Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act
  • provision of Article 19(1)(c) of the Constitution of India.
  • Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act, 1860.
  • SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT
  • Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act
  • Use) Act, 1950.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act
  • provision of Article 19(1)(c) of the Constitution of India.
  • Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act, 1860.
  • SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT
  • Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act
  • Use) Act, 1950.
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — R.K. Deshpande, J. (21 January 2019)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition challenges the order dated 4/10/2017 passed by the Assistant Registrar of Societies, Nagpur, which rejected Application No. 615 of 2017 seeking permission to register a charitable society named "Rashtriya Swayansevak Sangh" along with its Memorandum of Association, Rules and Regulations and related documents. Respondent Nos. 3 to 6 opposed the application as objectors, asserting that a society named Rashtriya Swayansevak Sangh had already been registered at Chandrapur under Registration No. MH08/D0018394 by the Indian Government since 1925 and that they are members of that society. The objectors relied on Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act, 1860 as a bar to registration without prior government permission. The Assistant Registrar found no documentary registration certificate from the objectors proving an existing society with that name but relied on a State Government circular dated 22/12/2005 (No. EMB1005/1440/30) and Section 3A to hold that the use of "Rashtriya" suggested government patronage and that registration without prior government permission was barred. The petition was heard and finally disposed of on 21 January 2019; the petition was dismissed and the rule discharged with no order as to costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the rejection of the petitioner's application to register a society named "Rashtriya Swayansevak Sangh" can be justified under Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act, 1860.
  2. What is the scope of the phrase "be deemed to be undesirable" in Section 3A — whether it is confined to the two expressly enumerated categories (identity/similarity with an existing society and suggesting government patronage/connection) or represents a broader residuary power to refuse registration.
  3. Whether the petitioner's claim to register the society implicates Article 19(1)(c) of the Constitution (freedom of association) and, if so, whether Section 3A is an unreasonable restriction on that right.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as advanced by Shri Ingole)

  • There is no documentary proof of any existing registered society in the name "Rashtriya Swayansevak Sangh"; therefore, the Assistant Registrar erred in rejecting the application.
  • There is no basis to conclude that the proposed name is undesirable on the grounds that it is identical with or resembles any previously registered society, or that it suggests government patronage or connection.
  • Relied on the decision of the learned Single Judge in Satyaprakash Sharma v. State of Maharashtra and another, 2013(1) Mh.L.J. 147, for the proposition that the expression "be deemed to be undesirable" should be read as referable only to the expressly enumerated grounds under Section 3A.

Respondents' and Government's Arguments

  • Respondent Nos. 4 and 5 (objectors), through Shri Sunil Manohar (assisted by Shri S.D. Abhyankar), argued that Section 3A is wide enough to permit the Registrar to reject an application if the proposed name is otherwise undesirable, even if it does not neatly fall within categories (i) or (ii) of the Section; the power can extend beyond the two enumerated categories.
  • The Additional Government Pleader, Shri Anand Deshpande, argued that the word "Rashtriya" indicates government patronage and is likely to create confusion or mislead the public; he supported the Assistant Registrar's reliance on the 22/12/2005 Circular introduced under the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, 1950.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Satyaprakash Sharma v. State of Maharashtra and another, 2013(1) Mh.L.J. 147 Cited by the petitioner for the proposition that the phrase "be deemed to be undesirable" at the end of Section 3A should be read merely as referable to the two specifically enumerated categories (similarity/identity with an existing society and suggestion of government patronage/connection). The court held that the decision in Satyaprakash Sharma dealt with a case pertaining to ground (i) (similarity/identity) and must be understood in the facts of that case; it was not applicable to the present question concerning whether a name suggesting government patronage (use of "Rashtriya") or a residuary "undesirable" category could justify refusal. Accordingly, the court did not follow it as controlling for the broader interpretive issue raised here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by reproducing Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act, 1860, and explaining—based on the text of that provision—that the Registrar's power to reject a proposed society name can be exercised on three distinct bases set out by the statute:

  1. That the proposed name is identical with, or so nearly resembles, the name of an existing registered society as to be likely to deceive the public or members of either society (ground (i));
  2. That, without prior government permission, the proposed name suggests or is calculated to suggest the patronage of the Government or a connection with a body constituted by that Government or any local authority (ground (ii));
  3. That the name may, subject to any rules, be deemed to be undesirable by the Registrar (ground (iii)), which the court treated as a residuary or general category.

The court rejected the petitioner's argument that the residuary phrase ("be deemed to be undesirable") is confined to, or only referable to, the two prior categories. The court accepted the respondents' submission that the residuary clause is a general category capable of covering names which are ex facie undesirable (for example, names that would indicate political organizations or those plainly objectionable such as a "Terrorist Organization"). The court observed that ground (ii) does not require the existence of any previously registered society and that registration under ground (ii) could be permissible with prior government permission.

