Shaffique, J. MA No.85/2009 has been filed by the petitioner in OP No 321/2000. The OP was filed for recovery of `60,000/- advanced by him to the 2nd respondent for purchasing a property when he was working abroad. The short facts that have arisen in the case are as under:-
2. Petitioner/appellant married the 1st respondent on 2/1/1989. During the relevant time, he was working in Gulf and he used to come only occassionally. While working abroad, he used to sent money regularly to the account of the 1st respondent. It is alleged that he had sent `60,000/- to the 2nd respondent to purchase a property, which he had misappropriated. He returned from Gulf in the year 1997. In September 1997, 1 st respondent became ill on account of rheumatic fever. While she was under treatment, on 6/4/1998, 1st respondent's father took her to the parental home on Mat.Appeal Nos.85 & 86/09 -:2:- the allegation that petitioner was not giving proper treatment. Thereafter she had not returned. He filed a petition for restitution of conjugal rights as OP No. 533/1998. When the 1 st respondent expressed that she was not ready to live with the petitioner, the said petition was dismissed. Appellant also filed divorce petition as OP No.288/2000 and OP No.320/2000 to get permanent custody of the minor child. The 1st respondent wife filed OP No.471/2000 for past and future maintenance. The wife and child also filed MC No.85/2000 claiming maintenance u/s 125 of Cr.P.C.
3. All the cases were jointly heard. By a common order dated 30/9/2008, his claim for return of `60,000/- was rejected. In OP No.471/2000, past maintenance was allowed at the rate of `500/- to the 1st respondent wife and `300/- for the minor child. Future maintenance was allowed at the rate of `600/- and `400/- respectively until the date of decree and thereafter at `750/- and `500/- respectively.
4. MA No.86/2009 is filed against OP No.471/2000. As far as Mat.Appeal No. 86/2009 is concerned, the amount awarded is very meagre and there is no reason why this Court should interfere with the said order. Learned counsel for the appellant Mat.Appeal Nos.85 & 86/09 -:3:- however contended that she was not entitled for maintenance as she had deserted him and failed to perform the marital obligations. But it is relevant to note that the Court below had dissolved the marriage only on the ground that the marital relationship has become irretrievably broken and that there is no chance for a reunion. She also alleged cruelty against her husband. Under such circumstances, it cannot be stated that she was remaining away from the company of her husband without any reasonable cause. Therefore, she is entitled for maintenance.
5. As far as the minor child is concerned there cannot be any dispute regarding the obligation to pay maintenance. Mat.Appeal No. 86/2009 is therefore liable to be dismissed.
6. As far as MA No.85/2009 is concerned, the Family Court observed that even the allegations in the plaint indicates that the money was sent in the year 1992 and the OP is filed in the year 2000. It was found that there is nothing to indicate that money was sent for purchasing property. We do not think that a different view is possible taking into consideration the aforesaid facts. There is no merit in this appeal also. Mat.Appeal Nos.85 & 86/09 -:4:- Therefore, Mat.Appeal Nos.85/2009 and 86/2009 are dismissed. No order as to costs. Sd/- A.M. SHAFFIQUE, JUDGE Sd/- P.SOMARAJAN, JUDGE //True Copy// PS to Judge