Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • u/s. 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961(Act)
  • s. 11(1)(a) of the IT Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • u/s. 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961(Act)
  • s. 11(1)(a) of the IT Act.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Tribunal Opinion (Rajendra, A.M.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Assessing Officer (AO) challenged the order dated 13.03.2012 of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-1, Mumbai. The assessee was a trust which filed a return declaring nil income. The assessment was finalised by the AO under section 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 on 27.12.2010 determining total income at Rs. 25,49,830/-. The AO made two principal adjustments in the assessment: (i) an addition by treating donations of Rs. 30,50,000 as receipts akin to capitation/sales of admissions and denied exemption under section 11 of the Act, and (ii) disallowance of depreciation amounting to Rs. 5.58 lakhs on the basis that allowance of depreciation would amount to a prohibited "double deduction" where application of income to acquire assets had already been allowed. The assessee appealed to the First Appellate Authority (FAA), which deleted the addition and allowed the depreciation; the AO (revenue) appealed to the Tribunal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the assessee-trust was entitled to exemption under section 11 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 in respect of the receipts described as donations (including whether such receipts amounted to capitation fees or sale of admissions)?
  2. Whether depreciation on capital assets is allowable to the trust (i.e., whether such allowance would constitute an impermissible "double deduction" when the capital expenditure had been treated as application of income), or whether depreciation may be claimed in computing the trust's income under section 11/normal commercial principles?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant / Departmental Representative (Revenue)

  • The AO (as appellant) contended that the receipts characterised as donations (Rs. 30.5 lakhs) were in substance capitation fees linked to admissions — essentially the sale of education — and therefore the trust was not carrying out charitable activities qualifying for exemption under section 11.
  • With respect to depreciation, the revenue argued that allowing depreciation in addition to having allowed the capital expenditure as application of income would amount to an impermissible double deduction; relied on precedents such as Escorts Ltd. and J.K. Synthatics to support this position.

Assessee / First Appellate Authority (FAA)

  • The FAA found there was no capitation fee scheme: out of the total donations of Rs. 30.5 lakhs only Rs. 1.98 lakhs were receipts from parents/students; the FAA held that imparting education is a charitable activity and that running courses which yield profit does not make the trust's activities non‑charitable if profits are used for the trust's objects.
  • On depreciation, the FAA noted the trust was registered under section 12A and that the AO had not disputed that the capital expenditure was for the objects of the trust; following the Bombay High Court decision in Institute of Banking Personnel Selection (Bombay) (264 ITR 110), the FAA allowed depreciation, treating so‑called double deductions as permissible in trusts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Escorts Ltd. v. Union of India (199 ITR 43) Stated (as cited by AO) that double deduction cannot be presumed if not specifically provided by law; relied upon by revenue to argue against permitting depreciation in addition to earlier application of income. The Tribunal recorded that the AO relied on Escorts but, on the depreciation point, declined to follow Escorts in view of contrary Bombay High Court authority (Institute of Banking Personnel Selection and related decisions) and therefore decided the issue against the AO.
J.K. Synthatics (65 Taxman 420) Relied upon by the AO alongside Escorts to support non-allowance of double deductions (as referred to by the AO). The Tribunal noted the AO's reliance but followed binding/precedential decisions of the Bombay High Court which supported allowance of depreciation; thus the AO's reliance on J.K. Synthatics did not prevail.
Vodithala Education Trust Society (20 SOT 353) Relied upon by the AO to deny trust benefits under section 11 on the ground that donations were for giving admissions (capitation). The Tribunal noted the AO's reliance on this authority but found the factual findings did not support capitation; the FAA and Tribunal accepted the assessee's position and applied other Supreme Court authorities instead.
Gujarat Maritime Board (295 ITR 561) Supreme Court authority relied upon to determine the charitable nature of certain activities (as applied by FAA). The Tribunal held that the principles enumerated in Gujarat Maritime Board were applicable and relied upon them (as the FAA had) to conclude the assessee carried out charitable activities and was entitled to exemption under section 11.
Surat City Gymkhana (300 ITR 214) Supreme Court authority relied upon alongside Gujarat Maritime Board to determine whether activities were charitable despite profit‑making elements. The Tribunal applied the principles from Surat City Gymkhana (as the FAA did) to uphold the exemption under section 11, concluding that the trust's activities amounted to charitable activity.
Institute of Banking Personnel Selection, Bombay (264 ITR 110) Bombay High Court decision holding that depreciation claimed by a trust could be allowed (i.e., so called double deductions are allowable in trusts) and that income of a trust is to be computed on normal commercial principles allowing normal depreciation. The FAA and the Tribunal followed this Bombay High Court decision to allow depreciation to the assessee; the Tribunal explicitly relied on this authority in deciding the depreciation issue in favour of the assessee.
CIT v. Munisuvrat Jain (1994) Tax LR 1084 (Bom) Bombay High Court reasoning that s.11 permits computation of a trust's income on commercial principles and that normal depreciation can be considered a legitimate deduction in computing real income; s.32 is not the sole source of depreciation for trusts' income computation. The Tribunal quoted and relied on this decision (as part of the line of Bombay High Court authorities) to support the view that depreciation is allowable to a trust despite prior allowance of capital expenditure as application of income.
Director of Income-tax (Exemption) v. Framjee Cawasjee Institute (1993) 109 CTR 463 (Bom) Bombay High Court authority confirming that treatment of capital expenditure as application of income in the year of acquisition does not preclude claiming depreciation in subsequent years when computing income from those assets. The Tribunal treated this decision as covering the depreciation question (question No. 2 in the quoted passage) and followed it to allow depreciation to the assessee.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal proceeded issue by issue, applying findings of fact and precedent as presented in the record.

