Section 5(1) PMLA may not be forthwith at that stage communicated to the person adversely affected thereby, the reasons as recorded in the file have to accompany the complaint filed by such officer within 30 days before the AA under Section 5(5) PMLA.

    (iv) A copy of such complaint accompanied by the reasons, as found in the file, must be served by the AA upon the person affected by such attachment after the AA adds its own reasons why he prima facie thinks that the provisional attachment should continue.

    75. There are two reasons to believe. One recorded by the officer passing the order under Section 5(1) PMLA and the other recorded by the AA under Section 8(1) PMLA. Both these reasons to believe should be made available to the person to whom notice is issued by the AA under Section 8(1) PMLA. The failure to disclose, right at the beginning, the aforementioned reasons to believe to the noticee under section 8(1) PMLA would not be a mere irregularity but an illegality. A violation thereof would vitiate the entire proceedings and cause the order of provisional attachment to be rendered illegal.

    76. The Court disagrees with the learned counsel for the Union of India that there is no mandatory requirement, under section 8(1) PMLA, to communicate to the noticee the reason to believe. On a collective reading of Section 5(1) PMLA and Section 8(1) PMLA, such an interpretation is contraindicated and cannot satisfy the requirement of what the AA is supposed to do under Section 8(2) PMLA, viz. to consider the reply of the noticee, give them and the FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 36 of 45 Director a hearing and take into account all relevant materials placed on record.

    77. Although at the stage of issuance of notice under Section 8(1) PMLA all the relevant material on record which constituted the basis for reasons to believe may not be made available, if the noticee demands to see those materials on record, the AA is bound to make available all those materials on record to them. It is most likely that without such access to such material on record, the noticee will be unable to file an effective reply. Therefore, there cannot be any denial of access to the noticee of the materials on record. If there is any sensitive material, it can probably be redacted before issuing copies thereof, after nothing the reasons for such redaction in writing in the file. But even such redacted material will have to be nevertheless shown to the noticee. Though the operation of the aforesaid judgment has been stayed by the Honble Supreme Court, the above dicta cannot cease to be law of precedential value and binding in other matters i.e. third parties, in view of settled law. One of such decision reported as vide Shree Chamundi Mopeds Ltd. v. Church of South India Trust Assn., (1992) 3 SCC 1 (para 10).

    35. A division bench of the Honble Calcutta High Court in NiranjanChatterjee v. State of West Bengal &Ors., 2007 SCC OnLine Cal 283 after relying on the aforesaid decision has held that:

    17. After hearing the learned Counsel for the parties and after going through the aforesaid position of fact, we find that the Supreme Court by those interim order has, no doubt, stayed the operation of the order of the Division Bench of this Court by directing the parties to maintain status quo but at the same time, has even restrained the State from inducting the third parties on the lands which were the subject matters before the Apex Court. Such interim order is binding upon the parties to the proceedings but the law is equally settled that by mere passing of an interim order staying the operation of a FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 37 of 45 judgment with certain further conditions, the existence of the said judgment is not wiped out and at the same time, for such interim order inter parties, the authority of a decision as a precedent is never undermined. Unless a decision is set aside by the Superior Court, the said decision remains effective as a precedent though may not be binding upon the parties to the proceeding where the superior Court has granted interim order.

    20. Therefore, the effect of the order of stay in a pending appeal before the Apex Court does not amount to any declaration of law but is only binding upon the parties to the said proceedings and at the same time, such interim order does not destroy the binding effect of the judgment of the High Court as a precedent because while granting the interim order, the Apex Court had no occasion to lay down any proposition of law inconsistent with the one declared by the High Court which is impugned. [Emphasis Supplied]

    36. In the light of above, it is held that the provisional attachment order is bad as no valid reason to believe has been passed within the meaning of the provision of Section-5(1) of the Act is read meaningful manner, the same is the intent of the statue, it is held that the officer concerned must be recorded after having gone through the materials available and in legal manner.

    37. In the present case, prima facie, there is no valid findings with the properties mortgaged with the appellant as to who is the financial institution and possession of the proceeds of crime or the same is likely to be concealed, transferred or dealt with in any manner as the said properties are already mortgaged with the appellant.

    38. It is also a matter of fact that the mortgaged properties are attached under the 2nd proviso of Section 5(1) of the Act, which reads as under: FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 38 of 45 PROVIDED FURTHER that, notwithstanding anything contained in first proviso, any property of any person may be attached under this section if the Director or any other officer not below the rank of Deputy Director authorised by him for the purposes of this section has reason to believe (the reasons for such belief to be recorded in writing), on the basis of material in his possession, that if such property involved in money-laundering is not attached immediately under this Chapter, the non-attachment of the property is likely to frustrate any proceeding under this Act".

