Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 4 CENTRAL EXCISE ACT 1944
  • Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and under Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002.
  • consideration.5.2Rule 10A of the Central Excise [Valuation] Rules
  • CENTRAL EXCISE ACT 1944
  • him.Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000
  • Rule 10A of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000
  • Rule 10A(i) or (ii) or Rule 8 of the Valuation Rules
  • Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000
  • Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules
  • Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.
  • Rule 8 of the Valuation Rules
  • provisions of Rule 11
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 4 CENTRAL EXCISE ACT 1944
  • Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and under Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002.
  • consideration.5.2Rule 10A of the Central Excise [Valuation] Rules
  • CENTRAL EXCISE ACT 1944
  • him.Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000
  • Rule 10A of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000
  • Rule 10A(i) or (ii) or Rule 8 of the Valuation Rules
  • Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000
  • Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules
  • Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.
  • Rule 8 of the Valuation Rules
  • provisions of Rule 11
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Tribunal Order (per P.R. Chandrasekharan, Member (T))

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal and stay application challenge Order-in-Appeal No. SB(23)/23/MV/2011 dated 28-02-2011 passed by the Commissioner of Central Excise (Appeals), Mumbai.

The appellants, M/s. Indian Extrusions, Goregaon, Mumbai, manufactured plastic bottles/containers (Chapter 39). They manufactured goods from raw materials supplied by M/s. Marico Ltd. and supplied the finished goods to M/s. Aero Pharma Pvt. Ltd. for packing hair oil branded by Marico Ltd., discharging excise duty on the basis of cost of raw materials plus job charges.

The Department alleged incorrect assessment of assessable value and issued a show-cause notice dated 09-06-2009 proposing revision of assessable value under Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000, demanding a differential duty of Rs. 3,33,110/- on a differential assessable value of Rs. 22,09,577/- for clearances between 01-04-2007 and 25-10-2008. Interest under Section 11AB and penalties under Section 11AC and Rule 25 were also proposed.

Adjudication confirmed the duty (Rs. 3,33,110/-) under Section 11A, interest under Section 11AB, and penalty of Rs. 3,33,110/- under Section 11AC. The appellant appealed to the Commissioner (Appeals), who rejected the appeal; the appellant then approached this Tribunal with this appeal and a stay application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Rule 10A of the Central Excise (Valuation) Rules, 2000 or Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules applies to job-work situations where the job-worker manufactures goods using raw materials supplied by another and the finished goods are consumed by the principal manufacturer (i.e., not sold by the principal at removal).
  2. Whether the assessable value should be determined as 110% of the cost of production under Rule 8 (as the Department contends) or on the cost of raw materials plus job charges (as advanced by the appellants and based on the ratio in Ujagar Prints).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The job work was undertaken on a principal-to-principal basis; therefore Rules 10A and 8 are not attracted and the assessable value must be determined on cost of raw materials plus job charges.
  • Reliance on the Hon'ble Supreme Court decision in Ujagar Prints v. Union of India (ratio: assessable value on cost of raw materials plus processing charges) and Board Circular No. 619/10/2002-EX (dated 19-02-2002) to support valuation on raw-materials-plus-job-charges basis.
  • Cited Tribunal precedents (Rolstar Pvt. Ltd. v. CCE, Daman; Palco Metals Ltd.; Advance Surfactants India Ltd. v. CCE, Mangalore) holding that Rule 10A(i)/(ii) and Rule 8 do not apply where job-worked goods are consumed by the principal and not sold, and that valuation on raw-material cost plus job charges is correct.
  • Prayed for grant of stay based on these submissions.

