Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule 31 of the Code,
  • Section 96 of the Code. 15.
  • rules, Rule 31
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule 31 of the Code,
  • Section 96 of the Code. 15.
  • rules, Rule 31
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

A suit was instituted on 30.10.2010. The trial Court dismissed the suit. The plaintiff appealed to the learned First Appellate Court (first appeal under Section 96 CPC), which delivered a judgment and decree. The present court examined a further appeal against the judgment and decree passed by the First Appellate Court and found that the First Appellate Court had not decided the case in accordance with the law. The present court set aside the judgment and decree of the First Appellate Court and remanded the matter to that court for fresh disposal. The parties were directed to appear before the First Appellate Court on 06.05.2019, and the First Appellate Court was requested to decide the matter by 30.09.2019. The appeal (before the present court) was disposed of in the stated terms.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the learned First Appellate Court complied with its duty as a court of first appeal to appreciate the entire evidence, address all issues and record findings supported by reasons as required under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure and Order XLI Rule 31 CPC.
  2. Whether a first appellate court, in reversing findings of fact, must engage closely with the reasoning of the trial court and record its own reasons for reaching a different conclusion.
  3. Whether the impugned judgment and decree of the First Appellate Court should be set aside and the matter remanded for fresh disposal because the First Appellate Court's judgment was cryptic and failed to consider relevant aspects and the trial court's findings and reasons.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shasidhar and others vs. Smt. Ashwini Uma Mathad and another, 2015 AIR SCW 777 Referred to for the scope, ambit and power of the First Appellate Court while deciding a first appeal. The court cited this pronouncement as part of the body of authority defining the wide jurisdiction of the first appellate court to reappreciate evidence and the expectations from appellate judgments.
Kurian Chacko vs. Varkey Ouseph, AIR 1969 Kerala 316 Reminds that an appellate court is ordinarily the final court of fact and a litigant is entitled to full, fair and independent consideration of evidence at the appellate stage; an appellate court must not dispose of matters glibly without adequate reasons. The court relied on this decision to emphasise the duty of the first appellate court to give independent consideration to evidence and to provide reasoned findings.
Santosh Hazari vs. Purushottam Tiwari (Deceased) by L.Rs., (2001) 3 SCC 179 The appellate court has jurisdiction to reverse or affirm findings of the trial court; first appeal is a valuable right and the appellate judgment must reflect conscious application of mind and record reasons on all issues. Used to reiterate that the first appellate court must state points for determination and reasons, and must come into close quarters with the trial court's reasoning when reversing findings.
Madhukar & Ors. v. Sangram & Ors., (2001) 4 SCC 756 Reiterates the duty of a High Court sitting as a court of first appeal to deal with all issues and the evidence before recording its findings. The court cited it to reinforce the principle that a first appellate court must address all issues and evidence before reaching conclusions.
H.K.N Swami v. Irshad Basith (Dead) By Lrs., (2005) 10 SCC 243 The first appeal must be decided on facts as well as on law; the first appellate court is required to address all issues and decide the case by giving reasons. Cited to stress that failure to record findings on facts or law is a dereliction of obligation by a first appellate court.
Jagannath v. Arulappa & Anr., (2005) 12 SCC 303 A court of first appeal can reappreciate the entire evidence and come to a different conclusion. Relied upon to support the proposition that the appellate court's jurisdiction is wide and it may arrive at conclusions different from the trial court after reappreciation of evidence.
B.V. Nagesh & Anr. vs. H.V. Sreenivasa Murthy, (2010) 13 SCC 530 Order 41 CPC and Rule 31: the judgment of the appellate court shall state points for determination, decision thereon, reasons for decision, and where the decree is reversed or varied, the relief to which the appellant is entitled; appellate court must reflect conscious application of mind. Used to emphasise the formal requirements of appellate judgments and to show the standard against which the impugned judgment was examined.
State Bank of India & Anr. vs. Emmsons International Ltd. & Anr., (2011) 12 SCC 174 Reiterated the established principle regarding the duty and scope of the first appellate court. Cited as an instance where the Court reiterated the same principles relied upon in the present opinion.
Vinod Kumar vs. Gangadhar, 2014 (12) Scale 171 Recognised as a recent decision taking the same view on similar facts. Referred to as further support for the proposition that the first appellate court must properly examine and record reasons on issues and evidence.
Union of India vs. K.V. Lakshman and others, 2016 AIR SC 3139 Listed as a subsequent judgment reiterating the same principles regarding the duty of the first appellate court. Relied upon to show continuity of judicial approach on the obligations of a first appellate court.
Laliteshwar Prasad Singh & Ors. vs. S.P. Srivastava (deceased) through LRs, 2017 (2) SCC 415 Another subsequent decision cited as reiterating the principles concerning the first appellate court's duty to record reasons and address issues and evidence. Cited to demonstrate consistent reaffirmation of the legal standards expected of the first appellate court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in a sequence grounded on established principles about the nature and duty of the first appellate court:

