Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    R.N. Kurmi v. Union Of India

    Mr. L.K. Joshi, Vice Chairman (A) : The simple question, which has been placed before us for consideration, is whether an un-communicated grading in the Annual Confidential Report (ACR), which is below the prescribed bench mark grading for promotion, should be communicated to the employee by the competent authority, comments of the former obtained and considered, as per the prescribed procedure and if on such consideration the grading is upgraded commensurate to the bench mark, the matter placed before the review Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) or it should be ignored by the DPC, while considering the employee for promotion.

    2. The genesis of the aforesaid reference lies in the judgments of the Honourable Supreme Court in Dev Dutt Vs. Union of India and Others, (2008) 8 SCC 725= JT 2008 (7) SC 463 and Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar Vs. Union of India and Others, Civil Appeal number 6227/2008, decided on 22.10.2008. In Dev Dutt (supra), the appellant was overlooked for promotion as Superintending Engineer because, as per the prescribed bench mark, candidates could be considered for promotion only if all the five ACRs, which were considered had Very Good grading and the appellant had one Good grading in the ACR of 1993-94. The grievance of the appellant was that the good entry of 1993-94 was not communicated to him. He submitted that he would have had an opportunity of making a representation for upgrading of that entry from `Good to `Very Good, had he been given an opportunity to make a representation against the entry. The case of the respondent-Union of India was that Good entry was not an adverse entry, which only had to be communicated as per the extant instruction and, therefore, no illegality has been committed by not communicating the adverse ACR. In this context the Honourable Supreme Court observed that: 9. We do not agree. In our opinion every entry must be communicated to the employees concerned, so that he may have an opportunity of making a representation against it if he is aggrieved.

    10. In the present case the bench mark ( i.e. the essential requirement) laid down by the authorities for promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer was that the candidate should have very good entry for the last five years. Thus in this situation the good entry in fact is an adverse entry because it eliminates the candidate from being considered for promotion. Thus, nomenclature is not relevant, it is the effect which the entry is having which determines whether it is an adverse entry or not. It is thus the rigours of the entry which is important, not the phraseology. The grant of a good entry is of no satisfaction to the incumbent if it in fact makes him ineligible for promotion or has an adverse effect on his chances.

    11. Hence, in our opinion, the good entry should have been communicated to the appellant so as to enable him to make a representation praying that the said entry for the year 1993-94 should be upgraded from good to very good. Of course, after considering such a representation it was open to the authority concerned to reject the representation and confirm the good entry (though of course in a fair manner), but at least an opportunity of making such a representation should have been given to the appellant, and that would only have been possible had the appellant been communicated the good entry, which was not done in this case. Hence, we are of the opinion that the non-communication of the good entry was arbitrary and hence illegal, and the decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the respondent are distinguishable. .. .. .. ..

    20. Thus it is not only when there is a bench mark but in all cases that an entry (whether it is poor, fair, average, good or very good) must be communicated to a public servant, otherwise there is violation of the principle of fairness, which is the soul of natural justice. Even an outstanding entry should be communicated since that would boost the morale of the employee and make him work harder. The observation that all entries in the ACR, including the Outstanding entry is recurring again and again in the judgment. It is the leit motif of the judgment. The following directions were given: 48. We, therefore, direct that the good entry be communicated to the appellant within a period of two months from the date of receipt of the copy of this judgment. On being communicated, the appellant may make the representation, if he so chooses, against the said entry within two months thereafter and the said representation will be decided within two months thereafter. If his entry is upgraded the appellant shall be considered for promotion retrospectively by the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) within three months thereafter and if the appellant gets selected for promotion retrospectively, he should be given higher pension with arrears of pay and interest @ 8% per annum till the date of payment. In Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (supra), the appellant had adverse remarks in his ACR and a note of caution. Moreover, the gradings in his ACRs for the relevant period of consideration were Good whereas the prescribed bench mark for promotion was Very Good. The Patna Bench of this Tribunal, in the Original Application filed by Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar, had directed that the note of caution and the adverse remarks should not be taken note of, while considering him for promotion. Pursuant to the direction of the Tribunal (Patna Bench) a review DPC met on 9.09.2002 but did not find the appellant fit for promotion. He was later promoted on the recommendation of a regular DPC, which met in March 2003. He later retired from service. The appellants case before the Honourable Supreme Court was that he should have been promoted from the year 2000 and he could not be promoted earlier because of Good gradings in his ACR. In this context, the Honourable Supreme Court observed thus: 4. It is not in dispute that the CAT, Patna Bench passed an order recommending the authority not to rely on the order of caution dated 22.09.1997 and the order of adverse remarks dated 09.06.1998. In view of the said order, one obstacle relating to his promotion goes. Coming to the second aspect, that though the benchmark very good is required for being considered for promotion admittedly the entry of good was not communicated to the appellant. The entry of good should have been communicated to him as he was having very good in the previous year. In those circumstances, in our opinion, non-communication of entries in the ACR of a public servant whether he is in civil, judicial, police or any other service ( other than the armed forces), it has civil consequences because it may affect his chances for promotion or get other benefits. Hence, such non-communication would be arbitrary and as such violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. The same view has been reiterated in the above referred decision relied on by the appellant. Therefore, the entries good if at all granted to the appellant, the same should not have been taken into consideration for being considered for promotion to the higher grade. The respondent has no case that the appellant had ever been informed of the nature of the grading given to him.

