Shri N.S Saini, A.M:— This is an appeal filed by the Revenue against the order of Ld. CIT(A)-I dated 20.03.2008
2. The sole issue involved in this appeal is that the Ld. CIT(A) erred in deleting the penalty of Rs. 5,25,33,000/- levied u/s. 271(c) of the Act.
3. The facts of the case are that the assessee company is a manufacturer of detergent powder and allied products. Initially the assessment order in this case was passed on 31/3/03 u/s. 143(3) at a total income of Rs. 1,57,65,29,678-. Subsequently, a notice u/s. 148 dated 31/3/04 was issued and on this basis, assessment u/s. 143(3) r.w.s 147 of the I.T Act was passed on 23/3/05 at a total income of Rs. 1,70,41,30,474/-. In the assessment order, disallowance of Rs. 13,64,43,850/- was made on account of claim of deduction u/s. 80-IA/80-IB in respect of Trikampura Division. The Ld. CIT(A) dismissed the appeal of the appellant against this order vide his order dated 8/2/06 against which the appellant went in appeal to ITAT, which is pending for decision. Meanwhile, it is on the basis of this assessment that penalty u/s. 271(1)(c) has been levied by the Assessing Officer on 23/3/07. While levying the penalty, the Assessing Officer has also invoked explanation-1 of section 271(1)(c) in para 5 of his penalty order. It is this penalty order, which is the subject matter of appeal under the present proceedings.
4. The Ld. CIT(A) held as under:
“In ground of appeal No. 2, the appellant has disputed the levy of penalty of Rs. 5,25,33,0007/- u/s. r. 271(1)(c) in this case. The main points of argument given by the appellant in its defence are—
(a) The appellant was engaged in the manufacturer of detergent power and allied products wherein he undertook all activities except manufacturing, which was got done from job-workers. The appellant was under bonafide belief that the deduction u/s. 80-1 A was available to him even if the goods were not manufactured by the appellant company itself.
(b) There was no concealment or furnishing of inaccurate particulars-real or deemed. All the basic and primary facts were disclosed by way of Note No. 2 forming part of return of income about calculation of deduction which reads as under:
“Deduction u/s. 80-1 & 80-1A is leviable as per calculation given in the income of the respective units. Depreciation is claimed after excluding other incomes as mentioned in the calculation.”
Therefore, the appellant was not caught by the mischief of Explanation-I below section 271(l.)(c).
(c) According to the appellant, there is only a difference of opinion regarding the allowability of deduction u/s. 80-IA/80-IB, so much so that the A.O as also the CIT(A) have analyzed and either applied of distinguished a number of reported-decisions. Thus, according to the appellant, there is a legal controversy for which there are two views possible. In such a situation, when the appellant company has not concealed particulars of income and the addition has been made because of difference of opinion, the penalty u/s. 271(1)(c) is not leviable in the case of the assessee. In support of this contention, it relied on three court decisions, which are reproduced as under.
(i) National Textiles v. CIT (2001) 249 ITR 125 (Guj.)
It has been held that when there are more than one views possible on the same set of facts, no penalty under Sec. 271(1)(c) of the Act can be levied.
(ii) Sarabhai Chemicals P. Ltd. v. CIT Tax. (2002) 257 ITR 355 (Guj.)
“When the full facts are narrated and categorically stated in the return of income itself, there cannot be any concealment or furnishing of inaccurate particulars of income more so when ratio of decision of Hon'ble Jurisdictional High Court is followed.”
(iii) K.C Builders v. ACIT (2004) 265 ITR 562 (S.C)
“The Appellant further submits that even after the amendment w.e.f 1.4.1976 the omission of the word “deliberately” from the language of Sec. 271(1)(c) of the Act, it has still to be provided that the concealing of particulars of income or furnishing inaccurate particulars of income was a deliberate act on the part of the assessee and the same has resulted into tax avoidance on the part of the assessee. This view is supported by the decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of K.C Builders. Relevant extract of the same is reproduced hereinbelow”.
(d) He has farther quoted judgement of Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the case of Penwalt India Ltd. 196 ITR 813 which, held that deduction u/s. 80-1A is available even when goods got manufactured by the outsiders.
