Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 733
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 12 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 24 of the Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board Act, 1981
  • Section cannot be found in this excerpt, but 'C.W.J.C. NO.10698 of 1994' is a court case number and not an Act/Article Citation.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 733
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 12 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 24 of the Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board Act, 1981
  • Section cannot be found in this excerpt, but 'C.W.J.C. NO.10698 of 1994' is a court case number and not an Act/Article Citation.
Smart Summary

Trigun Chand Thakur v. State of Bihar & Ors.

Court: Supreme Court of India (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)

Citation: Civil Appeal No(s). 10003 of 2010; Order dated July 09, 2019; Non-reportable

Coram: R. Banumathi, J.; A.S. Bopanna, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, appointed as a Sanskrit teacher on 01.01.1985, faced allegations from the School Department. A show cause notice issued on 06.09.1994 was followed by a communication dated 01.10.1994 informing him of his suspension on account of absence on the eve of Independence Day and Teachers' Day.

He filed a writ petition before the Patna High Court. During its pendency, his services were terminated on 23.12.1994. By a consent order dated 31.08.1995, a learned Single Judge disposed of the writ petition, permitting the appellant to agitate his rights before the Chairman, Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board, who was directed to consider his representation in accordance with law.

On 03.08.1996, the Chairman considered the appellant’s representation against the Managing Committee’s dismissal order, found the punishment of termination disproportionate, and directed his reinstatement. The Managing Committee appealed under Section 24 of the Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board Act, 1981 to the Special Director (Secondary, Primary and Adult Education), who, by order dated 13.12.1997, remanded the matter to the Chairman for reconsideration in light of the appeal’s grounds.

Aggrieved by the remand, the appellant filed a writ petition seeking to quash the 13.12.1997 order. The learned Single Judge, relying on Chandra Nath Thakur v. The Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board & Ors., 1999 (1) PLJR 529, dismissed the writ on 29.04.1999, holding that writ petitions are not maintainable in matters of teacher termination by a private school’s Managing Committee. The Division Bench, in L.P.A. No. 670 of 1999, by order dated 21.01.2008, affirmed the dismissal, reiterating that a teacher of a privately managed school—even if financially aided by the State Government or the Board—cannot maintain a writ against a termination order of the Managing Committee, and observing that the earlier consent order could not confer jurisdiction or render the Managing Committee “State” under Article 12 of the Constitution. The present civil appeal challenges the Division Bench decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Managing Committee of a privately managed school is “State” within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India, thereby permitting the maintainability of a writ petition against its termination orders.
  2. Whether the earlier consent order directing the appellant to approach the Chairman of the Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board could, by itself, confer jurisdiction or render the Managing Committee “State” under Article 12.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chandra Nath Thakur v. The Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board & Ors., 1999 (1) PLJR 529 In matters concerning termination of teachers by the Managing Committee of a privately managed school, a writ petition is not maintainable; such Managing Committees are not “State” under Article 12, even if the school is financially aided. Relied upon by the learned Single Judge and affirmed by the Division Bench to dismiss the writ and LPA for non-maintainability; the Supreme Court found no ground to take a different view and dismissed the appeal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court succinctly affirmed the High Court’s approach. After considering the submissions of counsel and the material on record, it found no reason to depart from the Division Bench’s decision, which had upheld the Single Judge’s reliance on the precedent holding that Managing Committees of privately managed schools are not “State” under Article 12. Consequently, writ jurisdiction could not be invoked against termination decisions by such Committees, even where the school receives financial aid. The Division Bench’s observation that the earlier consent order could not confer jurisdiction or alter the Managing Committee’s constitutional status was left undisturbed. The Court did not enter into the merits of the disciplinary dispute, as the threshold issue of maintainability was dispositive.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED; No costs.

