Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 364
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2-A of the 1956 Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Constitution of India, Art. 226
  • Article 226, Constitution of India
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 364
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2-A of the 1956 Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Constitution of India, Art. 226
  • Article 226, Constitution of India
Smart Summary

Facts

The appellants appealed the judgment of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh in Writ Petition No.1495 of 2004. The Division Bench upheld the order of the Single Judge, which declined to interfere with the order of the District Collector in refusing to grant ryotwari patta in favour of the appellants. The appellants claimed that their predecessor-in-interest obtained a saswatha patta dated 31.12.1940 from Sri Hathiramjee Math for dry land admeasuring 6.00 acres T.D. No.464 and predecessors of the appellants and the appellants have been in possession ever since. Appellant Sri Sarvepalli Ramaiah filed Writ Petition No.2759 of 1990 before the High Court seeking direction to the Tahsildar, Tirupati Rural for implementation of the patta granted to him by the Deputy Tahsildar vide order dated 29.09.1980 by making entries in the revenue.

Issues

  1. Whether the District Collector was correct in refusing to grant ryotwari patta to the appellants?
  2. Whether the land in question was classified as "Peddacheruvu Tank" and therefore could not be transferred?
  3. Whether the appellants had challenged the Gazette Notification dated 03.09.1984?

Decision

The Division Bench affirmed the order of the learned Single Judge that the land is classified as "Peddacheruvu Tank" which vests in the government and in view of the bar contained in Section 2-A of the Inams Abolition Act and the same cannot be transferred. The High Court held that the ban contained in Section 2-A of the Inams Abolition Act meant that the tank bed lands cannot be alienated or assigned. The appeal was dismissed.

Reasoning

The Court held that the District Collector was correct in refusing to grant ryotwari patta to the appellants as the entire extent of land in Survey No.234 was classified as Tank and no extent was available for grant of ryotwari patta under the provisions of Inams Abolition Act. The Court also held that the land in S.No. 234 of Tiruchanur was declared as Tank poramboke and was brought u/s 2-A of the LA Act, 1956 and such communal lands are not available for grant of ryotwari patta. The Court further held that the decision of the Collector was based on materials and thus not liable to be interfered with. The High Court did not sit in appeal over the decision impugned, nor did it adjudicate hotly disputed questions of fact. The Court also held that it was well settled that poramboke (tank) cannot be alienated and land comprised in water bodies cannot be alienated to any person even if it is dry.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sarvepalli Ramaiah v. District Collector, Chittoor

    Per R. Banumathi, J.

    The District Collector had referred to the Gazette Notification as per which the entire area in question was classified as “Peddacheruvu Tank” and held that no extent of land was available for issuance of ryotwari patta. As pointed out by the High Court, even though, in his order the District Collector has referred to the Gazette Notification, the appellants have not challenged the same. The Division Bench of the High Court also referred to the conduct of the appellants as to how they have withheld the crucial part of the Gazette Notification which contains the classification of the land as “Peddacheruvu — Tank Poramboke”. Upon consideration of the materials, the High Court rightly declined to quash the order of the District Collector. There is no infirmity in the impugned order warranting interference.
    (Para 16)

    Per Indira Banerjee, J. (concurring)

    In exercise of power under Article 226, the Court does not sit in appeal over the decision impugned, nor does it adjudicate hotly disputed questions of fact. The decision of the Collector was based on materials and thus not liable to be interfered with. The High Court very rightly did not interfere with the decision. It was not for the High Court, exercising its extraordinary power of judicial review, to re-analyse the evidence on record and adjudicate the disputed question of whether Saswatha Patta had at all been granted to the predecessors-in-interest of the appellants, whether the takeed was duly executed, whether the ryotwari pattas were genuine or otherwise valid or not. Nor was it for the High Court to adjudicate the disputed fact of whether the land in question was in fact a water body or the dried bed of a water body. Cultivation is often carried out on the dried bed of water bodies. That does not denude the land of its character as a water body.
    (Paras 43 and 44)
    The High Court rightly based its decision on the declaration of the entire survey area as water body and held, in effect, that the plots in question had vested in the Government free from all encumbrances under Section 2-A of the 1956 Act. The respondents could not, therefore, be compelled to grant ryotwari pattas in respect of the said plots.
    (Para 45)
    The High Court rightly held that it was well settled that poramboke (tank) cannot be alienated. No patta can be granted in respect of tanks and water bodies including those that might have dried up or fallen into disuse. The Supreme Court has time and again emphasised the need to retain and restore water bodies and held that water bodies are inalienable. Land comprised in water bodies cannot be alienated to any person even if it is dry.
    (Paras 48 and 49)
    Susetha v. State of T.N., (2006) 6 SCC 543; M.C. Mehta v. Union of India, (1997) 3 SCC 715; Intellectuals Forum v. State of A.P., (2006) 3 SCC 549, relied on
    In this case relief under Article 226 was also liable to be refused on the grounds of delay, laches, acquiescence and/or omission of the appellants to assert their right, if any, within a reasonable time after the commencement of the 1956 Act. The appellants and/or their predecessors were tardy and lethargic. The application for patta was made over two decades after the commencement of the 1956 Act, when the statute required that such an application be made soon after its commencement.
    (Paras 46 and 47)
    Both the Single Bench and the Division Bench having concurred in their well-reasoned findings, interference of this Court is not warranted.
    (Para 50)
    Sarvepalli Ramaiah v. Collector, Writ Appeal No. 1495 of 2004, order dated 22-2-2006 (AP), affirmed
    S. Ramaiah v. Collector, WP No. 5807 of 2003, order dated 23-4-2003 (Hyd); S. Ramaiah v. Tahsildar, WP No. 29664 of 1995, order dated 28-11-2001 (Hyd); Collector v. E. Bhaskar, Writ Appeal No. 193 of 1990, order dated 9-11-1994 (Hyd), referred to
    E. Administrative Law — Judicial Review of Administrative Action — Judicial review — Of decision-making process — When warranted — Irrationality and illegality — What amount to — When vitiate decision warranting Court's interference — Constitution of India, Art. 226
    Held :

    Per Indira Banerjee, J. (concurring)

    Administrative decisions are subject to judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution, only on grounds of perversity, patent illegality, irrationality, want of power to take the decision and procedural irregularity. Except on these grounds administrative decisions are not interfered with, in exercise of the extraordinary power of judicial review.
    (Para 40)
    A decision is vitiated by irrationality if the decision is so outrageous, that it is in defiance of all logic; when no person acting reasonably could possibly have taken the decision, having regard to the materials on record.
    (Para 41)
    A decision may sometimes be set aside and quashed under Article 226 on the ground of illegality. This is when there is an apparent error of law on the face of the decision, which goes to the root of the decision and/or in other words an apparent error, but for which the decision would have been otherwise.
    (Para 42)
    Judicial review under Article 226 is directed, not against the decision, but the decision-making process. A patent illegality and/or error apparent on the face of the decision, which goes to the root of the decision, may vitiate the decision-making process.
    (Para 43)
    In the present case, the impugned decision of the Collector taken pursuant to orders of Court, was based on some materials. It cannot be said to be perverse. The decision in this case is not irrational. Further, there is no patent illegality or apparent error in the decision. Therefore, interference in exercise of the High Court's extraordinary power of judicial review is not warranted.
    (Para 41)

    Appeal dismissed R-D/62013/CV

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sarvepalli Ramaiah v. District Collector, Chittoor
    (Mar 14, 2019)