  • The court began by stating the settled principle that the right to file a first appeal under Section 96 CPC is a valuable legal right, and that the jurisdiction of the First Appellate Court is wide—similar to the trial court—permitting reappreciation of evidence on both facts and law.
  • The court reviewed a number of authoritative decisions (both High Court and Supreme Court precedents) which consistently require that a first appellate court: (a) appreciate the entire evidence; (b) address all issues raised by the parties; (c) record findings supported by reasons; and (d) where reversing a trial court's finding, engage closely with the trial court's reasoning and provide its own reasons for arriving at a different conclusion (including Order XLI Rule 31 CPC requirements).
  • Having set out these legal benchmarks, the court examined the impugned judgment of the learned First Appellate Court and concluded that the First Appellate Court did not advert to the findings and reasons recorded by the learned trial court. Instead, the First Appellate Court wrote a separate judgment without taking into consideration the facts and circumstances that prevailed upon the trial court to dismiss the suit.
  • The court characterized the impugned judgment as cryptic and stated that none of the relevant aspects had been noticed; it fell short of the standards expected of a court of first appeal.
  • On that basis, and without deciding the substantive merits of the underlying claim of either party, the court concluded that the appropriate remedial course was to set aside the impugned judgment and decree and to remand the regular first appeal to the First Appellate Court for fresh disposal in accordance with law.
  • The court then gave consequential directions: parties to appear before the First Appellate Court on 06.05.2019 and the First Appellate Court was requested to decide the matter expeditiously and in any event by 30.09.2019; the appeal before the present court was disposed of in these terms along with any pending applications.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court's core ruling was to set aside the judgment and decree of the learned First Appellate Court and remand the matter to the First Appellate Court for fresh disposal.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The impugned judgment and decree of the First Appellate Court cannot be sustained; the appeal before the present court is disposed of by setting aside that judgment and remanding the first appeal to the First Appellate Court for a fresh adjudication in accordance with law.
  • Procedure and timeline: Parties were directed to appear before the First Appellate Court on 06.05.2019. Because the suit was instituted on 30.10.2010, the First Appellate Court was requested to decide the matter by 30.09.2019.
  • Pending applications: The opinion disposes of the appeal and, in the same terms, also disposes of any pending applications (if any) before the present court.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion relies upon and reiterates established Supreme Court jurisprudence concerning the duties of a first appellate court rather than announcing a new principle. The opinion discusses no broader novel principle beyond applying existing authorities to the facts at hand.

Date and signature as recorded in the provided opinion: 26th April, 2019 — (Tarlok Singh Chauhan) (krt) Judge.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sunder Singh v. Roop Singh

    rt o first appellate Court has not at all decided the case as is required under the law.

    3. It is settled principle of law that right to file first appeal against the decree under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure is a valuable legal right of the litigant. The jurisdiction of the First Appellate Court while hearing the First appeal is very wide like that of learned trial Court and it is open to the appellant to attack all findings of fact or/and of law in the first appeal. It is duty of the first appellate Court to appreciate the entire evidence and may come to a different conclusion from that of the trial Court. While doing so, the j dgment of the Appellate Court must reflect its conscious application of mind and record findings supported by reasons, on all issues arising along with the contentions put forth, and pressed by the parties for decision of the Appellate Court. While reversing a finding of fact, the Appellate Court must come into close quarters with the reasoning assigned by the trial Court and then assigned its own reasons for arriving at a different finding. This would satisfy the court hearing a further appeal that the First Appellate Court had discharged the duty expected of it.

