Sunil Hali:— The petitioner was granted Short Service Commission (SSC) in the Indian Army in Army Education Corps on 04.03.2000. After serving for an initial period of five years, she opted for extension for a further period of five years and she was granted extension for the said period of five years. On being asked vide communication dated 17.03.2009 whether she was desirous of getting further extension for four years, she gave her willingness. Based on such willingness and fulfilling the QRs, she was granted further extension of four years upto March, 2014.
2. There was no provision for grant of Permanent Commission to the lady SSC officers, at the time the petitioner was enrolled in the short service commission, the matter was taken up by some of the serving SSC women officers before the Hon'ble Delhi High Court. The Division Bench of Delhi High Court in its order dated 10.03.2014 allowed the petition and directed that women SSC officers be offered permanent commission provided they satisfy the QRs laid for such absorption. In terms of the directions passed by the Hon'ble High Court, the respondents initiated the process of seeking the option from the SSC women officers for their absorption permanently in the service. In this behalf, a decision was approved by the respondents on 04.10.2010 after seeking approval from the Hon'ble President of India. A decision to convey the order of disseminating the decision to offer permanent commission was taken on 27.10.2010. As per the communication dated 27.10.2010, all those SSC women officers recruited prior to 2006 will be considered for grant of permanent commission in November, 2010. An option was sought from the petitioner by the respondents on 30.09.2010. The petitioner is stated to have shown her unwillingness to be considered for grant of permanent commission through her communication dated 30.09.2010. Based on her unwillingness, she was not considered for appointment. The petitioner, however, was granted extension in her service till March, 2014. Thereafter, she was posted to Lucknow.
3. She moved an application for withdrawal of her earlier unwillingness for grant of permanent commission. The matter was processed through the Commanding Officer through proper channel. Recommendations were made for withdrawal of her earlier unwillingness and to be absorbed permanently. She is stated to have been strongly recommended for permanent commission based upon her merit. The prayer of the applicant was rejected by the respondents vide their communications dated 10.01.2014. It was acknowledged that the case of the petitioner for consideration for permanent commission duly recommended by the Command channel had not been received. Therefore, the case issue was closed. This order is a subject matter of challenge before this court.
4. The case set out by the petitioner is that:
(a) Army Order No. 110 of 1980 provides for change in the option which must be routed through Formation Commanders. Therefore, the contention of the respondent that there is no provision for withdrawal of the option, is incorrect.
(b) That the option was exercised by the petitioner when she was posted in Afghanistan and was unaware of the consequences of the judgment on the basis of which the option was sought. At the relevant point of time when the option was exercised, she had some matrimonial problems and was trying to sort out the same. As a matter of fact, she was not aware that the permanent commission was being granted on account of the directions issued by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi. The letter of option was sent to the petitioner by the respondents much before the decision was taken to seek option from the SSC women officers. Her option was obtained on 13.09.2010 whereas the sanction was accorded by the Hon'ble President to offer permanent commission to the women officers on 04.10.2010. The petitioner being away from the country, was not aware of the terms and conditions on the basis of which option was offered to her. It is further averred that only after the sanction was accorded by the Hon'ble President, the respondents had initiated the process of offering permanent commission and not before that. Therefore, the exercise undertaken by them before the orders were passed, was an exercise undertaken without proper sanction and authority.
(c) Lastly, it has been contended that the petitioner could withdraw her option before her actual term in the office came to an end. It is further contended that the petitioner was a meritorious officer, was given Sena Medal (gallantry) for having bravely faced the attacks of militants in Afghanistan. Recommendations for her permanent absorption has been made by the officers under whose command she was working thereby testifying the facts that she was otherwise meritorious, to be granted the permanent commission.