On the application of these principles to the present facts, the Assistant Registrar had found that the use of the word "Rashtriya" in the proposed society name, read in the light of the State Government Circular dated 22/12/2005, would directly or by implication suggest the patronage of the Government of India or the State Government. The Assistant Registrar therefore held that registration without prior permission of the Government was barred by Section 3A. The court accepted that the decision in Satyaprakash Sharma concerned ground (i) and did not address the situation where there is no existing registered society but the proposed name suggests government patronage; thus that decision was not applicable to the present case.

Regarding the Article 19(1)(c) challenge, the court acknowledged that freedom of association is a fundamental right but noted (as the opinion records) that Article 19(4) contemplates that reasonable restrictions imposed by law in the interest of sovereignty and integrity, public order or morality may be valid. The opinion states that it was not argued that Section 3A is unreasonable or contravenes Article 19(1)(c). The court concluded that the authority acting under Section 3A is competent to reject a registration claim if, in its opinion, the proposed name is undesirable.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The petition is dismissed; the rule stands discharged. No order as to costs.

Implications:

  • The court affirmed a broad reading of Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act: the Registrar may refuse registration where a proposed name is identical with or resembles an existing society's name, where it suggests government patronage or connection without prior permission, or where it is otherwise "deemed to be undesirable" (a residuary category).
  • On the facts of this petition, the Assistant Registrar's conclusion—that the inclusion of "Rashtriya" suggested government patronage and therefore registration without prior government permission was barred—was upheld by the court.
  • The opinion expressly states that the earlier decision in Satyaprakash Sharma concerned ground (i) (similarity) and was not applicable to the present facts concerning suggestion of government patronage; the court did not treat the earlier decision as settling the broader question posed here.
  • The opinion does not state any broader authoritative declaration beyond the resolution of the petition; directly, the consequence is dismissal of the petition and preservation of the Assistant Registrar's order. The judgment does not indicate that it set a novel binding precedent beyond its application to the facts before the court.

Order dated and pronounced: 21 January 2019. Judges: R.K. Deshpande, J. and VINAY JOSHI, J.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Janardan v. State Of Maharashtra

    DATE OF PRONOUNCING THE JUDGMENT : 21 st JANUARY, 2019 JUDGMENT (PER : R.K. DESHPANDE, J.) :

    1. Rule. The learned counsels appearing for the parties waive service of notice. The petition is being finally disposed of.

    2. The challenge in this petition is to the order dated 4102017 passed by the Assistant Registrar of Societies, wp6700.17.odt Nagpur, rejecting Application No.615 of 2017 for grant of permission to register a charitable society under the name and style of Rashtriya Swayansevak Sangh along with the Memorandum of Association, Rules and Regulations and other relevant documents enclosed with it. The application was opposed by the respondent Nos.3 to 6, who were the objectors, claiming that the society under the name and style of Rashtriya Swayansevak Sangh has already been registered at Chandrapur vide Registration No.MH08/D0018394 by the Indian Government since 1925 and they are the members of such society. According to the objectors, the petitioner cannot claim registration of the society under the name and style of Rashtriya Swayansevak Sangh in view of the bar created under Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act, 1860.

    3. The Assistant Registrar, in the impugned order, has recorded the finding that there is no documentary evidence in the form of registration certificate filed by the objectors on record to prove that the society under the name and style of Rashtriya Swayansevak Sangh or similar or identical to it, has wp6700.17.odt already been registered. Relying upon the Circular dated 22122005 issued by the General Administration Department of the State Government bearing No.EMB1005/1440/30, it is held that the Circular impliedly prohibits the use of name Rashtriya in the name of society. The order holds that the true spirit of the Circular is to prevent the name of society or trust, which will directly or by implication suggests the patronage of the Government of India or the State Government. It holds that to register the petitionersociety containing the name Rashtriya, is against such Circular. It also holds that the registration of the petitionersociety is also barred by Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act in the absence of prior permission of the Government.

    4. It is urged by Shri Ingole, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, that in the absence of existence of any society being already registered in the name of Rashtriya Swayansevak Sangh, the learned Assistant Registrar has committed an error in rejecting the application. He has further urged that there is no basis to form an opinion that the registration of the society in the wp6700.17.odt name of Rashtriya Swayansevak Sangh is undesirable either on the ground that the name is identical with, or resembles with any society previously registered, or that it suggests or is calculated to suggest the patronage of the Government or connection with any body constituted by the Government or any local authority. The reliance is placed upon the decision of the learned Single Judge of this Court in the case of Satyaprakash Sharma v. State of Maharashtra and another, reported in 2013(1) Mh.L.J. 147.

    5. As against the aforesaid contentions, Shri Sunil Manohar, the learned Senior Advocate, assisted by Shri S.D. Abhyankar, Advocate, appearing for the respondent Nos.4 and 5, the objectors, has urged that the provision of Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act is wide enough to include the power of the Registrar to reject the application for registration of the society in any particular name if it is found to be otherwise undesirable, though not even referable to categories 1 and 2 under Section 3A of the said Act. He submits that the decision of the learned Single Judge relied upon has to be understood in the facts of the case before the Court. wp6700.17.odt

    6. According to Shri Anand Deshpande, the learned Additional Government Pleader appearing for the respondent Nos.1 and 2, the word Rashtriya shows the patronage of the Government, which definitely creates confusion or it may mislead the public. He supports the order and relies upon the Circular dated 22122005, introduced by virtue of the provisions as contemplated under the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, 1950.