On the exemption under section 11 (donations / alleged capitation)

  • The Tribunal noted the factual record that out of total donations of Rs. 30.5 lakhs only Rs. 1.98 lakhs were received from parents/students. The AO had not disputed that the assessee imparted education.
  • The Tribunal accepted the FAA's conclusions that imparting education falls within charitable activity under settled tax law, that running courses with profits does not make the activity non‑charitable where profits are applied to the trust's objects, and that there was no evidence of contravention of sections 11–13 by the trust.
  • Relying on the principles in the Supreme Court decisions of Gujarat Maritime Board and Surat City Gymkhana (as applied by the FAA), the Tribunal concluded the trust was carrying out charitable activities and thus entitled to exemption under section 11. Accordingly, the Tribunal confirmed the FAA's deletion of the addition relating to the donations.

On the depreciation / "double deduction" point

  • The Tribunal examined the AO's contention that allowing depreciation in addition to having treated capital expenditure as application of income would result in a prohibited double deduction and noted the AO's reliance on Escorts Ltd. and J.K. Synthatics.
  • However, the Tribunal followed binding/regional precedent of the Bombay High Court (Institute of Banking Personnel Selection; and earlier decisions such as CIT v. Munisuvrat Jain and Framjee Cawasjee Institute) which held that for trusts the income derived from assets should be computed on normal commercial principles and that normal depreciation is a legitimate deduction when computing the real income of the trust.
  • The Tribunal quoted and relied on the Bombay High Court reasoning that section 11(1)(a) and general principles permit allowance of depreciation in computing trust income even where the capital expenditure had been treated as application of income in the year of acquisition.
  • On that basis the Tribunal allowed the depreciation claim and decided the AO's ground on this issue against the revenue.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: The appeal filed by the Assessing Officer is DISMISSED; the Tribunal confirmed the order of the First Appellate Authority.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The addition of Rs. 30.50 lakhs made by the AO on the ground that donations represented capitation/sale of admissions was deleted; the trust was held to be entitled to exemption under section 11 for the relevant receipts.
  • The disallowance of depreciation of Rs. 5.58 lakhs was reversed; depreciation was allowed in computing the trust's income in accordance with Bombay High Court precedent relied upon by the FAA and Tribunal.

The opinion does not discuss broader legal implications beyond the effect on the parties; the Tribunal applied existing Supreme Court and Bombay High Court authorities to the facts and did not purport to lay down new precedent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Adit v. St. Francis Educational Trust

    Rajendra, A.M:— Challenging the order dtd. 13.03.2012 of the CIT(A)-1, Mumbai, Assessing Officer (AO) has raised following grounds of appeal:

    1. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) was right in holding that the assessee is entitled to exemption u/s. 11 of the I.T Act, 1961.