    39. In consonance with the statutory requirement, the Respondent can in the absence of a complaint or a chargesheetimmediately attach a property if non-attachment of the property is likely to frustrate any proceedings under this Act, which condition is sine-qua-non to the provisional attachment of properties by the Respondent. The basis of the Department for immediate attachment of the Properties which was subsequently upheld by the Adjudicating Authority is recorded on Page Number 62 of the Impugned Judgment, which reads as under: ..ShriMehulChoksi is not co-operating with the investigation at all as he has not attended this office despite of three summons issued to him under the provisions of the PMLA, 2002. Similarly,Mr. Sunil Verma is also not co-operating with the investigation as he has not attended this office despite of three Summons issued to him under the provisions of the PMLA Therefore, the likelihood of selling and/or disposing of the said property are extremely high. Therefore I have reason to believe that the properties mentioned hereinabove i.e the proceeds of crime are likely to be concealed, transferred or dealt with in such a manner which may result in frustrating any proceedings relating to confiscation of such proceeds of crime under Chapter III of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act.

    40. The above reasons reveal how the Respondent is taking the onerous duty cast upon it under Section 5 of the Act, lightly and in flagrant disregard of the statutory safeguards incorporated therein. The FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 39 of 45 non-cooperation of Mr.MehulChoksi with the investigation as was conducted by the Respondent cannot give rise to an apprehension that in case the Properties are not attached immediately, proceedings under the Act would be frustrated.

    41. The immediacy, as is a statutory safeguard incorporated in the Act, could have been inferred from an actual attempt to sell or alienate the Properties by Mr.MehulChoksi or one of the group companies. However, no such attempt to act/alienate the properties was mentioned by the Respondent in their PAO, Complaint or the Impugned Judgment. The Respondent, in its Reply to the present Appeal, has for the first time in Reply to Ground E at internal Page No. 4 of the Reply stated, It is further submitted that during the course of investigation it was revealed that ShriMehulChoksi was desperately trying to dispose of his entire properties. This fact is neither mentioned in the PAO, Complaint or the Impugned Judgment, making it a malafide afterthought and desperate attempt on behalf of the Respondent to improve its case at the Appellate stage. Even otherwise, barring this bald statement, the Respondent has not placed on record any material to corroborate and substantiate the said allegation.

    42. Furthermore, there could not have be any likelihood of concealment, transfer or dealing of the Properties by Mr.MehulChoksi or the group companies related to the Appellant since the same were and continue to remain hypothecated/mortgaged/pledged to the Appellant, for which the Deeds executed are binding and continue to remain in force. This eliminates any possibility of the Properties being sold or FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 40 of 45 alienated or dealt with in any manner whatsoever which would frustrate any proceedings under this Chapter.

    43. The Constitutional bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Barium Chemicals Ltd. &Ors V/s The Company Law Board &Ors. (AIR 1967 SC 295) held that when a statute postulates the exercise of discretion by an authority contingent to the existence of certain circumstances envisaged therein, the formation of such opinion by the authority has to be compulsorily based on the actual existence of the stipulated circumstances as envisaged in the statute. Therefore upon the inability of the Respondent to demonstrate the existence of circumstances, which satisfy the necessary ingredients of S. 5(1)(b) of the Act and its second proviso, the POA and consequently the Impugned Order are liable to set aside being bad in law.

    44. A bare perusal of the Complaint as was filed by the Respondent reveals a glaring absence of any mention of investigation into the charge of the Appellant over the Properties and the existence of the factum of the banks dues, recoverable from the Borrowers. This reflects the inadequate investigation undertaken by the Respondent, which on the basis of incomplete facts has taken the drastic measure of provisionally attaching properties already charged with the Appellant and in the absence of a Complaint or Chargesheet being filed

    45. It is evident from the second provision of Section 5(1) that only those properties shal be attached if such property involved in the money laundering unlike the first proviso, which is general rule that the FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 41 of 45 properties shall not be attached unless the report of under Section 173 Cr.P.C. has been filed. The condonation stipulated in second proviso is not formed part of first proviso.

    46. In the present case, admittedly, the properties were attached by invoking second proviso. The authorised officer has failed to trace out the other properties which are involved in the money laundering. Without any proper investigation in this regard, the officer concerned straightaway target the mortgaged properties which are not acquired from the proceed of crime and the same were purchased and mortgaged prior to the date of offence committed. It is the duty of the authorised officer to investigate all the properties. The second appeal filed by Vijay Garg are having the same facts.

