Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act, 1317 F., (Act VIII of 1317 F.) or the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Record of Rights in Land Regulation, 1358 F. (Regulation LVIII of 1358 F)
  • Section 87 of the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana) Area Land Revenue Act (for short the Act), 1317
  • 1923 Act, Section 87 of the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act
  • Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act,
  • Section 87-A of Land Revenue Act 1317 Fasli.9.
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • SECTION 18 LAND ACQUISITION ACT
  • section 87 of the A.P (T.A) L.R Act, 1317
  • Section 87 of Land Revenue Act,
  • Section 87 of the L.R Act, 1317
  • Agricultural Land Reforms Act
  • 87 of Land Revenue Act, 1317
  • Section 18 of the L.A Act
  • State Amendment Act 22
  • Boundaries Act, 1923
  • AP Land Reforms Act
  • Amendment) Act, 1958
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act, 1317 F., (Act VIII of 1317 F.) or the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Record of Rights in Land Regulation, 1358 F. (Regulation LVIII of 1358 F)
  • Section 87 of the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana) Area Land Revenue Act (for short the Act), 1317
  • 1923 Act, Section 87 of the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act
  • Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act,
  • Section 87-A of Land Revenue Act 1317 Fasli.9.
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • SECTION 18 LAND ACQUISITION ACT
  • section 87 of the A.P (T.A) L.R Act, 1317
  • Section 87 of Land Revenue Act,
  • Section 87 of the L.R Act, 1317
  • Agricultural Land Reforms Act
  • 87 of Land Revenue Act, 1317
  • Section 18 of the L.A Act
  • State Amendment Act 22
  • Boundaries Act, 1923
  • AP Land Reforms Act
  • Amendment) Act, 1958
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Government of Andhra Pradesh acquired land in Sy. No. 1009 of Kukatpally village for the Andhra Pradesh Housing Board (APHB) and for the Water Works Department. An award was passed in 1968 for the acquisition of Ac.661.04 guntas of land for APHB and Ac.5.21 guntas for the Water Works Department. Claim petitions were filed by late Nawab Rayees Yar Jang and Mir Fazilath Hussain Khan claiming compensation, which was ultimately determined by the Supreme Court. Subsequently, Mir Fazilath Hussain Khan filed an application under Section 87 of the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana) Area Land Revenue Act seeking correction of revenue records to reflect an excess extent of land (Ac.11.10 guntas) not acquired by the Government but still in possession of the claimants. The District Revenue Officer (DRO) after survey and technical examination found a clerical error in the recorded extent of land and ordered correction. This order was confirmed by the Commissioner (Appeals) on appeal by APHB. APHB filed a writ petition challenging these orders, which was allowed by the learned single Judge. Against this judgment, two writ appeals were filed by the legal representatives of the sixth respondent and respondents 7 and 8 respectively. Additionally, a separate writ appeal (WA No. 257 of 2009) was filed against the dismissal of a writ petition seeking mandamus for disposal of an application related to property claims. There were also applications seeking impleadment of petitioners as parties in the writ appeals, claiming interest in the subject land based on agreements of sale and a Will.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the correction of land records under Section 87 of the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana) Area Land Revenue Act to rectify a clerical error in land extent is sustainable.
  2. Whether the learned single Judge was justified in holding that the error was not a clerical error and in allowing the writ petition filed by APHB.
  3. Whether the writ appeals challenging the single Judge's order should be allowed and the orders of the DRO and Commissioner (Appeals) restored.
  4. Whether the petitioners seeking impleadment as parties in the writ appeals have a proper interest and should be permitted to be impleaded.
  5. Whether claims related to title to the property can be adjudicated under writ jurisdiction or should be relegated to competent civil courts.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (APHB) Arguments