(e) The appellant also submitted that mere disallowance of deduction u/s. 80-1A cannot make a ground for levy of penalty u/s. 271(1)(c). In support of this contention, the appellant relied on the following 12 cases:
i.
Navjivan Oil Mills v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax
252 ITR 417 (Guj.)
ii.
CIT v. B.S Badve
138 ITR 682 (Bom)
iii.
Sohanlal Sangi v. ACIT
125 ITR 184 (M.P)
iv.
Addl. CIT v. Agarwal Mistan Bhandar
131 ITR 619 (Raj)
v.
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. J.K.A Rajappa Chettiar
153 ITR 215 (Mad.)
vi.
Alyanbi Enterprises v. ACIT
83 ITD 764
vii.
CIT v. Baroda Tin Works
221 ITR 661 (Guj.)
viii.
Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills Co. v. State of U.P
118 ITR 326 (SC)
ix.
CIT v. Haryana Education Society
251 ITR 846 (P & H)
x.
CIT v. Ram Singhani Dall Mills
254 ITR 264 (M.P)
xi.
CIT v. Sivanand Steels Ltd.
256 ITR 683 (Mad.)
xii.
Chandrapal Bagga v. ITAT
261 ITR 67 (Raj.)
It also filed a compilation of 14 reported cases from pages 1 to 140, which included all these 12 cases and two of the three cases discussed in (c) above.
(f) The appellant also drew attention to the decision of Hon'ble Ahmedabad Tribunal in the case of Nirma Chemical Works Ltd., one of the sister concerns of the appellant company, vide appeal No. ITA/220.Ahd/2007 dated 20/8/07 for assessment year 2001-2002 wherein Hon'ble ITAT deleted the penalty, though addition was confirmed on facts.
(g) The appellant further pleaded that there were identical issues in the penalty order levied u/s. 271(1)(c) in the case of the appellant company for the A.Y 2001-2002 and the same has been deleted by CIT(A)-II/CC. 1(1)/273/06-07 dated 6/2/07. Since the case under consideration has identical facts, the penalty levied u/s. 271(1)(c) for the year under consideration should also be deleted.
(h) The appellant has also pleaded that the decisions referred to in the penalty order are not applicable to the facts and circumstances of the appellant's case.
7.1 I have carefully considered the contention of the appellant and have also gone through the written submissions filed by the appellant. I have also considered the case records as also the judgments relied upon by the appellant.
7.2 The appellant has referred to many cases. For a better perspective, it will be in the fitness of things to discus them in brief as under:
(a) K.C Builders v. ACIT (265 ITR 562) (SC):
Head note-Word and phrases-“concealment”, meaning of:
“Concealment’ inherently carries with it the element of mens rea. The fact that some figure or some particulars have been disclosed, even if it takes out the case from non-disclosure, would not by itself take the case out of the purview of furnishing inaccurate particulars. Mere omission from the return of an item of receipt amounts neither to concealment nor to deliberate furnishing of inaccurate particulars of income, unless and until there is some evidence to show or circumstances are found from which it can be gathered that the omission was attributable to an intention or desire on the part of the assessee to hide or conceal the income so as to avoid imposition of tax thereon.”
(b) Kalyanbi Enterprises v. ACIT (83 ITD 764):
In this case the Department's allegation was that the vehicle on which depreciation was claimed could not have been put to use on or before 30th March 1989 and, therefore claim of depreciation on that vehicle for A.Y 1989-1990 was disallowed and the assessee did not file appeal against the same. The Department levied penalty and the Tribunal deleted it observing that though the assessee had not filed appeal against the quantum assessment, it would not be correct to hold that the assessee had accepted the finding of the appellate authority that the vehicle had not been used for the purpose of the business during the year. In the Circumstances of the present case, it could not be held that the failure on the part of the assessee to return the correct income for the assessment year 1989-1990 had arisen from any fraud, or gross, or-wilful neglect. It was a legal stand taken by the assessee that even when the vehicle was running from Indore to Coimbatore after the purchase, it was running for the purpose of the assessee's business and so it was entitled to the allowance of depreciation. The rejection of the contentions raised by the assessee cannot lead to the conclusion that there has been any concealment of the particular of income or that, the assessee has furnished inaccurate particulars of its income. Having regard to the facts of the present case and the judicial decisions on the subject of concealment of Income, the Assessing Officer was not justified in levying the penalty on the ground that by making the claim for the allowance of depreciation on the vehicle purchased on 30/3/1989 and running far the assessee's purpose, it was making a false claim of depreciation. The Commissioner (Appeals) was not correct in upholding the levy of penalty in the instant case
(c) CIT v. Baroda Tin Works (221 ITR 661) (Guj.):
Assessment year was 1971-1972 and it was held that the Explanation to section 271(1)(c) which was inserted w.e.f 1.4.1-976 was not applicable and hence even when income returned was less than 80% of the assessed income penalty was not leviable because Tribunal had given a finding that the initial presumption of concealment was successfully rebutted by the assessee.