    4. The scope, ambit and power of the first Appellate Court while deciding the first appeal have been the subject matter of various judicial pronouncements and I may refer to the rt o pronouncement of the Honble Supreme Court in Shasidhar and others vs. Smt. Ashwini Uma Mathad and another 2015 AIR SCW 777 wherein it was held as follows:

    11. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the record of the case and examining the issue arising in this appeal, we find force in the submissions of the learned counsel for the appellants.

    12. The powers of the first appellate Court, while deciding the first appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule

    31 of the Code, are indeed well defined by various judicial pronouncements of this Court and are, therefore, no more res integra.

    13. As far back in 1969, the learned Judge V.R. Krishna Iyer, J (as His Lordship then was the judge of Kerala High Court) while deciding the first appeal under Section 96 of the CPC in Kurian Chacko vs. Varkey Ouseph, AIR 1969 Kerala 316, reminded the first appellate Court of its duty as to how the first appeal under Section 96 should be decided. In his distinctive style of writing and subtle power of expression, the learned judge held as under:

    1. The plaintiff, unsuccessful in two Courts, has come up here aggrieved by the dismissal of his suit which was one for declaration of title and recovery of possession. The defendant disputed the plaintiff's title to the property as also his possession and claimed both in himself. The learned Munsif, who tried the suit, recorded findings against the plaintiff both on title and possession. But, in appeal, the learned Subordinate Judge disposed of the whole matter glibly and briefly, in a few sentences.

    2. An appellate court is the final Court of fact ordinarily and therefore a litigant is entitled to a full and fair and independent consideration of the evidence at the appellate stage. Anything less than this is unjust to him and I have no doubt that in the present case the learned Subordinate Judge has fallen far short of what is expected of him as an appellate Court. Although there is furious contest between the counsel for the rt o appellant and for the respondent, they appear to agree with me in this observation..... (Emphasis supplied)

    14. This Court in a number of cases while affirming and then reiterating the aforesaid principle has laid down the scope and powers of the first appellate Court under Section 96 of the Code.

    15. We consider it apposite to refer to some of the decisions.

    16. In Santosh Hazari vs Purushottam Tiwari (Deceased) by L.Rs . (2001) 3 SCC 179, this Court held (at pages 188- 189) as under: .........the appellate court has jurisdiction to reverse or affirm the findings of the trial court. First appeal is a valuable right of the parties and unless restricted by law, the whole case is therein open for rehearing both on questions of fact and law. The judgment of the appellate court must, therefore, reflect its conscious application of mind and record findings supported by reasons, on all the issues arising along with the contentions put forth, andpressed by the parties for decision of the appellate court......while reversing a finding of fact the appellate court must come into close quarters with the reasoning assigned by the trial court ... and then as sign its own reasons for arriving at a different finding. This would satisfy the court hearing a further appeal that the first appellate court had discharged the duty expected of it............

    17. The above view has been followed by a three-Judge Bench decision of this Court in Madhukar & Ors.v. Sangram & Ors. ,(2001) 4 SCC 756, wherein it was reiterated that sitting as a court of first appeal, it is the duty of the High Court to deal with all the issues and the evidence led by the parties before recording its findings.

    18. In H.K.N Swami v. Irshad Basith (Dead) By Lrs. . Basith ,(2005) 10 SCC 243, this Court (at p. 244) stated as under:

    3. The first appeal has to be decided on facts as well as on law. In the first appeal parties have the right to be heard both on questions of law as also on facts and the rt o first appellate court is required to address itself to all issues and decide the case by giving reasons. Unfortunately, the High Court, in the present case has not recorded any finding either on facts or on law. Sitting as the first appellate court it was the duty of the High Court to deal with all the issues and the evidence led by the parties before recording the finding regarding title.

