Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 252
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 25 of the Arms Act
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 252
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 25 of the Arms Act
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 25 March 1993, Mahipal and his wife Prakashee (PW 3) were travelling to their fields on a buffalo cart when three assailants—Om Pal, Mukhtiar and Navin—allegedly emerged from a sugarcane field and attacked Mahipal. A firearm discharge by Mukhtiar struck Mahipal, while Navin purportedly hit him with the butt of a pistol. Mahipal died en route to the hospital after an FIR was lodged by Naresh Pal (PW 1) on information supplied by eyewitness Dharmendra (PW 2).

The investigation led to the recovery of weapons and the arrest of Mukhtiar. All three were charged under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC; Mukhtiar also faced a charge under Section 25 of the Arms Act. The Sessions Court convicted them and imposed life sentences with fines. On appeal, the Allahabad High Court found the key prosecution witnesses unreliable and acquitted the accused on 6 April 2007. The State of Uttar Pradesh sought special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, resulting in the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court erred in disbelieving the testimony of key prosecution witnesses (PWs 1, 2 and 3) and in acquitting the accused.
  2. Whether the Supreme Court should exercise its powers under Article 136 of the Constitution to interfere with an acquittal where the prosecution evidence is allegedly unreliable.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State of Uttar Pradesh)

  • The High Court failed to properly appreciate the presence and consistent testimony of eyewitnesses PWs 2 and 3 at the scene.
  • Medical evidence and injuries on the deceased corroborate the prosecution version, supporting conviction.
  • The trial court’s judgment was well-reasoned, and the High Court committed a grave legal error in reversing it.

Respondents (Accused) – Represented by Amicus Curiae

  • The High Court correctly assessed the credibility of witnesses and found their evidence unreliable.
  • No compelling grounds exist for the Supreme Court to disturb an order of acquittal.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined the evidence of the three principal prosecution witnesses:

  • PW 1 (Naresh Pal): Admittedly not an eyewitness; hostile relationship with the accused; gave inconsistent accounts of how he learned of the incident.
  • PW 2 (Dharmendra): Claimed to be an eyewitness, yet his Section 161 CrPC statements conflicted with his in-court testimony. He offered no satisfactory explanation for his presence, failed to lodge a complaint himself, and displayed conduct the Court deemed unnatural, undermining credibility.
  • PW 3 (Prakashee): Allegedly unconscious for a month after the incident, a claim unsupported by medical evidence. Her behaviour and testimony were regarded as implausible.

The Court noted additional flaws: absence of independent witnesses despite others allegedly seeing the crime, contradictions regarding the recovery of weapons, and an uncorroborated conspiracy theory advanced through PW 4, whose testimony the trial court had already doubted.

Given these deficiencies, the High Court’s conclusion that the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt was found to be sound. Following the settled principle that interference with an acquittal is warranted only where findings are perverse or manifestly erroneous, the Supreme Court saw no justification to invoke Article 136 powers.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The criminal appeal is dismissed; the acquittal of the respondents stands affirmed.

Implications: The decision maintains the High Court’s order, resulting in the immediate release (or continued freedom) of the respondents. The judgment turns on fact-specific credibility assessments and sets no new legal precedent beyond reaffirming the limited grounds for appellate interference with acquittals.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of Uttar Pradesh v. Om Pal And Others

    N.V. Ramana, J.— This appeal by way of special leave petition is filed by the State of Uttar Pradesh against the final judgment and order dated 6-4-2007 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Om Pal v. State of U.P. 2007 SCC OnLine All 2034, (2007) 58 ACC 685 By the said judgment, the High Court has acquitted the respondents who were accused in Sessions Trial No. 1090 of 2003 before the District Court, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh.