(d) CIT v. National Textiles (249 ITR 125 (Guj.):
The assessment year involved was 1974-1975 and squared up cash credits in the range of Rs. 5000 to Rs. 5500 appeared in the books totalling Rs. 90,000. Assessee had claimed that they represented interest free loans. It was held that there were no circumstances to lead a reasonable and positive inference that the explanation that cash credits were arranged as temporary loan was false. It was held that the facts and circumstances were equally consistent with the hypothesis that they could have been sundry loans obtained from different parties. Therefore, the imposition of penalty was not justified.
The court adjudicated as under;
“In order to justify the levy of penalty, two factors must co-exist, (i) there must be some material or circumstances leading to the reasonable conclusion that the amount represents the assessee's income. It is not enough for the purpose of penalty that the amount has been assessed as income and (ii) the circumstances must show that there was conscious concealment or act of furnishing of inaccurate particulars on the part of the assessee. It further clarifies that Explanation-1 to section 271(1)(c) has no bearing on factor No. 1, but has a bearing on factor No. 2. The Explanation does not make the assessment order conclusive evidence that the amount assessed was in fact the income of the assessee. No penalty can be imposed if the facts and circumstances are equally consistent with the hypothesis that the amount does not represent concealed income with the hypothesis that it does. If the assessee gives an explanation which is unproved but not disproved, i.e, it is not accepted but circumstances do not lead to the reasonable and positive inference that the assessee's case is false, the Explanation cannot help the Department because there will be no material to show that the amount in question was the income of the assessee. Alternatively, treating the Explanation as dealing with, both the ingredients (i) and (ii) above, where the circumstances do not lead to the reasonable and positive inference that the assessee's explanation is false, the assessee must be held to have proved that there was no mens rea or guilty mind on his part. Even in thin view of the matter the Explanation alone cannot justify levy of penalty. Absence of proof acceptable to the Department cannot be equated with fraud or wilful default.
(e) Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills Co, v. State of U.P (118 ITR 326) (SC):
This, decision is on the aspect of promissory estoppel and hence, not relatable to the appellant's case.”
(f) CIT v. Haryana Education Society (251 ITR 846) (P&H):
Head notes on page 847 give the gist of the case as under:
“The Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) had found in relation to the assessment years 1986-1987 and 1987-1988 that actual payment of house tax was made and the claim was made bona fide for deduction and such-claim would not amount to concealment for the purpose of penalty under section 271(1)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The penalty was cancelled: Penalty for the assessment years 1988-1989 and 1989-1990 was cancelled by the Tribunal for the same reason. On appeal:
Held, that once the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) had accepted the explanation given by the assessee in respect of the allegation of concealment of income, there was no scope for interference by the court.
(g) CIT v. Ram Sirighani Dall Mills (254 ITR 264) (MP):
In this case for A.Y 1979-1980, the dispute was about the claim for sales-tax in respect of which penalty u/s. 271(1)(c) was levied on the ground that the assessee had wrongly claimed the deduction of Sales Tax which, amounted to concealment. The High Court decided as under:
“Before initiating penalty proceedings under section 271(1)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the authority concerned has primarily to see the nature of the concealment, the explanation offered by the assessee, his conduct, etc. These are essentiality the matters to be gone into. Once these are examined-within a view to finding out whether penalty should be imposed, the issue comes to an end.
