AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 15 of the Tamil Nadu Private Schools (Regulation) Act and Rules.
  • V Section 19 of the Private Schools (Regulation) Act,
  • Nadu Private Schools (Regulation) Act
  • Rule 15(9)(ii)
  • Rule 15(9)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 15 of the Tamil Nadu Private Schools (Regulation) Act and Rules.
  • V Section 19 of the Private Schools (Regulation) Act,
  • Nadu Private Schools (Regulation) Act
  • Rule 15(9)(ii)
  • Rule 15(9)
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary: S.S. Subramani, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitions arise from orders of the respondent refusing to approve the appointment of Secondary Grade Teachers on the ground that the roster (reservation) had not been followed. The petitioners challenged those orders, contending that the usual institutional practice—whereby, if the District Employment Exchange reports no eligible Scheduled Caste (SC) / Scheduled Tribe (ST) candidate, the institution fills the vacancy from Backward Community candidates after obtaining an undertaking to appoint an SC/ST candidate at the next vacancy—has been followed and approved in the past. Petitioners asserted that the Government recognised this procedure (including by G.O. Ms. No. 113 for appointments of Graduate Teachers to Secondary Grade Posts) and that urgency and the welfare of students require immediate filling of vacancies rather than leaving posts vacant. The Government (first respondent) filed a common counter-affidavit asserting that Rule 15(9) of the Tamil Nadu Private Schools (Regulation) Act and Rules prohibits filling SC/ST quota vacancies in the year they arise when eligible SC/ST candidates are not available and requires such vacancies to be carried forward as 'backlog' vacancies to the next recruitment. The matter was heard and the court delivered the impugned judgment dismissing the writ petitions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent's order refusing to approve the appointment of Secondary Grade Teachers (on the ground that the roster/reservation was not followed) was proper.
  2. Whether the institutional practice of appointing candidates from other communities after obtaining an undertaking to fill the next vacancy with an SC/ST candidate is permissible in light of Rule 15(9) of the Tamil Nadu Private Schools (Regulation) Act and Rules.
  3. Whether G.O. Ms. No. 113 (permitting appointment of Graduate Teachers in Secondary Grade Posts) or considerations of urgency and student welfare justify filling SC/ST quota vacancies in the year they arise when no eligible SC/ST candidates are reported to be available.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • It is usual practice to obtain a list of qualified candidates from the District Employment Exchange; when the Exchange reports no eligible SC/ST candidate, institutions fill the vacancy with a Backward Community candidate after securing an undertaking to appoint an SC/ST candidate at the next vacancy.
  • This practice has been accepted by authorities in the past and is necessary to avoid disruption to students and to safeguard students' interests by ensuring vacancies are not kept unfilled for long periods.
  • The Government has recognised the procedure (petitioners relied on G.O. Ms. No. 113) and petitioners had furnished the required undertakings; despite this, the authorities refused to approve the appointments.
  • The petitioners argued that urgency and single vacancies should not permit long vacancies and that the rule of carry-forward should not be applied in a manner that leaves solitary vacancies unfilled.
  • Counsel relied on certain precedents (listed in the opinion) to support their contention (specific principles relied upon were not detailed in the opinion).

