Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 10(a)(iv)/section 37 of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969 (hereinafter referred to as the Act), and regulation 51 of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Commission Regulations, 1991,
  • section 2(o)(ii)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 10(a)(iv)/section 37 of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969 (hereinafter referred to as the Act), and regulation 51 of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Commission Regulations, 1991,
  • section 2(o)(ii)

    Paras Brothers, In Re

    Sardar Ali, Member:— This order will dispose of an enquiry instituted under section 10(a)(iv)/section 37 of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1969 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”), and regulation 51 of the Monopolies and Restrictive Trade Practices Commission Regulations, 1991, against Paras Brothers, 18-19, Bengali Market, Babar Road, New Delhi (hereinafter called “the respondent”). A complaint has been filed by Shri Om Prakash alleging that the respondent had overcharged him to the extent of Rs. 12 for 12 bottles of Bisleri Mineral of 1000 ml. per bottle. The bottles were purchased on July 23, 1990.

    2. On the basis of this complaint the Commission directed the Research Wing of the Commission to investigate into the allegations made in the complaint and submit the preliminary investigation report (PIR). The preliminary investigation report was submitted on May 6, 1991, recommending the initiation of an enquiry against the respondent. The notice of enquiry dated July 2, 1991, was issued against the respondent returnable on August 12, 1991. On receiving the notice of enquiry the respondent tendered a reply controverting the allegations made therein. The Director-General did not file a rejoinder and the following issues were framed:

    (1) Has the respondent indulged in the restrictive trade practice as mentioned in the notice of enquiry?

    (2) Whether the said practice is not prejudicial to the public interest?

    (3) Relief.

    3. Mr. C.M Sharma, the advocate appearing for the respondent, admitted that the respondent had sold the product in question for Rs. 84 per crate. Since the facts were admitted, the parties were left to address only on the question of law.

    4. The evidence of the Director-General was closed, vide the Commission's order dated October 30, 1991, but on the request of the Director-General, he was allowed to lead evidence to prove the facts mentioned in the notice of enquiry and the statement of AW-1, Shri Kadar Khan, was recorded. The Director-General also produced in evidence admitted documents, which were marked as exhibits A-1 to A-6. The Director-General dropped the other witness and closed his evidence. Thereafter the case was fixed for respondent evidence. On behalf of the respondent, the statement of RW-1, Shri Krishan Kumar Gupta, was recorded and the case was fixed for arguments on December 8, 1993. On this date, arguments were heard and order reserved.

    5. In the instant case, it has been alleged by the complainant that the respondent had sold 12 bottles of mineral water for Rs. 84 as against the maximum recommended price of Rs. 72 and thereby caused unjustified costs to the complainant, which allegedly is a restrictive trade practice within the meaning of section 2(o)(ii) of the Act. In support of his case, apart from certain documents which have been exhibited accordingly, the Director-General has produced AW-1, Shri Kadar Khan. He has made a statement verifying the price list prevailing in the year 1990. But in his cross-examination, he makes a statement that they had not been issuing any price-list for the public or even to the retailers and the price-list verified by him, in his opinion, was only in the form of detail provided to the director (research) and according to him that was not the price-list in the real sense. According to his own statement, they had not printed the pricelist on the bottles because the price keeps on changing according to increase/decrease in the price of raw material. However, they have been putting up stickers indicating the price on every bottle and stickers are either removed or not affixed at all. It was also stated that they do not have any control on the retailers as regards the price at which they sell the product to the ultimate consumers and in the instant case the respondent is neither a stockist nor a distributor of the product in question.