Held, that in the case of concealment of income whether to accept the explanation offered by the assessee or not was essentially on facts. The Tribunal had examined the entire facts and then came to a conclusion that no case of concealment was made out. Thus, no question of law arose out of its order:
(h) CIT v. Sivanand Steels Ltd. (256 ITR 264) (MP):
In this case based on some High Court decision assessee had claimed depreciation and investment allowance on newly installed machinery and that claim was withdrawn subsequently. It was held that it was not a fit case for penalty u/s. 271(1)(c). The catch-words read as under:
“PENALTY LEVIED ON GROUND OF DELIBERATE FURNISHING OF INACCURATE PARTICULARS IN ORIGINAL RETURN-NO FINDING THAT CLAIM WAS MALA FIDE-TWO OPINIONS ON QUESTION COULD EXIST-SUBSEQUENT WLTHDRAWAL DID NOT AMOUNT TO DELIBERATE FURNISHING OF INACCURATE PARTICULARS IN ORIGINAL RETURN-TRIBUNAL CANCELLING PENALTY-JUSTIFIED-INCOME-TAX ACT, 1961, S. 271(1)(C).”
(i) Chandrapal Bagga v. ITAT 261 ITR 67 (Raj.):
Relevant parts of the headnotes on page 67 read as follows:
“The assessee, an individual, had sold immovable properly in the accounting year relevant to the assessment year 1992-1993. He filed-a revised return but claimed that capital gains tax was not payable because it was long-term capital gain and the assessee had purchased a new property within six months against the consideration received on the sale of his house property on April 26, 1991. The Assessing Officer did not accept this explanation and taxed the difference of Rs. 1,40,000 as short term capital gain. No appeal was preferred and the addition had become final. Thereafter, the Assessing Officer initiated the penalty proceedings under section 271(1)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and levied penalty. The Tribunal reduced the penalty. On further appeal to the High Court:
Held that the assessee had shown “long-term capital gain” and claimed exemption, but the transaction had been disclosed in the return. There was no concealment of income and penalty could not be imposed.”
(j) Navjivan Oil Mills v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax 252 ITR 417 (Guj.):
In that case for A.Y 1972-1973 on the basis of some materials seized by the Sales-tax Department, the Assessing Officer estimated unaccounted sales and profit thereof but in the proceedings u/s. 271(1)(c) it was held that addition made on the basis of such estimate could not be said to result in a situation where it would be possible to ascribe the failure to return the correct income to the assessee on account of any fraud or any gross or willful neglect.
(k) CIT v. B.S Badve (138 ITR 682) (Bom.):
In the case, return was filed on the basis of estimates on which, modest additions were made by the A.O Concealment penalty was not found valid by the court. The Catch-word notes of the case are as follows:
“PENALTY-CONCEALMENT OF INCOME-ACCOUNT BOOKS DESTROYED BY FIRE-BOOKS NOT MAINTAINED THEREAFTER-RETURNS FILED ON BASIS OF ESTIMATES-MODEST ADDITIONS MADE BY ITO TO ESTIMATES OF INCOME-NO FINDING THAT ESTIMATES WERE FRAUDULENT OR THERE WAS DELIBERATE UNDERESTIMATION OF INCOME-LEVY OF PENALTY NOT VALID-INCOME-TAX ACT, 1961, S. 271(1)(C), EXPLN.
(1) Sohanlal Sangi v. ACIT (125 ITR 184) (MP):
Catchword notes are as follows:
“PENALTY-CONCEALMENT OF INCOME-TRANSPORT BUSINESS-ASSESSMENT YEAR 1959-1960-OVERWRITING IN DAILY COLLECTION SHEETS-ADDITION TO INCOME MADE ON ESTIMATE BASIS-NO MATERIAL TO SHOW THAT OVERWRITING WAS DONE BY ASSESSEE OR UNDER HIS AUTHORITY-NO DELIBERATE OR CONSCIOUS CONCEALMENT OF INCOME-IMPOSITION OF PENALTY NOT VALID-INCOME-TAX ACT, 1961, S, 271(1)(C).”
