[Order per : Mathew John, Member (T)]. - As per their ER-1 return filed by the Appellant for the month of Dec. 2006 they should have filed duty to the extent of Rs. 16,12,837/- in PLA or in cash under a TR-6 challan by the due date i.e. 5-1-2007. They did not do so. Neither did they pay it with interest, within 30 days from the due date as provided in Rule 8(3A) of the Central Excise Rules, 2002.
2. In such circumstances Rule 8(3A) of the Central Excise Rules enjoins certain penal consequences. For the sake of convenience this sub-rule is re-produced below.
(3A) If the assessee defaults in payment of duty beyond thirty days from the due date, as prescribed in sub-rule (1), then notwithstanding anything contained in said sub-rule (1) and sub-rule (4) of Rule 3 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, the assessee shall, pay excise duty for each consignment at the time of removal, without utilizing the CENVAT credit till the date the assessee pays the outstanding amount including interest thereon; and in the event of any failure, it shall be deemed that such goods have been cleared without payment of duty and the consequences and penalties as provided in these rules shall follow.
3. The Appellant paid the duty defaulted along with interest, in three instalments and the final date on which the due to the government along with applicable interest was paid was 20-4-2007. Thus the Appellant was a defaulter from 6-2-2007 to 20-4-2007. This period is hereinafter referred to as “defaulting period”.
4. The case made out by revenue is that during the defaulting period the Appellants were required to pay duty on each consignment without availing Cenvat credit as required under sub-rule (3A) of Rule 8. This was not done. They continued to pay duty from Cenvat credit. So it is alleged that the clearances made during the defaulting period were without proper discharge of duty amounting to Rs. 21,17,829/, that is, the amount of Cenvat credit utilized during the said period.
5. A Show Cause Notice in respect of the above contravention of Rules was issued which was adjudicated resulting in confirmation of duty demanded amounting Rs. 21,17,829/- under Section 11A of the Act. As already explained this amount corresponds to Cenvat credit utilized by the Appellants during the defaulting period. Interest under Section 11AB was also demanded. A penalty of Rs. 5,00,000/- under Rule 25 of Central Excise Rules, 2002 was also imposed.
6. Aggrieved by this order the Appellant has filed this appeal before the Tribunal.
7. The Appellants submits the following :
(i) They are willing to pay duty in PLA provided the amount paid using Cenvat Credit during the defaulting period is allowed to be re-credited in their Cenvat Account.
(ii) They are willing to pay interest on duty payable on the clearances made during the defaulting period till the date on which they paid all the defaulted amount.
(iii) The question whether penalty under Rule 25 could be imposed under such circumstances was examined by the Gujarat High Court in CCE v. Saurashtra Cement Ltd. - and it was decided that penalty under Rule 27 only could be imposed in such cases.
8. It is to be noted that in Rule 8(3A) there is no ban on taking of credit. There is a ban only on utilization of Cenvat Credit for payment of duty. Now the fact to be noticed is that the adjudication order does not deal with the Cenvat credit utilized during the defaulting period for payment of the duty due on the goods, though such utilization is in contravention of the provisions of Rule 8(3A). If duty as demanded in the adjudication order is also to be paid (in cash) and if thereafter the amount utilized in Cenvat credit is not refunded, there is double payment of duty on the same goods. There is no authority under law for collection of duty twice.
9. At this stage it is necessary to revisit the provisions of Rule 8(3A). The Rule stipulates two things namely-
(i) duty should be paid on each consignment during the period of default as against payment at month end which is permissible under Rule 8(1) if there is no such default.
(ii) the duty should be paid without availing Cenvat credit whereas duty payment through Cenvat is allowed if default was not there.
The Appellant did not comply with either of the requirements.
10. Now we have to look at the penal consequences prescribed by Rule 8(3A). The Rule says that if the above two conditions are not complied with “it shall be deemed that such goods have been cleared without payment of duty and the consequences and penalties as provided in these rules shall follow”.
11. It is relevant to note that what is prescribed is “the consequences and penalties as provided in these Rules” not “consequences and penalties as provided in the Act”. Before deciding this issue let us examine what are the consequences of clearances without payment of duty prescribed under the Act and the Rules. These are,-
(i) Action under Section 11A for the recovery of the amount and interest payable
(ii) Interest will have to be paid under Section 11AB;
(iii) Penalty will be payable under Section 11AC;
(iv) Goods will be liable to confiscation by virtue of provisions made under Section 12.
(i) Confiscation of goods and penalty under Rule 25 of the Rules.
(ii) Penalty under Rule 25, 26 or 27 as is applicable will have to be paid.
12. If there is no payment of duty then consequences under the Act will follow and it does not have to be stated in the Rules. If the payment is not in conformity with the provisions of Rule 8(3A) only consequences under the Rules will follow.
13. It is also relevant to note that even the consequence under the Act are that duty will have to be paid, interest will have to be paid, penalty will have to be paid and goods are liable to confiscation. In fact there is nothing in the Act which will bar payment of such short paid duty from Cenvat credit. Once the Act and Rule 8(3A) are read together a harmonious interpretation will be that during the period of default, payment through Cenvat credit will not be due discharge of duty. Interest will be payable so long as there is no proper discharge of duty. This is a consequence from Act but that will follow even if it is not mentioned in the Rules. That is to say duty paid during the defaulting period will be proper discharge once the default in payment from PLA, for the month of Dec. 2006 in this case, is made good and applicable interest is paid. With the result the only consequence that arises in this case is payment of interest and penalty. But interest will be payable from the date of each clearance to the date on which the default is made good that is 20-4-2007. This is so because once the defaulted amount is paid, thereafter the payment made through Cenvat become proper even if it is paid before the date on which defaulted amount is paid. So we do not find it necessary to ask the Appellant to pay duty in cash and take re-credit of equivalent amount debited in Cenvat Credit account earlier.
14. Rule 8(3A) prescribes only consequences mentioned in the Rules. As already discussed the consequences prescribed are confiscation of goods and penalties under Rule 25, Rule 26 or Rule 27. The issue as to which penalty will apply has been examined by the Gujarat High Court in CCE v. Saurashtra Cement Ltd. - (Guj.) and it has been decided that penalty under Rule 27 only can be imposed
15. In view of the position as explained we hold that there is no case for demanding the duty paid through Cenvat credit to be paid again through cash/PLA. Penalty under Rule 27 will have to be paid. So we order that the Appellant shall pay penalty of Rs. 5000/- under Rule 27 of the Rules.
16. The Appeal is disposed of accordingly.
(Pronounced in Court)