    19. Again in Jagannath v. Arulappa & Anr. (2005) 12 SCC 303, while considering the scope of Section 96 of the Code this Court (at pp. 303 -04) observed as follows: 2.A court of first appeal can reappreciate the entire evidence and come to a different conclusion.........

    20. Again in B.V Nagesh & Anr. vs. H.V.Sreenivasa Murthy, (2010) 13 SCC 530, this Court taking note of all the earlier judgments of this Court reiterated the aforementioned principle with these words:

    3. How the regular first appeal is to be disposed of by the appellate court/High Court has been considered by this Court in various decisions. Order 41 CPC deals with appeals from original decrees. Among the various rules, Rule 31 mandates that the judgment of the appellate court shall state: (a) the points for determination; (b) the decision thereon; (c) the reasons for the decision; and (d) where the decree appealed from is reversed or varied, the relief to which the appellant is entitled.

    4. The appellate court has jurisdiction to reverse or affirm the findings of the trial court. The first appeal is a valuable right of the parties and unless restricted by law, the whole case is therein open for rehearing both on questions of fact and law. The judgment of the appellate court must, ... therefore, reflect its conscious application of mind and record findings supported by reasons, on all the issues arising along with the contentions putforth, and pressed by the parties for decision of the appellate court. Sitting as a court of first appeal, it was the duty of the High Court to deal with all the issues and the evidence led by the parties before recording its findings. The first appeal is a valuable right and the parties have a right to be heard both on questions of law and on facts and the judgment in the first appeal must address itself to all the issues of law and fact and decide it by giving reasons in support of the findings. (Vide Santosh Hazari v.Purushottam Tiwari , (2001) 3 SCC 179 at p. 188, para 15 and rt o Madhukar v.Sangram , (2001) 4 SCC 756 at p. 758, para

    5. In view of the above salutary principles, on going through the impugned judgment, we feel that the High Court has failed to discharge the obligation placed on it as a first appellate court. In our view, the judgment under appeal is cryptic and none of the relevant aspects have even been noticed. The appeal has been decided in an unsatisfactory manner. Our careful perusal of the judgment in the regular first appeal shows that it falls short of considerations which are expected from the court of first appeal. Accordingly, without going into the merits of the claim of both parties, we set aside the impugned judgment and decree of the High Court and remand the regular first appeal to the High Court for its fresh disposal in accordance with law.

    21. The aforementioned cases were relied upon by this Court while reiterating the same principle in State Bank of India & Anr. vs. Emmsons International Ltd. & Anr.(2011)

    12 SCC 174. This Court has recently taken the same view on similar facts arising in Vinod Kumar vs. Gangadhar, 2014(12) Scale 171.

    5. Similar reiteration of law can be found in the subsequent judgments of the Honble Supreme Court in Union of India vs. K.V. Lakshman and others , 2016 AIR SC 3139 and in Laliteshwar Prasad Singh & Ors. vs. S.P. Srivastava (deceased) through LRs , 2017 (2) SCC 415.

    6. Adverting to the facts of the case, it would be noticed that the learned first Appellate Court had not at all adverted to the findings and reasons recorded by the learned Court below and has, in fact, simply chosen to write a separate judgment, that too, without taking into consideration any of the facts and rt o circumstances that prevailed upon the learned trial court to dismiss the suit.

    7. In view of the aforesaid exposition of law, the judgment and decree passed by the learned First Appellate Court cannot be countenanced and sustained and, therefore, this Court has no option, but to set aside the judgment and decree so passed by it and remand the matter for decision afresh. Ordered accordingly.

    8. Parties, through their learned counsel, are directed to appear before the learned first Appellate Court on 06.05.2019.

    9. Since the suit was instituted more than eight years back i.e. on 30.10.2010, the learned first Appellate Court is requested to decide the same as expeditiously as possible, in no event later than 30.09.2019.

    10. The appeal is disposed of in the aforesaid terms, so also the pending applications, if any. 26th April, 2019 (Tarlok Singh Chauhan) (krt) Judge

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sunder Singh v. Roop Singh
    (Apr 26, 2019)