Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • u/s 143 (3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961
  • u/s 271(1)(c) of Income tax Act 1961
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • u/s 143 (3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961
  • u/s 271(1)(c) of Income tax Act 1961
Smart Summary

Tribunal Opinion Summarized — Key Elements from the Provided Text

Factual and Procedural Background

The Revenue filed an appeal against the order dated 20.01.2012 of the CIT(A)-XXXI, New Delhi, relating to the assessment year 2007-08. The Assessing Officer (AO) made an addition of Rs. 1,54,38,601 to the assessee's income by disallowing amounts claimed as compensation (treating them as capital / purchase consideration rather than revenue expenditure). The AO recorded that these payments represented amounts to re-acquire rights in allotted plots and therefore should be capitalized; penalty proceedings under section 271(1)(c) were initiated.

The assessee contested the AO's disallowance before the CIT(A), presenting detailed breakup of the Rs. 1,54,38,601 and arguing that the amounts were compensatory payments made as a matter of business exigency and had been treated as revenue expenditure in earlier years. The CIT(A) accepted the assessee's claim, relying on factual findings and a precedent (Sasun J. David & Co. Pvt. Ltd. 118 ITR 261), and allowed the deduction.

The Revenue appealed to the Tribunal. At the Tribunal, the parties filed submissions (including references to prior ITAT orders involving Vatika Township Pvt. Ltd.). The Tribunal examined whether the CIT(A)'s allowance properly rested on the factual record and whether full evidence had been considered. The Tribunal ultimately restored the matter to the file of the CIT(A) for further factual scrutiny and directed the CIT(A) to pass a speaking order after confronting the AO with all evidence. The appeal of the Revenue was allowed for statistical purposes. The order was pronounced on 12th December 2014.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the compensation payments made by the assessee for revocation/cancellation of plot allotments (totaling Rs. 1,54,38,601) constitute revenue expenditure allowable as deduction from business income, or are capital in nature and therefore not deductible.
  2. Whether the appellate officer (CIT(A)) erred in allowing the expenditure without adequately considering and verifying all relevant evidence and documents on the factual matrix of the case.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments (before CIT(A) and represented before the Tribunal)

  • The AO had used rounded figures from the balance sheet; the correct claim was Rs. 1,54,38,601 with a detailed breakup provided by the assessee (items listed and amounts for individual customers).
  • The amounts were compensatory payments to customers who had booked plots and whose advances had been utilized by the assessee for business purposes; these payments were shown in the books under "advances" and were paid as a commercial/commercial-exigency measure when the assessee could not honor the commitments.
  • Such compensation payments had been claimed as expenses since assessment year 1995-96 and had, in many years, been allowed; the assessee invoked the principle of consistency and relied on past acceptance of similar claims.
  • One component (Rs. 3,00,000) arose from a double booking of the same area by mistake, damaging the builder's reputation and necessitating payment to one of the parties.
  • The assessee placed on record some documents evidencing payments and cancellations and submitted that the practice and accounting treatment (recording as advances and expensing when paid) were consistent.
  • Before the Tribunal, the assessee's representative (Ld. AR) relied on prior ITAT decisions (DCIT v. Vatika Township Pvt. Ltd., ITA Nos. cited) to submit that the issue was covered in the assessee's favour by earlier appellate outcomes.