5. On the other hand, the stand of the respondent is that the petitioner had exercised her option of unwillingness for granting permanent commission on 13.09.2010. In terms of the policy of 1980, option once given could not be withdrawn as the same is irrevocable. It is further contended by the respondents that there is a provision for reconsideration of the option but that must be received much before the 5th Selection Board undertakes the process of considering the cases of officers for permanent commission. The petitioner had slept over the matter for more than three years before she realized that the earlier option given by her needs to be withdrawn.
6. The option can be withdrawn only under exceptional circumstances and that too prior to the consideration by the 5 Selection Board and not thereafter under any circumstances. Her case was considered by the Special No. 5 Selection Board consequent to the order of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and as per her option, she was granted extension and allowed to serve upto 14 years i.e. 03.03.2014. Any change in option after holding of No. 5 Selection Board and its implementation, will alter the basic foundation and conduct of the 5 Selection Board that could strike at the root of cadre structure of the Indian Army.
7. The applicant opted for extension in September, 2010 and thereafter on grant of extension, she availed of the benefits of last leg posting in the years 2011 and 2013. She insisted for her posting in Delhi prior to her retirement in March, 2014. Her request to stay in Delhi was granted in view of the fact that she had not opted for permanent commission. Her request for change of the option was recommended by the officers under whose command she was working but the papers were not received till January, 2014, as a result of which her case was to be closed in so far as grant of permanent commission is concerned. In a nutshell, this is the stand of the respondents.
8. It is pertinent to mention here that when the impugned order dated 10.11.2014 was received, she requested the concerned authorities to re-process her case as per the Army Order as the same was earlier returned vide order of 2013. The respondents on 20.03.2014 received the statement of case along with the other documents duly processed but no decision was taken on the said request.
9. There was no policy for granting permanent commission to the women officers. It was only through the intervention of the Hon'ble Delhi High Court that a direction was issued to consider the women officers for grant of permanent commission in order to obviate gender bias. As a consequence of this direction, steps were taken by the respondents to grant permanent commission to women SSC officers who had not been granted commission prior to 2006. All those officers who had been granted commission prior to 2006 were eligible for grant of permanent commission. The only condition was that they should fulfill the QRs laid down by the respondents and must give their willingness. The process for granting permanent commission is contained in Army Order No. 110 of 1981. This order specifically deals with the grant of permanent commission to the SSC officers (Technical and Non-Technical). Para 2 of the order specifies that “the officers should use utmost discretion in exercising their options as OPTIONS ONCE EXERCISED WILL BE FINAL AND IRREVOCABLE. Request for change in option necessitated because of circumstances beyond control, if any, should be routed through the formation Commanders and Command HQs will ensure that these are forwarded to Army HQ only under exceptional circumstances after scrutinizing the merits of the case.”
10. The import of the policy enumerated hereinabove clearly envisages that option once exercised will be final and irrevocable subject to a request being made for change in option provided such a change is necessitated by circumstances beyond control. In such an eventuality, the request can be routed through the formation of Commanders and Command HQs. It is not correct to say that option once exercised cannot be revoked, the policy is expressly clear on this question. The only condition is that such a change must be necessitated by circumstances beyond ones control and commanders in the chain must recommend it on merits. The first contention of the respondent is that policy of October, 1981 does provide for change in option provided such an option is received before the 5 Selection Board is constituted.
11. However, no such condition is reflected in the policy. Therefore, the option can be exercised even if the Selection Board has concluded the issue. It is trite that an option can be withdrawn any time before the tenure of an officer comes to an end. A person can withdraw the option as it is clearly reflected by what has been held by the Hon'ble apex court in UOI v. Wing Commander T. Parthasarathy decided on 10.11.2000, wherein it has been observed that:
“So far as the case in hand is concerned, nothing in the form of any statutory rules of any provision of any Act has been brought to our notice which could be said to impede or deny this right of the appellants. On the other hand, not only the acceptance of the request by the Headquarters, the appropriate Authority was said to have been made only on 20.2.86, a day after the respondent withdrew his request for pre-mature retirement but even such acceptance in this case was to be effective from a future date namely 31.8.86. Consequently, it could not be legitimately contended by the appellants that there was any cessation of the relationship of master and servant between the Department and the respondent at any rate before 31.8.86. While that be the position inevitably the respondent had a right and was entitled to withdraw or revoke his request earlier made before it ever really and effectively became effective.