Respondent's (Government's) Arguments

  • Rule 15(9) provides that where a qualified and suitable SC/ST candidate is not available for selection in the turn allotted to them, the SC/ST turn does not lapse; the vacancy must be carried over to the next recruitment and selection shall first be made for the carried-over turn.
  • Vacancies reserved for SC/ST that are not filled in a given year are to be carried over as 'backlog' vacancies and should be filled in the next academic year; the institutions should have kept such backlog vacancies for recruitment in the next year (1998–99) instead of unilaterally filling them with other categories.
  • The authorities are bound to follow the Rules under the Tamil Nadu Private Schools (Regulation) Act and cannot rely on informal or customary practice in derogation of the clear provision of Rule 15(9).
  • G.O. Ms. No. 113 is applicable only in exceptional cases and cannot be made generally applicable to appointments of Secondary Grade Teachers to justify deviation from Rule 15(9).
  • The urgent need to fill vacancies cannot be used to circumvent reservation rules and affect the chances of SC/ST candidates; where a wrongful approval was made earlier, it was rectified by withdrawing it.
  • Respondents prayed for dismissal of the writ petitions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1964 SC 179 The opinion records that petitioners' counsel relied on this decision; the specific principle from the decision is not stated in the provided opinion. The court held that this decision was not relevant to the present question because Rule 15(9) is clear and those decisions gave directions on the basis of their peculiar facts.
(1995) 2 SCC 745 The opinion records reliance upon this citation by petitioners; the opinion does not specify the principle invoked from this case. The court considered it not relevant for deciding the present case, observing that those decisions were fact-specific and did not displace the clear Rule 15(9).
(1998) 3 SCC 620 The opinion records reliance upon this citation by petitioners; the specific rule or principle relied upon was not detailed in the judgment. The court declined to apply it, stating that Rule 15(9) governs the matter and that the cited decisions involved peculiar facts distinct from the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded from the text and operation of Rule 15(9) of the Tamil Nadu Private Schools (Regulation) Act and Rules (which were framed under Chapter V Section 19 of the Act). The court reproduced Rule 15(9) in full and emphasised its clarity. Key points of the court's reasoning, as articulated in the opinion, are:

  1. Rule 15(9)(ii) specifically governs situations where no qualified and suitable SC/ST (or Backward Classes) candidate is available in the turn allotted to them. The Rule provides that the SC/ST turn does not lapse in the year the vacancy arises; instead, unfilled SC/ST vacancies must be carried over to the next recruitment and selection for appointment to that post shall be made first for the carried-over turn.
  2. The petitioners' claimed institutional practice of filling the vacancy by other-community candidates on the basis of an undertaking has no legal sanction where Rule 15(9)(ii) unambiguously prohibits filling the vacancy in that year and requires it to be carried forward.
  3. The validity of Rule 15(9) was not challenged in these petitions; accordingly, the Authorities are bound to follow the Rule and cannot approve appointments contrary to its mandate merely because of past practice or expediency.
  4. Only if, even after being carried over to the next recruitment, qualified SC/ST candidates remain unavailable, will the carried-over turn lapse and the vacancy be filled by the next turn in the order of rotation—i.e., lapse occurs only after the carry-forward mechanism is exhausted.
  5. While recognising the legitimate concern that vacancies in educational institutions should not remain unfilled for the welfare of students, the court held that such policy or practical considerations cannot justify a judicial direction contravening an express statutory rule; to do so would amount to the court framing a rule, which it is not empowered to do.
  6. The court found the precedents relied upon by petitioners inapposite, observing that those decisions gave directions based on peculiar facts and therefore did not displace the clear mandate of Rule 15(9) in the present cases.
  7. The court applied the same legal principle to all the writ petitions before it, including W.P. No. 2280 of 1998, because the vacancies in question had arisen in 1997 and were governed by the same Rule.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court dismissed all the writ petitions. The judgment states: "Petition dismissed." and also records that all the writ petitions are dismissed with no costs; connected W.M.Ps. are also dismissed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The respondent Authorities' refusal to approve the appointments (on the ground that the roster/reservation was not followed) is upheld by the court; the appointments made in deviation from Rule 15(9) cannot be ratified on the basis of the institutional practice or undertakings relied upon by the petitioners.
  • Procedure to be followed: SC/ST reserved vacancies not filled in the year they arise (because no eligible SC/ST candidate is available) must be carried forward to the next recruitment, and only if after carry-forward no eligible SC/ST candidate is available will the reserved turn lapse and the vacancy be filled by the next turn in rotation, in accordance with Rule 15(9).
  • Broader precedent: The court applied and enforced the clear statutory provision (Rule 15(9)) and did not rely on the precedents cited by petitioners; the opinion does not purport to establish or lay down a new legal principle beyond applying the existing rule to the facts of these cases.

