Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 6 (3) (c) of the Cenvat Credit Rules 2004, (in short "2004 Rules").
  • clause (c) of sub Rule 3 of Rules 6 of 2004 Rules
  • Rule 6(3)(c) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002,
  • Rule position till 31-3-2011 Rule 2(e):
  • Rule 6(3D) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004.
  • SECTION 66 FINANCE ACT
  • Rule 6 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002
  • SECTION 66 FINANCE ACT
  • Rule 6(3)(c) of the 2004 Rules
  • Rule 2(e) of the 2004 Rules
  • 31-3-2011 Rule 2(e):
  • Rule 6(3)(c),
  • Rule 2(e)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 6 (3) (c) of the Cenvat Credit Rules 2004, (in short "2004 Rules").
  • clause (c) of sub Rule 3 of Rules 6 of 2004 Rules
  • Rule 6(3)(c) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002,
  • Rule position till 31-3-2011 Rule 2(e):
  • Rule 6(3D) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004.
  • SECTION 66 FINANCE ACT
  • Rule 6 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002
  • SECTION 66 FINANCE ACT
  • Rule 6(3)(c) of the 2004 Rules
  • Rule 2(e) of the 2004 Rules
  • 31-3-2011 Rule 2(e):
  • Rule 6(3)(c),
  • Rule 2(e)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant engaged in trading activities and commission business, trading in items such as MS scraps and iron ore, primarily with Essar Steels Ltd., and acting as a commission agent for Essar Steels Ltd. and other steel companies. The appellant had centralized service tax registration for "Business Auxiliary Services." An internal audit revealed that the appellant claimed service tax credit on input services used both for trading and commission agent activities. While service tax was paid on commission agency services, no service tax was paid on trading activities. The audit concluded that excess credit was claimed in violation of Rule 6(3)(c) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004, quantifying excess credit at Rs. 6,78,459/-. Additionally, irregular credit was claimed on services not used for output services, which was reversed by the appellant. A Show Cause Notice was issued, the appellant disputed the excess credit claim, but the Adjudicating Authority rejected the refund claim. The Commissioner (Appeals) set aside the Adjudicating Authority's order, but the Revenue appealed to the Tribunal, which partly allowed the Revenue's appeal, holding against the appellant on excess credit related to trading activities. The appellant then filed the present appeal before this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Rule 6(3)(c) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002 applies in cases where service tax on input services is not used for trading activity but only for taxable services?
  2. Whether trading activity can be categorized as an exempted service for invoking Rule 6 of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002 prior to 1-4-2011?
  3. Whether, when trading was not a service or exempted service at the relevant time, requiring reversal of any part of credit on input services is legal?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant argued that the amendment to Rule 2(e) of the 2004 Rules effective from 01.04.2011 included trading activity as an exempted service, and thus Rule 6(3)(c) would apply to trading only after that date.
  • The appellant contended that the period in issue (2006-2008) predates this amendment, so the excess credit reversal was not justified.