The reliance place upon the so-called policy decision which obligated the respondent to furnish a certificate to the extent that he was fully aware of the fact that he cannot later seek for cancellation of the application once made for premature retirement cannot, in our view, be destructive of the right of the respondent, in law, to withdraw his request for pre-mature retirement before it ever became operative and effective and effected termination of his status and relation with the Department. When the legal position is that much clear it would be futile for the appellants to base their rights on some policy decision of the Department or a mere certificate of the respondent being aware of a particular position which has no sanctity or basis in law to destroy such rights which otherwise inhered in him and available in law. No such deprivation of a substantive right of a person can be denied except on the basis of any statutory provision or rule or regulation.”
12. Therefore, on a principle of law, an option once exercised can be withdrawn before the tenure of an officer comes to an end.
13. This judgment clearly reflects that a substantive right of a person cannot be denied by invoking some provisions of a policy which have no statutory flavour.
14. The next question that calls for consideration is as to whether any option was sought from the petitioner in terms of the order dated 04.10.2010. The said order relates to the sanction being granted by the Hon'ble President to consider the women officers for permanent commission in terms of the directions passed by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court on 12.03.2010. The order dated 27.10.2010 indicates that grant of permanent commission to women officers of AEC and JAG has been approved by the Government with effect from 02.08.2010. Women officers of AEC and JAG commissioned between August, 1996 and March, 2006 are being considered for grant of permanent commission in November, 2010. Therefore, any process for seeking option from the women officers could be initiated only after 04.10.2010. This would be an option strictly in consonance with the directions of the Hon'ble Delhi High Court as well as the Apex court. It appears from the record that the petitioner was asked to give an option much before 30.09.2010 and she is stated to have given the same on 30.09.2010. Once the option for granting permanent commission was not authorized by the Government, which was only done on 04.10.2010, under what instructions or orders the option was sought from the petitioner on 30.09.2010. Therefore, it clearly appears that no option was sought from the petitioner after the sanction was granted by the Hon'ble President on 04.10.2010. The respondents have sought option from the petitioner based upon a communication which was not authorized by the Hon'ble President. Therefore, any option sought on that basis has no relevance in the present context. Any option that the respondents were competent to seek from the officers was only after approval was accorded by the Hon'ble President vide his communication dated 04.10.2010. Therefore, the petitioner is right that she has not exercised any option not was any such option sought from her after 04.10.2010. Admittedly, no fresh option was sought from the petitioner after 04.10.2010. Therefore, rejection of her claim for permanent commission on the pretext of having given her option not to be absorbed permanently, was never issued after the order dated 04.10.2010 was issued.
15. Lastly, it has been contended by the respondents that there are no exceptional circumstances which necessitated for the change in the option. The petitioner has stated that when the earlier option was sought from the petitioner, she was under mental stress on account of matrimonial disputes. It is also stated that she was not aware of the circumstances under which this option was sought from her. She was away in Afghanistan at the relevant date.