  • Challenged the jurisdiction of the DRO to entertain the correction application under Section 87 of the Act.
  • Contended that the claim of excess land by the respondents was belated and not sustainable.
  • Argued that the error was not a clerical error as defined under the relevant circular and that the writ petition was rightly allowed by the learned single Judge.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Claimed that the excess land was not acquired and the error in the land records was a clerical error warranting correction under Section 87 of the Act.
  • Relied on the technical report of the Assistant Director of Survey and Land Records confirming the excess land on the ground.
  • Asserted that the orders of the DRO and Commissioner (Appeals) were valid and based on material on record.
  • Petitioners seeking impleadment argued they have interest in the property by virtue of agreements of sale and a Will, and thus are necessary parties to the appeals.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Joint Collector v. K. Sathaiah (WA No. 152 of 1985 dated 05.03.1991) Interpretation of the applicability and deletion of Chapters including Section 87 of the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act after extension of the Andhra Pradesh (Andhra Area) Survey and Boundaries Act, 1923 The court relied on this precedent to hold that since no survey was made under the 1923 Act, Section 87 of the Land Revenue Act remains available as a remedy in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the facts surrounding the acquisition and the subsequent claim for correction of the land extent under Section 87 of the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act. The DRO's order to correct the land extent was supported by a technical survey report confirming excess land beyond the extent acquired by APHB. The Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the DRO's order, finding the error to be clerical as per the Commissioner's circular defining clerical errors as minor errors that do not involve alteration in area or change of ownership but include errors such as incorrect area calculation where ground measurement supports the correct area.

The learned single Judge erred in holding that the error was not clerical and in relying on declarations under the Agricultural Land Reforms Act to deny the claim, as these declarations were irrelevant to the correction process. The court found that the correction orders were based on material evidence and technical reports, and were not perverse or unsupported by evidence. Therefore, the learned single Judge's order was set aside, and the orders of the DRO and Commissioner (Appeals) were restored.

Regarding the writ appeal concerning mandamus for disposal of an application related to property claims, the court observed that the nature of the claim was for title, which is not suitable for adjudication under writ jurisdiction. The parties were directed to pursue their claims before competent civil courts.

The court also allowed the applications for impleadment of petitioners as parties to the writ appeals, recognizing their claimed interest in the property and permitting them to agitate their rights before competent courts.

Holding and Implications

The court allowed Writ Appeals Nos. 1311 and 1781 of 2005, setting aside the learned single Judge's order and restoring the orders of the District Revenue Officer and Commissioner (Appeals) that corrected the land records under Section 87 of the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act as a clerical error.

Writ Appeal No. 257 of 2009 was disposed of by directing the parties to pursue their title claims in competent civil courts, as such matters are not appropriate for adjudication under writ jurisdiction.

Applications for impleadment of petitioners as parties in the writ appeals were allowed, permitting them to be part of the proceedings and to pursue their claims before the appropriate courts.

No new precedent was established; the decision primarily restored the validity of correction orders under Section 87 of the Act and clarified the procedural limits of writ jurisdiction in property title disputes.

    Azamunnisa Begum v. A.P. Housing Board

    For the reasons stated in the affidavit, it is therefore prayed that the Hon'ble Court may be pleased to implead the petitioners as respondent Nos. 16 & 17 and permit them to put forth their claim for proper adjudication of claim and pass such other order or orders as the Hon'ble Court deems fit in the interest of justice.

    For the reasons stated it is prayed that this Hon'ble Court maybe pleased to implead the petitioners as the respondent Nos. 16 and 17 in the Writ Appeal No. 1311 of 2005 and pass such other order or other orders as it may deem fit pending disposal of Writ Appeal.

    For the reasons stated it is prayed that this Hon'ble Court maybe pleased to implead the petitioners as therespondent Nos. 16 and 17 in the Writ Appeal No. 1781 of 2005 and pass such other order or other orders as it may deem fit pending disposal of Writ Appeal.

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Vilas V. Afzulpurkar, J.

    WA. Nos. 1311 and 1781 of 2005:

    1. WA. Nos. 1311 and 1781 of 2005 are directed against the judgment of the learned single Judge in WP. No. 13927 of 2003 dated 19.04.2005 While WA. No. 1781 of 2005 is filed by respondents 7 and 8 in the writ petition - [appellant No. 1 (seventh respondent), since died is represented by appellants 3 to 7], W.A No. 1311 of 2005 is filed by the legal representatives of the sixth respondent in the writ petition.