Revenue's Arguments

  • The Revenue relied on the Tribunal's judgment, asserting no interference was needed as trading activity was an exempted service at the relevant time.
  • They argued that the Explanation to Rule 2(e) of the 2004 Rules clarifying that exempted services include trading merely reiterated the existing position that trading was exempted from service tax.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mercedes Benz India Pvt. Ltd. Vs CCE Pune-I (Tribunal Division Bench) Proportionate credit on trading activity; trading is not a service and cannot be considered an exempted service prior to 1-4-2011 The Court applied this precedent to hold that the appellant was not eligible for entire credit on common input services used for trading and taxable services, only proportionate credit was permissible.
Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Meerut V. Sharvan Kumar Swarup & Sons, (1994) 6 SCC 623 Applicability of newly inserted rules to pending proceedings; retrospective effect of procedural changes The Court distinguished this case, holding it inapplicable because the issue here was substantive apportionment of credit, not procedural computation or retrospective application of rules.
C-172/96 (Court 5th Chamber, England and Wales, Queen's Bench Division) Determination of turnover for VAT purposes by considering the spread (difference between selling and purchase price) The Court found this precedent irrelevant as the dispute concerned apportionment of input service tax credit, not turnover computation for tax liability.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the definitions and amendments to Rule 2(e) of the 2004 Rules, noting that during the period 2006-2008, trading activity was not liable to service tax and was not considered an exempted service. The amendment in 2011, which explicitly included trading as an exempted service, was clarificatory and not retrospective. Since no service tax was paid on trading activity in the relevant period, the appellant could only claim credit on input services on a pro-rata basis as per Rule 6(3)(c) of the 2004 Rules. The Court rejected the appellant’s argument that the formula for apportionment applied only post-2011, holding that the rule applied at the relevant time. The Court relied on the Tribunal’s decision in Mercedes Benz India Pvt. Ltd. to support this interpretation. It further clarified that the appellant’s failure to maintain separate accounts for taxable and non-taxable services invoked the application of Rule 6(3)(c). The Court declined to apply precedents cited by the appellant that concerned retrospective application of procedural rules or turnover computations unrelated to service tax credit apportionment.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The Court upheld the Tribunal’s order that the appellant is not entitled to claim the entire service tax credit on input services used partly for trading activities which were not taxable during the relevant period. The appellant must apply Rule 6(3)(c) to apportion the credit on a pro-rata basis. The decision confirms that amendments clarifying exempted services cannot be applied retrospectively to alter substantive liabilities. The direct effect is that the appellant must reverse excess credit claimed for the period 2006-2008. No new precedent beyond the facts of this case was established.

    Ruchika Global Interlinks v. The Customs Excise

    1. This appeal is preferred against the Judgment and order dated 19.02.2015, passed by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal. (in short the "Tribunal".) 1.1. The captioned appeal was admitted on 02.07.2015, when the following questions of law were framed for consideration by this Court: "a) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, Rule 6(3)(c) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002, attracted, in cases, where the service tax on input services are not used in respect of trading activity but used only for taxable services?

    b) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, trading activity can be categorized as an exempted service for the purpose of invoking Rule 6 of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002 prior to 1-4-2011.

    c) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, when trading was not a service or exempted service at the relevant time, requiring the appellant for reversal of any part of the credit on input services is legal?"

    2. In order to adjudicate upon the issues arising in the appeal, the following facts are required to be noticed. 2.1. The appellant herein is engaged in trading activities as well as in commission business. The record shows that the appellant during the relevant period traded in MS Scraps, MS Angles, CTD Bars, Shredded Steel Scrap, Iron ore, etc. The appellant, it appears, largely, bought and sold the aforementioned articles from Essar Steels Ltd. 2.2. This apart, the appellant, as it emerges from the record, also acted as a commission agent for and on behalf of Essar Steels Ltd. In its capacity as the commission agent, the appellant sold HBI fines, (which emerges as a by-product in the process of manufacturing steel) to various parties on behalf of Essar Steels Ltd. In respect of sales made to third parties, albeit, on behalf of Essar Steels Ltd, the appellant earned commission. 2.3. It appears that apart from Essar Steels Ltd, the appellant also acted as commission agent for M/S.Meenakshi Steels and M/S.Pulkit Steels. 2.4. It appears that the appellant had obtained Centralized registration with the Service Tax Department for services provided by it under the category "Business Auxiliary Services". 2.5. Evidently, the appellant's records were examined by the internal audit party of the Department on two consecutive days, i.e., 23.06.2008 and 24.06.2008. The audit carried out revealed that the appellant had been claiming credit of service tax on various common input services like telephone services, maintenance and repair services, which were used not only for its trading activity but also qua its commission agent business. 2.6. Admittedly, in so far as the Commission Agency business was concerned, service tax was paid by the appellant, while no service tax was paid for trading activity. The latter stands affirmed upon a query being put, in that behalf, to Mr.K.Jayachandran, learned counsel for the appellant. 2.7. It is for this reason, that the audit party came to the conclusion that excess credit of service tax had been claimed by the Assessee, contrary to the restriction imposed as per Rule 6 (3) (c) of the Cenvat Credit Rules 2004, (in short "2004 Rules"). The excess amount worked out, in that behalf, by the Department was a sum of Rs.6,78,459/-. The other irregularity, which was pointed out by the Audit Department, was with regard to the availment of Cenvat Credit not used by the appellant qua their output services.

