AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion addresses a petition filed under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 challenging the Arbitral Award dated 11.06.2018 and the Additional Award dated 08.10.2018 arising from disputes related to three contracts executed on 21.08.2012 between SKS Power Generation (Chhattisgarh) Ltd (Petitioner) and ISC Projects Private Limited (Respondent). The petitioner initially filed the petition on 14.01.2019, but it was deficient in several respects including absence of affidavit, vakalatnama, signatures, pagination, and annexures of the awards. The petition was returned on objections and refiled on 26.03.2019 after a delay of 33 days beyond the prescribed limitation period. Subsequent objections led to further refiling on 28.03.2019 when the matter was finally registered for listing. The petitioner sought condonation of delay in refiling, which is the subject matter of this order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the original petition filed on 14.01.2019, despite procedural defects, can be considered a valid filing to stop the limitation period under Section 34(3) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
  2. Whether the delay of 33 days in refiling the petition beyond the limitation period can be condoned by the Court.
  3. The extent to which procedural defects such as absence of affidavit, vakalatnama, signatures, and annexure of awards affect the validity of a petition under Section 34 of the Act.
  4. The applicable standard of diligence required from the petitioner when seeking condonation of delay in refiling arbitration challenge petitions.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The limitation period under Section 34(3) of the Act commenced only from 22.10.2018, the date the petitioner received the copy of the Additional Award.
  • The petition originally filed on 14.01.2019 was within the limitation period despite procedural defects such as absence of affidavit, vakalatnama, signatures, and annexures.
  • Procedural defects are curable and should not invalidate the original filing, relying on Supreme Court and Delhi High Court precedents.
  • Under the Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 2018, it is not mandatory to file the Impugned Award along with the petition.
  • The delay in refiling beyond the limitation period should be liberally construed in favor of the petitioner, relying on the Supreme Court judgment in Northern Railway v. Pioneer Publicity Corporation Pvt. Ltd.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The petition filed on 14.01.2019 cannot be treated as a valid petition but only a "bunch of papers" lacking essential documents and authorizations.
  • The petitioner’s delay of over two months in curing defects and refiling the petition beyond the limitation period is not excusable.
  • The Court should not apply a liberal test for condonation of delay given the inadequate nature of the original filing.
  • Reliance on various judgments of this Court and Delhi Development Authority v. Durga Construction Co. to support the strict approach towards delay and procedural deficiencies.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Uday Shankar Triyar v. Ram Kalewar Prasad Singh and Anr, (2006) 1 SCC 75 Procedural defects such as absence of vakalatnama or signature do not invalidate appeal if not deliberate or mischievous. Rejected by the Court as in the present case the defects were deliberate to stop limitation and thus not applicable.
Alka Kasana v. Indian Institute of Technology, 2015 SCC OnLine Del 11455 Procedural defects may be cured later and should not affect original filing validity. Distinguished since petitioner here made no effort to cure defects promptly.
Northern Railway v. Pioneer Publicity Corporation Pvt. Ltd., (2017) 11 SCC 234 Delay in refiling petitions should be liberally construed for condonation. Not accepted by the Court for delay beyond limitation period with inadequate original filing.
Sravanthi Infratech Pvt. Ltd. v. Greens Power Equipment (China) Co. Ltd., OMP 470/2015 Filing without documents, vakalatnama, affidavit or authority renders petition inadequate. Applied by the Court to hold original petition as non est and of no consequence.
Delhi Development Authority v. Durga Construction Co., 2013(139) DRJ 133 (DB) Petitions fundamentally defective are to be treated as non est; condonation of delay requires due diligence. Followed as binding precedent to reject condonation of delay due to petitioner’s lack of diligence.
Delhi Transco Ltd. & Anr. v. Hythro Engineers Pvt. Ltd., FAO(OS) 295/2012 Strict approach to delay condonation in arbitration petitions with fundamental defects. Relied upon to support rejection of liberal condonation where original filing was defective.
India Tourism Development Corporation v. CP Associates Pvt. Ltd. & Ors., MANU/DE/0959/2019 Emphasizes importance of due diligence in refiling petitions beyond limitation period. Invoked to underscore petitioner’s failure to act diligently.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the nature and timing of the original filing on 14.01.2019 and found it to be fundamentally defective: it lacked signatures, vakalatnama, affidavit, and did not annex the impugned awards. The Court characterized the original filing as merely a "bunch of papers" intended to halt the running of the limitation period. The petitioner failed to take prompt steps to cure these defects after the petition was returned on 15.01.2019, instead delaying refiling until 26.03.2019, which was beyond the permissible limitation period.

The Court relied on established precedents holding that petitions with fundamental defects are to be treated as non est, meaning they have no legal effect. It further emphasized that while courts may have jurisdiction to condone delay in refiling beyond the statutory period, such condonation is not to be granted liberally and must be based on due diligence and promptness by the applicant. The petitioner’s conduct was found lacking in these respects.