16. On her last leg of posting at Lucknow, she became aware of the decision for grant of permanent commission to women SSC officers which was based upon the judgment of Hon'ble Delhi High Court. She, in her application seeking withdrawal of her earlier option, has stated that she has on account of her present domestic and financial problems at home, exercised an option not to be considered for permanent commission. However, with the passage of time, most of her domestic and financial problems have been resolved. This application of the petitioner was duly recommended by her officers under whose command she was working and they found that there were sufficient reasons and exceptional circumstances under which this option is sought to be withdrawn. She is also found to be an officer whose performance was excellent and well deserved of the exceptional circumstances for change of option being an officer the service would benefit from. The other question that calls for consideration is as to whether there existed any exceptional circumstances which necessitated change in the option. This Tribunal in its order dated 27.3.2014 in OA No. 467/2013 entitled Wing Commander Subrata Das v. UOI decided a case which was identical in facts of the present case. In this judgment, the following observations were made:
“11. The question that now requires to be considered is as to whether his application for withdrawal should be allowed or rejected since that the ground which existed in his earlier application is not a ground seeking withdrawal. To say candidly, the petitioner has not disclosed in his application for withdrawal that the circumstances which existed at the time of submitting his application for PSS have undergone material change. He has also not disclosed that his chances of promotion have brightened on the date he sought the withdrawal of the application. Since the policy does not contemplate that such a requirement is essential. Therefore, this question has to be examined in the context of what is stated in the policy. He has shown extreme compassionate ground for seeking withdrawal of his earlier application. The contents of the application clearly reflects that the applicant was constrained to apply against his wish for PSS due to acute problems on the domestic front. This kept compounding to a stage when it started to affect him adversely, it was under these circumstances he had applied for PSS. However, on deepest scrutiny he found that the release from service did not in any way less his problems. As a matter of fact he started realizing the impact of decision to seek PSS at a later stage. The visible issue which stared in the face were loss of six years of service and reduction of his pay. These factors weighed at the time he filed the application for withdrawal of his application for PSS. Loss of service for six years and reduction in the pay scale by itself gives him a feeling that he will not be able to sustain himself and his family. Therefore, he sought the withdrawal purely on compassionate grounds.
12. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner cannot be brush aside by this court. Immediate effect of his application for PSS would result into loss of six years service and reduction in pay scale. However, it may not lead to any future prospective in his career in the service. But the fact remains that this was the immediate loss to the petitioner which he realized at the time he made the application for withdrawal. We find that the application of the petitioner was clearly within the precincts of the policy.”
17. While applying the principles of the present case, it would be seen that when the petitioner was asked to submit her option for grant of permanent commission, she was posted in Afghanistan. As a matter of fact, she was not aware that such an option is being sought in terms of the directions of the Hon'ble Delhi High Court and the Hon'ble Apex Court. She has stated that on account of her domestic problems in respect of her matrimonial issues, she was not inclined to seek absorption in permanent commission. However, the applicant while withdrawing such an option, stated that she has overcome matrimonial dispute and other aspects which inspired her to give the option not to seek absorption permanently. Even one cannot put a straight jacket formula while considering the issue as to whether change in option is necessitated. A change in the option is necessitated under circumstances beyond control. Therefore, here was an offer to get absorbed permanently in the service which necessitated the change in option. It was also a contention of the petitioner that after putting in 14 years of service, she would not be able to get other employment thereby rendering hardships to her. The petitioner was not aware at the time of giving her option that this benefit is being extended to all the women officers as she was, admittedly, away in Afghanistan. Even if she was away, the mere allurement of getting permanently absorbed is in itself indicative of considerations which could have worked in the mind of the petitioner to seek a change in the option, more particularly, when so many women officers were granted permanent commission. She also would like to seek benefit of absorption permanently. Therefore, the circumstances by itself were sufficient to necessitate change in her option.
18. It is pertinent to mention here that this court had vide its directions dated 03.03.2014 directed the respondents to constitute a Special Selection Board No. 5 and consider the case of petitioner for grant of permanent commission. It appears from the stand of the respondents that they have not taken any steps in this behalf. The petitioner is still working under interim orders of this court.
19. We, therefore, allow this petition and set aside the impugned order dated 10.01.2014 and direct the respondents to consider the constitution of Special Selection Board No. 5 (or inclusion of this agenda in any other appropriate board) and consider the case of the petitioner for grant of permanent commission to her. Let this process be completed within a period of three months from today. Till then the petitioner shall continue in service. We also modify the earlier order to the extent that the petitioner shall be allowed to draw her salary and allowances till her matter is considered by the Special Selection Board. No orders as to costs.