Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 1005
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Section 124 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Section 126 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Section 125 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 1005
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Section 124 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Section 126 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Section 125 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a 74-year-old childless widow, executed a registered document styled as a “gift deed” in favour of her nephew (the respondent). The deed stated that:

  • It was executed partly for consideration already paid and partly for consideration to be paid later.
  • Possession and enjoyment would remain with the appellant and her husband during their lifetimes, and the transfer would take effect only after their death.

Feeling aggrieved, the appellant executed Deed of Cancellation No. 1844/1999 on 2-6-1999. Litigation ensued:

  • OS 32/2000 (filed by the respondent) sought a declaration that the cancellation deed was null and void and that he had title to the property.
  • OS 97/2000 (filed by the appellant) sought an injunction to restrain the respondent from trespassing or committing waste.
  • On 11-12-2006, the learned Munsif decreed both suits.
  • The District Court (AS 30/2007) allowed the appellant’s appeal on 23-9-2010 and dismissed the respondent’s connected appeal.
  • The High Court, on 3-4-2017, allowed RSA 757/2011 filed by the respondent and reversed the District Court’s decree.
  • The present appeal challenges the High Court’s judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a document labelled as a gift deed, but executed for consideration (partly paid and partly promised), can legally operate as a valid gift under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
  2. Whether a deed reserving the donor’s right to possess and enjoy the property during her lifetime, with the transfer to take effect only after her death, is a gift or actually a will.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The deed could not constitute a gift because it was supported by consideration, contrary to Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act which requires a gift to be “without consideration.”
  • Because the appellant retained possession and the deed postponed transfer until after her death, the instrument was testamentary in nature and therefore could be revoked during her lifetime.
  • Consequently, the appellant acted within her legal right in executing the deed of cancellation.

Respondent's Arguments

No detailed arguments of the respondent were provided in the opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Naramadaben Maganlal Thakker v. Pranjivandas Maganlal Thakker (1997) 2 SCC 255 A gift is complete only when there is (i) execution of a registered deed, (ii) acceptance by the donee, and (iii) delivery of the property; thereafter the donor is divested of title. Relied upon to underscore that delivery and acceptance are essential for completion of a gift, thereby emphasising that these elements were absent/incomplete in the present case.
Renikuntla Rajamma (Dead) by LRs v. K. Sarwanamma (2014) 9 SCC 445 Reservation of possession or income by the donor does not, by itself, invalidate a gift if the statutory requirements are otherwise satisfied and the gift is accepted during the donor’s lifetime. The Court agreed with this ruling in principle but distinguished the present facts: here the deed was for consideration and expressly conditional on future events, so a valid, completed gift never came into existence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court applied Sections 122–126 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882:

  • Absence of Gratuitous Intent: Section 122 defines a gift as a transfer “without consideration.” The impugned deed was admittedly executed for consideration; hence it failed the statutory definition.
  • Conditional Nature of the Deed: The deed was contingent upon the donee looking after the appellant and her husband and upon the death of both donors. Such conditions meant the transfer was not immediate and unconditional.
  • Lack of Completion: Because acceptance and delivery (or transfer of title) had not occurred during the donor’s lifetime, no completed gift arose. Under the principles in Naramadaben and Renikuntla, the donor therefore retained full title.
  • Right to Revoke: With title remaining in the donor and the gift being incomplete, the appellant validly exercised her right to cancel the instrument through Deed of Cancellation No. 1844/1999.
  • Error of the High Court: The High Court failed to appreciate these statutory pre-conditions and precedential principles, warranting reversal.

Holding and Implications

HELD: The appeal is allowed; the High Court’s judgment dated 3-4-2017 (2017 SCC OnLine Ker 41624) is set aside.