Revenue's Arguments

  • The learned Assistant/AR for the Revenue reiterated the findings of the lower adjudicating and appellate authorities (i.e., that Rule 8 applies and the assessable value should be revised leading to differential demand).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ujagar Prints v. Union of India (Hon'ble Supreme Court) Principle that assessable value for job-worked goods (where appropriate) is to be ascertained on the cost of raw materials plus processing/job charges. The Tribunal applied the Ujagar Prints ratio as the correct test for valuation in the instant job-work situation and held that discharge of duty on cost of raw materials plus job charges is correct in law.
Rolstar Pvt. Ltd. v. CCE, Daman (Tribunal - Ahmedabad) Held that Rule 10A and Rule 8 are not applicable in situations where goods are manufactured on job-work basis and consumed by the principal manufacturer (not sold); valuation on raw-materials-plus-job-charges is appropriate. The Tribunal relied on this precedent as supportive authority that Rule 10A and Rule 8 do not apply to the facts of this case and that Ujagar Prints formula applies.
Palco Metals Ltd. v. CCE (Tribunal - Ahmedabad) Similar view that Rule 10A and Rule 8 are not applicable for job-work goods consumed by the principal; valuation to follow raw-materials-plus-job-charges. The Tribunal cited this case as further support for applying the same principle to the present appeal.
Advance Surfactants India Ltd. v. CCE, Mangalore (Tribunal - Bangalore) Held that Rule 10A(i)/(ii) and Rule 8 do not apply where job-worked goods are consumed by the principal and not sold; Rule 11 may be invoked and valuation determined by reasonable means consistent with Valuation Rules and Section 4(1) of the Central Excise Act; affirmed application of Ujagar Prints formula. The Tribunal expressly followed this decision, observed that Rule 11 provides a recourse for the Revenue, and applied the Advance Surfactants ratio to hold that valuation on cost of raw materials plus job charges is correct, thereby setting aside the impugned order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal proceeded by textual and purposive analysis of the relevant Valuation Rules and the facts:

  1. Examined Rule 10A and noted its sub-rules:
    • Sub-rule (i) applies where the principal manufacturer sells the goods at the time of removal from the job-worker's factory (not the present case).
    • Sub-rule (ii) applies where goods are not sold at removal but are transferred to another place from where they will be sold (also not applicable here, since the principal consumes the goods in packing and does not sell the job-worked goods).
  2. Considered Rule 8, which provides that where excisable goods are not sold by the assessee but are used for consumption by him or on his behalf in production of other articles, the value shall be 110% of cost of production or manufacture. The Tribunal observed that Rule 8 contemplates the position of the manufacturer/assessee consuming the goods; here, the appellant is a job-worker, not the raw-material supplier/principal manufacturer, and the job-worker is not the captively consuming manufacturer. Thus, Rule 8 was held inapplicable on these facts.
  3. Recalled the Tribunal's own earlier decision in Advance Surfactants and other Tribunal precedents and the Supreme Court ratio in Ujagar Prints: where job-worked goods are consumed by the principal manufacturer and not sold, valuation should follow the Ujagar Prints formula (cost of raw materials plus processing/job charges).
  4. Noted that Rule 11 provides that where other rules are not directly applicable, reasonable means consistent with principles and general provisions of the Valuation Rules, read with Section 4(1) of the Central Excise Act, may be used; the Tribunal observed that Revenue may invoke Rule 11, but that does not alter the applicability of the Ujagar Prints approach to valuation in this factual matrix.
  5. Concluded that Rule 10A (i)/(ii) and Rule 8 do not apply to the appellant's factual situation, and that the correct assessable value is by applying the Ujagar Prints formula (cost of raw materials plus job charges). On that basis, the Tribunal allowed the appeal.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Appeal allowed; impugned order set aside.

Consequences and immediate effect:

  • The Tribunal set aside the order-in-appeal dated 28-02-2011 and allowed the appellant's appeal. The appellant's method of discharging duty on the basis of the cost of raw materials plus job charges (following Ujagar Prints) was held to be correct in law for the facts of this case.
  • The Tribunal granted consequential relief, if any, arising from allowing the appeal (as stated in the order).
  • The Tribunal observed that Rules 10A(i)/(ii) and Rule 8 are not applicable to the factual circumstances of this job-work case; Rule 11 may be the provision Revenue can invoke in general, but that does not negate application of Ujagar Prints for valuation here.