Revenue's Arguments

  • The Revenue (represented by Ld. Senior DR) relied upon the assessment order: the AO's view that the payments were purchase consideration to re-acquire rights in plots and therefore capital in nature and not deductible as revenue expenditure.
  • Implicitly, the Revenue contested the CIT(A)'s allowance and contended that the disallowance by the AO was justified on the facts and legal character of the payments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sasun J. David & Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT, 118 ITR 261 Interpreting the expression "wholly & exclusively" — it does not mean "necessarily"; expenditure voluntarily incurred for promoting business and earning profits may be deductible even if not compelled. The CIT(A) relied on this Supreme Court decision to hold that the compensation payments, though voluntary and not legally compelled, could nonetheless be allowable as wholly and exclusively laid out for business and thus deductible.
DCIT v. Vatika Township Pvt. Ltd., ITA No.-1505.Del/2005 (order dated 05.10.2007) Used by the assessee's representative to demonstrate appellate history and prior treatment of similar claims (the ITAT had set aside an earlier appellate order and directed reconsideration of facts and accounting policy issues). The Tribunal record shows the Ld. AR relied on this ITAT order as part of a line of decisions in favour of the assessee on similar claims; the Tribunal noted these prior orders but ultimately remanded the matter for factual verification.
DCIT v. Vatika Township Pvt. Ltd., ITA No.-2832.Del/2012 (order dated 21.06.2013) Invoked to show that a subsequent Coordinate Bench had upheld relief granted by the CIT(A) in the second round (i.e., appellate precedent favouring the assessee). The Ld. AR relied on this order to contend that the issue was covered in the assessee's favour. The Tribunal acknowledged the past position but held that past practice/precedent could not substitute for a proper factual examination, and therefore remanded the issue to the CIT(A).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal examined both the legal posture and the factual record placed before the CIT(A). It observed that the CIT(A) had allowed the deduction partly by relying on the assessee's past practice and prior appellate outcomes (including reliance on Sasun J. David & Co. Pvt. Ltd. and past ITAT orders in the Vatika matter). The Tribunal acknowledged that the past position on identical claims could be said to favour the assessee and that the legal submissions of the assessee were, to an extent, correct.

However, the Tribunal emphasized that acceptance of past practice or reliance on earlier legal positions does not relieve the CIT(A) of the obligation to examine and verify the factual matrix of the present claim. The Tribunal noted that the CIT(A) appeared to have been "swayed by the past legal position" and had not adequately considered the facts: only "some of the documents" relating to the payments had been placed on record and considered (para 5.12 of the impugned order). The Tribunal held that the CIT(A) is required to look at the complete evidence necessary to arrive at a conclusion.

Consequently, rather than deciding the issue finally in favour of either party on the record before it, the Tribunal restored the matter to the file of the CIT(A) with specific directions:

  • The assessee is granted liberty to place all necessary evidence before the CIT(A) in support of its claim.
  • The CIT(A) shall re-examine the claim on facts, confront the evidence with the AO, and thereafter pass a speaking order in accordance with law.

The Tribunal thus treated the factual insufficiency as the core defect in the appellate decision and remanded for a factually complete adjudication, while recognizing but not being bound by prior appellate outcomes that had favoured the assessee.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Tribunal allowed the Revenue's appeal for statistical purposes and restored the issue to the CIT(A) for fresh consideration on facts.

Implications

  • Direct effect on the parties: The CIT(A)'s order allowing the deduction is not sustained at the Tribunal level; the matter is remitted to the CIT(A) who must re-examine the full factual material, confront the AO with that material, and pass a reasoned/speaking order.
  • The assessee has explicit liberty to place all necessary evidence before the CIT(A) in support of its claim.
  • The Tribunal's order does not itself decide the substantive question of whether the payments are revenue or capital in nature; it directs further factual inquiry. The opinion does not state that a new legal precedent was established; rather, it remands for factual verification despite past appellate orders favourable to the assessee.

Order pronounced on 12th December 2014 (as recorded in the provided opinion).

    Cit v. Vatika Ltd.

    Diva Singh, J.M:— This is an appeal filed by the Revenue against the order dated 20.01.2012 of the CIT(A)-XXXI, New Delhi pertaining to 2007-08 assessment year on the following grounds:—

    2. “On the fact and in the circumstances of the case, the Ld. CIT(A) has erred in law as well as in facts in deleting the addition of Rs. 1,54,38,601/- made by the Assessing Officer on account of compensation charges claimed by the assessee holding the same as revenue expenditure and as such allowable as against capital expenditure held by the Assessing Officer.”