    2. The facts, in brief, are as follows:

    (a) The Government of Andhra Pradesh acquired Ac.661.04 guntas of land in Sy. No. 1009 of Kukatpally village for Andhra Pradesh Housing Board (APHB) and further, an extent of Ac.5.21 guntas was acquired by the Government for Water Works Department. To the extent of the land acquired for APHB an award No. 2 dated 10.06.1968 was passed by the Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition (General), Hyderabad and the other extent of Ac.5.21 guntas is in possession of Manjeera Water Works Department. During the award enquiry, late Nawab Rayees Yar Jang and later Mir Fazilath Hussain Khan, S/o late Nawab Rayees Yar Jang, filed claim petitions claiming compensation. The said claimants prosecuted the claim petitions and the Land Acquisition Officer, originally passed award @ Rs. 500/- per acre. Dissatisfied therewith, the owners sought reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act vide O.P No. 330 of 1968 before the Chief Judge, City Civil Court and ultimately the compensation was finally determined by the order of the Honourable Supreme Court. However, the same is not the subject matter of the present proceedings. Suffice it to notice that the acquisition notification as mentioned above was issued on 24.05.1963 and the possession of the land was taken over on 24.06.1968 by APHB.

    (b) Mir Fazilath Hussain Khan S/o late Nawab Rayees Yar Jang filed an application before the District Revenue Officer (DRO), Ranga Reddy District, under Section 87 of the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana) Area Land Revenue Act (for short ‘the Act’), 1317 Fasli claiming to be the pattedar and owner of the acquired land bearing Sy. No. 1009 and 1043 to 1065 totally admeasuring Ac.1121.71 guntas but as per the revenue record, the extent recorded is Ac.1110.07 guntas. The said applicant stated that after excluding the acquisition of the acquired land for APHB and Manjeera Water Works, an extent of Ac.11.10 guntas in Sy. No. 1009 is still in his possession and as such; it is necessary that corrections with regard to the extent of the said balance land may be made in the revenue record. The specific contention of the said applicant was that out of Sy. No. 1009 the Government having acquired Ac.661.04 guntas for APHB and having paid compensation, thereafter, an extent of total area of Sy. No. 1009 found on the spot is Ac.672.14 guntas and after acquisition an extent of Ac.5.21 guntas for Manjeera Water Works, still an extent of Ac.11.10 guntas, which is part of Sy. No. 1009 is left over and as such, sought correction of revenue record by including the name of the owners/claimants by passing necessary orders. In the said application, the applicants/claimants also stated that necessary orders for condonation of delay be passed and the correction as prayed for be ordered. The Commissioner of Survey, Settlements and Land Records, Hyderabad, vide his proceedings in letter No. P5/834/96 dated 15.09.1997 examined the matter and directed the DRO to take action as per circular instructions of the Commissioner by opining that the error pointed out falls in the category of ‘clerical error’ vide Para 5(a) of the circular and directed the DRO to hear APHB and the applicant under Section 87 of the Act.

    (c) Accordingly notices were issued to APHB to file their objections and then the DRO considered the entire matter with reference to the records and was of the view that survey is required to be carried out to ascertain the factual position. The claimant/applicant also filed several documents showing their entitlement as legal representatives and also notifications earlier issued together with the sketch of the survey number. The DRO referred the case to Assistant Director, Survey and Land Records, who reported that the boundaries of Sy. No. 1009 are fixed with the help of the map and site survey tippans and measured the area and reported that an extent of Ac.20.18 guntas is coming in excess on the sport, which is part and parcel of Sy. No. 1009. The DRO, on enquiry and on examination of acquisition proceedings culminating in the award dated 10.06.1968, found that though the compensation was paid for Ac.661.04 guntas in Sy. No. 1009, the remaining property of the claim, found exceeding, was neither acquired nor APHB is otherwise entitled to. Taking into consideration the technical opinion of the Assistant Director with regard to the dimensions and measurement of Sy. No. 1009 fixed with reference to traverse data of tippans and theodolite survey method found that there is excess land available and the claim of the applicants seeking correction was found to be justified, as there was clearly a clerical error. In conclusion, the DRO found that under Section 87 of the Act, a correction of extent in Sy. No. 1009 of Kukatpally village, Balanagar Mandal, is required to be made by correcting the extent from Ac.666.25 guntas to Ac.687.03 guntas and to include the names of owners in the khata by deleting the area acquired by APHB admeasuring Ac.661.04 guntas.