Implications: Ownership of the property remains with the appellant, and the respondent acquires no rights under the cancelled deed. The decision reinforces that (i) consideration vitiates a purported gift, and (ii) conditional or incomplete gifts can be revoked by the donor. No new legal doctrine is created, but the ruling affirms strict adherence to the statutory definition of “gift” under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    S. Sarojini Amma v. Velayudhan Pillai Sreekumar .

    Indira Banerjee, J.— Leave granted. This appeal has been filed against the judgment and order dated 3-4-2017 passed by the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in Velayudhan Pillai Sreekumar v. S. Sarojini Amma 2017 SCC OnLine Ker 41624 whereby the High Court was pleased to allow the second appeal filed by the respondent and set aside the judgment and decree passed by the first appellate court in favour of the appellant.

    2. The short question involved in this appeal is whether a document styled as gift deed but admittedly executed for consideration, part of which has been paid and the balance promised to be paid, can be treated as formal document or instrument of gift. Another related question is whether a gift deed reserving the right of the donor to keep possession and right of enjoyment and enforceable after the death of the executant is a gift or a will.

    3. The appellant is a childless widow aged 74 years whose husband expired on 6-6-2015. The respondent is the nephew of the appellant (brother's son). In the expectation that the respondent will look after the appellant and her husband and also for some consideration, the appellant executed a purported gift deed in favour of the respondent. The gift deed clearly stated that the gift would take effect after the death of the appellant and her husband.

    4. According to the appellant, on or about 2-6-1999, the appellant executed Deed of Cancellation No. 1844/1999 cancelling the gift deed. After about eight months, on or about 1-2-2000, the respondent filed Original Suit No. 32 of 2000 in the Court of the learned Munsif, Sasthamcotta for declaration that the cancellation deed executed by the appellant is null and void and also for declaration of his right over the suit property being the subject-matter of the purported deed of gift.

    5. On or about 20-3-2000, the appellant filed original suit being OS No. 97 of 2000 before the Court of the learned Munsif, Sasthamcotta for permanent injunction restraining the respondent or his men from trespassing or committing waste or mischief in the suit property. On 12-5-2000, the appellant and her husband filed the written statement in the suit being OS No. 32 of 2000 filed by the respondent. On 25-7-2000, the defendants in OS No. 97 of 2000 filed their written statement contending that the registered Document No. 687/2000 was executed for consideration.

    6. By a judgment and order dated 11-12-2006, the learned Munsif, Sasthamcotta decreed Original Suit No. 32/2000 and OS No. 97 of 2000.

    7. Being aggrieved, the appellant filed first appeal being AS No. 30 of 2007 before the District Court, Kollam. The defendants in OS No. 97 of 2000 filed their first appeal before the District Court, Kollam. By an order dated 23-9-2010, the Additional District Judge III, Kollam allowed the application being AS No. 30 of 2007 filed by the appellant and dismissed AS No. 77 of 2000 filed by the respondent in OS No. 97 of 2000.

    8. The respondent filed regular second appeal against the judgment and decree in AS No. 30 of 2007. By the judgment and order dated 3-4-2017 2017 SCC OnLine Ker 41624, the High Court allowed RSA No. 757 of 2011 and set aside the judgment and decree in AS No. 30 of 2007.

    9. On behalf of the appellant, it was contended that the document styled as gift deed was to come into effect only after the death of the appellant and her husband. The question was whether a document in terms whereof the executant of the document retained possession and reserved her right over the property being the subject-matter of the document could be a deed of gift or whether such a document was a document in the nature of a will.

    10. Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 defines gift as hereunder:

    “122. “Gift” defined.—“Gift” is the transfer of certain existing movable or immovable property made voluntarily and without consideration, by one person called the donor, to another, called the donee, and accepted by or on behalf of the donee.”