    7. The question involved is whether the rejection of the application of the petitioner for registration of the charitable society in the name of Rashtriya Swayansevak Sangh can be justified on the basis of the provision of Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act. The provision of Section 3A of the said Act, being relevant is reproduced below :

    3A. Prohibition against registration of societies with undesirable names. No society shall be registered by a name which, in the opinion of the Registrar, is undesirable, being a name which is identical with, or which in the wp6700.17.odt opinion of the Registrar so nearly resembles the name by which any other existing society has been previously registered, as to be likely to deceive the public or members of either society, or which, without the previous permission of the Government concerned, suggests or is calculated to suggest the patronage of that Government or connection with anybody constituted by that Government or any local authority, or which may, subject to any rules made in this behalf, be deemed to be undesirable by the Registrar.
    Our reading of the provision of Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act is that the power of the Registrar to reject the application for registration of the society by name proposed, can be exercised on three grounds (i) that such registration is undesirable being a name which is identical with, or so nearly resembles the name by which any other existing society has been previously registered, as to be likely to deceive the public or members of either society, or (ii) which suggests or is calculated to suggest the patronage of the Government or connection with any body constituted by that Government or any local authority, or (iii) which may be deemed to be undesirable. Ground No.(i) contemplates existence of registered Society in the identical name wp6700.17.odt or the name which resembles with such society. Ground No.(ii) does not contemplate existence of registered society, but it suggests or calculated to suggest the patronage or connection with the Government or local authority. For the society falling in ground No.(ii), the registration may be permissible with the prior permission of the Government concerned, whereas ground No.(iii) is subject to any rules made in that behalf.

    8. It is urged by Shri Ingole that there is no third category unconnected with ground Nos.(i) and (ii) under Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act. Relying upon the decision of the learned Single Judge in Satyaprakash Sharma's case, cited supra, it is urged that the word undesirable in the last portion of the said Section does not denote general notion or concept of undesirable, which is ruled out. He, therefore, submits that the expression be deemed to be undesirable at the end of the provision is referable only to ground Nos.(i) and (ii). The argument of Shri Manohar is that the decision relied upon is distinguishable and the Court therein was dealing with similarity with the name of the society already registered. wp6700.17.odt

    9. It is not possible for us to accept the argument of Shri Ingole that the ground No.(iii) in Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act is referable only to ground Nos.(ii) and (iii) therein. In our view, Shri Manohar is right in urging that the expression be deemed to be undesirable pertains to a general category which may or may not include the ground Nos.(i) and (ii) under Section 3A of the said Act for rejection of the application. Shri Manohar was right in pointing out an instance where a charitable society is sought to be registered in the names of Indian National Congress, Bhartiya Janta Party or such similar names, which are political organizations, but may not be registered under the provisions of the Societies Registration Act. The rejection may also be on the ground that registration of society in such a name is likely to deceive the public because of similarity or resemblance with any other organizations, like Indian National Congress, Bhartiya Janta Party. Apart from this, if the name of the Society is found ex facie undesirable, like Terrorist Organization, there can be rejection in terms of ground No.(iii), which can be termed as residuary. wp6700.17.odt

    10. So far as the challenge based on Article 19(1)(c) of the Constitution of India is concerned, no doubt, it relates to a fundamental right of the association or union. Of course, by Article 19(4), the operation of any existing law insofar as it imposes or prevents the State from making any law imposing reasonable restrictions on the exercise of right conferred by this Article in the interest of sovereignty and integrity of India, public order or morality and operation of such law is not affected. It is not the argument advanced that the provision of Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act is in any way unreasonable or contravenes the provision of Article 19(1)(c) of the Constitution of India. The authority acting under Section 3A of the said Act is competent to reject the claim for registration of society in particular name, if in its opinion it is found to be undesirable.

    11. In the present case, the Assistant Registrar has recorded the finding that the registration of the petitionersociety is barred under Section 3A of the Societies Registration Act in the absence of prior permission of the Government. Relying upon the wp6700.17.odt interpretation of the Circular dated 22122005, it is held that the use of name Rashtriya in the name of the society directly or by implication suggests the patronage of the Government of India or the State Government. The decision of the learned Single Judge of this Court in the case of Satyaprakash Sharma, cited supra, will have to be seen in the light of the facts of the case. It was a case of rejection which pertained to ground No.(i) in Section 3A of the said Act. It was not the question involved as to whether in the absence of existing registered society having the name identical or resembling with the name of the society to be registered. The said decision is not applicable. We, therefore, do not find any substance in the arguments so advanced.

    12. In the result, the petition is dismissed. Rule stands discharged. No order as to costs. (VINAY JOSHI, J.) (R.K. DESHPANDE, J.) Lanjewar

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Janardan v. State Of Maharashtra
    (Jan 21, 2019)