[Order per : A.K. Goel, C.J.]. - This appeal has been preferred by the Revenue under Section 35G of the Central Excise Act, 1944. Learned counsel for the appellants states that substantial question of law for consideration be reformulated as follows :-
“Whether the assessee is entitled to utilize Cenvat credit of Basic Excise Duty for payment of Education Cess.”
2. He further states that the question is covered in favour of the assessee vide judgment of this Court dated 29-6-2011 in Central Excise Reference No. 4/2009 Commissioner of Central Excise, Dibrugarh v. M/s Prag Bosimi Synthetics Ltd. [ (Gau.)].
3. In the said case, following question was taken up for consideration :
“Whether NCC Duty(National Calamity Contingent Duty) is a Duty exempted under Notification No. 32/99-C.E., dated 8-7-1999 and, if not, whether Cenvat Credit under the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004, can be utilized, towards payment of such duty, which is not exempted under the said Notification.”
4. Considering the second party of the said question which was similar to the question involved herein, it was observed :
“17. Rule 3(7) limits the utilization of Cenvat credit in respect of NCC duty as also other duties mentioned in Rule 3(7)(b). It provides that Cenvat credit in respect of NCC duty and other duties shall be utilized towards payment of duty of excise leviable under various statutes respectively. The use of the word “respectively” in this regard is important inasmuch as it confines the utilization of Cenvat credit obtained to a particular statute and for utilization of payment of duty under that statute only. The converse, however, does not follow. That is to say that merely because Cenvat credit in respect of NCC duty can be utilized only for payment of NCC duty, it does not follow that any other credit of duty cannot be utilized for payment of NCC duty.
18. This being the position, in our opinion the Commissioner of Central Excise at Dibrugarh was in error in coming to the conclusion that Cenvat credit of basic excise duty cannot be utilized for payment of NCC duty on the final product.
19. Under the circumstances the second part of the substantial question of law must be answered in the affirmative and it must be held that while Cenvat credit of NCC duty can be utilized under the Cenvat Credit Rules only towards payment of such NCC duty, Cenvat credit obtained from other sources can be utilized for payment of NCC duty on the final product.”
5. In the present case, the assessee utilized Cenvat credit of Basic Excise duty for paying Education Cess to which department raised objection. The Adjudicating authority held that Cenvat Credit of Basic Excise Duty could not be utilized for payment of Education Cess and accordingly deducted the amount from the refund due to the assesse.
6. The assessee preferred revision petition under Section 35EE of the Act which was allowed as follows :
“The appellant has utilized the Cenvat credit for payment of education Cess on final products in respect of which exemption under said notification is availed of and since Education Cess is also a Duty of excise, I hold that the appellant’s action is correct and is in conformity with the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004.”
7. The above view was upheld by the Tribunal while dismissing appeal of the Revenue against the above order. It was held that there was no bar to utilize Cenvat credit of Basic Excise Duty for payment of Education Cess.
8. Since the view taken by the Tribunal is in conformity with the view taken by this Court referred to above, the question of law raised by the Revenue has to be decided against it and answered in the affirmative.
9. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.