    5. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has pointed out that the officer who was immediately junior in service to the appellant was given promotion on 28.09.2000. Therefore, the appellant also be deemed to have been given promotion from 28.08.2000. Since the appellant had retired from service, we make it clear that he is not entitled to any pay or allowances for the period for which he had not worked in the Higher Administrative Grade Group A, but his retrospective promotion from 28.08.2000 shall be considered for the benefit of re-fixation of his pension and other retiral benefits as per rules. ( emphasis supplied)

    3. One thing, which luminously stands out, is that there is no discussion in both the judgments, cited above, about whether a below benchmark grading should be communicated to the aggrieved employee or whether it should be ignored by the DPC. In Dev Dutt (supra), the Applicants submission before the Honourable Supreme Court was that the Good grading should be communicated to him. The issue, whether it should be ignored, was not even considered. The ratio in Dev Dutt (supra) is that any grading in the ACR, which is not communicated and which results in adverse civil consequences for an employee, e.g., his being overlooked for promotion, is an adverse grading. The other direction is that all gradings in the ACR should be communicated to an employee regardless of whether these are below average, average, good, very good or outstanding. These are not to be read to be mandating that the only option before the competent authority is to communicate the contents of the ACRs with below bench mark grading to the employees, regardless of the circumstances. In Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (supra), the directions to ignore the good grading have been given because he was a retired officer. In these circumstances, the Honourable Supreme Court considered it to be the best option. Although the judgment in Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar has followed Dev Dutt (supra), yet the directions are to ignore the ACRs and not to communicate these. The long and short of it is that we may not look for clues in these judgments regarding the course of action to be followed i.e. (i) to communicate or (ii) to ignore the gradings.

    4. The learned counsel for the Respondents has placed before us an order dated 21.08.2009 of this Tribunal in Krishna Mohan Dixit Vs. Union of India and Others. The Tribunal has, at the outset observed thus: It is now well settled principle in administrative law that any grading in the Annual Confidential Report (ACR) of an employee of the Government, which is below the bench mark prescribed for promotion to a higher grade in the employees service would be considered to be an adverse remark and, as per the procedure prescribed for adverse remarks, would have either to be communicated to the concerned employee, his representation obtained and a fresh view taken on the grading or it has to be ignored depending on the facts and circumstances of the case [See A.K. Aneja V. Union of India & Ors., OA No.24/2007, decided on 7.05.2008 by a Full Bench of the Tribunal; Dev Dutt V. Union of India and others, (2008) 8 SCC 725; and Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar v. Union of India and others, Civil Appeal No.6227/2008, decided on 22.10.2008.] Thereafter the Tribunal considered the Office Memorandum (OM) number 22011/3/88-Estt. (D) dated 11.05.1990, issued by the Department of Personnel and Training (DOP&T), which deals with how the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) should deal with the adverse remarks in the ACR. The OM, inter alia, reads thus: 12.1: Where the DPC find that the adverse remarks in the confidential Report of an officer have not been communicated to him but the adverse remarks are of sufficient gravity to influence their assessment of the officer concerned, then the Committee shall defer consideration of the case of the officer, provided these remarks have been recorded in any of the CRs pertaining to three years immediately preceding years prior to the year in which DPC is held and direct the cadre controlling authority to communicate the adverse remarks to the officer concerned so that he may have an opportunity to make a representation against the same. Where the un-communicated adverse remarks pertain to a period earlier than the above or where the remarks are not considered of sufficient gravity to influence the assessment of the officer concerned, the DPC may ignore the remarks while making the assessment. (emphasis added). [Source: Swamys Complete Manual on Establishment and Administration, Tenth Edition, 2006, pages 283-284]. In Smt. Indrani Sarkar Vs. Union of India and Others, OA number 2709/2009, decided on 12.04.2010, this Tribunal took the view that the ACRs containing adverse remarks, which would, of course, include remarks below the prescribed bench mark should be ignored if both the Reporting and Review Officers had retired.