(m) Addl. CIT v. Agarwal Mistan Bhandar (131 ITR 619) (Raj.):
Catchword notes of the case are as under:
“PENALTY-CONCEALMENT OF INCOME-ASSESSEE, A-SMALL TRADER, DOING HALWAI BUSINESS-NET PROFIT DECLARED VERY LOW-ESTIMATED HIGHER ASSESSMENT MADE BY ITO ACCEPTED BY ASSESSEE TO AVOID DISPUTES. BY WAY QF APPEALS, PENALTIES, ETC.-TRIBUNAL FINDING THAT SUCH BOOKS OF ACCOUNT AS WERE POSSIBLE OR PRACTICABLE IN SUCH BUSINESS WAS MAINTAJNED-NO MANIPULATION OR OTHER INDICATION OF CONCEALMENT OF INCOME POINTED OUT BY DEPARTMENT-CO-OPERATION EXTENDED IN COMPLETING ASSESSMENT DOES NOT AMOUNT TO CONFESSION OF CONCEALMENT OF INCOME-LEVY OF PENALTY NOT VALID-INCOME-TAX ACT 1961, S. 2710)(C).”
(n) Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. J.K.A Rajappa Chettiar (153 ITR 215) (Mad.):
Assessment years involved were 1963-1964 and 1964-1965. Catchword notes are as follows:
“PENALTY-SALE OF ACTUAL USER‘S LICENCE FOR IMPORT OF ART-SILK YARN AT PROFIT-ACCOUNTS. MAINTAINED ON BASIS OF IMPORT OF YARN, MANUFACTURE OF TEXTILES AND SALE OF TEXTILES-RETURN OF INCOME FILED ON THAT BASIS-ASSESSEE MAKING VOLUNTARY DISCLOSURE-FILING OF REVISED RETURNS SHOWING HIGHER INCOME ON BASIS OF SALE, OF LICENCES-ASSESSMENT ON BASIS OF REVISED RETURN ON ESTIMATE-NO CONCEALMENT IN COURSE OF ASSESSMENT PROCEEDINGS-LEVY OF PENALTY FOR CONCEALMENT NOT JUSTIFIED-INCOME-TAX ACT, 1961, SS. 271(1)(C), 277-FINANCEACT, 1965, S. 68.”
(o) Sarabhai Chemicals P. Ltd. v. CIT (2002) 257 ITR 355 (Guj.)
“When the full facts are narrated and categorically stated in the return of income itself, there cannot be any concealment or furnishing of inaccurate particulars of income more so when ratio of decision of Hon'ble Jurisdictional High Court is followed.”
7.3 From the case laws, discussed above and others relied upon by the appellant, the following points emerge:
a) Mere on the basis of addition, estimated or otherwise, the concealment penalty cannot be levied.
b) The concealment penalty is not justified even in a case where the quantum addition has been confirmed by the appellate authority.
c) The concealment penalty also cannot be justified merely because the assessee did not go in appeal against an assessment order or against an appellate order in the quantum appeal.
d) The concealment penalty cannot be levied when a deduction claimed by the assessee is not allowed by the A.O
e) The concealment penalty is not leviable when there is difference of opinion with regard to a deduction, which the assessee may claim, considering it allowable while the A.O may reject it, not accepting the view of the assessee.
7.4.1 The adjudication of the Courts, particularly of jurisdictional Gujarat High Court, in the case of National Textiles referred to (supra) has laid down specifically the two prima facie important conditions to be fulfilled for levying concealment penalty u/s. 271(1)(c) viz.
i) There must be some material or circumstances leading to the reasonable conclusion that the amount represents the assessee's income. It is not enough for the purpose of penalty that the amount has been assessed as income.
ii) The circumstances must show that there was conscious concealment or act of furnishing of inaccurate particulars on the part of the assessee. It further clarifies that Explanation-1 to section 271(1)(c) has no bearing on factor No. 1, but has a bearing on factor No. 2.’
