Honble Shri V.K.Majotra, Vice-Chairman (A): Applicant is aggrieved that though he had been working as Chief Controller w.e.f. 2.9.1998, he was reverted to the post of Deputy Chief Controller w.e.f. 28.10.2002. According to him, vide orders dated 16.3.2001 in OA No.741/1999 the 1998 panel on the basis of which he was promoted was quashed and set aside with a direction that respondents should hold a fresh selection for the post of Chief Controller (grade Rs.7450-11500). The matter had been carried to the High Court through CWP 2506/2001. The High Court vide order dated 23.4.2001 directed that those holding the post of Chief Controller would continue to hold the post till a fresh selection was made and would vacate the post in case they were not selected, while such a selection process had to be completed within four months, i.e., by 16.7.2001. It was clarified by the High Court that continuance of those holding the post would not confer any legal and vested rights on them to continue, which would be only subject to the result of the selection made. According to applicant he appeared in the written test conducted on 7.7.2001 and 14.7.2001 but before viva voce was conducted on 17.10.2001 and 19.10.2001, he was admitted in the hospital and could not participate in the viva voce test. Applicant has maintained that doctors declared applicant unfit for performing hazardous nature of duties but declared him fit in C-1 category. Thus, applicant has claimed that respondent No.2 should be directed to organize viva voce test for the post of Chief Controller for applicant and that his substantive pay that he was drawing prior to his reversion to the post of Deputy Chief Controller should be restored.
2. The learned counsel relying on Annexure A-VI (Advance Correction Slip No.77) relating to absorption of disabled/medically decategorised staff in alternative employment, contended that the disabled staff should be shifted to some other post with the same pay scale and service benefits. If such a railway servant cannot be immediately regularized or absorbed in any suitable alternative post he may be kept on a special supernumerary post in the grade in which the concerned employee was working on regular basis before being declared medically unfit pending location of suitable alternative employment for him with the same pay scale and service benefits; efforts to locate suitable alternative employment starting immediately. The special supernumerary post so created would stand abolished as soon as alternative employment is located. The learned counsel further relied on 2004 (2) SCSLJ 266 Union of India v Sanjay Kumar Jain contending that in terms of Section 47 of the Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995, if an employee after acquiring disability is not suitable for the post he was holding, he could be shifted to some other post with the same pay scale and service benefits. If it is not possible to adjust the employee against any post he may be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable alternative post is available or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier.
3. On the other hand, the learned counsel of respondents contended that applicant had not been working on the post of Chief Controller (Rs.7450-11500) on a substantive basis. The Tribunal vide its orders dated 16.3.2001 in OA No.741/1999 had quashed and set aside the panel dated 2.9.1998 directing respondents to hold a fresh selection for the post of Chief Controller grade Rs.7450-11500. However, on the basis of the directions of the Honble High Court in CWP No.2506/2001, applicant was allowed to hold the post till fresh selection was completed. The High Court had also clarified that holding of the post by applicant in this manner would not confer any legal or vested right upon him to continue, which would be only subject to the selection made. As applicant had acquired disability prior to the conduct of viva voce test, he could not be selected in the fresh selection. He was medically decategorised on 22.12.2001 before the conduct of vive voce test. The medical certificate dated 22.12.2001 stated that he was unfit as Chief Controller/operating permanently however, he is fit in his original medical category Cey-One and below with glasses and is to be given duties under restriction of Para 574 of IRMM 2000. His case was further reviewed by CMC, Delhi vide letter dated 4.12.2002. The following recommendations were made: He is fit in Cee-One * below with following restrictions- He is not fit to work Railway Track, in Railway yard, on bridges, unguarded high places, near machines. Any duties in connection with running trains which would subject the individual to great mental strain for example Control Duty. Any technical duties involving more than ordinary strain and self control. Applicant as such was not placed on the panel of Chief Controller and was reverted to the post of Deputy Chief Controller on 28.1.2002. He had earlier on filed OA No.371/2003, which was dismissed as withdrawn vide order dated 19.2.2003. His second OA No.271/2004 was disposed of with a direction to respondents to consider applicants representation dated 25.2.2003 by passing appropriate orders. He had filed another OA No.2227/2003 which was also withdrawn with liberty. Respondents have passed Annexure A-I dated 28.6.2004 whereby applicants representation dated 25.2.2003 has been disposed of on the basis of the medical certificate dated 4.12.2002 rejecting his claim for selection in the post of Chief Controller.
4. We have considered the respective contentions of parties as also perused the material on record.
5. The medical certificates indicate that applicant is fit in C-1 category with certain restrictions. He has not been found fit for the post of Chief Controller (Rs.7450-11500). Advance Correction Slip No.77 and the decision in the case of Sanjay Kumar Jain (supra) indicate that an employee acquiring disability and medical decategorisation should have been holding a post on a regular basis before being declared medically unfit, only then he can be adjusted or absorbed in an alternative post with the same pay scale and service benefits. In the instant case applicant has failed to establish that he had been holding the post of Chief Controller on a substantive basis. As a matter of fact, he was allowed to continue on the post of Chief Controller in terms of the directions of the High Court which had clarified that such continuance would not confer any legal and vested right on him and would be subject to the fresh selection made. Furthermore, applicant has neither challenged Annexure A-I whereby his representation dated 25.2.2003 was rejected nor has he challenged the medical certificate whereby he was medically decategorised.
6. If one has regard to the facts and circumstances of the case as discussed above, this OA is liable to be dismissed being devoid of merit. Dismissed accordingly. No costs. ( Meera Chhibber ) ( V. K. Majotra ) Member (J) Vice-Chairman (A) /as/