    5. The argument on behalf of the Respondents mainly is that the judgment in Dev Dutt (supra) has been referred to a larger Bench of Honourable Supreme Court in Union of India Vs. A.K.Goel & Ors, arising out of SLP ) no. 11589 of 2009 by noticing divergent views in Dev Dutt (supra) and K.M. Mishra Vs. Central Bank of India and others, 2008 (9) SCC 120. It is also contended that order dated 5.08.2009 of this Tribunal in OA no. 592/2009, Shri Sanjay Kumar Vs. Union of India and Others, has been stayed by the Honourable Delhi High Court in WP ( C ) no. 13585/2009 by order dated 11.03.2010. In the aforesaid OA no. 592/2009, it had been directed that the ACR of the year 2002-03 should be ignored. It is, therefore, urged that the Tribunal may not consider this issue, till the decision of the Larger Bench of the Honourable Supreme Court in Dev Dutt (supra) case.

    6. We do not agree with the Respondents. The issue in the reference is entirely different. We are not considering whether the grading in the ACR, which is below the prescribed bench mark, would be considered to be adverse. The issue is well settled as of now in the light of Dev Dutt (supra) and Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (supra) and this Tribunals Full Bench judgment in A.K. Aneja Vs. Union of India, OA number 24/2007, decided on 7.05.2008. The ratio laid down in these judgments will govern the field, especially considering that Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (supra) is later than K.M. Mishra (supra). If, however, the Honourable Supreme Court holds otherwise on consideration of the issue by a Larger Bench, then that will be the law. This can only be a hypothetical postulate till then. Till then the law laid down in Dev Dutt (supra), as followed in Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (supra) has to be followed, subject to the decision by the Larger Bench. In spite of specific query the learned counsel could not produce any judicial precedent to the effect that consideration of cases identical to a case in which reference to the larger Bench of the Honourable Supreme Court has been made, should be stayed by other courts. Be that as it may, the issue here is different and, therefore, we need not dwell on this argument any longer.

    7. In essence, there cannot be any rigid rule laying down that the grading, which is below bench mark should always be communicated or should always be ignored. What view has to be taken in each case will depend entirely on the facts and circumstances of the case. Indeed on this there has not been any conflicting opinion also in Original Applications before this Honourable Tribunal. It is stated in the order of reference by the learned Bench that directions have been given in different OAs either to ignore the grading in the ACR or to communicate it. These would surely be on consideration of the facts of a particular case, as we have seen in Krishna Mohan Dixit (supra), adverted to in a preceding paragraph. No law in this regard has been laid down by the Honourable Supreme Court in Dev Dutt (supra) or Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (supra). It was neither an issue in the aforesaid cases nor was it adjudicated upon. Considered in this light, it would seem that perhaps the reference was not even necessary.

    8. The reference is thus answered by holding that grading below the prescribed bench mark in the ACR should be ignored or communicated, depending on the facts of the case and the extant rules and directions in this regard. Should it be a case where the ACR of a particular year has to be ignored, in the light of the rules/instructions in force, ACR (s) of the preceding year (s) will have to be considered in the light of DOP&Ts instructions contained in OM number 22011/1/90-Estt(D) dated 12.10.1990 read with OM number 22011/7/98-Estt(D) dated 6.10.2000 and OM number 22011/5/86-Estt(D) dated 20.06.1989 that equal number of ACRs in respect of all the employees considered for promotion should be taken into account. [Source: Swamys Complete Manual on Establishment and Administration, Tenth Edition, 2006, pages 852-854].

    9. The OA is remitted back to the DB for consideration on merit. ( Shanker Raju ) ( L.K. Joshi ) ( V.K. Bali ) Member (J) Vice Chairman (A) Chairman /dkm/

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    R.N. Kurmi v. Union Of India
    (May 14, 2010)