Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rajasthan Medical & Health Service Rules, 1963. D.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rajasthan Medical & Health Service Rules, 1963. D.P.C

    Dr. Murlidhar Paliwal v. State Of Rajasthan

    Sandeep Mehta, J.:— By way of this writ petition, the petitioner Dr. Murlidhar Paliwal has approached this Court craving for issuance of a direction to the respondents to promote him on the post of Senior Medical Officer in the promotion quota of the year 1995-96 with all consequential benefits.

    2. Facts relevant and essential for the sake of disposal of the writ petition are noted hereinbelow:-

    The petitioner, after facing due process of selection conducted by the R.P.S.C was selected/appointed on the post of Medical Officer vide order dated 31.3.1981 The prescribed criterion of promotion from the post of Medical Officer to Senior Medical Officer is seniority cum merit as per Rajasthan Medical & Health Service Rules, 1963. D.P.C meeting was convened for considering promotions against the vacancies of the year 1995-96 from the post of Medical Officer to Senior Medical Officer and promotions were made vide order dated 2.9.1998 The petitioner claims that in the said process, persons junior to him were promoted but his case for promotion escaped consideration without any justification. Copy of the promotion order dated 2.9.1998 Annexure-2 is placed on record of the writ petition in an attempt to demonstrate that the persons standing at S. No. 27 and below were junior to the petitioner in the cadre of Medical Officers but were promoted by breaking seniority in the cadre. This assertion is also based on the provisional seniority list dated 8.8.1990 Annexure-3. The petitioner made representations to the authorities for promoting him on the post of Senior Medical Officer against the vacancies of the year 1995-96 and to place his name in between the incumbents placed at S. No. 26 and 27 in the promotion list. The representation of the petitioner was answered by letter dated 19.12.1998 intimating that the petitioner's candidature could not be considered by the D.P.C because of non availability of his service record. The petitioner was directed to complete his service record. It is also alleged that promotions were further made on the post of Senior Medical officer on 18.6.2003, 28.2.2004, 28.8.2004, 5.4.2005 and 2.5.2006 respectively but in all these promotional exercises the petitioner's case was not taken up on the very same pretext that his service record was not complete. On each occasion, persons junior to the petitioner were promoted. Finally a belated promotion order dated 20.10.2006 came to be issued whereby the petitioner was promoted on the post of Senior Medical Officer against the quota of vacancies of the year 2003-04. The petitioner has challenged the action of the respondents not considering his case for promotion as per the actual year of entitlement i.e 1995-96 when the vacancies arose.

    3. The respondents have filed a reply to the writ petition wherein the petitioner's assertion that he stood higher in seniority as compared to the persons listed at S. No. 27 and downwards in the promotion order Annexure-2 dated 2.9.1998 is not disputed. However, it is averred in the reply that the petitioner's case could not be considered for promotion by the D.P.C in that years as well as the subsequent years owing to non-availability of his ACRs. This is the sole reason offered by the respondents for justifying non consideration of the petitioner's case for promotion as per his entitlement against the vacancies of 1995-96. The petitioner has filed a rejoinder to the reply annexing therewith a copy of the order dated 4.4.2008 passed by this Court in the case of Dr. Prabhat Kumar Purohit v. State of Rajasthan S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 6353/2003 wherein, after examining an identical controversy, this Court directed the State Government to consider the candidature of the said writ petitioner for promotion against the appropriate year in which the vacancies arose.

    4. I have heard and considered the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the parties and have perused the material available on record.

    5. The fact that the petitioner was placed higher in the order of seniority as compared to the promotees at S. No. 27 and below in the promotion list dated 2.9.1998 is not denied by the respondents. The sole ground offered by the department for not taking up the petitioner's case for promotion in the year corresponding to accrual of vacancies i.e 1994-95 is that his service record was not complete and so his case could not be considered by the D.P.C In the entire pleadings of the respondents, no case is set up that the responsibility for deficiency/non availability of service record is attributable to the petitioner. That being the situation, this Court is of the opinion that no sooner the service record was completed or became available, the respondents were under an obligation to convene a review D.P.C for considering the petitioner's candidature for promotion against the vacancies of the corresponding year as per his entitlement i.e 1995-96. There is no justification whatsoever in the action of the respondents in not taking up the petitioner's case for promotion against the vacancies occurring in said year by convening a review D.P.C and rather promoting him belatedly against the vacancies of 2003-04. The impugned action is absolutely unjustifiable arbitrary, perverse and discriminatory. Persons junior to the petitioner having been promoted against the vacancies of the year 1995-96 vide promotion order dated 2.9.1998 and admittedly there being no adversity in the service record of the petitioner, he too was entitled for consideration against the very same year of vacancies no sooner his service record became available/was completed. This Court in the case of Dr. Prabhat Kumar Purohit (supra) in an identical situation held that if consideration could not be made in the original D.P.C owing to missing of service record, then candidature of the incumbent has to be considered for promotion against the appropriate year of vacancy by convening a review D.P.C.

    6. The writ petition thus deserves acceptance and is hereby allowed. The respondents are directed to convene a review D.P.C and consider the petitioner's case for promotion against the vacancies of the year 1995-96. Upon being found suitable, the petitioner shall be promoted as Senior Medical officer for the vacancy occurring in the said year. He shall also be entitled to all consequential benefits. The entire exercise as directed above shall be completed within a period of six months.

    7. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dr. Murlidhar Paliwal v. State Of Rajasthan
    (Jan 6, 2017)