No suggestion is made in the opinion that the Tribunal was creating a new precedent; it applied existing Supreme Court and Tribunal authorities to the facts before it.

(Pronounced in Court)

    Indian Extrusions v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, Mumbai .

    [Order per : P.R. Chandrasekharan, Member (T)]. - This appeal and stay application are directed against the order-in-appeal No. SB(23)/23/MV/2011 dated 28-2-2011 passed by Commissioner of Central Excise (Appeals), Mumbai.

    2. The appellants, M/s. Indian Extrusions, Goregaon, Mumbai, are manufacturer of Plastic bottles/containers falling under Chapter 39 of the First Schedule to Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. They were manufacturing the said goods from the raw-materials supplied by M/s. Marico Ltd., and after manufacturing they were supplying the goods to M/s. Aero Pharma Pvt. Ltd., Thane for use by the latter for packing hair oil bearing the brand name of Marico Ltd., on payment of excise duty. The appellants were discharging the excise duty on the cost of raw-materials plus job charges. The department was of the view that the assessees were not paying duty on the correct assessable value and the duty should have been paid under Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000 and the value for the purpose of duty should be 110% of the cost of production. Accordingly, a show-cause notice dated 9-6-2009 was issued proposing to revise the assessable value under Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules and a differential duty of Rs. 3,33,110/- was demanded on a differential assessable value of Rs. 22,09,577/- in respect of goods cleared by them during the period from 1-4-2007 to 25-10-2008. The show-cause notice also proposed to demand interest under Section 11AB and impose penalties under Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and under Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002. The case was adjudicated and a duty demand of Rs. 3,33,110/- was confirmed under the provisions of Section 11A of the Central Excise Act, 1944 along with interest thereon under Section 11AB and a penalty of Rs. 3,33,110/- was imposed on the appellant under Section 11AC. The appellant preferred an appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals), who vide the impugned order rejected their appeal and, hence, the appellants are before us.

    3. The ld. Counsel for the appellant submits that the provisions of Rules 10A and 8 of the Valuation Rules are not attracted in this case as has been held by the lower authorities, as they undertook the job work on a principal to principal basis and in respect of such transactions the assessable value has to be determined on the cost of raw-materials cost plus job charges collected as per the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Ujagar Prints v. UOI, reported in (S.C.) and as clarified by Board’s Circular No. 619/10/2002-EX, dated 19-2-2002.

    3.1 The ld. Counsel also relies on the judgment of this Tribunal in the case of Rolstar Pvt. Ltd. v. CCE, Daman, reported in (Tri.-Ahmd.) wherein the Tribunal has considered a situation in respect of goods manufactured on job work basis and cleared back by the assessee to the principal manufacturer, who had given raw-materials for doing such job work and consuming the same in further manufacture of final products. In that case the Tribunal held that Rule 10A of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000 is not applicable and Rule 8 of the Valuation Rules are also not applicable and discharge of duty liability on the cost of raw-materials plus job charges is correct in law as held by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Ujagar Prints case. A similar view has held by this Tribunal in the case of CCE, Ahmedabad v. Palco Metals Ltd., reported in (Tri.-Ahmed.). The Bangalore Bench of this Tribunal in the case of Advance Surfactants India Ltd. v. CCE, Mangalore, reported in 2011-TIOL-787-CESTAT-Bangalore = (Tri.-Bang.) also held that in the case of job worked goods consumed by the principal manufacturer and not sold, Rule 10A(i) or (ii) or Rule 8 of the Valuation Rules will not apply and cost of raw materials plus job charges and profits, if any, should be the assessable value for the purpose of discharge of excise duty. In the light of these submissions, the ld. Advocate prays for grant of stay.