    3. A perusal of the record by the audit party had revealed that the appellant had taken credit qua banking services, which was not a service used for providing the said output service. 3.1. What is important to note is that in so far as the first aspect was concerned, i.e., excess utilization of Cenvat Credit vis-a-vis non-taxable trading activity, the appellant, in the very first instance, paid the quantified tax, equivalent to Rs.6,78,459/-, along with appropriate interest, which was pegged at Rs.98,421/-. 3.2. In so far as the other aspect was concerned, which involved, as indicated above, irregular availment of Cenvat Credit for services not used for generating output services, the credit wrongly availed of, which was quantified at Rs.7,01,979/- was reversed, after making a suitable entry in the Cenvat Credit Account leaving a closing balance of Rs.28,359/-, as on 31.03.2008. The appropriate interest on this amount, which was quantified at Rs.1,08,787/- was paid by the Assessee. The common ground before us, is that, in so far as this aspect of the matter is concerned, there is no lis obtaining between the parties.

    4. Continuing with the narrative, based on the aforesaid, a Show Cause Notice dated 03.03.2009 (in short "SCN"), was issued to the appellant, to which, a reply was filed. 4.1. The stand taken by the appellant, in the reply, was that due to an incorrect audit objection with regard to the alleged excess utilization of Cenvat Credit qua the exempted services, the appellant had paid up the purported excess amount, which was, otherwise not payable. 4.2. The Adjudicating Authority, however, was not impressed with the stand taken by the appellant, and therefore, proceeded to reject its claim for refund with regard to both aspects, to which, we have made a reference above.