    Bharathi Middle School, Sahadevanpettai v. State Of Tamil Nadu And Others

    S.S Subramani, J.:— In all these cases, a common question arises for consideration, namely, whether the Order of respondent refusing to approve the appointment of Secondary Grade Teacher is proper. Respondent has refused to approve the appointment on the ground that roster has not been followed.

    2. In these writ petitions, petitioners challenge the order of respondent on the ground that whenever a vacancy arises, it is the usual practice to get a list from the concerned District Employment Exchange to send a list of qualified candidates, and whenever the Employment Exchange informs the respective Institutions that no Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe candidate is available, the same will be filled from candidates belonging to Backward Community on condition that when next vacancy arises, the same will be filled by a candidate belonging to Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe Community. It is also said that it has been the usual practice to approve such appointments on the Institutions filing such undertaking that they will follow the roster system.

    3. It is further said that such practice is absolutely necessary to avoid difficulties of the students and also safeguard the interests of the students. Taking into consideration the welfare of the students, the vacancy cannot remain unfilled and the Government has also recognised the procedure which is being followed by the various Institutions. It is said that when the Employment Exchange reports that there is no eligible Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe candidate available, the government obtains an undertaking from the Institution to the effect that the next appointment will be from among the Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe candidates. After obtaining such undertaking, the Authorities used to approve the appointment in the next roster point. It is said that all these petitioners have given such undertaking and, in spite of the same, under the various Orders impugned in these writ petitions, the Authorities have refused to approve the appointments. It is also said that when the Employment Exchange itself has declared that there is no eligible Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe candidate to be appointed, and when the Government has also taken note of that situation, it issued G.O Ms. No. 113 permitting appointment of Gradudate Teachers in Secondary Grade Posts. The same reasoning will have to follow in these cases also. The action of the respondents, according to the ppetitioners, is unreasonable and unfair, and, if it is a case of single vacancy, it cannot be kept vacant for a long period and the rule of carry forward cannot be applied for a solitary vacancy.

    4. A common counter-affidavit has been filed by the first respondent-Govemment in W.P No. 1325 of 1998 Main contention raised therein is that when the petitioners knew that there was no Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe candidate available for appointment, the Rule provides that those vacancies should not be filled up with other categories like O.C, B.C, etc. and these vacancies should be carried forward for appointment in the next year. Such carrying over of SC/ST vacancies are called ‘backlog’ vacancies. Petitioners should have kept such backlog vacancies for recruitment in the next academic year 1998–99. Instead, they have totally disregarded the Rules relating to SC/ST vacancies, and have decided unilaterally to fill up SC/ST vacancies with Backward Community candidates. Even though such appointments were made after due publicity and also after getting a Certificate from the Employment Exchange, the action cannot be ratified in view of the specific Rule which prohibits the filling up of the vacancy, and when there is a specific provision for filling up the post next year. The Authorities under the Tamil Nadu Private Schools (Regulation) Act are bound to follow the Rules, and they cannot rely on a practice as stated by the petitioners. It is also said that the Government has never approved any appointment violating Rule 15 of the Tamil Nadu Private Schools (Regulation) Act and Rules. Regarding G.O Ms. No. 113 referred to in the writ petitions, it is said that the same can be made applicable only in exceptional cases and it cannot be applied in the case of appointment of Secondary Grade Teachers. It is also said that the Rule is applicable even for a single post that falls vacant. Reservation is permissible only for vacancies under SC/ST quota. The vacancies in reference have arisen only during 1997–98, and as such they have not been kept vacant for a long period. Those vacancies ought to have been carried over for the year 1998–99 as backlog vacancies or being filled up on priority basis during 1998–99 along with the current Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes vacancies of that year. The urgent need cannot be used as a device to fill up the Vacancies and thereby effect the chances of SC/ST candidates being appointed. A mistake was committed in approving the appointment of one candidate, and the same was rectified, which necessitated the filing of W.P No. 1519 of 1998. The wrong approval was later withdrawn. Respondents prayed for dismissal of the writ petitions.