    (d) As against the aforesaid order of the DRO, APHB preferred an appeal under Section 158 of the Act before the Commissioner (Appeals), O/o The Chief Commissioner of Land Administration, Hyderabad. The learned Commissioner re-examined the matter and found as follows at Paras 4, 5 and 7:

    “4. The appellant Housing Board has acquired an extent of Ac.661.04 guntas in Sy. No. 1009 of Kukatpally (V) and award was passed on 10.06.1968 The pattadar filed claim petition under Section 18 of the L.A Act in O.P No. 330 of 1968 in the court of the Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. In para (6) of the claim petition among other things, it is mentioned that the remaining extent of 11 acres and odd is not acquired and the same remain to be the property of the claimant. As such, the plea of the appellant that the respondent's claim is belated is not correct.

    5. The error noticed in the instant case is difference in the are of Sy. No. 1009 of Kukatpally (V) which falls under category of clerical error in para 5(d) of thecircular issued vide D.O.S Ref. No. F2/10568/94, dt. 19.04.1995 There is no time limit for entertaining clerical errors and the D.R.O is competent to entertain such clerical errors and pass orders under section 87 of the A.P (T.A) L.R Act, 1317 F. As such, the plea that respondent No. 2 exercise powers for correction of extent under Section 87 of the L.R Act, 1317 F without jurisdiction is not accepted.

    7. The D.R.O, Ranga Reddy District has entertained the petition for correction error in the extent of Sy. No. 1009, Kukatpally under section 87 of the A.P (T.A) L.R Act, 1317 F as per the clarification given by the Commissioner SS & LR, A.P, Hyderabad vide Ref. P5/834/96, dt.15-09-1997. As per award an extent of Acs.661-04 gts., was acquired in Sy. No. 1009 of Kukatpally (v) by the appellant Housing Board and the excess extent available in the said Sy. No., belongs to the pattadar and as such there is no need to take into consideration BSO 34 B while re-survey of the land in question.”

    3. In conclusion, the learned Commissioner agreed with the order of the DRO as proper and confirmed the same. Aggrieved thereby, APHB filed WP. No. 13927 of 2003 before this Court. Under the impugned judgment, the learned single Judge has allowed the writ petition. Against the said judgment of the learned single Judge, two writ appeals are preferred by the respective claimants, namely, sixth respondents' legal representatives have preferred WA. No. 1311 of 2005 and respondents 7 and 8 have preferred W.A No. 1781 of 2005.

    4. We have heard Sri. J. Prabhakar, learned standing counsel for APHB and Sri. B. Ram Moham Reddy and Sri. Mahmood Ali, learned counsel, appearing for the appellants respectively in these two appeals. We have also heard learned counsel for proposed parties.

    5. During the hearing, we had entertained a doubt as to whether Section 87 of the Act is still an available remedy. However, neither of the counsel could enlighten us on this aspect. A Division Bench of this Court in Joint Collector v. K. Sathaiah (WA. No. 152 of 1985 dated 05.03.1991) was considering the correctness of the judgment of the learned single Judge, who had held that after extension of the Andhra Pradesh (Andhra Area) Survey and Boundaries Act, 1923 to the entire State by the State Amendment Act 22 of 1985 the Chapters under the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act, which includes Section 87 was deleted. The Division Bench considered the aforesaid in the light of the Andhra Pradesh Survey and Boundaries (Extension and Amendment) Act, 1958 and particularly Section 7 thereof, which is as follows:

    “7. Effect of other laws:— Nothing contained in the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act, 1317 F., (Act VIII of 1317 F.) or the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Record of Rights in Land Regulation, 1358 F. (Regulation LVIII of 1358 F) shall apply in so far as they relate to any matter or proceeding dealt within the principal Act as amended by this Act except as respects things done or omitted to be done before the commencement of this Act.”

    6. The Division Bench, thereafter, came to the conclusion that since it is nobody's case that any survey was made in pursuance of the 1923 Act, Section 87 of the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act would still be available. In the present case also there is no material nor it is anybody's case that any survey was made under the 1923 Act and therefore, the proceedings in question under Section 87 of the Act are sustainable.