    2. The relevant facts of the case are that the assessee returned an income of Rs. 110,82,11,014/- from the head “business & profession” which was varied to the disadvantage of the assessee by the AO after issuance of notice u/s 143(2)/142(1) etc by an amount of Rs. 1,54,38,601/- finalizing the assessment at an income of Rs. 112,36,50,014/-. The specific reasons for the addition rejecting the assessee's claim of business expenses are set out in para 4 of the assessment order. For the sake of brevity the same is reproduced hereunder:—

    4. “From above it is clear that the compensation claimed by the assessee is nothing but a purchase consideration to re-acquire the rights in the plots which have been allotted to the various customers of the assessee. As such it is a part of purchase which can only be capitalized and can never be claimed/allowed as revenue expenditure. Moreover such payments which are claimed by the assessee as compensation are not under any obligation, statutory or otherwise to pay any damage to the customers is linked with the intention of the assessee and its allottees to earn more profit in the future, which again can not be charged to its Profit and Loss Account, not being expenses or damages arising out of any statutory obligations.

    In view of the above facts, it is clear that compensation paid by the assessee towards repurchase of plots is not allowable as revenue expenditure and as such cannot be debited in Profit and Loss account rather can only be capitalized. As such the compensation paid is disallowed and added back to the income of the assessee. Penalty proceedings are initiated u/s 271(1)(c) of Income tax Act 1961 for filing inaccurate particulars of income/concealing particulars of income.”

    3. In appeal before the First Appellate Authority it was submitted that the AO has considered the figures taken from the balance sheet which are necessarily rounded off to the nearest thousand and infact the correct claim of expenses incurred and debited in the books is Rs. 1,5438,601/- which consist of the following specific amount:—

    (i) “Compensation in respect of rights in surrender of plot Pertaining to Vatika farms/Woods/Greens 1,51,38,601/- (ii) Compensation paid on account of area booked by merged Company M/s Vatika Greenfield Pvt. Ltd. 3,00,000/- 1,54,38,601/-

    3.1 The breakup of Rs. 1,54,38,601/- it was submitted consisted of the following details:—

    Name of the Customer Date of agreement of sale Consideration received between the period Date of Revocation agreement Amount Refunded Amount Received Compensation i.e Advance Refunded Umesh Malhotra 27.04.1988 1988–1989 18.07.2006 1,05,000 4,70,000 1989–1990 25,000 Vinod Kumar Rastogi 22.02.1990 1989–1990 06.10.2006 1,27,980 43,60,490 Vijay Sachdev & 30.11.1994 1994–1995 23.10.2006 1,80,000 4,32,000 Prem Sachdev & 1995–1996 1,20,000 Vikas Vig 1996–1997 40,000 Meera Mohan Sabnani & Jayshree Jain 25.03.1990 1989–1990 30.06.2006 1,10,000 14,36,104 Ram Lakhman & Company Jewellers Private Limited 28.06.1989 1989–1990 30.06.2006 1,10,000 13,09,803 1990–1991 40,000 Pooja Shyam Sabnani 07.09.1990 1990–1991 30.06.2006 1,50,000 13,74,247 Kunj Shyam Sabnani & Meera Mohan Sabnani, Gobind Khiani & Kavita Khiani 08.08.1994 1991–1992 30.06.2006 2,64,000 13,20,213 Rudhra Mercantile 28.01.1993 1991–1992 30.06.2006 50,000 8,49,094 Private Limited & Mulak 1992–1993 1,00,000 S.N Sodhi (B-247) 15.12.1989 1989–1990 26.05.2006 1,50,000 35,86,650 Rajesh Tewari & Mrs. Shukla Tewari 03.03.1988 2001-2002 08.05.2006 16.49,516 3,00,000 Total 1,54,38,601