    2. The prosecution case, in brief, is that on 25-3-1993 at about 9.00 a.m. Mahipal (deceased) and his wife Prakashee (PW 3) were going to their fields on a buffalo cart and Tej Pal, Ram Swaroop and Dharmendra (PW 2) were following them. While they were on their way, the three accused (the respondents herein) appeared out of a sugarcane field near the fields of one Alias, while hurling abuses against Mahipal fired at him. The fire opened by Om Pal was missed but the fire opened by Mukhtiar hit Mahipal. Navin assaulted Mahipal with the butt of the tamancha on his head. On receiving information from Dharmendra (PW 2) about the incident, Naresh (PW 1) accompanied by Dharmendra took the injured Mahipal to Police Station, Babugarh and lodged FIR. Thereafter, on the way to hospital, Mahipal succumbed to the injuries.

    3. The Investigating Officer, Sub-Inspector R.K. Chaudhary (PW 6) carried out the investigation, recorded statements, prepared site plan (Ext. Ka-3), collected plain earth as well as bloodstained earth from the place of occurrence and after conducting inquest at the hospital, sent the dead body for post-mortem.

    4. The accused Mukhtiar was arrested on 29-3-1993 near Village Bacchrota and from his possession one illegal pistol of .315 bore and one ammunition cartridge (Ext. K-13) were recovered. On 8-4-1993 the IO recorded the statements of other accused Ompal and Navin. A tamancha, allegedly used in the crime, was later recovered at the instance of accused Ompal on 14-4-1993. The statement of the wife of the deceased (PW 3) was recorded on 24-4-1993. After concluding the investigation, the Judicial Magistrate, Hapur committed the case to the Court of Session where charges were framed under Section 302 IPC read with Section 34 IPC against all the three accused and additionally charges were framed against accused Mukhtiar under Section 25 of the Arms Act. The accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

    5. At the trial, the prosecution mainly relied on the evidence of complainant Naresh Pal (PW 1) and eyewitnesses Dharmendra (PW 2) and Prakashee (PW 3), wife of the deceased. The motive for committing the crime was said to be that there was enmity between the parties as about three years before the date of occurrence, accused Mukhtiar was shot at and in that regard a case was in progress at Hapur Court in which Mahipal (PW 1) was accused. PW 4 Pratap Singh was examined as a witness to prove the conspiracy. PW 5 is Dr Hari Kishan Agarwal, who had conducted the post-mortem of deceased Mahipal. PW 6 SI R.K. Chaudhary IO and PW 7 Paltoo Ram, Head Constable are the formal witnesses. At the end of the trial, the trial court came to the conclusion that the prosecution has successfully proved the guilt of the accused. Accordingly, the accused were convicted under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC and sentenced to suffer life imprisonment and to pay a fine of Rs 5000 each and in default thereof, to further suffer six months' rigorous imprisonment.

    6. The trial court's judgment awarding conviction and sentence has been assailed by the accused by way of criminal appeal before the High Court. On appreciation of the material placed before it, the High Court recorded its finding that the prosecution witnesses, on whose evidence the trial court has relied on, are not reliable. Accordingly, the High Court set aside the judgment of the trial court and acquitted all the three accused. Dissatisfied with the acquittal order passed by the High Court, the State of Uttar Pradesh has preferred the present appeal before this Court.

    7. We have heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant and the learned Amicus Curiae appearing on behalf of the respondents.

    8. The learned counsel for the State vehemently contended the impugned order and submitted that the High Court has failed to appreciate the factum of presence of two eyewitnesses PWs 2 and 3 at the spot, who deposed in clear terms the way in which the accused carried the assault on the deceased resulting in his death. The injuries on the body of the deceased fully corroborate the prosecution case and the medical evidence also supports the case of the prosecution, but the High Court has, by setting aside the well-reasoned judgment rendered by the trial court, committed a grave error of law calling for this Court's interference.

    9. The learned Amicus Curiae, however, supported the view taken by the High Court and submitted that there is no need for this Court to interfere with the order of acquittal passed by the High Court.