    2. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Hon'ble High Court was right in ignoring the ratio of Hon'ble Supreme Court judgments in the case of Escorts Ltd. v. Union of India (199 ITR 43) wherein Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that double deduction cannot be presumed if the same is not specifically provided by law, in addition to normal deduction.

    3. The Appellant prays that the order of the Ld. CIT(A)-1, Mumbai be set aside and that of the Assessing Officer be restored.

    4. The Appellant craves leave to amend or alter nay ground or add a new ground which may be necessary.

    2. Assessee-trust filed its return of income on declaring nil income. Assessment was finalised by the AO u/s. 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961(Act) on 27.12.2010 determining the total income at Rs. 25,49,830/-. First ground of appeal is about deletion of addition made by the AO under the head donation amounting to Rs. 30.5 lakhs. During the assessment proceedings AO found that assessee had received donation amounting to Rs. 30,50,000/-. He directed the assessee to file explanation in this regard. After considering the reply of the assessee he held that trust was taking donations for giving admissions in the school, that it amounted to selling of education, that assessee was not entitled to benefits of exemption u/s. 11 of the Act, that assessee was not carrying charitable activities. Relying on the case of Vodithala Education Trust Society (20 SOT 353) he denied the trust benefits of section 11 of the Act.

    2.1 Assessee preferred an appeal before the First Appellate Authority (FAA). After considering the submissions of the assessee and the assessment order he held that assessee was not collecting capitation fees, that out of total donation a sum of Rs. 1.98 lakhs was received from the parents of the students, that finding given by the AO were against the provisions of law, that imparting education was part of charitable activities, that running of courses resulting in profit did not make the activities of the trust non charitable, that profits earned were utilised for the objects of the of the trust, that AO had not pointed out even a single instance about contravention of the provisions of sections 11-13 of the Act. Relying upon the judgments of Gujarat Maritime Board (295 ITR 561) and Surat City Gymkhana (300 ITR 214) delivered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court he deleted the addition made by the AO.

    2.2 Before us, Departmental Representative (DR) submitted that the assessee had collected capitation fees, that activities carried out by the assessee were not charitable in nature, that donations were over and above the fees paid by the stundents.

    2.3 We have heard the rival submissions and perused the material before us. It is found that out of the total donation of Rs. 30.5 lakhs a sum of Rs. 1.98 lakhs was received from the students. AO has not doubted the fact that the assessee is imparting education and as per the settled law of taxation imparting education is covered by the word charitable activity. If income earned by a trust is utilised for charitable purposes it cannot be held that trust is carrying out business. FAA has rightly pointed out that there is no evidence on record that profit earned by the assessee-trust were not utilised by it for non charitable purposes. It is also a fact that there is no instances of violation of provisions of sections 11-13 of the Act by the trust. In our opinion principles enumerated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the cases of Gujarat Maritime Board and Surat City Gymkhana are applicable to the case under consideration. Therefore, we are of the opinion that assessee-trust was carrying out charitable activities and was entitled to exemption. Therefore, confirming the order of the FAA we decide Ground No. 1 against the AO

    3. Next Ground of appeal is about disallowance of claim of depreciation amounting to Rs. 5.58 lakhs. During the assessment proceedings, AO held that the provisions of section 11 of the Act provided for deduction on expenditure incurred for objects of the trust and the deduction of depreciation on capital assets would amount to double deduction, that depreciation could not be allowed in the case of allowance of exemption u/s. 11 of the Act. He relied upon the judgments of Escorts Ltd. (199 ITR 43) and J.K Synthatics (65 Taxman 420) delivered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.

    3.1 Assessee preferred an appeal before the First Appellate Authority (FAA). After considering the submissions of the assessee and the assessment order he held that trust was registered u/s. 12A of the Act, that AO had not doubted that capital expenditure was towards the objects of the trust. Following the order of the Hon'ble Jurisdictional High Court delivered in the case of Institute of Banking Personal Selection, Bombay (264 ITR 110) he held that depreciation claimed by the assessee had to be allowed. As a result, addition made by the AO was deleted.