    5. Heard learned counsel on both sides.

    6. Under Chapter V Section 19 of the Private Schools (Regulation) Act, the Government is empowered to make Rules for regulating the number, qualifications and conditions of service (including promotion, pay, allowance, leave, pension, provident fund, insurance and age of retirement and rights as respect disciplinary matters) of the teachers and other persons employed in any private school. Rules have been framed under the said section, and Rule 15 deals with the same. Rule 15(9) is the relevant provision which requires consideration for the purpose of these writ petitions. It reads thus:—

    “9(i) The claims of the candidates belonging to Backward Classes, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes shall also be considered for the remaining 32 per cent of unreserved vacancies which are filled on the basis of merit. Where a candidate belonging to Backward Classes, Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes is selected on the basis of merit in the said 32 percentage the number of percentage, reserved for Backward Classes, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes as the case may be, shall not in any way be affected:

    (ii) If a qualified and suitable candidate belonging to any of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes or Backward Classes is not available for selection for appointment in the turn allotted for them in the cycle, the turn so allotted to the Backward Classes shall lapse and the vacancy shall be filled by the next turn in the order of rotation, but the turn so reserved for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes shall not lapse and the number of candidates to be selected in that recruitment shall be reduced by the number of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes candidates not available for selection against the turn reserved for them, all unfilled vacancies reserved for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes shall be carried over to the next recruitment and selection for appointment to that post in the next recruitment shall be made first for the carried over turn and then the normal rotation shall be followed. If qualified. Scheduled. Castes and Scheduled Tribes candidates are not available, even then, the carried over turn shall lapse and the vacancy shall be filled by the next turn in the order of rotation.”

    (Emphasis supplied)

    7. It is the case of the petitioners that taking into consideration the urgency, candidates belonging to other communities also will be applied when qualified SC/ST, candidates are not available for the post It is further said that the practice is that whenever vacancies for appointment of SC/ST candidates arise, the Institutions concerned would ask the Employment Exchange to send for a list of qualified candidates belonging to SC/ST community, and if qualified candidates are not availabe, the Employment Exchange used to issue such a Certificate. Thereafter, after due publicity, applications will be invited and after holding an interview, the vacancy will be filled up on filing an undertaking that when the next vacancy arises, it will be filled by SC/ST candidate. The Authorities also used to approve such appointments. I do not think that the so called practice has got any legal sanction when Rule 15(9)(ii) (extracted supra) makes it clear that if in a particular year there is no qualified SC/ST candidate, that vacancy shall not be filled up. It has to be carried over for the next year. The validity of that Rule is not challenged in any of these writ petitions. The Authorities are bound by the Rule which prohibits the filling up of the vacancy in that year. When the vacancy is carried over for the next year, and if even at that time there is no qualified candidate, then alone the reservation for the Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe will lapse and the vacancy has to be filled up in the next turn in the order of rotation. When the Rule is very clear that the vacancy shall not be filled up, there is no question of appointing candidates belonging to other communities on the basis of an undertaking.

    8. It is true that being an educational institution, vacancy will have to be filled up immediately. Otherwise, it is the future of the students that is affected. But, that is a matter which the respondents-Authorities have to look into and take necessary action, and Courts cannot give any direction contrary to the Rule. If the Court gives a direction, that amounts to framing a Rule, which is not empowered to do.

    9. Learned Counsel for the petitioners relied on the following decisions:— AIR 1964 SC 179, (1995) 2 SCC 745 and (1998) 3 SCC 620. I do not think that any of these decisions are relevant for deciding the question on hand since the Rule is very clear. In fact, in all the above decisions, directions were given taking into consideration the peculiar facts of the case. So far as these writ petitions are concerned, we are only-governed by Rule 15(9) and its effect on appointment.

    10. Even though an argument was put forward in W.P No. 2280 of 1998 that the facts therein are different from the other Writ petitions. I do not think that the submission of learned counsel is correct. There also, vacancy arose only in the year 1997 and the principle said above will fully apply to the facts of that case also.

    11. In the result, I do not find any merit in all these writ petitions and consequently all the writ petitions are dismissed. No costs. Connected W.M Ps. are also dismissed.

    12. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bharathi Middle School, Sahadevanpettai v. State Of Tamil Nadu And Others
    (Feb 19, 1999)