AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961,
  • Urban Land Ceiling Act (ULCA)
  • section 21 of the ULCA.2.4
  • Transfer) Act, 1973,
  • INCOME TAX ACT
  • WEALTH TAX ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961,
  • Urban Land Ceiling Act (ULCA)
  • section 21 of the ULCA.2.4
  • Transfer) Act, 1973,
  • INCOME TAX ACT
  • WEALTH TAX ACT
Smart Summary

Case Summary — ITAT Opinion (Per K.G. Bansal, Accountant Member)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal by the assessee arises from the order of the CIT(A)-I, Pune dated 27-09-1999, against an assessment order passed under section 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 by the DCIT, SR-2, Pune on 26-02-1998. The assessee raised seven grounds of appeal; grounds 6 and 7 were procedural/prayer-type and not pursued before the Tribunal.

Material facts (as recorded in the opinion): The assessee had purchased land on Sassoon Road, Pune in 1963. Part of this land (28.691 sq.ft.) was converted into stock-in-trade on 26-04-1989 and sold during the relevant previous year. For substitution of cost under the capital gains provisions, the assessee filed a registered valuer's report asserting the fair market value on 01-04-1981 at Rs. 27 per sq.ft. The Assessing Officer (AO) rejected that valuation and instead relied on values shown in wealth-tax proceedings (variously recorded as Rs. 88,871, Rs. 2,10,000 and the AO ultimately adopting Re. 1 per sq.ft. for computation). The CIT(A) rejected the valuer's Rs. 27 figure but directed that the fair market value be taken at Rs. 2.10 lakhs (the value assessed under wealth-tax). The assessee appealed to the Tribunal contesting the CIT(A)'s decision and seeking adoption of the registered valuer's Rs. 27 per sq.ft. figure (and arguing that ULCA restrictions should not be treated as applicable for valuation on 01-04-1981 for the purpose of substitution).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the fair market value of the land on 01-04-1981 for substitution in place of acquisition cost (for long-term capital gains computation) should be taken at Rs. 27 per sq.ft. as per the registered valuer's report.
  2. Whether the valuation taken in wealth-tax proceedings (Rs. 2,10,000) or values adopted by the AO should control or be treated as estoppel against the assessee for capital gains computation.
  3. How, if at all, restrictions under the Urban Land Ceiling Act (ULCA) applicable on 01-04-1981 should affect the fair market valuation used for capital gains substitution.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee / Appellant's Arguments

  • The registered valuer valued the land at Rs. 27 per sq.ft. as of 01-04-1981; this should be adopted for substitution of cost for capital gains computation.
  • On the date of conversion into stock-in-trade, the land had been exempted from the purview of the ULCA, and therefore value on 01-04-1981 should be determined as if ULCA restrictions were not applicable.
  • The value shown in the wealth-tax return (variously stated) should not operate as estoppel against the assessee for the purposes of capital gains computation; the wealth-tax figure was ad hoc and not determinative.
  • Cited authorities (including ITAT decisions) to support the proposition that a registered valuer's report should not be disturbed unless there is cogent contrary evidence.