The petitioner’s explanation for delay—that the arbitral records were bulky—was deemed frivolous and insufficient. The Court rejected the petitioner’s reliance on precedents that allow curing of procedural defects, distinguishing the present case on the ground that the defects were deliberate and aimed at stopping limitation, rather than inadvertent omissions.

Consequently, the Court dismissed the application for condonation of delay, holding that the original filing could not be considered valid and the delay in refiling was unjustified.

Holding and Implications

The Court’s final decision is DISMISSAL of the application seeking condonation of delay in refiling the petition under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The petition challenging the arbitral awards and all pending applications stand dismissed with no order as to costs.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioner’s challenge to the arbitral awards is barred by limitation and cannot be entertained. The Court did not set any new precedent but applied existing principles strictly to emphasize that procedural defects that are fundamental and deliberate cannot be treated as valid filings for limitation purposes, and that delay in refiling must be accompanied by due diligence.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sks Power Generation (Chhattisgarh) Ltd . v. Isc Projects Private Limited .

    $~35 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

    + O.M.P. (COMM) 132/2019

    rd Date of Decision : 3 April, 2019

    SKS POWER GENERATION (CHHATTISGARH) LTD

    ..... Petitioner

    Through: Mr.Amit Sibal, Sr.Adv. with Mr.Atul Shanker Mathur,

    Ms.Priya Singh, Ms.Deepabali Datta, Mr.Aishwary Vikram

    and Mr.Soham Kumar, Advs.

    versus

    ISC PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED ..... Respondent Through: Mr.Sameer Parekh, Ms.Smita Bhargava, Ms.Aishwarya Dash

    and Mr.Sarthak Gaur, Advs.

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA

    NAVIN CHAWLA, J. (Oral) IA 4684/2019(delay of 33 days in re-filing the petition)

    1. This petition under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as the „Act") has been filed by the petitioner challenging the Arbitral Award dated 11.06.2018 and the Additional Award dated 08.10.2018 passed by the Arbitral Tribunal adjudicating the disputes that had arisen between the parties in relation to three contracts, namely Services, Supply and

    1

    Coordination Agreement, all executed on 21.08.2012, between the parties.

    2. It is asserted by the petitioner that the petitioner received the copy of the Additional Award from the Arbitral Tribunal only on 22.10.2018 and therefore, the period of limitation under Section 34(3) of the Act would commence only from that date.

    3. The petition was original filed by the petitioner on 14.01.2019. The petition as filed contained only 29 pages without book marking, without complete pagination and more importantly without any affidavit, vakalatnama or documents. The petition did not even contain the copy of the Impugned Award and/or the Additional Award.

    4. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has handed across the so called petition that was filed by the petitioner on 14.01.2019. It does not contain the signature of the petitioner or its authorized representative. Infact, in paragraph 3 of the petition, the name of the authorized representative of the petitioner company has been left blank. There is also a blank left in prayer „b" of the so called petition.

    5. The petition was returned back under objection on 15.01.2019. The same was refiled on 26.03.2019, that is beyond the period of 30 days from the expiry of three months from even the date of receipt of the Impugned Additional Award.

    6. Certain objections were again pointed out by the Registry of this Court and the petition was returned on 27.03.2019. It was

    2

    thereafter refiled on 28.03.2019 when it was finally registered for listing.

    7. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that under the Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 2018 it is not essential for the petition under Section 34 of the Act to be accompanied by the Impugned Award. He also refers to Section 8(2) of the Act to contend that where the legislature intended filing of certain documents to be compulsory, it has provided for the same in the Act itself.

    8. As far as non filing of the affidavit, authorization on behalf of the petitioner to file the petition, as also the vakalatnama is concerned, learned senior counsel for the petitioner, relying upon the judgments of the Supreme Court in Uday Shankar Triyar v. Ram Kalewar Prasad Singh and Anr. (2006) 1 SCC 75 and of this Court in Alka Kasana v. Indian Institute of Technology, 2015 SCC OnLine Del 11455, submits that these defects being procedural in nature, could be cured at a later stage and therefore, shall have no effect as far as the original filing of the petition is concerned. He submits that therefore, the original filing of the petition being 14.01.2019, is within the time prescribed under Section 34(3) of the Act and the delay is only in re- filing of the petition.

    9. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner further relies upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in Northern Railway v. Pioneer Publicity Corporation Private Limited ., (2017) 11 SCC 234 to contend that for purposes of considering the condonation of delay in refiling of the petition, Section 34(3) of the Act shall have no application. The

    3

    reason for such delay has to be liberally construed and benefit granted to the petitioner.