    5. Being aggrieved, the appellant preferred an appeal with the Commissioner of Central Excise (Appeals), [(in short the Commissioner (Appeals)]. 5.1. The Commissioner (Appeals) set aside the Order-in-Original in its entirety vide dated 29.04.2009. Against this order, an appeal was preferred by the Revenue to the Tribunal. 5.2 The Tribunal with regard to the aspect concerning irregular availment of Cenvat Credit, (which, purportedly was not used for output services), sustained the view taken by the Commissioner (Appeals) and thus, in effect, held that the appellant was eligible for input credit amounting to Rs.7,01,979/-. As indicated hereinabove, this aspect of the matter is not subject matter of the appeal before us, as the Revenue has not instituted, we are told, any appeal as regards this issue. However, in so far as the other aspect of the matter is concerned, which is, excess utilization of Cenvat Credit in respect of exempted services, the Tribunal, Ruled against the appellant and in that behalf has made the following observation in paragraph 10 of the impugned judgment and order: "10) As regards the excess credit of Rs.6,78,459/- availed by the respondents on the common input services, used for both output service as well as for trading activity, I find that the respondents holding centralised registration and not maintained separate accounts of input services for the trading activity as well as for the taxable service. I find from the records and findings of the OIO, there is no dispute on the fact that respondents are carrying out both trading activity and taxable service under BAS as commission agents. The Division Bench of the Tribunal in the case of Mercedes Benz India Pvt.Ltd. Vs CCE Pune-I (supra) has clearly held that entire credit on trading activity is not eligible and only proportionate credit with reference to turnover is eligible. The relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced as under :- 16. In view of the above, we have come to the conclusion that trading was not a service and therefore, cannot be considered as an exempted service during the period prior to 1-4-2011 and the amended provision with effect from 1-4-2011 will not have retrospective effect. The next issue to be decided is how to apportion the credit of input service taken by the appellant, where such input services have been used both in the manufactured goods and trading activities of the imported goods. It is in this context that the Ld. Sr. Advocate for appellant has argued that the same should be computed with reference to clause (c) of Explanation I appended after Rule 6(3D) of Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004. The said provision as noted earlier was inserted with effect from 1-4-2011. The argument of the Ld. Sr. Advocate is that the said explanation only provides that procedure for computation and since this change is procedural in nature it will have a retrospective effect. Ld. Sr.Advocate also argued that in case of traded goods, the value addition by the appellant is only the difference between the sale price and the purchase price of the goods which is not so in the case of manufactured goods. On a query by the Bench that since Ld. Sr. Advocate is arguing that only the value addition should be taken in respect of the traded goods, then why the same criteria should not be applied in the case of manufactured goods i.e. take the differential amount between the selling price and cost of various raw materials. Ld. Sr. Advocate stated that in case of manufactured goods so many things go into production process like labour, electricity and many other services and it will not be appropriate to take the value addition. In support of his contention that in case of traded goods only value addition should be taken, Ld. Sr. Advocate took us through the judgment of the Court (5th Chamber) dated 14-7-1998 in case C-172/96 which was passed on a reference under Article 177 of the EC Treaty by the High Court of Justice of England and Wales, Queen's Bench Division. We have gone through the said judgment carefully. In the said case, the issue was how to determine the turnover for purpose of value added tax in case of transactions in different currencies by the First National Bank of Chicago. The Bank used to purchase various currencies at a certain rate in other currencies. Similarly, the Bank used to sell various currencies in other currencies. The difference between the two is generally understood as spread and would be the income of the Bank. The question was what should be considered as the turnover for purpose of VAT. It is in that context, the said court has held that the spread the difference between the selling price and purchase price should be taken for the purpose of VAT. In the present case, the dispute is not relating to computation of turnover for purpose of charging a tax as there is no tax liability in case of traded goods. The question is how to apportion the credit of tax on the input service between the manufactured goods and the traded goods, whether we should take the turner of the manufactured goods and traded goods for apportioning the credit of the service tax on input services or some other criteria should be followed. We, therefore, do not find any applicability whatsoever of the said judgment in the facts and circumstances of the present case. Another judgment quoted by the Ld. Sr. Advocate is the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Meerut V. Sharvan Kumar Swarup & Sons reported in (1994) 6 SCC 623. In this case, wealth-tax was applicable on various assets. A new Rule was inserted with effect from 1-4-1979 to determine the market value of properties. The question was whether the new inserted Rule can be used for determining the value of properties for earlier period and hence determine the wealth-tax. It is in this context that the Hon'ble Supreme Court has taken a view that the same would be applicable to all the proceedings pending at the time of its enactment. In the present case, as mentioned earlier, it is not the computation of tax but apportionment of the credit of service tax on input services availed for manufactured goods and traded goods. As we have already held that trading was not a service and therefore cannot be considered as an exempted service before 1-4-2011, therefore, the substantive provision itself did not exist before the said date. Under the circumstances, we are of the view that the said judgment is not applicable in the facts and circumstances of the present case...... 11) The Division Bench of Tribunal's decision (supra) is squarely applicable to the present case and the respondents are not eligible for the entire credit availed on the common input services. Since the department rightly demanded the excess credit of Rs.6,78,459/- which is in excess of 20% of the total service tax payable, the respondents paid the excess amount and they are not eligible to take re-credit in cenvat account nor they are eligible for refund. The adjudication order rejecting the refund of Rs. 6,78,459/- and the interest amount is upheld and the L.A.A. Order allowing credit is liable to be set aside....." 5.3. Accordingly, the Tribunal partly allowed the appeal of the Revenue by interfering with the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) in so far as the purported irregular availment of Cenvat Credit for output services was concerned.

    6. Mr.Jayachandran, who appears for the appellant, says that the view of the Tribunal cannot be sustained for the reason that the definition of Rule 2 (e) of the 2004 Rules underwent amendment with effect from 01.04.2011, whereby, it was indicated that trading activity would fall in the category of exempted services. Learned counsel, thus, went on to say that, therefore, by a logical corollary Rule 6(3)(c) of the 2004 Rules would apply to trading activity only after 01.04.2011. In this behalf, Mr.Jayachandran brought to our notice the fact that the period in issue involved in this case was 2006 2007 and 2007 2008.

    7. As against this, Mr.A.P.Srinivas, relied upon the judgment of the Tribunal and, thus, submitted that no interference was called for. It was the learned counsel's submission that trading activity was, at the relevant point in time, an exempted activity and, in that sense, the Explanation appended to Rule 2(e) of the 2004 Rules, which sought to clarify that exempted services included trading activity, did nothing more than reiterate the obvious.