Revenue / Respondent's Arguments

  • The Assessing Officer contended that on 01-04-1981 the land was subject to restrictions under the Urban Land Ceiling Act, 1976 (ULCA) and therefore the market value must reflect those statutory restrictions (including possible acquisition and prescribed compensation rates).
  • The AO relied on the value determined in wealth-tax proceedings (Rs. 2,10,000 assessed by the WTO) and other indications when rejecting the valuer's Rs. 27 per sq.ft.
  • Before the Tribunal, the Departmental Representative (DR) relied upon the orders of the authorities below (AO and CIT(A)).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dr. Louis Prakasam Kannaiya v. CIT [2000] 74 ITD 379 (ITAT, Madras Bench) Illustrated that a value used in wealth-tax proceedings may be discounted for peculiar facts (e.g., lack of possession) and that such a discounted wealth-tax valuation should not be mechanically adopted for capital gains purposes when the factual basis for discount is absent. The Tribunal distinguished that decision: the discount in that case arose from lack of possession and prolonged litigation; those facts were not present here. The ratio was used to show that a wealth-tax discount based on peculiar facts does not automatically apply to capital gains valuation in different factual settings.
Mrs. Sosamma Paulose v. Jt. CIT [2003] 79 TTJ 572 (ITAT, Cochin Bench) Holds that in absence of cogent evidence in possession of the Assessing Officer, the report of a registered valuer cannot be disturbed. Relied upon to support the proposition that the registered valuer's report in the present case ought not to have been wholly ignored since the AO/CIT(A) produced no substantive evidence to displace it.
Shekhawati General Traders Ltd. v. ITO [1971] 82 ITR 788 (Supreme Court) Principle that certain subsequent events (e.g., issue of bonus shares after a specified date) may be extraneous and the property should be considered as it existed on the relevant base date (here analogous: consider property as on 01-01-1954 in that case; analogy to base date 01-04-1981 here). Cited for the general proposition that valuation for substitution should consider the property as it stood on the relevant base date (analogously supporting valuation as on 01-04-1981).
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Lady Hirabai C. Jehangir [1990] 186 ITR 60 (Bombay High Court) Followed the principle that value has to be taken as it existed on the statutory base date when continuity and identity are not altered. Referred to as following the ratio of Shekhawati and reinforcing that the relevant base date value must be used where continuity/identity of asset is maintained.
Meccane Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax [2002] 254 ITR 175 (Madras High Court) Holds that subsequent higher sale values or change of intended use does not alter the actual cost of acquisition; what matters is real profit (difference between sale price and actual acquisition price) rather than notional costs premised on changed use. Applied to reject the assessee's contention that land should be valued as if free from ULCA encumbrance on the date of conversion or sale; emphasized actual cost/real profit principle.
CWT v. Raj Kumari Bhuvaneshwari [1995] 215 ITR 198 (Rajasthan High Court) Holds that statutory restrictions on transfer affect valuation and such effects must be taken into account (valuation not necessarily limited to a fixed figure like Rs. 3 lakhs where restrictions apply). Applied by the Tribunal to support the proposition that the registered valuer should have considered the impact of ULCA restrictions on the market value and that a valuation ignoring statutory restrictions is not correct.
Commissioner Of Wealth Tax, Patna v. Raghubar Narain Singh [1984] 146 ITR 228 (Supreme Court) Holds that if an asset is subject to hazards or liabilities that diminish market value, those factors are relevant in estimating open market value. Relied upon for the proposition that statutory impediments which diminish the marketability/use of property (such as ULCA restrictions) are relevant and must be taken into account in valuation for substitution purposes.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal proceeded through a structured analysis based strictly on the materials and authorities before it:

  1. The assessee had filed a report from a registered valuer asserting a fair market value of Rs. 27 per sq.ft. on 01-04-1981; the AO rejected that report without assigning reasons and instead relied on values or estimates from wealth-tax proceedings and other indications (leading at one point to an adopted value of Re. 1 per sq.ft.).
  2. The CIT(A) did not accept the AO's very low figure nor the valuer's Rs. 27 figure; instead he directed that the fair market value be taken at Rs. 2.10 lakhs (the valuation adopted in wealth-tax assessment), as an alternate relief.
  3. The Tribunal reviewed authorities. It accepted the general proposition from Mrs. Sosamma Paulose that a registered valuer's report should not be completely ignored in the absence of substantive contrary evidence in the hands of the AO. The Tribunal found that neither the AO nor the CIT(A) had produced specific evidence to displace the valuer's report.
  4. However, the Tribunal analyzed the content of the valuer's report itself and noted that the valuer had valued the property "as if it was freehold" and had not taken into account the impact of ULCA restrictions on 01-04-1981. The opinion cites Raj Kumari Bhuvaneshwari and Raghubar Narain Singh for the proposition that statutory restrictions affecting transferability/use are relevant in estimating market value and must be considered.
  5. The Tribunal distinguished Dr. Louis Prakasam Kannaiya: in that case the wealth-tax discount was due to lack of possession and prolonged litigation (a fact-specific discount of 60% in the wealth-tax proceedings), which did not apply in the present case. Here, the assessee remained in possession but the use was curtailed by ULCA restrictions and there was a possible alternative (sanction of a scheme under section 21) besides acquisition; acquisition under ULCA was not inevitable.
  6. Considering these facts—the registered valuer's failure to account for ULCA’s impact, the presence of significant curtailment of user although possession remained, and the relevant precedents—the Tribunal concluded that the registered valuer's figure reasonably required a discount to reflect the market diminution caused by statutory restrictions. The Tribunal, guided by the cited authorities and the facts, applied a 50% discount to the valuer's Rs. 27 per sq.ft. figure, arriving at Rs. 13.50 per sq.ft. as the fair market value on 01-04-1981.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Tribunal allowed the appeal in part. The core ruling is emphasized as follows:

PARTLY ALLOWED

The Tribunal fixed the fair market value of the property on 01-04-1981 at Rs. 13.50 paise per sq.ft. (i.e., a 50% reduction of the registered valuer's Rs. 27 per sq.ft. valuation) and directed that the capital gains be computed accordingly.

Immediate Consequences for the Parties

  • The assessee's appeal is partly allowed.
  • The fair market value for substitution in capital gains computation is fixed at Rs. 13.50 per sq.ft. on 01-04-1981.
  • The AO/CIT(A) are to recompute the long-term capital gains in accordance with this valuation.

Broader Implications

The opinion does not announce a new legal principle beyond the application of existing authorities: it emphasizes that (i) a registered valuer's report should not be ignored without substantive contrary evidence, and (ii) statutory restrictions (such as ULCA) that affect use/transferability are relevant to market valuation and must be taken into account. The Tribunal applied these principles to the facts and adjusted the valuer's figure downward by 50% to reflect the effect of restrictions.

Disposition: Appeal partly allowed; capital gains to be recomputed in accordance with the valuation fixed by the Tribunal.

    Ajit J. Mehta v. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax, SR-2

    Per K.G. Bansal, Accountant Member. - This appeal of the assessee arises out of the order of CIT(A)-I, Pune, passed on 27-9-1999. The corresponding order of assessment was made by the DCIT, SR-2, Pune (hereinafter called ‘the Assessing Officer’), under the provisions of section 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, on 26-2-1998. The assessee has taken up seven grounds of appeal. Ground Nos. 6 and 7 are in the nature of prayer and residuary ground, which do not require any decision from us. The main ground of appeal is that the learned CIT(A) erred in not appreciating that the fair market value of the property, transferred by the assessee in this previous year, for working out the long-term capital gains was, Rs. 27 per sq.ft. as worked out by the registered valuer. It is inter alia mentioned that the said land was converted into stock-in-trade and on the date of such conversion, the restrictions of Urban Land Ceiling Act (ULCA) were not applicable. Therefore, the value on 1-4-1981 had to be made on the basis that the restrictions of ULCA were not applicable. It is further mentioned that the assessee had shown the value of the land on 1-4-1972, for the purpose of the levy of Wealth-tax, at Rs. 2,90,971 and, therefore, the value claimed on 1-4-1981 was reasonable. It is also mentioned that the value of the property shown in the wealth-tax return on 1-4-1981 ought not to have been taken as the fair market value on that day for the purpose of computing capital gains and that the value declared in that return did not act as estoppel against the assessee. Certain case laws were also cited in support of the aforesaid proposition. In view thereof, it was also mentioned that the learned CIT(A) erred in rejecting the grounds of appeal of the assessee before him.