    6. RW-1 is the proprietor of the respondent and is carrying on the business of chemists and druggists and also has been selling Bisleri mineral water. He has made a statement that no price was printed on the bottle nor were there any instructions from the company in regard to the price charged on such bottles. According to him also, no price list had been issued by the company for the sale of mineral water. When he was asked to explain what was mentioned by him in his cash memo and specifically when his attention was drawn to exhibit A-1 wherein he has admitted that the sum of Rs. 84 was charged for the sale of mineral water, the following explanation was given:

    “I was not present at the time of sale. However, on my return to the shop I restored (sic) that there was a complaint that we have overcharged on the sale of those bottles. We were told that at other places the bottles have been sold at Rs. 72 per crate. Thereupon, I offered to refund the difference pointed out by the customers.”

    7. In this enquiry the question before us is whether mere selling of a consumer item by a shop-keeper at a price higher than that printed on the carton will be a restrictive trade practice within the meaning of section 2(o)(ii) of the Act. The relevant portion of section 2(o)(ii) of the Act reads as follows:—

    2(o) “restrictive trade practice” means a trade practice which has, or may have, the effect of preventing, distorting or restricting competition in any manner and in particular—

    (ii) which tends to bring about manipulation of prices, or conditions of delivery or to affect the flow of supplies in the market relating to goods or services in such manner as to impose on the consumers unjustified costs or restrictions…

    8. A simple analysis of the above definition would show that a restrictive trade practice must have the following elements:

    (a) it should be a trade practice as defined in section 2(u) of the Act;

    (b) it should have an actual or probable effect of preventing, distort ing or restricting competition in some manner;

    (c) the competition necessarily envisages the same or a similar situation. In other words, there can be no question of competition between a retailer and wholesaler, between the metropolitan city and the village or between two different types of articles, etc.;

    (d) there should be manipulation of prices (so far as, it is relevant for our present purpose);

    (e) there should be unjustified costs or restriction as a result of such manipulation.

    9. In the circumstances of the case, we are not convinced that there was any distortion or restriction of competition in regard to sale of Bisleri water in the market and there is no question of manipulation of prices. “Manipulation” means handling or managing an affair so as to give a false appearance for the purpose of one's personal advantage. Such controversy was also the subject-matter of R.T.P.E No. 1639 of 1987, in the matter of Director-General (Investigation and Registration) v. Aero Art Emporium, decided on May 9, 1991. In that case the complainant was Consumer Unit and Trust Society, who had made complaint to the Director-General (Investigation and Registration) that the secretary-cum-executive director of the complainant had purchased a 100 grams tin of Pan Parag, Sada Pan Ka Masala at a price of Rs. 23 from the respondent, whereas the maximum retail price embossed at the bottom of the tin was Rs. 20 only and according to the complainant charging of the higher price, about 15 per cent, over and above the retail price, would amount to a restrictive trade practice within the meaning of section 2(o) of the Act. On this basis, the notice of enquiry was issued against the respondent requiring him to show cause as to why an order should not be passed prohibiting them from indulging in any such restrictive trade practices. The respondent had filed a detailed reply admitting the fact of having sold the Pan Parag Masala tin for a price of Rs. 23 as against the retail price of Rs. 20 embossed at the bottom of the tin. In that case the Commission has held that there was no manipulation of prices because it implies something sinister in the presentation. It was further held that “it will be difficult to say that a man is guilty of manipulation of prices simply by selling the goods at a price higher than the price embossed on the packet or the tin containing the product when he sells the article openly to everybody without any false or untrue pretext for the purpose of selling it.” In the present case admittedly there were no prices fixed. The respondent is running a shop in the market and it was open to the consumer to purchase such bottles from the other shops, which are normally available there. So, the essential ingredients mentioned above of the restrictive trade practice within the meaning of section 2(o)(ii) are missing in this case.

    10. In view of our above discussion and perusal of the documents and the witnesses examined, issue No. 1 is decided in the negative. Since issue No. 1 has been decided in the negative, the other issues become redundant. In the net result, the allegations made in the notice of enquiry are not substantiated and the notice of enquiry is, therefore, discharged.

    11. The parties shall bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Paras Brothers, In Re
    (Mar 15, 1994)