    8. We heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    9. Clearly, during the period in issue, i.e., 2006 - 2007 and 2007 2008, trading activity, which was one of the businesses, carried on by the appellant, was not amenable to service tax. The amendment to Rule 2(e), as correctly argued by Mr.A.P.Srinivas, only stated the obvious that there was no liability to pay service tax on trading activity, during the relevant period. Pertinently, Mr.Jayachandran does not dispute that trading activity was not taxable during the period in issue. The argument of Mr.Jayachandran, however, is that, the formula for apportionment provided in Rule 6(3)(c) can only apply post 01.04.2011, as a clarification was issued only on that day onwards.

    10. To our minds, such a submission cannot be accepted. The reason for this is, that once Mr.Jayachandran has accepted before us that the appellant was not paying service tax on trading activity, then, the credit of service tax vis-a-vis input services could only be taken on a pro-rata basis, as per the formula stipulated in Rule 6(3)(c), as it obtained at the relevant point in time. 10.1. In this context, it may also be relevant to note, how exempted services was defined in Rule 2(e) of the 2004 Rules till 31.03.2011 and thereafter. Rule position till 31-3-2011 Rule 2(e): "exempted services" means taxable services which are exempt from the whole of the service tax leviable thereon, and includes services on which no service tax is leviable under Sec,.66 of the Finance Act" Rule position with effect from 31-3-2011 Rule 2(e): Exempted services means taxable services which are exempt from the whole of the service tax leviable thereon, and includes services on which no service tax is leviable under Sec.66 of the finance Act; and taxable services whose part of value is exempted on the condition that no credit of inputs and input services, used for providing such taxable service, shall be taken. EXPLANATION: For the removal of doubts, it is hereby clarified that "exempted services" includes trading. 10.2. Clearly, both before and after amendment, "exempted services" meant those taxable services, which were exempt from whole of service tax and, included those services on which service tax was not leviable, under Section 66 of the Finance Act. The inclusion in Explanation to Rule 2(e) "trading" was, without doubt, only clarificatory. As accepted by Mr.Jayachandran, the appellant had not being paying service tax on trading activity during the relevant period. 10.3. Therefore, given the rule position, what would govern the matter would be the determination of the issue as to whether or not, a particular service is amenable to service tax under Section 66 of the Finance Act. 10.4. Since, the trading activity was not amenable service tax during the relevant period, surely, the apportionment, as provided in Rule 6(3)(c) would get triggered. This is apparent, upon a bare perusal of Rule 6(3)(c) the relevant part of which is as follows. Rule 6. Obligation of manufacturer of dutiable and exempted goods and provider of taxable and exempted services. (1) XXXX (2) XXXX (3) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-Rules (1) and (2), the manufacturer or the provider of output service, opting not to maintain separate accounts, shall follow either of the following conditions, as applicable to him, namely:- (a) XXXX (b) XXXX (c) The provider of output service shall utilize credit only to extent of an amount not exceeding twenty per cent of the amount of service tax payable on taxable output service

    11. Having regard to the Rule position and given the admitted fact that no separate accounts were maintained by the appellant, with regard to the taxable and non taxable services, clause (c) of sub Rule 3 of Rules 6 of 2004 Rules would apply.

    12. For the foregoing reasons, we feel no interference is called for with the order of the Tribunal. Accordingly, the questions of law, as framed, are answered in favour of the Revenue and against the Assessee.

    13. The appeal will stand dismissed. Resultantly, pending miscellaneous petition shall stand closed. There shall, however, be no order as to costs. (R.S.A., J.) (R.S.K., J.) 18.04.2017 raja/gg

    1. The Customs Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, South Regional Bench, Haddows Road, Chennai 600 006.

    2. The Commissioner of Service Tax, Chennai. RAJIV SHAKDER.J., & R.SURESH KUMAR.J., raja/gg C.M.A.No.1226 of 2015 M.P.No.1 of 2015 18.04.2017

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ruchika Global Interlinks v. The Customs Excise
    (Apr 18, 2017)