    3.2 It was argued that the payment at times after about 10 years would show that the amounts had been paid to compensate the customers who had booked the space, area, land on paying advances which had been utilized by the assessee for the business purposes and the assessee had also shown the same under the head “advances”. It was submitted that it was not an isolated event and compensation has been paid year after year on account of commercial exigencies and for the purposes of its business. Addressing the past history it was submitted that such expenditure has been claimed as an expense from 1995–96 assessment year and has been consistently allowed and for the first time disputed in 2001-02 assessment year wherein against the appeal filed by the Revenue challenging the relief granted by the CIT(A), the issue was restored by the ITAT to the AO to consider afresh. The issue it was submitted again arose in 2005-06 and 2006-07 assessment years when the disallowance made by the AO was reversed by the CIT(A) and against this the Revenue is in appeal pending before the ITAT. Reliance was placed upon the principle of consistency on the issue deserves to be followed. It was contended that the same method of the accounting for recording the transactions as “advances” on the receipt of payment for booking space or flat has been followed and only when it could not be honoured due to inability of the assessee the assessee necessarily had to compensate the concerned parties.

    3.3 Explaining the remaining amount of Rs. 3 lacs it was explained that the very same area inadvertently was booked for two different parties. Extract of these details from para 5.9 are reproduced hereunder:—

    25th August 2001 Mr. Rajesh Tiwari S/o-Late L.N Tiwari Mrs Shukla Tiwari W/o Rajesh Tiwari Jointly/both 21st September, 2001 Mrs Shagufta Salim W/o of Mr. Mohd Salim Aisha Salim D/o of Mohammad Salim And Mohammad Abdulla S/o Mohammad Atique, jointly R/o 1177 HHH, Ballimaran, Delhi-110 006.

    3.4 The double booking it was submitted impacted the reputation of the builder. In view thereof one of the parties had to be paid. Apart from relying upon various decisions as per para 5.12 of the impugned order, the assessee is also found to have filed details of payment made by it as a compensation and also placed on record copies of some of the documents executed for payment of compensation and cancellation of bookings made by it.

    4. Considering the arguments on facts and law the CIT(A) came to the following conclusion on facts:—

    6. “Determination:

    6.1 I have considered the claim of the appellant and the contentions raised by it along with objections of the assessing officer in assessment order against allowability of such expenses. After examination of records placed before me, I find that no sale had been booked by the appellant in respect of bookings already made having cancelled. Such advances were received by the appellant since Financial Year 1988–1989 and were reflected in accounts as advance from customers. The amount of compensation was paid as a measure of business exigency and as a prudent businessman appellant had accepted the request of the intending purchaser to maintain reputation of the appellant and with mutual consent repaid the advance made along with compensation for this period. The decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Sasun J. David & Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT reported as 118 ITR 261 speaks of the expression ‘wholly & exclusively’ and it is held that the expression ‘wholly & exclusively’ does not mean ‘necessarily’. It was held that ordinarily it is for the appellant to decide whether any expenditure should be incurred in the course of its business. Such expenditure may be incurred voluntarily and without any necessity and if it is incurred for promoting the business and to earn profits, the appellant can claim deduction even though there was no compelling necessity to incur such expenditure. The fact that somebody, other than the appellant, is also benefitted by the expenditure should not come in the way of an expenditure being allowed by way of deduction under the Act, if it satisfies otherwise, the tests laid down by law.

    6.2 I have further considered that for the assessment year 2001-2002 the appellant had incurred an expenditure of Rs. 21,02,000/- in the like manner. The said claim of expenses though was disallowed by the assessing officer yet my predecessor had allowed the claim after he was satisfied that said claim of expenses incurred is an allowable business expense vide his appellate order dated 06.01.2005 in appeal number: 31/04-05. The aforesaid order was set aside in appeal by Income Tax Appellate Tribunal vide its order dated 05.10.2007 in ITA number: 1505.Del/2005 and restored the matter for fresh consideration. While setting aside the order the Tribunal directed the issue be re-examined having regard the method of accounting policy followed by appellant, method of valuation of closing stock whether consistently followed by appellant and as to whether such expense has been allowed to the appellant in earlier years. As evident from the records of the case, the method of accounting policy followed by the appellant is to claim the expenses in the year when the compensation was paid on the revocation of the agreement entered with the customers. The assessments have been framed u/s 143 (3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 from the assessment year 1995–1996 to 1998–1999 when such a claim of expense has not been disallowed by the assessing officer and thus the claim stood allowed. In so far assessments year 1999–2000 to 2000-2001 are concerned assessment were not taken up for scrutiny assessment, however the expense had been incurred in those years too. Further in assessment year 2002-2003 and 2004-2005 the assessing officer did not disallow the expense incurred. It is only in the year 2003-2004, no such expense had been incurred. Further the method of valuation of closing stock was the cost. method which did not include the amount paid as compensation which was not treated by the appellant company as the capital cost as it represented the expenses incurred on account of commercial expediency. Thus on facts I find the submissions made by appellant as recorded in para 5.5 & 5.6 convincing. I further find that the appellant has shown the income from sale of aforesaid land and had shown the income without including the aforesaid sum as cost of the land sold, thus revenue neutral.”

