Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts

    Bishan Singh v. Union Of India

    Heard the learned counsel for the parties.

    2. Though delay defeats justice, a hyper-technical plea of limitation sometimes in a case where fundamental rights are affected, also results in miscarriage of justice.

    3. In this view of the matter, applicants claim in the present OA is directed against an order by the respondents on 14.12.2005 whereby complying with the directions of the Tribunal in OA-1995/2004, the claim of the applicant to ascertain his working period had been turned down on the ground that from 1971 the staff registers have been checked but the name of the applicant was not found in the staff register.

    4. Learned counsel for applicant states that the respondents have verified the working period of the applicant from 1971 onwards when the applicant was not performing the duties and ultimately attained the age of retirement on superannuation. The records, which had to be verified in the wake of the directions of the Tribunal, are the records pertaining to period from 1953 to 1971, which on computation in accordance with rules and instructions, would have accorded him the right of pension, which is a fundamental right and cannot be denied de hors the Constitution of India.

    5. On the other hand, learned counsel for respondents raised a preliminary objection of res judicata by contending that when the issue has earlier been finalized between the same parties on an identical cause of action, the proceeding on the same cause of action would be hit by the doctrine.

    6. The following two decisions have been relied upon by the respondents: Ratan Chandra Sammanta & others v. Union of India & others, JT 1993 (3) 418 and Bhoop Singh v. Union of India & others, 1992 (2) SLJ 103. to contend that delay defeats justice and one who sleeps over his remedy, looses his right as well.

    7. It is also contended that law of limitation has to be applied with rigor, however, harsh the consequence may be. It is also stated that inordinate and unexplained delay defeats the right of a person.

    8. Learned counsel would contend that the applicant had not pursued his remedy since 1971 and now agitating the grievance, which pertains to a period from 1953 to 1971, is barred by Section 21 of Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, as the jurisdiction of the Tribunal would not extend to a matter beyond three years prior to its inception, i.e., 20.11.1982.

    9. Learned counsel would also contend that the claim of the applicant having been considered in its entirety when evidence of his working is not found and the records are also not available, it would be a futile exercise to process the case of the applicant, which is not otherwise legally tenable.

    10. I have carefully considered the rival contentions of the parties and perused the material placed on record.

    11. A government servant, whatever the nomenclature of his status is, by the dint of his service rendered with the Government, gets pension as a reward, which sustains him after the service tenure is over. Deprivation of such a right cannot be countenanced in law and law of limitation would not override as a technical objection to impede this fundamental right, which is not only guaranteed under the Constitution but protected as well by the Apex Court in D.S. Nakara & others v. Union of India, 1983 SCC (L&S) 145.

    12. In the light of above, the law of limitation would have no application in the present case. Earlier when the applicant had approached the Tribunal, a categorical finding on the same arguments as has now been tendered by the respondents opposing the OA on the ground of limitation, had been repelled and overruled by observing that once a right of pension has accrued to the employee till he gets his dues in the form of pay and allowances, the cause of action would not only be recurring but a continuous one till it is discharged.

    13. Being the fundamental duty of the respondents and corresponding right of the applicant of pension, respondents cannot be absolved of the duty by raising such a hyper-technical plea of limitation.

    14. In the light of above, the earlier claim of the applicant once disposed of in the wake of a direction in OA-3122/2003 decided on 2.1.2004 culminating into an order whereby for non-availability of the records and on limitation, the claim when turned down was meticulously considered by the Tribunal in OA-1995/2004.

    15. Taking cognizance of staff register as per item no.37 at Sl.No.1666 of Circular dated 16.7.1962, it was observed by the Tribunal that the register was never destroyed and was the permanent proof of working of a person. On the above directions and keeping in light the availability of staff register, re-examination of the claim of the applicant on verification of working period, the said OA was disposed of.

    16. The respondents in compliance of the aforesaid order, though verified the record of the applicant by scanning through the staff register, this exercise was restricted from 1971 onwards. This shows that no efforts have been made at all to verify the earlier record of working of the applicant from the year 1953 to 1971 in the staff register to ascertain the period of the applicant. If it is so, then by no reason or logic, aforesaid is a compliance of the Tribunals order in true letter and spirit.

    17. Once the duty is cast upon the Government to act in a manner, which is prescribed or directed by the Court, the respondents cannot change the mode of exercise and are not allowed to devise their own means to comply with the directions. Directions of the Tribunal were not to verify the records from 1971 onwards but to verify the records pertaining to the service of the applicant. Having failed to examine the relevant record of the applicant from 1953 to 1971, the action of the respondents cannot be countenanced in law.

    18. Insofar as the plea of res judicata is concerned, as borrowed in Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 from Section 11 of Cr.PC, which provides that when an issue has attained finality between the parties on the same cause of action, a fresh proceeding is not maintainable. However, condition precedent for applicability of this doctrine is that there must be a final disposal of the right. As in the present case, the right of the applicant for accord of pension on verification of his working period was not a final conclusion of the right, in such an event, when an order passed by the respondents on 14.12.2005 being assailed, is not a valid compliance by the respondents of Tribunals directions. The issue or cause of action is still open and the objections of res judicata and limitation raised by the respondents are overruled.

    19. In the result, OA is allowed. Impugned orders are set aside. Matter is remitted back to the respondents to verify the working period of the applicant for determining his claim for pensionary benefits in accordance with rules, instructions and law, for the period from 1953 to 1971 in the light of staff register being maintained for the yesteryears. This exercise shall be completed within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. No costs. ( Shanker Raju ) Member (J) /sunil/

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bishan Singh v. Union Of India
    (Aug 4, 2006)