Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    P. Sai Krishnan v. Union Of India

    By Justice N.K. Balakrishnan, Judicial Member This Original Application has been filed complaining of denial of promotion to the applicant to the post of MT Fitter HS-II. He has approached this Tribunal for a direction to be given to the respondents to grant promotion to the applicant with consequential benefits.

    2 The applicant commenced his service as Fitter Auto (Skilled) on 09.01.2002 at INS Hansa which is coming under Western Naval Command. He continued there till 23.7.2005. He was transferred to INS Zamorin on compassionate ground with effect from 25.7.2005. His post was re-designated as MT Fitter (Skilled) from 4.8.2006 onwards. The applicant was qualified for MT Fitter (High Skilled) with effect from 29.11.2006. He had the qualification of Diploma in Mechanical Engineering (Automobile Technology). According to the applicant, his seniority was fixed with effect from 4.8.2006 and was promoted to the post of MT Fitter HS II on 1.2.2010 on completion of 4 years service in the parent post. He was discharging the duties of MT (Fitter) Gr.I & Gr.II. According to hims he was entitled to be promoted to the post of MT Fitter HS -II. But the respondent denied the same contending that the applicant had not satisfied the

    8 years service as per the rules. His representation was rejected as per Annexure A-4 order. His request for promotion was turned down as per Annexure A-5 order dated 13.5.2013. Hence this Original Application has been filed by him.

    3. Respondents filed reply statement contending as follows:- The crucial date for determining the eligibility for promotion is the 1st day of January as per DoP&T official memorandum dated 17.9.1998 (Annexure R-2). For promotion to Tradesman Highly skilled Grade II, Tradesmen Skilled must have eight years regular service in the grade and in the respective trade and also should have passed in departmental qualified test with 50% aggregate marks. The applicant has not completed 8 years of qualifying service as on 1.1.2013. He will be completing 8 years of qualifying service only on 23.7.2013. The Headquarters of Southern Naval Command implemented the restructure orders by applying relaxation of conditions up to 14.6.2010. There was no vacancy of MT Fitter (Highly Skilled Grade) available on 14.6.2010 and so the applicant could not be placed in higher grade in the restructure order.

    4. In the rejoinder filed by the applicant he has stated that he has successfully completed the departmental qualifying test and so he is entitled for the promotion post of MT Fitter HS II on completion of 8 years of regular service on 1.11.2011. The applicant has been working as MT Fitter (Grade I) with effect from 2005 onwards. That vacancy which arose during the year 1994. It has not get been filled up so far.

    5 The applicant obtained transfer on compassionate grounds to join, under the 2nd respondent on zero seniority and he accepted zero seniority for which an undertaking was also given by him (Annexure R-6). If the past service rendered by the applicant in other commands/establishments is reckoned for his seniority for promotion, the same will adversely affect the promotional avenues of other individuals who had joined that organisation prior to the reporting of the applicant under the second respondent. After he joined the second respondent Command on transfer on 25.7.2005 he has completed 5 years as only on 1.1.2011 whereas

    8 years regular service is required for promotion as per the recruitment rules.

    6. We have heard the learned the learned counsel for both parties.

    7. The point for consideration is whether the applicant is entitled to get promotion as MT Fitter HS II with effect from 1.11.2011. The gravamen of the contention raised by the respondents is that the applicant has not satisfied the residency period or length of service of 8 years required as per the recruitment rules Annexure R-1. In Annexure R-1 the eligibility for promotion is as stated under:- ' Tradesmen skilled with eight years regular service in the grade and in the respective trade also and who have passed in a departmental qualifying test to become eligible for consideration for promotion, qualifying marks of which shall be fifty per cent aggregate.'

    8 There is no dispute regarding the fact that the applicant obtained transfer on compassionate grounds to the second respondent Command/Unit and he joined the second respondent Command on 25.7.2005. It is also not in dispute that since he obtained transfer on compassionate grounds to his home town he was placed at the zero seniority/bottom seniority. The applicant does not question his seniority position. But he contends that for his entitlement for promotion to the post of MT Fitter HS II he need to satisfy only 8 years regular service since there is no dispute that the applicant has satisfied other requirements as per Annexure R-1 Recruitment Rules. Therefore, the short question that calls for consideration is whether his past service prior to his transfer in the previous organization should be counted for computing the total period of 8 years regular service required for his promotion to the post of MT Fitter HS II . The fact that he had voluntarily opted to come on bottom seniority, does not forfeit his past service. Seniority is one thing and the past service for eligibility for promotion is quite another. There is no case for the respondent that just above the applicant there is any other person senior to the applicant so as to contend that the applicant is not entitled to promotion. There is also no case that there is no vacant post to promote the applicant to that post. His promotion was denied only on the simple reason that he has not completed 8 years after he joined the second respondent organization. But the respondents over-looked the fact that his past service in the previous organisation will not get forfeited. The decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India & Ors v. C.N Ponnappan 1996 1 SCC 524 which has been followed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in subsequent decisions would make it clear that the service rendered by an employee at the place from where he was transferred on compassionate grounds is regular service. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that : 'The service rendered by an employee at the place from where he was transferred on compassionate grounds is regular service. It is not different from the service rendered at the place where he is transferred. Both the periods are taken into account for the purpose of leave and retiral benefits. The fact that as a result of transfer he is placed at the bottom of the seniority list at the place of transfer does not wipe out his service at the place from where he was transferred. The said service, being regular service in the grade, has to be taken into account as part of his experience for the purpose of eligibility for promotion and it cannot be ignored only on the ground that it was not rendered at the place where he has been transferred.'

    9. It was contended that in 2010 there was no vacancy for promoting the applicant. As stated earlier he entered in service as Fitter Auto on 9.1.2002. There is also no dispute regarding the fact that the post was re-designated as MT Fitter (Skilled) with effect from 4.8.2006. The respondents wanted to contend that since the applicant joined the office of the 2 nd respondent on 25.7.2005, he must have completed 8 years from 25.7.2005 for getting promotion as MT Fitter HS II. Annexure A-5 order would also show that his claim for promotion was declined only on the ground that he has not completed 8 years of qualifying service; not on any other ground. There is no case that there was no vacancy at all. As has been stated earlier it is trite law that his past service will not get effaced or forfeited though he looses his seniority as he opted to come over to the second respondent organization on bottom seniority. As long as, there is no case for the respondents that there is any other person senior to the applicant, he is entitled to be promoted from 01.11.2011 as claimed by the applicant. It is stated by the applicant that he has been working as MT Fitter Grade I w.e.f 2005 onwards and that post is lying vacant. Therefore, there can be no difficulty for the respondents to promote the applicant with effect from 1.11.2011.

    10 In view of what has been stated earlier, we are inclined to allow this Original Application with a direction to the respondents to pass appropriate orders promoting the applicant to the post of MT Fitter HS II w.e.f 1.11.2011. His pay shall be notionally fixed and he shall be paid the actual pay with effect from the date applicant actually joined/assumed charge as MT Fitter HS II. The Original Application is disposed of accordingly. (MRS.P. GOPINATH) (N.K. BALAKRISHNAN) ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P. Sai Krishnan v. Union Of India
    (Feb 26, 2016)