    11. Some of the relevant provisions of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 with regard to a gift are set out hereinbelow:

    “123. Transfer how effected.—For the purpose of making a gift of immovable property, the transfer must be effected by a registered instrument signed by or on behalf of the donor, and attested by at least two witnesses.
    For the purpose of making a gift of movable property, the transfer may be effected either by a registered instrument signed as aforesaid or by delivery.
    Such delivery may be made in the same way as goods sold may be delivered.
    124. Gift of existing and future property.—A gift comprising both existing and future property is void as to the latter.
    125. Gift to several of whom one does not accept.—A gift of a thing to two or more donees, of whom one does not accept it, is void as to the interest which he would have taken had he accepted.
    126. When gift may be suspended or revoked.—The donor and donee may agree that on the happening of any specified event which does not depend on the will of the donor a gift shall be suspended or revoked; but a gift which the parties agree shall be revocable wholly or in part, at the mere will of the donor, is void wholly or in part, as the case may be.
    A gift may also be revoked in any of the cases (save want or failure of consideration) in which, if it were a contract, it might be rescinded.
    Save as aforesaid, a gift cannot be revoked.
    Nothing contained in this section shall be deemed to affect the rights of transferees for consideration without notice.
    Illustrations
    (a) A gives a field to B, reserving to himself, with B's assent, the right to take back the field in case B, and his descendants die before A. B dies without descendants in A's lifetime. A may take back the field.
    (b) A gives a lakh of rupees to B, reserving to himself, with B's assent, the right to take back at pleasure Rs 10,000 out of the lakh. The gift holds goods as to Rs 90,000 but is void as to Rs 10,000, which continue to belong to A.”

    12. Gift means to transfer certain existing movable or immovable property voluntarily and without consideration by one person called the donor to another called the donee and accepted by or on behalf of the donee as held by the Supreme Court in Naramadaben Maganlal Thakker v. Pranjivandas Maganlal Thakker (1997) 2 SCC 255. As further held by this Court in Naramadaben Maganlal Thakker (1997) 2 SCC 255:

    “7. It would thus be clear that the execution of a registered gift deed, acceptance of the gift and delivery of the property together make the gift complete. Thereafter, the donor is divested of his title and the donee becomes absolute owner of the property.”

    13. A conditional gift with no recital of acceptance and no evidence in proof of acceptance, where possession remains with the donor as long as he is alive, does not become complete during lifetime of the donor. When a gift is incomplete and title remains with the donor, the deed of gift might be cancelled.

    14. In Renikuntla Rajamma v. K. Sarwanamma (2014) 9 SCC 445 a Hindu woman executed a registered gift deed of immovable property reserving to herself the right to retain possession and to receive rent of the property during her lifetime. The gift was accepted by the donee but later revoked.

    15. In Renikuntla Rajamma (2014) 9 SCC 445, this Court held that the fact that the donor had reserved the right to enjoy the property during her lifetime did not affect the validity of the deed. The Court held that a gift made by registered instrument duly executed by or on behalf of the donor and attested by at least two witnesses is valid, if the same is accepted by or on behalf of the donee. Such acceptance must, however, be made during the lifetime of the donor and while he is still capable of making an acceptance.

    16. We are in agreement with the decision of this Court in Renikuntla Rajamma (2014) 9 SCC 445 that there is no provision in law that ownership in property cannot be gifted without transfer of possession of such property. However, the conditions precedent of a gift as defined in Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act must be satisfied. A gift is transfer of property without consideration. Moreover, a conditional gift only becomes complete on compliance of the conditions in the deed.

    17. In the instant case, admittedly, the deed of transfer was executed for consideration and was in any case conditional subject to the condition that the donee would look after the petitioner and her husband and subject to the condition that the gift would take effect after the death of the donor. We are thus constrained to hold that there was no completed gift of the property in question by the appellant to the respondent and the appellant was within her right in cancelling the deed. The judgment and order 2017 SCC OnLine Ker 41624 of the High Court cannot, therefore, be sustained.

    18. The appeal is allowed and the judgment and order under appeal is set aside.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S. Sarojini Amma v. Velayudhan Pillai Sreekumar .
    (Oct 26, 2018)