    2.1 From the assessment order, it is found that the assessee purchased land situated at Sassoon Road, Pune in the year 1963. This land was converted into stock-in-trade on 26-4-1989 and the value for the purpose of conversion was taken at Rs. 53,72,157. The assessee developed the land and constructed ownership flats, shops, etc. under the project name "Sharadaram Park". In the relevant previous year 28.691 sq.ft. of the land, being a part of the whole land, was sold, whose conversion price was Rs. 36,83,988. The fair market value of the land on 1-4-1981 was taken at Rs. 27 per sq.ft. The indexed cost was worked out at Rs. 13,32,433, leading to long-term capital gains of Rs. 23,51,555. The value of the land was shown in the Wealth-tax return for assessment year 1981-82 at Rs. 2,10,000. However, it was stated that on the date of conversion of the land into stock-in-trade, the land had been exempted from the purview of ULCA. Therefore, the land should be valued on 1-4-1981 as if it was outside the purview of the ULCA. It was further stated that the value adopted by the Wealth-tax Officer at Rs. 2,10,000 was an ad hoc value, while the registered valuer had valued the land on scientific basis at Rs. 27 per sq.ft. Accordingly, it was urged that the value of the land may be adopted as shown in the return of income. The learned Assessing Officer did not accept the submissions and arguments of the assessee. It was pointed by him that the land was subjected to ULCA, 1976 on 1-4-1981. In terms of that Act, if any person held the land exceeding 10,000 sq.ft., it was liable to be acquired by the Government by payment of compensation at the rate of Rs. 10 per sq.mtr. The assessee had shown fair market value of the land in the return of wealth-tax at Rs. 88,871 only on the aforesaid basis. The WTO estimated the value at Rs. 2,10,000, which was accepted by the assessee. Therefore, he adopted the value of the land at Re. 1 per sq.ft.

    2.2 Aggrieved by this order, the assessee carried the matter in appeal before the learned CIT(A). The arguments of the assessee before the learned CIT(A) were the same as before the Assessing Officer. The learned CIT(A) pointed out that the land was subjected to restrictions under the ULCA. However, the price placed by the Assessing Officer at Re. 1 per sq.ft. was ridiculously low. It appears that an alternate claim was made by the assessee before the learned CIT(A) that the Assessing Officer may be directed to take the value of the land at Rs. 2,10,000 assessed under the wealth-tax proceedings for assessment year 1981-82. Therefore, he directed that the cost of acquisition of the land may be replaced by fair market value on 1-4-1981 of Rs. 2,10,000.

    2.3 Before us, the learned counsel narrated the facts regarding conversion of land into stock-in-trade, its development and sale of flats. In regard to computation of capital gains, it was pointed out that the registered valuer valued the land at Rs. 27 per sq.ft. The Assessing Officer reduced the value by taking into consideration the value shown in the corresponding Wealth-tax return and the restrictions placed under the ULCA. However, the learned CIT(A) allowed the value of Rs. 2.10 lakhs on the basis of wealth-tax assessment. The registered valuer of the assessee had valued the land at Rs. 27 per sq.ft. In the report, it was inter alia mentioned that as per the scheme sanctioned under section 21 of the ULCA, 1976, there were various impediments such as restriction on sale, scheme for weaker sections, plinth area restricted to 40 sq.mtr. for 45 tenements and 80 sq.mtr. for 22 tenements and restriction of 10 per cent of dwelling units for sale at the rate of Rs. 130 per sq.ft. to the Government allottees etc. The impact of these restrictions was taken into consideration, however, he valued the land as if it was a freehold land and, thus, impact of the ULCA was not taken into consideration. Taking a comparable instance of sale in Bund Garden, he valued the land, which could be used for commercial purposes at Rs. 1,500 per sq.mtr., as if there is no restriction, and residential portion at Rs. 150 per sq.mtr., taking into account the restrictions of the scheme. The weighted average value was worked out at Rs. 27 per sq.ft. The learned counsel pointed out that the valuation had been made on a reasonable basis taking into account the scheme approved under section 21 of the ULCA.