    7. So far as the claim of APHB with respect to land in Sy. No. 1009 is concerned, the same is only through the acquisition proceedings initiated and culminating into the award No. 2 dated 10.06.1968 passed by the Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition, Hyderabad. Undisputedly, the extent covered by the said acquisition is only Ac.661.04 guntas. As per the award the amount awarded was Rs. 3,30,500/- for the extent of Ac.661.04 guntas. The vesting of the land acquired under the aforesaid acquisition proceedings is, therefore, only confined to the extent of Ac.661.04 guntas. Any extent, over and above the same in the said Sy. No. 1009, obviously does not belong to APHB nor any claim can be made by APHB to the detriment of the real owners thereof. The proceedings under Section 87 of the Act taken up by the owners for correction of the clerical error in the records so as to include their names in the khata for the balance extent of the land, was enquired into by the DRO in detail by seeking technical report from the survey and land records department. The report of the survey authorities confirmed the said excess land available on the ground, as has been, mentioned above. The learned Commissioner of land administration had also examined the matter before the DRO exercised his powers under Section 87 of the Act and had opined and communicated by his letter No. P5/834/96 dated 15.09.1997 that the aforesaid error falls in the category of clerical error vide Para 5(a) of the circular orders of the Commissioner and consequently directed the DRO to hear APHB and the claimants and pass appropriate orders under Section 87 of the Act. It was also mentioned in the said proceedings that it is not necessary to send the proposals to the Commissioner for condonation of delay or rectification of error. It is only in pursuance of the aforesaid directive of the Commissioner that the DRO has examined the matter in detail and accepted the application of the appellants and ordered necessary correction. On appeal, against the said order, at the instance of APHB, the learned Commissioner has confirmed the said order of DRO.

    8. The learned single Judge had allowed the writ petition firstly, on the ground that the said error cannot be said to be a clerical error. The learned single Judge noticed that what constituted the clerical error is covered by circular of Commissioner in proceedings P1/4392/94 (SS&LR) dated 15.10.1994 For the sake of convenience the entire circular is extracted hereunder.

    “Section 87 of Land Revenue Act, 1317 Fasli does not provide definition of clerical errors and errors other than clerical errors. The clerical errors are minor errors which do not involve alteration in area, change of classification, or change of name of the pattedar.

    A few examples of errors, which come under the category of clerical errors, are furnished below:—

    a) Name of Pattedar misspells,

    b) Inter-change of survey numbers,

    c) Survey No. missing in survey map,

    d) Area is calculated wrongly though measurement on ground and records support the correct area.

    Since the definition of clerical error and errors other than clerical errors is not there in the Act, it is not proper to leave it to the judgment of Asst. Director Survey and Land Records whether particular survey error falls under the category of clerical error or errors other than clerical error. Therefore, the Asst. Director, Survey and Land Records shall send detailed technical report to Director, Survey Settlement and Land Records, regarding proposed error. This is purely a technical and non-statutory function. The report so sent shall be examined at Directorate whether the error falls under the category of clerical error or error other than clerical error and the fact will be communicated to Asst. Director Survey and Land Records. On obtaining clearance from the Directorate, the Asst. Director shall sent the file to District Revenue Officer to dispose of the case at District Revenue Officers level under Section 87 of Land Revenue Act, if the error is a clerical error. If the error is other than clerical error, the District Revenue Officer, shall send proposals to Commissioner Survey Settlement and Land Records duly condoning the delay as per rules for disposal of the case by Commissioner, Survey Settlement and Land Records, under Section 87-A of Land Revenue Act 1317 Fasli.”