    4.1 Thereafter he proceeded to address the legal precedent supporting his conclusion.

    5. Aggrieved by this the Revenue is in appeal before the Tribunal.

    6. The Ld. AR relies upon the order in the case of DCIT v. Vatika Township Pvt. Ltd. in ITA No.-2832.Del/2012 dated 21.06.2013 (2001-02 assessment year) and another order dated 05.10.2007 for the very same assessment year in the case of DCIT v. Vatika Township P. Ltd. in ITA No.-1505.Del/2005. On the basis of the same it was his submission that the order of the ITAT dated 05.10.2007 which had restored the issue to the file to the CIT(A) with the direction to re-examine the same was again decided in assessee's favour and this order challenged by the Revenue was dismissed by the Co-ordinate Bench vide his order dated 21.06.2013 upholding the relief granted by the CIT(A) in the second round also. Accordingly on the basis of the same it was his submission that the issue is covered in assessee's favour.

    6.1 The Ld. AR was required to address the position of 2002-03 & 2006-07 assessment years which as per the submissions was pending before the ITAT. The Ld. AR submitted that in 2002-03 to 2004-05 assessment years the issue did not arise on account of the smallness of the amount claimed and was allowed in both these years and in 2003-04 assessment year no such expense was claimed. In 2005-06 & 2006-07 assessment years it was his submission that the issue is pending before the CIT(A) as the ITAT has restored the issue.

    7. The Ld. Sr. DR on the other hand relies upon the assessment order.

    8. We have heard the rival submissions and perused the material available on record. It is seen that the past position on identical claims can be said to be covered in assessee's favour and the arguments of the Ld. Sr. Adv. to the extent are found to be correct. It is seen that considering this past position the Ld. CIT(A) has arrived at a finding, however it is seen that the Ld. CIT(A) has been swayed by the past legal position on the issue and unfortunately has not cared to consider the same on facts. Simply because the past practice demonstrates that the assessee in its nature of business may require to compensate the parties to the extent the parties from whom advances have been received could not fulfill the commitment warranting payment of compensation does not mean that all claims without verification have to be allowed. A perusal of para 5.12 of the impugned order shows that as per assessee's submissions only “some of the documents” relatable to the issue were made available to the CIT(A) based on which finding has been arrived at. The specific para is reproduced hereunder:—

    5.12 “The appellant also filed a detail of payment made by it as compensation and also placed on record copies of some of the documents executed for payment of compensation and cancellation of bookings made by it.”

    8.1 The said approach of the CIT(A) on facts cannot be upheld. The CIT(A) is necessarily required to look at the complete evidence necessary for arriving at a conclusion. The issue accordingly is restored back to his file. The assessee is granted liberty to place all necessary evidences before the CIT(A) in support of its claim as the same evidently has not been done. The CIT(A) shall thereafter pass a speaking order in accordance with law after duly confronting the same to the AO. 9. In the result the appeal of the Revenue is allowed for statistical purposes.

    The order is pronounced in the open court on 12th of December 2014.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Cit v. Vatika Ltd.
    (Dec 12, 2014)