1. Heard Sri Harendra Belwal and Sri Vinai Upadhyay, counsel for the petitioners and standing counsel for the respondents.
2. By the present writ petition, the petitioners have prayed for a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to treat the appointment of the petitioners as regular and substantive from the date of their initial appointment not from the date of exemption of training as they were appointed under dying in harness rules. Briefly stated the petitioners were appointed as Assistant Teachers in various schools on different dates. Their date of appointment and names of schools are as under:
Sl. No.NamesSchoolsDate of appointment1.Ram ChandraPrimary School Patola21-7-19892.Ravindra KumarPrimary School, Chanakpur12-2-19933.Devendra KumarPrimary School, Jaitpur Ghoshi28-3-1992
4.Krishna KumarPrimary School, Lambarkhera, Gadarpur1-9-19935.Raghuvendra Kumar SinghPrimary School, Ratanpur, Gadarpur29-12-1990
3. According to the petitioners after their appointment as Assistant Teacher, Junior Basic School they are continuously serving. Pursuant to G.O No. 860/15(13) 197-1499/8/77 dated 15-5-1997 as many as 54 Assistant Teachers serving in District Udham Singh Nagar and Nainital were granted relaxation from training vide order dated 20-8-1997 passed by Assistant Director of Education (Basic) Kumaun Region; Nainital. The petitioner Nos. 3 and 5 figures at serial No. 41, 53and 40 respectively in the said list of teachers contained in G.O dated 20-8-1997 and petitioner Nos. 2 and 4 were granted exemption from training and status of trained teacher was conferred upon them vide order dated 13-9-1998.
4. The grievance of the petitioners is that in 1999, 2003 and 2004 promotion exercise of the Assistant Teachers to the post of Head Master were undertaken by the respondents but despite of the eligibility of the petitioners they were not considered for promotion while junior persons to them were promoted. The petitioners have submitted that on enquiry they were orally informed by the respondents that in the promotional exercise held in the year 1999, 2003 and 2004, the eligibility list was prepared on the basis of date of grant of trained pay scale.
5. The petitioners have alleged that no transparency was maintained by the respondents in the promotional exercise. The service of the petitioners should have been calculated from the date of their initial appointment. As the petitioners were appointed on compassionate ground under U.P Government Servants (Appointment under Dying in Harness) Rules and thus the appointment of the petitioners was stop gap arrangements and as such their seniority should be determined form the date of initial appointment and not from the date of completion of training.
6. The counsel for the petitioners has placed reliance on the observations made by this Court in Writ Petition No. 1620 of 2005 (SS) Balam Singh v. Chief Engineer, decided on 21-12-2005. In that judgment this Court has observed as under:
“In absence of counter-affidavit, learned standing counsel could not show any reason as to why the petitioner was appointed on temporary basis despite the fact that he was appointed under Dying in Harness Rules. I find force in the submissions of the learned counsel for the petitioner that since the petitioner was appointed under Dying in Harness Rules, his appointment should have been treated on regular basis and not on temporary basis.”
7. A Division Bench of Allahabad High Court in (1999) 3 UPLBEC 2263 : (1999 All LJ 1475), Ravi Karan Singh v. State of U.P has held as under:
“In our opinion, an appointment under the Dying in Harness Rules has to be treated as permanent appointment otherwise if such appointment is treated to be a temporary appointment then it will follow that soon after the appointment the service can be terminated and this will nullify the very purpose of the Dying in Harness Rule because such appointment is intended to provide immediate relief to the family on the sudden death of the bread earner. We, therefore, hold that the appointment under Dying in Harness Rule is a permanent appointment and not a temporary appointment and hence the provisions of U.P Temporary Government Servant (Termination of Services) Rules, 1975 will not apply to such appointments.”
8. Thus in view of the principle of law enumerated as above, the service of the petitioners should be calculated for all purposes from the date of their initial appointment as Assistant Teacher and not on the date of their completion of training. In view of above, a writ of mandamus is issued directing the respondents to calculate the service of the petitioners from the date of their initial appointment for the purpose of their seniority and promotion.
9. Accordingly, the writ petition is al lowed. No order as to costs.
10. Petition allowed.