    9. It cannot be denied that the report of the Assistant Director of Survey and Land Records does support the claim of the appellants regarding the clerical error as envisaged above. The DRO, therefore, was satisfied that the case warrants correction under Section 87 of the Act. The learned single Judge, therefore, was not justified in holding that “record prepared at the time of survey is not produced to show that there is wrong calculation of area, though the measurement on ground and record support the correct area so entered recording extent of Sy. No. 1009 cannot be said to have been made wrongly due to clerical mistake…”. The learned single Judge, thereafter, considered the said aspect from the point of view of the declaration filed by Mir Fazilath Hussain Khan and others under the Agricultural Land Reforms Act and that they did not claim excess land in the said proceedings and having not declared the said excess extent of Ac.11.10 guntas in the aforesaid declaration, they cannot make a claim for the aforesaid land. The aforesaid conclusion also appears to us to be erroneous inasmuch as neither Mir Fazilath Hussain Khan nor the appellants were holding the land and as such their declaration thereafter under the AP Land Reforms Act or otherwise has hardly of any relevance. In any case, until the survey takes place and orders as to correction are made, it cannot be said that the appellants have to be non-suited on that ground. The learned single Judge, therefore, felt that any correction, at this stage, would lead to litigation in future and that if the claimants/appellants have any right in any part of the said land, their remedy is elsewhere but not to seek correction of the extent. Based on the said conclusions, the learned single Judge allowed the writ petition.

    10. As noted above, the present case of the appellants falls within the category of a clerical error as contemplated under Section 87 of the Act and as such, the application made by the appellants' predecessor is clearly sustainable. The orders passed by the primary authority i.e District Revenue Officer, under Section 87 of the Act and as confirmed by the learned Commissioner in his appellate jurisdiction is clearly based on material on record including the report of the Assistant Director, Survey and Land Records and therefore, once the appellants make out a case establishing that the entries suffer from clerical error in terms of the Commissioner's circular extracted above, the concurrent orders of the competent authorities could not have been reversed by the learned single Judge under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, as the said orders cannot be said to be either perverse or not based on material on record or contrary to the material on record. We are, therefore, of the opinion that the impugned order is liable to be set aside and thereby restoring the order of the District Revenue Officer, Ranga Reddy Distirct in file No. G8/635/94 dated 09.06.1998 as confirmed by the Commissioner (Appeals). O/o The Chief Commissioner of Land Administration, Andhra Pradesh, in Commissioner Appeals proceedings No. P5/466/98 dated 04.01.2003

    11. The writ appeals accordingly are allowed.

    WA. No. 257 of 2009:

    12. So far as WA. No. 257 of 2009 is concerned, the same is directed against the order of the learned single Judge in WP. No. 8388 of 2004 dated 25.07.2006 The prayer in the aforesaid writ petition was for Mandamus complaining the inaction on the part of the respondents in disposing of the petitioner's application.

    13. The petitioner in the said writ petition, who is the appellant herein, claims to be a house building society. It is alleged that one of the heirs of the Mir Fazilath Hussain Khan executed a gift in favour of the petitioner society with respect to the land other than land acquired by APHB and based on that a civil litigation in O.S No. 122 of 1973 on the file of the Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court is pending regarding apportionment of compensation among the rightful owners and another suit in O.S No. 189 of 1974 on the file of the II Additional Judge, City Civil Court, for declaration that the plaintiffs in the said civil litigation are real owners. It is, further, alleged that a compromise was recorded in one of the civil suits and it is further alleged that the seventh respondent has admitted to sell the said property, which is otherwise claimed by the petitioner society and as such, the writ petitioner - society has interest in claiming title to the property.

    14. Learned single Judge having noticed the order of the other learned single Judge in WP. No. 13927 of 2003 dated 19.04.2005 (which is impugned in the earlier writ appeals above referred) dismissed the writ petition on the ground that the learned single Judge has already allowed the writ petition in W.P No. 13927 of 2003.

    15. In the earlier part of this judgment, we have set aside the said judgment in WP. No. 13927 of 2003. Consequently, therefore, the impugned order of the learned single Judge dismissing WP. No. 8388 of 2004 dated 25.07.2006 is also liable to be set aside. However, the nature of the claim made by the appellant/petitioner in the writ petition, being a claim for title to the property, it is neither possible nor desirable to adjudicate upon and decide the rival title of the parties in the present proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

    16. But, taking note of the averments in WAMP Nos. 2475 and 1156 of 2008, we are of the opinion that all the parties shall agitate their rights before the civil court of competent jurisdiction. Accordingly, we leave it open and relegate all the parties to agitate their claims by approaching a competent Court of law for seeking appropriate relief. W.A No. 257 of 2009 is accordingly disposed of.

    17. In the result, the WA. No. 1311 and 1781 of 2005 are allowed and W.A No. 257 of 2009 is disposed of as above. There shall be no order as to costs.