7.4.2 In the case under consideration, the appellant, has claimed, deduction u/s. 80-I/A/80-1/B for Trikumpura division. The A.O disallowed the claim by not accepting the appellant's claim and the CTT(A) confirmed the same, taking recourse to different reported case laws. The appellant has not concealed the fact of the claim, the same has been disallowed because of difference of opinion about its allowability. Hence, there is nothing to show that there is any conscious concealment or act of furnishing inaccurate particulars on the part of the appellant. Consequently, since the appellant has not concealed the primary facts and the addition has resulted only because of legal controversy, the appellant does not become liable for the levy of concealment penalty. The case of the appellant does not get covered by Explanation-1 to section 271(1)(c) because it cannot be regarded as consciously concealing, the facts or furnishing inaccurate particulars-real or deemed.
7.5 The fact that CIT(A) has confirmed the quantum addition also does not make it a case of levying concealment penalty. In the case of Nirma Chemicals for the A.Y 2001-2002, one of the sister concerns of the assessee company, ITAT has deleted the penalty though it confirmed the quantum addition.
7.6 Further, as pointed out by the appellant, penalty u/s. 271(1)(c) was also levied in the case of the appellant on identical issue for the A.Y 2001-2002. Vide appeal order No. CIT(A)-II/CC. 1(1)7273/06-07 in that year, the CIT(A) deleted the penalty holding that there was no concealment or furnishing of inaccurate particulars, either real or deemed, as all’ primary facts were disclosed and the addition was made only because of difference of opinion in the sense that the assessee thought it was entitled to such deduction and the A.O and the CIT(A) thought otherwise. Since the facts of the case are identical, there is nothing for me to differ from the conclusion drawn by the CIT(A) in this regard.
7.7 In view of the discussion above, I hold that there is no concealment of primary facts on the part of the appellant. There is denial of the deduction claimed merely on the basis of difference of opinion which cannot support levying of the penalty u/s. 271(1)(c). The penalty order I, therefore, cancelled.”
5. The Ld. DR supported the order of the Assessing Officer whereas the Ld. AR relied on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Mak Data Private Limited v. Commissioner Of Income Tax-Ii . (2013) 38 taxmann.com 448 (SC).
6. We have heard the rival submissions and perused the orders of lower authorities and material available on record. In the instant case, the assessee claimed deduction u/s. 80IA for Rs. 13,64,48,850/- in respect of Trikampura Division. The same was disallowed by the Assessing Officer and the appeal of the assessee before the Ld. CIT(A) against such disallowance was dismissed by the Ld. CIT(A) vide order dated 08.02.2006
7. Thereafter, the Assessing Officer levied penalty u/s. 271(1)(c) of the Act on the ground of concealment of particulars of income by the assessee for Rs. 5,25,32,807/- being 100% of the amount of tax sought to be evaded.
8. The assessee filed appeal before the Ld. CIT(A) and submitted that the assessee has not concealed any particulars of its income. The claim for deduction u/s. 80IA was made in the return of income filed by the assessee which was disallowed because of difference of opinion about its allowability by the Assessing Officer. Thus, there is no conscious concealment or act of furnishing inaccurate particulars of income by the assessee.
9. The Ld. CIT(A) held that in his view, there was no concealment of primary facts on part of the assessee. There is denial of the deduction claimed merely on the basis of difference of opinion which cannot support the levying of penalty u/s. 271(1)(c) and cancelled the penalty order.
10. Being aggrieved against the said order of the Ld. CIT(A), the Revenue is in appeal before us.
11. The Ld. DR has supported the order of the Assessing Officer.
12. The Ld. AR supported the order of the Ld. CIT(A).
13. After considering the rival submissions and perusing the orders of lower authorities and material available on record, we find that the Ld. DR could not point out any specific error in the findings of the Ld. CIT(A). The order of the Ld. CIT(A) is in conformity with the view of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT v. Reliance Petroproducts (P) Ltd. (2010) 322 ITR 158 (SC) wherein it was held that a mere making of a claim which is not sustainable in law, by itself, will not amount to furnishing inaccurate particulars.
14. We, therefore, do not find any good reason to interfere with the order of the Ld. CIT(A) which is confirmed and the ground of the Revenue is dismissed.
15. In the result, the appeal of the Revenue is dismissed.