    47. The Adjudicating Authority further failed to take note of the fact that NCLT, Mumbai pronounced the Admission Orders vide Judgement dated 08.10.2018 and 29.01.2019, respectively and has declared Moratorium under section 14 of the I&B Code against GGL & NWL to come into operation with immediate effect. The said Judgements have declared moratorium, which prohibits the continuation of pending suits or other civil proceedings, including the present attachment proceedings against the corporate debtors i.e. GGL & NWL. The Judgement dated 08.10.2018 was in the knowledge of the Adjudicating Authority since the Insolvency Resolution Professional as appointed by NCLT, was party to the proceedings before the Adjudicating Authority. The impugned judgement is thus liable to be set aside since the Adjudicating Authority FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 42 of 45 could not have continued with the attachment proceedings under the PMLA upon the declaration of Moratorium under the I&B Code which is prior in time to the impugned judgement.

    48. It is a matter of fact that ED has registered the ECIR and passed the provisional attachment order after the moratorium order is passed by the NCLT. Thus, on the face of record, it is evident that the ED and the Adjudicating Authority have not understood the legal issues involved rather they have ignored the settled law and passed the impugned order. The serious situation is that ED has registered ECIR on the basis of FIR which was registered at the request of banks complaint as borrowers who failed to pay the loan amount. The banks have now become victim. Therefore, both the impugned order and provision attachment order are set- aside qua the appellant bank.

    49. The impugned order confirming the provisional attachment order is passed without application of mind and without understanding the law, it is liable to be quashed with regards to mortgage properties.

    50. I do not agree with the submission of counsel appearing on behalf of ED that the banks may not be allowed to dispose of the mortgage properties owned by MuhulChoksi and NiravModi and we should wait for trial to be faced by these offenders and it would also have some bearing in their extradition proceedings.The main reasons for disagreeing his arguments are that the mortgage properties were acquired much prior period from the date of offense. The banks are innocent and victims. The banks are not charge-sheeted. They are the secured creditors. Banks FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 43 of 45 moneys have been looted by these cheaters. Public Sectors banks money is the public money. The banks are in critical conditions as these alleged accused have cheated every citizen of this country. The courts in overseas countries are aware about the mortgage law. Rather, if their mortgage properties are disposed off, loan amount would be decreased. No doubt, they should also be dealt with criminal liabilities, but recovery process cannot be stalled in this way. These joneys are always happy if their mortgage properties shall remain attached and should not be disposed of. It is also held that if the mortgage properties are not the proceeds of crime, the said properties cannot be attached in lieu of value thereof as banks are the secure creditors, but ED, no doubt, after investigation, is welcome to attach the properties in lieu of value thereof only in the cases where it was virtually not possible to trace out the properties which were purchased from proceeds of crime, but other than the mortgage properties which were not acquired from proceeds of crime. Borrowers mortgage properties can not secure in safe heaven if they failed to return back the loan amount otherwise public will suffer.

    51. No doubt, this tribunal is clear in its mind that if the property was acquired from proceeds of crime and at the time of mortgage, the bank is aware and still the loan is sanctioned, then said property can be attached even in lieu of value thereof if the borrowers has concealed or is concealing the proceeds of crime, but under those circumstances, there must be material or prima facie evidence on record before passing the provisional attachment orders. FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 44 of 45

    52. This order is being passed in relation to mortgage properties in favour of banks which are not purchased from proceeds of crime. The same were purchased and mortgage with the banks prior to the of crime period.ED is not precluded to attach other private properties and all other assets of the alleged accused.

    53. It is clarified that this order shall have no bearing in any proceedings initiated against the alleged accused including extradition proceedings pending or proposed to be initiated in any part of the world. Those are to be considered as per law and without any influence of this order which is being passed in the interest of public as bank money is a public money. Most of the banks are public sector banks. Their valid and legal recovery cannot be blocked for years without valid reasons.Therefore the issue in hand is being decided only for limited purposes

    54. The period of continuation of proceedings before the Adjudicating Authority, PMLA, and before this Tribunal till the passing of the present judgment and order, from the date of commencement of the moratorium order, be treated as excluded while calculating limitation of the period of completion of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process.

    55. Thus, both appeals are allowed by setting aside the order dated 11.12.2018 passed in OC No. 1000/2018 titled Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement Vs. ShriMehulChoksi&Ors. by the Adjudicating Authority confirming the Provisional Attachment Order No. 09/2018 dated 25.06.2018, qua the properties secured to the Appellant. FPA-PMLA-2897 &2912 /MUM/2019 Page 45 of 45

    56. As far as merit of the allegations against the alleged accused is concerned, no opinion is expressed. The borrowers must be dealt with strictly in accordance with law.

    57. No costs. (Justice Manmohan Singh) Chairman New Delhi, 30thAugust, 2019

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    ICICI Bank Ltd. v. The Joint Director Directorate of Enforcement, Mumbai
    (Aug 30, 2019)