[Order per : Archana Wadhwa, Member (J)]. - Appellant are engaged in manufacture of cement and cement clinker. Inasmuch as the cement clinker was being used by appellant captively for the manufacture of cement, the same was exempted in terms of provisions of Notification No. 67/95, dated 16-3-95, as long as the final product cement was chargeable to duty. However, during the period involved in present appeal, cement was cleared at Nil rate of duty in terms of provisions of Notification No. 2/2001, dated 27-1-01 and Notification No. 16/01 dated 26-3-01. In as much as the final product became exempted, the exemption in terms of Notification No. 67/95, was no longer available to the cement clinker. Accordingly, the authorities below raised the demand of duty Rs. 17,97,495/- against the appellant and also imposed personal penalty of Rs. 5 lakhs. The said order passed by the original adjudicating authority was confirmed by Commissioner (Appeals) with reduction of penalty from Rs. 5 lakhs to Rs. 50,000/-.
2. It is seen that Notification No. 67/95 was amended vide another Notification No. 31/01 dated 1-6-01, vide which the benefit of duty on the captively consumed inputs was allowed even if the final product was exempted from duty subject to the condition that the obligation under Rule 57AB was discharged by the manufacturer. It is the appellant’s contention that the said notification should be treated as having retrospective effect and should be made applicable to the clearances effected by the appellant during the period May 2001. The above contention of the appellant does not stand accepted by the authorities below on the ground that the notification is effective from the date of its issuance and unless there is some indication to the same being retrospective or the notification is being clarificatory in nature, the same cannot be made applicable for the past period.
3. We have heard both sides and have seen the Notification No. 67/95. The said notification provided exemption to the goods manufactured in a factory and used within the factory for the production. Proviso to the said notification was to the effect that nothing contained in the notification shall apply to the inputs used in or in relation to the manufacture of final product which are exempted from the duty of excise leviable thereon or are chargeable to ‘Nil’ rate of duty. The notification also carves out the exception to the said proviso to the effect that if the final product is cleared to a unit situated in free trade zone or a 100% export oriented undertaking or to a unit in an electronic hardware technology park, or to a unit in software technology park, or supplied to United Nations, or to an international organization for their official use or supplied to a project funded by United Nations or an international organization, the benefit would still be available to the captively consumed input even if no duty was paid on the final product. Admittedly, during the relevant period i.e. May 01, the appellant was not covered by any of the exceptions contained in the proviso to the notification. However, w.e.f. 1-6-01, vide Notification No. 31/01, another exclusion was created in the proviso by adding Sr. No. (vi). As per the appellant, they are exempted by said exclusion clause and it is therefore their contention that the benefit of the same should be made effective with retrospective date.
4. We do not find any merits in the above contention of learned Advocate. Admittedly, the scope of exclusion having been extended w.e.f. 1-6-01, it cannot be said that the said exclusion was in the notification even prior to the date of its issuance. It is well settled that a notification granting relief has to be held effective from the date of the issuance of the same and such relief provided by notification cannot be made applicable for the period prior to the issuance of the same. It may be observed here that the said amendment is not in the nature of any clarification over the ambiguous language used in the earlier un-amended notification. There is also nothing on record indicating legislative intent to grant the benefit with retrospective effect. The fiscal statues/notifications are to be interpreted on the face of the plain language used by them. Reliance by learned advocate on the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Govt. of India v. Indian Tobacco Association as reported in (S.C.) giving retrospective effect to a notification is not applicable to the facts of the present case inasmuch as the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that not giving express retrospective effect to the notification was an obvious mistake which was corrected by legislature and the substituted port was otherwise eligible for benefit and all along had been granted duty exemption and the object of Govt, was to grant the same benefit to substituted port as given to listed ports. It was in view of the peculiar background fact of that particular case that the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that notification has to be held as retrospective. As contrast to the same, there is nothing in the appeal to show that carving additional exclusion to the proviso, was in the nature of a clarification and in any case was exempted by earlier exclusion, in the said proviso. Definitely and admittedly, the said exclusion clause is a new addition to the list of exclusions provided in the proviso to the notification and cannot be held to be retrospective. For our above view, we refer to Tribunal’s decision in case of BPL Mobile Communication reported in [ (Tribunal) = 2000 (40) RLT 249] and another decision of Tribunal in case of Usha Martin Telekom Ltd. v. CCE, Calcutta reported in (Tri-Kolkata).
5. In view of above, we hold that the benefit of amendment to Notification No. 67/95 was not available to the appellant in the month of May ’01 and duty of Rs. 17,97,495 has been rightly confirmed against them. However, we do not find any justification for imposition of penalty upon the appellant inasmuch as the dispute relates to legal interpretation and there does not exist any mala fide on the part of the appellant. We, accordingly, set aside the penalty of Rs. 50,000/- imposed on the appellant.
6. Appeal is disposed off in above terms.
(Pronounced in Court on 24-4-2007)