    2.4 The learned counsel relied on the decision of Hon’ble ITAT, Madras Bench, in the case of Dr. Louis Prakasam Kannaiya v. CIT [2000] 74 ITD 379. It may be worthwhile to state the facts of that case at some length. In that case certain jewellery was acquired under a Will and sold the same in the previous year relevant to assessment year 1994-95. The previous owner of the jewellery acquired it in 1935 and, therefore, option was exercised to substitute the cost of the previous owner with the fair market value of the property on 1-4-1981. In the wealth-tax assessment for assessment year 1991-92, the Assessing Officer had adopted the fair market value of the property. However, due to specific situation prevailing in that year, namely - that the Will was disputed, jewellery was under the custody of the court and even the previous owner had not taken the possession of the jewellery, the Tribunal discounted the value by 60 per cent and came to the conclusion that the value should be 40 per cent of the fair market value as on 1-4-1981. The Assessing Officer treated such discounted value on 1-4-1981 as the value in place of the cost to the original owner. The Hon’ble Tribunal pointed out that the value for the wealth-tax purpose was discounted because of existence of peculiar facts of that case that even the previous owner had not taken the possession of the property due to dispute about Will. The litigation in that respect started in 1965 and continued during the life time of the previous owner. However, litigation was over when the sale had taken place and that factor became irrelevant. Therefore, the discount given by the Tribunal in the wealth-tax proceedings could not have been considered for the purpose of fixing the value on 1-4-1981 for the purpose of computing the capital gains.

    2.5 The learned counsel also relied on the decision of Hon’ble Cochin Bench of the ITAT in the case of Mrs. Sosamma Paulose v. Jt. CIT [2003] 79 TTJ 5721., in which it was inter alia held that in absence of any cogent evidence in possession of the Assessing Officer, value determined by the registered valuer cannot be disturbed or questioned.

    2.6. As against the aforesaid, the learned DR relied on the orders of the Authorities below.

    3.1 We have considered the facts of the case and the submissions made before us. The facts of the case are that in the previous year, the assessee sold a part of land, which was earlier converted into stock-in-trade. The assessee opted to substitute the market value of the property on 1-4-1981 in place of its cost of acquisition. For this purpose, a report from the registered valuer was filed, in which the value was worked out at Rs. 27 per sq.ft. The Assessing Officer rejected this report without assigning any reason as to why this value was not acceptable. But, he relied on the value shown by the assessee in the wealth-tax return for assessment year 1981-82. The learned CIT(A) neither accepted the value of the Assessing Officer nor the value of the registered valuer but he placed the value at Rs. 2.10 lakhs, being the value assessed for W.T. purpose by the Assessing Officer. The assessee relied on the decision of Hon’ble ITAT, Cochin Bench, in the case of Mrs. Sosamma Paulose (supra), in which it was inter alia held that the report of a registered valuer cannot be completely ignored in absence of substantive evidence to the contrary in the possession of the Assessing Officer. No evidence has been cited by the Assessing Officer or the learned CIT(A) as to why the aforesaid report was not correct. Therefore, we are of the view that the learned CIT(A) erred in ignoring the report completely. The learned counsel also relied on the decision of Hon’ble ITAT, Madras Bench "A" in the case of Dr. Louis Prakasam Kannaiya (supra), in which the valuation of jewellery made by the Hon’ble Tribunal was not accepted for the purpose of valuation under the Income-tax Act. However, the reasons for non-acceptance were peculiar to the facts of the case, namely, that even the previous owner had not taken the possession of the property, the property was in the possession of the court and, therefore, a discount of 60 per cent was given for lack of possession. It was not a case where there were certain encumbrances were attached to the property. The ratio of the case was not that the property has to be considered as it was on the date of sale. On the other hand, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of Shekhawati General Traders Ltd. v. ITO [1971] 82 ITR 788, held that the issue of bonus shares, subsequent to 1-1-1954 was wholly extraneous and irrelevant and could not be taken into consideration, for the purpose of computation of capital gains. Thus, the ratio of the case was that the property has to be considered as it was on 1-1-1954 in that case and consequently 1-4-1981 in this case. The ratio of this decision, was followed by the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Lady Hirabai C. Jehangir. [1990] 186 ITR 60. In that case, the Tribunal had found as a matter of fact that the transactions in shares in 1958 did not alter the continuity or identity of the shares and, therefore, the value has to be taken on 1-1-1954 as the shares existed at that point of time. A question similar to the one in the case of the assessee also came up before the Hon’ble Madras High Court in the case of Meccane Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax [2002] 254 ITR 1751 .. The Hon’ble Court held that the fact that lands were sold at much higher value did not alter in any way the cost of acquisition, which remained constant. The fact that by the time the assessee sold them, they were to be put to use for non-agricultural purposes did not involve any additional cost being incurred by the assessee. What was to be ascertained was the real profits earned by the assessee, which had to be brought to tax as capital gains. The real extent of gain was obviously the difference between the price at which the assessee sold the property and the price which the assessee paid for acquiring the property. The actual cost of acquisition of agricultural land is material and not the notional cost on that date, on the basis that the lands were to put to non-agricultural use. The ratio of this case is completely contrary to the arguments made by the learned counsel that the property should be valued as if it was free from any encumbrance as on the date of conversion into stock-in-trade or on the date of sale, it was free from encumbrance of ULCA. The question regarding valuation of an immovable property, subject to statutory restrictions, was also discussed by the Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in the case of CWT v. Raj Kumari Bhuvaneshwari [1995] 215 ITR 198. The court pointed out that the Rajasthan Urban Property (Restriction on Transfer) Act, 1973, had placed restrictions on the right of the owner to transfer property and, therefore, its valuation was affected. However, it was not restricted to Rs. 3 lakhs alone. The learned court referred to the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Commissioner Of Wealth Tax, Patna v. Raghubar Narain Singh [1984] 146 ITR 2282., in which it was held that if an asset is subject to certain hazards including the liability of certain debt to be deducted from the asset, then, that factor which has the effect of diminishing the market value of the asset is a relevant factor to be taken into account while estimating its value in the open market. The Tribunal had not done that and, therefore, the matter was remitted to the Tribunal for deciding the matter afresh. We are of the view that the ratio of that decision, though given under the Wealth-tax Act, is fully applicable to the facts of this case.

