1. We have the presence of the Learned Counsel for the State of Punjab and also the concessioner who are present in terms of our direction issued on 31st May, 2017 which was reiterated on 3rd June, 2017.
2. Learned Counsel Mr. Manoj K. Singh reports the presence of Mr. Umesh Chopra. It is submitted that he has not received copy of the joint inspection report. Learned Counsel for the State of Punjab submits that the concessioner need not be heard as he has no role in the present proceedings.
3. It is difficult to appreciate the submission for the reason that the report filed by the State of Punjab conducted by the Advisory Committee constituted by the Tribunal directly indicts the concessioner for violation of the terms and condition which are under agreement.
4. In the circumstances, we direct copy of the report be furnished to the Concessioner who shall file written statement meeting the indictment in the report and also make such statement as may be necessary. We grant two weeks time to do the needful.