    4. The ld. AR appearing for the Revenue reiterates the findings of the lower adjudicating and appellate authorities.

    5. We have considered the rival submissions.

    After hearing the arguments, we are of the view that the appeal itself can be disposed of at this stage. Therefore, after granting stay, we take up the appeal for consideration.

    5.2 Rule 10A of the Central Excise [Valuation] Rules reads as follows :-

    “RULE 10A. Where the excisable goods are produced or manufactured by a job-worker, on behalf of a person (hereinafter referred to as principal manufacturer), then, -
    (i)      in a case where the goods are sold by the principal manufacturer for delivery at the time of removal of goods from the factory of job-worker, where the principal manufacturer and the buyer of the goods are not related and the price is the sole consideration for the sale, the value of the excisable goods shall be the transaction value of the said goods sold by the principal manufacturer;
    (ii)     in a case where the goods are not sold by the principal manufacturer at the time of removal of goods from the factory of the job-worker, but are transferred to some other place from where the said goods are to be sold after their clearance from the factory of job-worker and where the principal manufacturer and buyer of the goods are not related and the price is the sole consideration for the sale, the value of the excisable goods shall be the normal transaction value of such goods sold from such other place at or about the same time and, where such goods are not sold at or about the same time, at the time nearest to the time of removal of said goods from the factory of job-worker;
    (iii)    in a case not covered under clause (i) or (ii), the provisions of foregoing rules, wherever applicable, shall mutatis mutandis apply for determination of the value of the excisable goods :
    Provided that the cost of transportation, if any, from the premises, wherefrom the goods are sold, to the place of delivery shall not be included in the value of excisable goods.
    Explanation. - For the purposes of this rule, job-worker means a person engaged in the manufacture or production of goods on behalf of a principal manufacturer, from any inputs or goods supplied by the said principal manufacturer or by any other person authorised by him.

    Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules, 2000 also reads as follows :-

    “Rule 8 - Where the excisable goods are not sold by the assessee but are used for consumption by him or on his behalf in the production or manufacture of other articles, the value shall be one hundred and ten per cent of the cost of production or manufacture of such goods”.

    5.4 From a reading of the above Rules, it is seen that sub-rule (i) of the Rule 10A deals with a situation where the job worked goods are sold by the principal manufacturer. This situation does not arise in this case. The principal manufacturer does not sell the goods but consumes it in the packing of hair oil and other products. Sub-rule (ii) of Rule 10A also does not apply because that rule envisages sale of job worked goods from a place from where the goods are to be sold after clearance from the factory of the job worker. The department’s case is that Rule 8 would apply, but reading of the Rule clearly indicates that it applies to a situation where the goods are captively consumed by the assessee or on his behalf in the production/manufacture of other articles. The manufacturer/assessee in the instant case is the appellant job worker and not the raw-materials supplier. The appellant is not captively consuming the said items; therefore, Rule 8 has no application whatsoever to the facts of the case.

    5.5 This Tribunal in the case of Advance Surfactants India Ltd., cited supra, in an identical situation, held that Rule 10A(i) or (ii) or Rule 8 of the Valuation Rules will not apply in respect of job worked goods consumed by the principal manufacturer and not sold. It was further held that Rule 11 will apply in such cases and Revenue can take recourse to provisions of Rule 11 which talks about using reasonable means consistent with the principles and general provisions of the Valuation Rules read with sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the Central Excise Act, 1944. Keeping this in mind, the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ujagar Prints will squarely apply, that is, to ascertain the assessable value on the cost of raw materials plus processing charges. Similar view has been taken by this Tribunal in the case of Palco Metals Ltd. v. Rolstar Pvt. Ltd. (supra). In the light of these decisions, in the instant case also, the same principle will apply and, therefore, the discharge of duty liability by the appellant on the basis of Ujagar Prints formula, that is, on the cost of raw materials plus job charges is correct in law. Accordingly, we set aside the impugned order and allow the appeal with consequential relief, if any.

    (Pronounced in Court)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Indian Extrusions v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, Mumbai .
    (Mar 6, 2012)