    10. Having heard the learned counsel on either side, we have given our thoughtful consideration to the facts and circumstances of the case in the light of material placed before us. It appears that the trial court based its judgment mainly relying upon the evidence of three prosecution witnesses i.e. PW 1 Naresh Pal, the complainant, PW 2 Dharmendra, an eyewitness and PW 3 Prakashee, another eyewitness and wife of the deceased. However, in the view expressed by the High Court, the aforesaid witnesses are not credible. Since the entire prosecution case hinges on the depositions of these three witnesses, it is imperative for the Court to scrutinise their evidence properly so as to sift the chaff from the grain and find out the truth. In that pursuit, their evidence is to be considered from the point of view of credibility and trustworthiness. Once the same stands satisfied, it ought to inspire confidence in the mind of the Court to accept the stated evidence.

    11. Admittedly, the complainant PW 1 has not witnessed the occurrence. He believed whatever Dharmendra (PW 2) informed him and accordingly he lodged the complaint. It is also indisputable that PW 1 was inimical with the respondent party. There was also a criminal case pending in Hapur Court relating to an incident of firing at the accused, in which the deceased as well as PW 1 were accused and Respondent 3 herein was the victim. It is evident from the record that on the aspect of how PW 1 came to know about the incident, he made contradictory statements. There was no independent witness and according to the prosecution, despite the efforts made by the police to record statements from the public, no one was ready to give evidence. As per the statement of PW 1, besides PWs 2 & 3, two more persons Tej Pal and Ram Swaroop have also witnessed the incident. It is quite unnatural that none of the eyewitnesses has lodged complaint, but on the basis of information provided by Dharmendra (PW 2), PW 1 lodged the complaint believing the version of Dharmendra.

    12. On the other hand, the conduct and statements of PW 2 (Dharmendra) who was stated to be an eyewitness do not inspire confidence for the reason that his depositions under Section 161 CrPC were quite different to what he stated before the Court in his examination-in-chief. He could not even give a satisfactory reason for his presence at the time and place of occurrence. Furthermore, he did not choose to lodge complaint with the police by himself even though he had witnessed the occurrence as admittedly the complaint was lodged by PW 1 on the information provided by PW 2. Apart from that, there were certain conflicting statements in his evidence as regards how the deceased got injuries, and also his conduct of not making a hue and cry and not disclosing to anyone about the occurrence on his way to the house of Naresh Pal, gives rise to suspicion on the credibility and trustworthiness of PW 2. When the evidence of PW 2 itself is unbelievable and jeopardising the prosecution case, in no manner the evidence of PW 1 could be given credence.

    13. We are also not inclined to believe the conduct of PW 3 wife of the deceased, who was stated to be in a shock and not in consciousness for about a month after the death of her husband. We find no valid documentary or medical evidence on record in support of the claim of the prosecution that PW 3 was really in such unconscious state for about a month. Looking at the unnatural behaviour of eyewitnesses PWs 2 & 3 and their contradictory statements, it cannot be said that their evidence is genuine so as to convict the accused.

    14. Also there were some notable flaws in the prosecution case which cannot be ignored. According to PW 4 (Pratap Singh), on the previous night of the incident, he along with one Jakar (not examined) heard the accused hatching conspiracy to murder the deceased, but the prosecution did not present Jakar as a witness. It is incredible on the part of PW 4 that despite knowing about the conspiracy, he did not reveal it to the victim party so as to save the life of the deceased. The trial court also disbelieved his evidence.

    15. The High Court, while appreciating the evidence of the three important witnesses i.e. PWs 1, 2 and 3 rightly disbelieved the presence of PWs 2 and 3 at the place of occurrence and discredited the evidence of PW 1 complainant. Undoubtedly, the prosecution in its effort to establish the case with the support of evidence of PWs 1, 2 and 3 has miserably failed to prove the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt. The High Court has, therefore, committed no illegality or manifest error in acquitting the accused giving them the benefit of doubt, under the circumstances. We express our concurrence with the findings recorded by the High Court for acquitting the respondents. For the aforesaid reasoning, we do not find any merit in this appeal calling for our interference under Article 136 of the Constitution.

    16. Accordingly, the criminal appeal filed by the appellant State of U.P. is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Uttar Pradesh v. Om Pal And Others
    (Mar 21, 2018)