    3.2 Before us, Departmental Representative (DR) submitted that assessee was not enetiled to claim double deductions.

    4. We have heard the rival submissions and perused the material before us. We find that issue of double deduction was dealt by the Hon'ble High Court in the case of Institute of Banking Personal Selection (supra), it was held by the Hon'ble High Court that in case of trusts, so called double deductions are allowable. We would like to quote a portion of the said judgment:

    “….. the first question which requires consideration by this Court is: whether depreciation was allowable on the assets, the cost of which has been fully allowed as application of income under s. 11 in the past years? In the case of CIT v. Munisuvrat Jain (1994) Tax LR 1084 (Bom) the facts were as follows. The assessee was a charitable trust. It was registered as a public charitable trust. It was also registered with the CIT, Pune. The assessee derived income from the temple property which was a trust property. During the course of assessment proceedings for asst. yrs. 1977–78, 1978–79 and 1979–80, the assessee claimed depreciation on the value of the building @ 2-1/2 per cent and they also claimed depreciation on furniture @ 5 per cent. The question which arose before the Court for determination was: whether depreciation could be denied to the assessee, as expenditure on acquisition of the assets had been treated as application of income in the year of acquisition? It was held by the Bombay High Court that s. 11 of the IT Act makes provision in respect of computation of income of the trust from the property held for charitable or religious purposes and it also provides for application and accumulation of income. On the other hand, s. 28 of the IT Act deals with chargeability of income from profits and gains of business and s. 29 provides that income from profits and gains of business shall be computed in accordance with s. 30 to s. 43C. That, s. 32(1) of the Act provides for depreciation in respect of building, plant and machinery owned by the assessee and used for the business purposes. It further provides for deduction subject to s. 34. In that matter also, a similar argument, as in the present case, was advanced on behalf of the Revenue, namely, that depreciation can be allowed as deduction only under s. 32 of the IT Act and not under general principles. The Court rejected this argument. It was held that normal depreciation can be considered as a legitimate deduction in computing the real income of the assessee on general principles or under s. 11(1)(a) of the IT Act. The Court rejected the argument on behalf of the Revenue that s. 32 of the IT Act was the only section granting benefit of deduction on account of depreciation. It was held that income of a charitable trust derived from building, plant and machinery and furniture was liable to be computed in normal commercial manner although the trust may not be carrying on any business and the assets in respect whereof depreciation is claimed may not be business assets. In all such cases, s. 32 of the IT Act providing for depreciation for computation of income derived from business or profession is not applicable. However, the income of the trust is required to be computed under s. 11 on commercial principles after providing for allowance for normal depreciation and deduction thereof from gross income of the trust. In view of the aforestated judgment of the Bombay High Court, we answer question No. 1 in the affirmative i.e, in favour of the assessee and against the Department.

    4. Question No. 2 herein is identical to the question which was raised before the Bombay High Court in the case of Director of Income-tax (Exemption) v. Framjee Cawasjee Institute (1993) 109 CTR 463 (Bom). In that case, the facts were as follows: The assessee was the trust. It derived its income from depreciable assets. The assessee took into account depreciation on those assets in computing the income of the trust. The ITO held that depreciation could not be taken into account because, full capital expenditure had been allowed in the year of acquisition of the assets. The assessee went in appeal before the AAC. The appeal was rejected. The Tribunal, however, took the view that when the ITO stated that full expenditure had been allowed in the year of acquisition of the assets, what he really meant was that the amount spent on acquiring those assets had been treated as ‘application of income’ of the trust in the year in which the income was spent in acquiring those assets. This did not mean that in computing income from those assets in subsequent years, depreciation in respect of those assets cannot be taken into account. This view of the Tribunal has been confirmed by the Bombay High Court in the above judgment. Hence, question No. 2 is covered by the decision of the Bombay High Court in the above judgment. Consequently, question No. 2 is answered in the affirmative i.e, in favour of the assessee and against the Department.”

    Respectfully following the above, we decide Ground No. 2 against the AO.

    As a result appeal filed by the AO stands dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Adit v. St. Francis Educational Trust
    (May 7, 2013)