Implications: The dismissal leaves intact the High Court’s conclusion that writ remedies are not available against termination orders issued by the Managing Committee of a privately managed school, notwithstanding financial aid from the State or the Board. The immediate effect is that the appellant’s challenge fails and the High Court’s orders stand. The order does not articulate broader legal developments beyond affirming the non-maintainability of the writ in this context.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Trigun Chand Thakur v. State Of Bihar And Others

    1

    NON-REPORTABLE

    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

    CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    CIVIL APPEAL No(s). 10003 OF 2010 TRIGUN CHAND THAKUR Appellant(s)

    VERSUS

    STATE OF BIHAR & ORS. Respondent(s)

    O R D E R

    (1) This appeal arises out of judgment and order dated 21st January, 2008 in L.P.A. NO.670 of 1999 in and by which the Division Bench of the High Court of Patna affirmed the judgment of learned Single Judge holding that the Management Committee of the private schools is not "State" within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India and hence the writ petition of the petitioner is not maintainable.

    (2) The case has chequered history. The appellant was appointed as a Sanskrit teacher on 01.01.1985. On certain allegations, against the appellant by the School Department, a show cause notice was issued to him on 06.09.1994. On 01.10.1994, the appellant received the communication informing that he was suspended on account of his absence on the eve of Independence Day and Teachers' Day.

    2

    (3) Being aggrieved, the appellant has filed the writ petition before the High Court. During the pendency of the writ petition, the service of the appellant was terminated on 23.12.1994. Learned Single Judge of the High Court vide Order dated 31.08.1995 disposed of the writ petition with the consent of both the parties observing that the appellant may agitate his rights before the Chairman of the Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board and the Chairman of the Board shall consider the representation of the appellant and dispose of the same in accordance with law. On 03.08.1996, the Chairman, Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board, considered the matter on the basis of representation of the appellant against the order of dismissal passed by the Managing Committee and found that the punishment of termination of the appellant from service was disproportionate and directed reinstatement of the appellant. Being aggrieved, Managing Committee filed an appeal before the Special Director, Secondary, Primary and Adult Education- Respondent no.2, under Section 24 of the Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board Act, 1981. The Special Director (Secondary Education) by Order dated 13.12.1997 remanded the matter back to the Chairman, Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board, with a direction to reconsider the matter in the light of the grounds taken in the appeal.

    (4) Being aggrieved by remand of the matter to the Chairman, Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board, the appellant filed writ petition before the High Court seeking to quash Order dated 13.12.1997.

    3

    Learned Single Judge placed reliance upon the Judgment of the Patna High Court in Chandra Nath Thakur v. The Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board & Ors., 1999 (1) PLJR 529 and by Order dated 29.04.1999 dismissed the writ petition and held that in matters relating to the termination of the teachers by the Managing Committee of the private school, the writ petition is not maintainable and accordingly dismissed the writ petition.

    (5) Being aggrieved, the appellant has filed L.P.A. NO.670 of 1999 before Division Bench of the High Court. The Division Bench vide impugned order dated 21.01.2008 dismissed the L.P.A. filed by the appellant and affirmed the order passed by learned Single Judge. In the impugned order, the Division Bench of the High Court has also placed reliance on Chandra Nath Thakur v. The Bihar Sanskrit Shiksha Board & Ors., 1999 (1) PLJR 529 and held that a teacher of a privately managed school, even though financially aided by the State Government or the Board, cannot maintain a writ petition against an order of termination from service passed by the Management Committee. The Division Bench also pointed out that the consent order passed by the High Court in C.W.J.C. NO.10698 of 1994 cannot confer jurisdiction on this Court and does not make the Managing Committee "State" within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India.

    (6) Having considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties and the materials on record, we do not find any ground to take a different view.

    4

    (7) In the result, the appeal is dismissed. No costs.

    .........................J.

    (R. BANUMATHI)

    .........................J.

    (A.S. BOPANNA)

    NEW DELHI,

    JULY 09, 2019.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Trigun Chand Thakur v. State Of Bihar And Others
    (Jul 9, 2019)