    W.A.M.P No. 2475 of 2008 in W.A No. 1311 of 2005

    W.A.M.P No. 2476 of 2008 in W.A No. 1781 of 2005

    18. Since the parties in both applications are one and the same, both the applications are disposed of by a common order.

    19. The W.A.M.P No. 2475 of 2008 is filed by the petitioners seeking to implead them as respondent Nos. 16 and 17 in Writ Appeal No. 1311 of 2005 and W.A.M.P No. 2476 of 2008 is filed by the petitioners seeking to implead them as respondent Nos. 15 and 16 in W.A No. 1781 of 2005.

    20. Facts in both the applications are similar and in brief they are:

    It is alleged that the respondent Nos. 7 and 8 in the Writ Petition, who are appellants in Writ Appeal No. 1781 of 2005 have entered into an agreement of sale with the Petitioner No. 1-proposed respondent No. 16 and one Kusuma Jaipal on 23.1.2003 for the sale of an extent of 20 acres of land for a sale consideration of Rs. 10,50,00,000/-, out of which an amount of Rs. 65 lakhs was paid towards the advance. It is further alleged that one Kusuma Jaipal executed a relinquishment deed on 16.12.2005 in favour of the petitioner-proposed respondent No. 16 releasing all his rights in favour of petitioner No. 1-proposed respondent No. 16. It is further alleged that on 14.12.2005 the petitioner-proposed respondent No. 16 entered into an agreement of sale with proposed respondent No. 17 for sale of 15 acres of land out of 20 acres of land for a consideration of Rs. 7,87,50,000/- after receiving advance amount. It is further alleged that the proposed respondent No. 17 paid an amount of Rs. 2,00,000/- on 25.11.2006 and subsequently paid Rs. 3,00,000/- to the vendors as advance on 9.12.2006 It is submitted by the petitioners-proposed respondent Nos. 16 and 17 that since they are having interest in the property, which is the subject matter in the writ appeals, they have approached this Court to implead them as proper and necessary parties to the writ appeals.

    W.A.M.P No. 1156 of 2009 in W.A No. 1311 of 2005

    21. This petition is filed seeking to implead the petitioners as party respondent Nos. 16 & 17.

    22. The appellant-Azamunnissa Begum in W.A No. 1311 of 2005 was the owner of an extent of Ac. 1104-26 guntas in Sy. Nos. 1009, and 1043 to 1065 of Kukatpalli village. She inherited the said property through her husband and they have no issues and other heirs.

    23. The Government of Andhra Pradesh acquired the said land. Even after acquisition of land, still she was is in possession of an extent of Ac.20-18 guntas. After demise of her husband, she alone resided. The proposed respondent No. 16 worked as servant and rendered services till her death. When she was in financial problems, the proposed respondent No. 16 introduced the proposed respondent No. 17 to the said appellant and she obtained finance from the proposed respondent No. 17. To that effect, she executed a Will dated 9.7.2006 in their favour. After her death, the proposed respondents approached the authorities concerned for mutation of said land in their favour, but their claim was rejected on the ground that the matter is pending adjudication before this Court. Hence, they are proper and necessary parties to the proceedings and they filed the present petition seeking to implead them as respondent Nos. 16 and 17.

    24. However, in writ appeal No. 257 of 2009 it is alleged that the suit in O.S No. 189 of 1974 was filed for declaration that the plaintiffs therein are the real owners; that compromise was recorded in one of the civil suits; that the 7 respondent therein, namely Mrs. Azaunnisa Begum, has admitted to sell the property to the appellant-society, which is otherwise claimed by the appellant-society; and as such, the appellant is interested in claiming title to the property.

    25. In the facts and circumstances of the case, particularly in view of the plea raised by the petitioners that they are proper and necessary parties to the appeal basing on the Will executed by the appellant-landlord, We deem it appropriate to permit the petitioners to come on record.

    26. Accordingly, the WAMPs are ordered.

    27. In view of the observations made in the writ appeals that liberty is given to the parties to agitate their claims by approaching competent Court of law for seeking appropriate relief, We are of the opinion that the impleaded parties also can agitate their claims before the competent Court of law for seeking appropriate relief.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Azamunnisa Begum v. A.P. Housing Board
    (Sep 25, 2009)