    10. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent submits that the petition as filed on 14.01.2019 cannot be considered as a petition in the eyes of law. It was merely a bunch of papers filed in the name of a petition. He further submits that even if the same is to be considered as a petition, the petitioner having taken more than two months thereafter to cure the defects, while considering an application for condoning the delay in refiling, this Court must take into account the nature of the petition as originally filed and cannot apply the same liberal test as is usually applied to such an application. He placed reliance on the judgment dated 19.10.2016 passed by this Court in OMP 470/2015, Sravanthi Infratech Pvt. Ltd. v. Greens Power Equipment (China) Co. Ltd.; Delhi Development Authority v. Durga Construction Co., 2013(139) DRJ 133 (DB); judgment dated 11.07.2012 in FAO(OS) 295/2012, Delhi Transco Ltd. & Anr. v. Hythro Engineers Pvt. Ltd.; and India Tourism Development Corporation v. CP Associates Pvt. Ltd. & Ors., MANU/DE/0959/2019.

    11. I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsels for the parties. It is not contested by the petitioner that the original petition filed on 14.01.2019 contained only 29 pages with blanks and with no signature of the petitioner or its authorized representative. There was no vakalanama filed authorizing the advocate to file the said bunch of papers. I am intentionally using the words "bunch of

    4

    papers" as what was filed was nothing more than that. The petition sought to impugn the Arbitral Award and the Additional Award without even annexing the same. Clearly what was filed was merely a „bunch of papers" to somehow stop the period of limitation from running. The petitioner thereafter made no endeavour to refile the petition with expedition once the same had been returned back under objection on 15.01.2019. The petitioner took another two months to refile the petition only on 26.03.2019, albeit, still under defects. This filing was beyond a period of 30 days from three months of receipt of the Additional Award by the petitioner.

    12. In my view, while considering the application seeking condonation of delay in refilling, the above is a very relevant criteria and consideration to be kept in mind. As held by this Court in Durga Construction Co. (supra), where the petitions or applications filed by a party are so hopelessly inadequate and insufficient or contain defects which are fundamental to the institution of the proceedings, then in such cases the filing done by the party would be considered non est and of no consequence. This was reiterated by this Court in Sravanthi Infratech Pvt. Ltd. (supra), where the petition had been filed without documents, vakalatnama, affidavit or authority.

    13. In Durga Construction Co. (supra), this Court further held that while the Courts would have jurisdiction to condone the delay in refiling of the petition, once such delay is beyond the maximum period provided under Section 34(3) of the Act, the approach of the Court exercising such jurisdiction cannot be liberal and the conduct of the

    5

    applicant will have to be tested on the anvil of whether the applicant acted with due diligence and dispatch. From the above narration of the facts, it can easily be concluded that the petitioner did not act with due diligence or dispatch.

    14. Infact, in the application filed by the petitioner seeking condonation of delay in such re-filing, there is absolutely no explanation given as to how the original petition filed on 14.01.2019 did not bear the signature of the petitioner and didn"t contain a vakalatnama or the affidavit or the authorization of the petitioner to file such petition or the Impugned Award or the Impugned Additional Award. The only explanation, if at all it could be called one, is reproduced hereinunder:-

    "4. That pursuant to the filing of the petition on 14 January 2019 the Registry, Delhi High Court raised objections and directed the petitioner to file the entire arbitral records along- with the aforementioned petition. It is humbly submitted that the entire arbitral records are bulky and it required the Petitioner some time to file it. That the inadvertent delay to file the entire arbitral records was due to the records being bulky."

    15. The so called explanation is completely frivolous and bereft of particulars.

    16. The reliance of the learned senior counsel for the petitioner on the Judgment of the Supreme Court in Uday Shankar (Supra) is ill founded. In the said case it has been held that defect in signing the memorandum of appeal or any defect in the authority of the person signing the memorandum of appeal or the omission to file the

    6

    vakalatnama executed by the appellant alongwith the appeal, will not invalidate the memorandum of appeal, if such omission or defect is not "deliberate" or "mischievous". In the present case, the non filing was clearly deliberate and mischievous as it was intended only to stop the period of limitation from running and thereafter the petitioner took no steps to have the petition re-filed expeditiously.

    17. In Alka kasana (Supra) the petitioner therein had given justification for non-filing of the affidavit alongwith the petition. As noted above, in the present case the petitioner has not even made such an endeavour.

    18. In view of the above finding, no reason is found to condone the delay in re-filing of the present petition. The application is dismissed.

    OMP(Comm.) 132/2019 & IA 4682/2019

    In view of the above order, the petition and the pending applications also stand dismissed. There shall be no order as to cost.

    NAVIN CHAWLA, J

    APRIL 03, 2019/Arya

    7

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sks Power Generation (Chhattisgarh) Ltd . v. Isc Projects Private Limited .
    (Apr 3, 2019)