    3.2 Coming to the facts of the case, the assessee had filed valuation report and we have already held that this report ought to have been taken into account for determining the value on 1-4-1981. The report valued the property at Rs. 27 per sq.ft. on the footing that it was free from ULCA on 1-4-1981 also. Thus, this value is not in accordance with the decision of Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in the case of Raj Kumari Bhuvaneshwari (supra) or the decision of Apex Court in the case of Raghubar Narain Singh (supra). The registered valuer ought to have taken into account the impact of the restrictions on the property arising on account of applicability of ULCA. The effects of the ULCA were that the assessee was not free to sell the property, it could have been acquired by the competent authority or its use could have been allowed as per scheme sanctioned under section 21 of that Act. In other words, the ownership and possession of the assessee were not in any way affected but its use was affected; and it could have also been acquired by payment of a sum of about Rs. 2,10,000. However, the acquisition under the ULCA was not inevitable in the sense that that was the only consequence in respect of lands covered under the ULCA. There was an alternative to get the scheme approved under section 21 and put the land to use as per the scheme sanctioned. Thus, there were drastic restrictions on user without affecting the ownership and possession on 1-4-1981. In the case of Dr. Louis Prakasam Kannaiya (supra), the assessee was deprived of the possession and consequently the user of the jewellery. In such a circumstance, the Hon’ble Tribunal, in the wealth-tax proceedings, granted reduction of 60 per cent from the fair market value of the property. In the instant case, while the assessee was in possession of the property, its user was drastically curtailed and consequently possessory right was also affected. Looking to these peculiar facts, we are of the view that interest of justice will be served, as per the decision of Hon’ble Rajasthan High Court in the case of Raj Kumari Bhuvaneshwari (supra), if the value determined registered valuer is discounted by 50 per cent only. Thus, we are of the view that the fair market value of the property on 1-4-1981 should be taken at Rs. 13.50 paise per sq.ft.

    4. In result, the appeal of the assessee is partly allowed as discussed above and the capital gains shall be computed accordingly.

    114/122

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ajit J. Mehta v. Joint Commissioner of Income-tax, SR-2
    (Feb 24, 2006)